Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Sicilian pizza for takeout

A box of Sicilian pizza brought home allows for a quiet, uninterrupted meal.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Teglia Pizza Bar image 1
Teglia Pizza Bar image 2
Teglia Pizza Bar image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Tiny space with limited seating creates a takeout-focused vibe. Walls display exciting art pieces that add character. Pizza features Roman-style, thin and crunchy dough with fresh, in-house ingredients and generous toppings.

Thick crust stands out with its crunchy texture and rich flavor. Only Sicilian-style pizza is served here, focusing fully on that style.

Small interior and limited seating make it mainly a takeout spot. Food holds up well for pickup and delivery, fitting the takeout focus clearly.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've had in years."

"I thought the Sicilian pizza here was really good."

"I considered the pizza takeout to be some of the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Teglia Pizza Bar is primarily a takeout place with limited dine-in seating.

2

Parking in Montclair can be challenging, but they offer curbside pickup.

3

They only serve Sicilian pizza, crafted with sourdough dough.

02
Mario's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old-school pizza joint with a retro style and Detroit-style pizza sets a unique tone. The atmosphere blends laid-back vibes with bursts of liveliness, growing quieter later at night for conversations. Super Mario arcade game adds playful charm while small size keeps it intimate.

Square slices highlight Sicilian-style with thick crust and a crispy base. Pepperoni cups add a distinctive touch to the flavorful toppings.

Pizza and sandwiches hold up well for takeout here. Multiple orders show consistent quality and satisfaction with the takeout pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the deep dish pizza here was fantastic."

"The takeout pizza here has a fantastic thick, crunchy crust."

"I found the Sicilian pizza here to be fantastic."

Good to know

1

Mario's has an incredible all-day happy hour.

2

A single $25 pizza can easily feed three people.

3

Mario's can get busy on Friday or Saturday nights, so expect wait times.

03
St.Vito Focacceria image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with an open kitchen and rockin' music creates a cozy, intimate vibe blending Sicilian flair and Nashville grit. Guests watch chefs prepare food up close while enjoying lively energy and sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. The setting suits both dates and groups seeking unique Italian dining.

Authentic Sicilian pizza comes on a focaccia base with a thick, airy crust. The texture is heaven sent, capturing traditional flavors clearly.

Quick turnaround makes carryout convenient, with orders ready in under 10 minutes. The pre-baked focaccia helps speed up the process, though dining in offers full service and a more relaxed experience.

People are saying

"The pizza here is memorable and exceptionally delicious."

"The Sicilian Pizza here is heaven sent."

"The focaccia takeout is bready, beautiful, and absolutely luscious."

Good to know

1

The pizza pricing is $15 for a slice and $45 for a whole pie.

2

A 20% service fee is automatically added to all orders.

3

Happy hour includes a focaccia and a glass of wine.

04
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 1
Italian restaurant

Outdoor seating with spacious picnic tables and casual alfresco dining creates a lively, neighborhood atmosphere. Loud, energetic environment filled mostly with families shouting over each other. Old-school vibe offers nostalgic comfort and a no frills experience.

Thick, airy crust and a rich, sweet tomato sauce define the Sicilian pizza here. The pizza holds up well even when reheated, maintaining its distinctive flavor and texture.

Pickup happens at a separate counter, avoiding line waits. Takeout pizzas arrive piping hot and ready to eat. Boxes should be opened to check the bottom of the pizza before buying.

People are saying

"I thought their Spumoni ice cream was delicious."

"I thought the Sicilian Pizza was the best I ever had."

"The takeout sauce is top quality and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait 30 minutes outside during peak hours for a slice.

2

A tray of Sicilian pizza costs $29 and contains 12 slices.

3

Parking is not available; consider street parking around the block.

05
Dough Boyz Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with NYC subway decor and freestyle music creates an authentic New York pizza shop vibe. The atmosphere feels cozy and family-oriented, evoking a strong sense of Brooklyn. Seating is limited, with booths close to kitchen and bathroom doors, enhancing the intimate setting.

Thick, airy crust delivers a satisfying crunch with the Grandma Sicilian pizza. It features thin, crispy crust and insanely fresh ingredients that stand out.

Pickup orders focus on simple and delicious options like New York pizza, Penne Alla Vodka, and Stuffed Garlic Knots. The process for takeout is straightforward and efficient.

People are saying

"This pizza is phenomenal, just like back in New York."

