Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Montclair

Pizza

Made for those who hold strong opinions on the proper ratio of crust to sauce and refuse to settle for anything less.

Based on 419 Opinions
+416
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bivio Pizza Napoletana image 1
Bivio Pizza Napoletana image 2
Bivio Pizza Napoletana image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Wood-fired oven creates a cozy atmosphere with lively energy. Pizzas boast a sourdough crust and fresh mozzarella, offering authentic Neapolitan flavors. Intimate seating and warm music make it feel like Italy in a small space.

Wood-oven pizzas feature a sourdough crust with intense tomato flavors and fresh mozzarella. Traditional Neapolitan styles like margherita and filetto offer authentic tastes, while options like the Sorrento pizza add a light lemon hint to finish the meal.

People are saying

"This pizza's authentic Neapolitan flavors are simply outstanding."

"I loved the light, authentic wood fired pizza with its perfect char."

"It's the perfect intimate atmosphere for a date night."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must as the restaurant gets full quickly.

2

The restaurant is only open on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays.

3

They do not accept walk-in customers; all reservations are made through OpenTable.

02
Teglia Pizza Bar image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny space with limited seating creates a takeout vibe. Walls show exciting art that adds character. Pizza shines with thin crunchy dough and toppings like Mortadella and artichoke.

Square pizzas feature thin and crunchy dough with delicious toppings like Mortadella and artichoke. Sweet heat stands out as a notably flavorful slice among several tasty options.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've had in years."

"The owner's passion for food ingredients and delicious treats really stands out."

"I found the best sourdough pizza in northern NJ."

Good to know

1

Teglia Pizza Bar is primarily a takeout place with limited dine-in seating.

2

Parking in Montclair can be challenging, but they offer curbside pickup.

3

They only serve Sicilian pizza, crafted with sourdough dough.

03
BOSCHETTO image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers an intimate vibe with authentic Italy decor and a spacious outdoor patio that welcomes dogs. Upscale pizzas arrive perfectly cooked, ideal for families with toddlers thanks to casual service and fresh pizza bread in dishes like chicken parmesan sandwiches.

Upscale pizza comes out perfectly cooked with no sag or burn. Fresh, made-to-order pizza bread appears in dishes like a chicken parmesan sandwich. Casual service and toddler-approved pizza make it a solid family choice.

People are saying

"The casual pizzas here have a fantastic crust and fresh ingredients."

"You have to go back for the seafood risotto; it's a must-try."

"The Funghi pizza's crust had a perfect exterior crunch and soft interior."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.

2

Free parking is available in the lot attached to the restaurant.

3

The order-at-the-counter system streamlines the dining experience.

04
Sofiaโ€™s Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with a cozy vibe and clean setting offers large slices with thick crust and unique options like Birria tacos and panini vodka pizza. Staff deliver pizza directly to your car, making pickup quick and prices fair.

Pizza comes out crispy and delicious with a solid, consistent taste. The panini vodka pizza stands out as a notable option. Staff deliver pizza directly to your car.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and crispy."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, was delicious."

"I found the food here to be excellent and fresh."

Good to know

1

Delivery is quick, arriving hot, and pickup is ready within 20 minutes.

2

Prices are fair and portions are generous.

3

The pizzeria is small, which may affect seating availability.

05
Dhamaal image 1
Indian restaurant

Indian restaurant shines with beautiful murals and a vibrant vibe. Unique pizzas like Chicken Tikka Pizza offer bold flavors. Live Bollywood music adds to the energetic atmosphere on select days.

Chicken Tikka Pizza stands out as a unique and well-crafted option. The Bombay pizza also features prominently as a favorite, showcasing a thoughtful menu with bold flavors.

People are saying

"The Indian food here is incredibly flavorful and delicious."

"The food here is bursting with flavor and presented creatively."

"The Paneer Tikka Pizza was a fun twist with Indian flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is often fully booked.

2

There is no private parking available; street or public parking is necessary.

3

Dhamaal is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

06
Soho Pizza & Grill image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with huge slices and fresh ingredients that please all ages. Generous portions and a crispy grandma pizza make meals memorable. A local neighborhood vibe creates a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere despite occasional tension.

Pizzas come with fresh ingredients and generous portions. The grandma pizza stands out as crispy and incredible, while slices are notably huge and loved by kids and adults alike.

People are saying

"This pizza is outstanding, made with fresh ingredients."

"You have to get the meatballs; they're fantastic."

"The pizza here is so kid friendly, my children adored it."

Good to know

1

Soho Pizza & Grill offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering options.

2

Portions at Soho Pizza & Grill are large, providing good value for money.

3

Prices at Soho Pizza & Grill are competitive with other local pizza places.

07
Italiana by Zod image 1
Pizza restaurant

Modern space blends rustic Italian coziness with diner-inspired decor and a custom-built Neapolitan oven that creates thin, crispy pizzas. Wood-fired pizzas include creative options like lox pizza and truffle pizza. Atmosphere is warm and stylish with energetic 90s rock music.

Wood-fired pizzas come from a custom-built Neapolitan oven that bakes at a lower temperature for a thinner, crispier crust. Unique options like lox pizza and the truffle pizza show creative twists on classic Italian styles.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the mushroom truffle pizza, was outstanding."

"The spicy kale and spinach salad was amazing."

"You have to try the mushroom truffle pizza; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant is often packed.

2

Italiana by Zod is a BYOB restaurant, so bring your favorite drinks.

3

The prices are fair for the quality of food offered.

08
Porta Montclair image 1
Restaurant

Rustic design with old doors and long wood tables sets a unique vibe. Vegan pizzas shine with strong flavors, while the rooftop patio and upstairs disco offer lively spots for dining and dancing. Atmosphere shifts from cozy to noisy, fitting diverse crowds.

Vegan pizzas stand out with strong flavors. The Margherita pizza offers a classic taste. The summer vegetable pizza brings fresh, vibrant toppings.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing and freshly baked from the oven."

"The bibb salad was beautifully dressed and presented with whole leaves."

"I enjoyed the pizza, especially the 14 1/2 pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for events, especially during busy concert nights.

2

The drag brunch happens every Sunday and features live performances.

3

Parking is available in the deck behind Porta Montclair for easy access.

Discover more

Montclair, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...