Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

Sicilian pizza

There is a specific satisfaction in the thick, airy crunch of a Sicilian-style slice that standard thin crust just cannot replicate.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 1
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 2
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Big space with comfortable seating and a mix of counter and table service creates a casual, lively vibe. Atmosphere is warm and friendly but can be very loud and sweltering without strong air conditioning. Popular for thick crust Sicilian pizza and a bustling, nostalgic feel.

Slices come in large portions with a rich, creamy texture typical of New York pizza. Only plain square or round slices are available, and they tend to be greasy, which can be managed with a napkin.

Thick and doughy crust with a crisp bottom defines the Sicilian pizza here. It features a soft dough, moist sauce, and options like marinara or vodka sauce with toppings such as pepperoni.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, truly the best I've ever tasted."

"The Sicilian pizza here had great flavors."

"The pizza slices are large, rich, and filling."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant charges $3.12 for a small bottle of water.

3

Only one vegetarian option is available on the menu.

02
Carnegie Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizza spot with a small indoor seating area and covered outdoor picnic tables. Atmosphere is comfortable and clean, with great music enhancing the vibe. The place offers a classic New York environment and a strong aroma of fresh pizza.

Slices come huge and fresh with a good selection including standout options like Hawaiian and mushroom, peppers, and onion. Garlic knots also pair well with the pizza.

Thick, square-shaped Sicilian pizza offers a crispy crust with a satisfying texture. Options include a classic low triangular slice and a white Sicilian pizza alongside varieties like chicken pizza.

People are saying

"I found the NYC pizza here to have that classic New York cheese stretch."

"The pizza slices here have a delicious, fresh crisp."

"I found the Sicilian pizza to be perfectly crispy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves late night slices right before closing.

2

The pizza place is open late on weekends.

3

There are no toilets available in the restaurant.

03
Mario's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old-school pizza joint with a retro style and Detroit-style pizza sets a unique tone. The atmosphere blends laid-back vibes with bursts of liveliness, growing quieter later at night for conversations. Super Mario arcade game adds playful charm while small size keeps it intimate.

Lunch hours offer pizza by the slice with a very big slice and thick crust. The price feels like a steal for the amount of food you get.

Square slices highlight Sicilian-style with thick crust and a crispy base. Pepperoni cups add a distinctive touch to the flavorful toppings.

People are saying

"I thought the deep dish pizza here was fantastic."

"I found the Sicilian pizza here to be fantastic."

"The Detroit style pizza slices have crispy cheese and crust."

Good to know

1

Mario's has an incredible all-day happy hour.

2

A single $25 pizza can easily feed three people.

3

Mario's can get busy on Friday or Saturday nights, so expect wait times.

04
Luigi's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny, crowded pizzeria with no indoor seating and a cash-only policy creates a grab-and-go atmosphere. Outdoor seating spills into the street, accompanied by nostalgic music and an old-school vibe. The place feels like a family-run legacy with a genuine New York pizza shop energy.

Square pizza slices stand out with a crispier crust compared to regular slices. Fresh mozzarella slices offer a tastier alternative to standard cheese, all at an affordable price.

Soft bread and a perfectly crisp crust define the Sicilian pizza here. The sauce is flavorful, and the pizza has the right height, making it both fluffy and crunchy to the bite.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best in New York."

"Giovanni sent us complimentary pizza slices to sample."

"I had never had a more delicious Sicilian pizza."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash; no credit cards are accepted.

2

Pizza slices are priced at $2.75, and soda costs $1.50.

3

They are celebrating their 50th anniversary this year.

05
Home Slice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, artsy pizza spot with outdoor seating under a covered patio and a huge pizza oven that crisps pies perfectly. Atmosphere feels chill and vibrant, welcoming groups and families with dough balls for kids to play with. A cashless setup and a small bar add to the casual, modern vibe.

Big, flavorful slices capture the essence of NY style pizza. Options include vegan slices and ordering by the slice for quick, late-night takeout.

Crust stands out as quite delicious on the Sicilian pizza. Options include the Sicilian slice and Eggplant Pie, with the Sicilian slice offering a distinctive flavor compared to other pies.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I thought their New York-style pizza slices were great."

"I thought the Sicilian pizza was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Show your voting sticker for a free slice of pizza during the election promotion.

2

Parking can be tough to find during peak hours.

3

Home Slice Pizza does not accept cash payments.

06
Famous Ben's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Local pizzeria with New York Italian vibes and a lively atmosphere featuring music and pizza dough flipping. Space is small and simple with both indoor and outdoor seating. Known for crispy, tasty pizza with a variety of popular slices.

Palermo slice stands out as a notably good pizza slice in the area. Prices for pizza slices tend to be a bit expensive. Some slices do not match the genuine New York style.

Square-cut slices highlight the thick crust and generous toppings of the Sicilian pizza. It draws families and groups who focus on this classic style for a hearty meal.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent, truly one of the best."

"I enjoyed a very good pizza slice here."

"I thought the Sicilian pizza here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only; no credit cards accepted.

2

Slices of pizza are only $3 each.

3

They always have pizza slices ready to pick up.

07
Artichoke Basille's Pizza image 1

Small space with standing tables only creates a quick, no-lingering vibe. Lack of air conditioning makes the atmosphere extremely hot and uncomfortable. Classic pizza seasonings are chained to tables, adding a unique touch to the setup.

Slices come huge and filling, often as long as a human arm. The artichoke and vodka flavor stands out with a unique and tasty combination.

Soft, airy dough with a crunchy bottom defines the Sicilian pizza here. It features a rich tomato flavor and melts in your mouth, making each slice very delicious.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was the best I ever had."

"The artichoke pizza slice was big, creamy, and absolutely delicious."

"The Sicilian pizza here is delicious with rich tomato flavor."

Good to know

1

There is no seating available, only standing tables.

2

The price of $20 for 2 slices is considered high.

3

A slice of Artichoke pizza may contain 600 - 800 calories.

08
Scarr's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant combines quintessential New York slice joint vibe with a cocktail bar in the back. Atmosphere feels crowded and lively, with plenty of seating and an NBA Jam arcade adding to the fun. Late hours and gourmet edge distinguish the experience.

Slices stand out for their authentic New York style and affordable prices. The cheese slice with jalapeรฑos and the Hotboi slice offer distinct flavors that many find delicious.

Crust stands out with a crispy texture and a garlic-based flavor, similar to Detroit style. Pizza sometimes arrives reheated but cold.

People are saying

"The Hotboi pizza was amazing and spicy."

"The Hotboi pizza slice is huge with savory, sweet, and spicy notes."

"I found the Sicilian pizza to be amazing and excellent."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait on weekends, especially during peak hours.

2

Seating inside is only available for those ordering a full pie.

3

If you want a whole pie, go inside and order at the bar.

09
Prince Street Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, crowded pizza spot with no indoor seating and limited outdoor tables creates a bustling, vibrant atmosphere. Loud, energetic vibe matches the city's pace, with 90s dance hits adding to the mood. Separate counters for slices and whole pies streamline quick orders amid the cozy, hectic setting.

Thick pizza slices come oven-heated with a sauce that complements the bread's texture. Options like the spicy vodka slice and Prince Perfection stand out for their flavor and quality.

Sicilian pizza here features a thick, square crust with a crispy bottom. The pepperoni slice stands out as a delicious example of this style.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza had the greatest slices ever."

"I thought the pizza slices were delicious and great."

"I found the Sicilian pizza to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Prince Street Pizza only accepts cash payments.

2

There is no seating available; it's primarily a takeaway place.

3

The pizza costs $8 per slice.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...