"These meatballs are large, moist, and flavorful."

"The takeout crust was perfectly crisp and the cheese was bubbly."

Good to know

1

Dough Boyz Pizza charges $9.95 for a side of pasta.

2

Parking is available in the back of the building.

3

Third-party delivery services may add extra fees.

06
Solorzano's Pizzeria & Poolside Bistro image 1

Pizza restaurant combines Brooklyn-style decor with an outdoor poolside patio featuring a DJ and hookah. Atmosphere stays upbeat and lively even in the morning, with a mix of indoor and outdoor seating. Amenities include a basketball court and pond, creating a relaxed yet energetic vibe.

Slices feature a thick, well-made crust that stands out from typical versions. The pizza balances rich tomato sauce with a generous layer of cheese, delivering a classic Sicilian style.

Staff stays welcoming and professional during takeout pickups. Food, including pizza, is ready quickly and enjoyed by groups. The waiting area has a cool atmosphere.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always 10/10."

"The pizza takeout was fantastic and delicious."

"I had the best Sicilian pizza I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 12 to 3pm with unlimited pizza and drinks.

2

Karaoke nights are held on Mondays and Tuesdays for guests to enjoy.

3

The restaurant hosts Sunday Football games for sports fans.

07
Super Sardo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Narrow dining room with old school Italian decor and antique cars outside creates a New York diner vibe. Atmosphere is busy and loud, lively with friendly energy and a family-friendly feel. Outdoor patio offers clean, comfortable seating for casual dining.

Offers authentic style Sicilian pizza with a mouth-watering crust and rich flavor. The pizza also appears as a topping on a breaded fried chicken cutlet served with homemade marinara sauce.

Takeout orders include pizza and pasta with consistently excellent food quality. Customers often pick up orders in person and appear satisfied with their meals.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the pizza; it was incredibly good."

"This Sicilian pizza is the best I've had in the area."

"I thought the takeout pizza was really good."

Good to know

1

Super Sardo's Pizza closes at 9 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

You order at the counter, and food is brought to your table.

3

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

08
Home Slice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, artsy pizza spot with outdoor seating under a covered patio and a huge pizza oven that crisps pies perfectly. Atmosphere feels chill and vibrant, welcoming groups and families with dough balls for kids to play with. A cashless setup and a small bar add to the casual, modern vibe.

Crust stands out as quite delicious on the Sicilian pizza. Options include the Sicilian slice and Eggplant Pie, with the Sicilian slice offering a distinctive flavor compared to other pies.

Takeout orders arrive on time and are easy to pick up. Both Uber Eats and DoorDash handle pickups smoothly.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The pizza takeout was hot, fresh, and enormous."

"I thought the Sicilian pizza was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Show your voting sticker for a free slice of pizza during the election promotion.

2

Parking can be tough to find during peak hours.

3

Home Slice Pizza does not accept cash payments.

09
Prince Street Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, crowded pizza spot with no indoor seating and limited outdoor tables creates a bustling, vibrant atmosphere. Loud, energetic vibe matches the city's pace, with 90s dance hits adding to the mood. Separate counters for slices and whole pies streamline quick orders amid the cozy, hectic setting.

Sicilian pizza here features a thick, square crust with a crispy bottom. The pepperoni slice stands out as a delicious example of this style.

Ordering full pies ahead allows for quick pickup. Staff can split pizzas into two boxes for easier travel. Timing for pickup is usually prompt and the pizza holds up well for takeout.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza had the greatest slices ever."

"The takeout pizza here is delicious and satisfying."

"I found the Sicilian pizza to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Prince Street Pizza only accepts cash payments.

2

There is no seating available; it's primarily a takeaway place.

3

The pizza costs $8 per slice.

10
Scarr's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant combines quintessential New York slice joint vibe with a cocktail bar in the back. Atmosphere feels crowded and lively, with plenty of seating and an NBA Jam arcade adding to the fun. Late hours and gourmet edge distinguish the experience.

Crust stands out with a crispy texture and a garlic-based flavor, similar to Detroit style. Pizza sometimes arrives reheated but cold.

People are saying

"The Hotboi pizza was amazing and spicy."

"The calzone takeout was large and generously filled."

"I found the Sicilian pizza to be amazing and excellent."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait on weekends, especially during peak hours.

2

Seating inside is only available for those ordering a full pie.

3

If you want a whole pie, go inside and order at the bar.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...