Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in California

NY style pizza

A slice of New York style pizza needs to be thin, foldable, and exactly like the ones back home. Anything else just does not feel right.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mateo Pizza Restaurant image 1
Mateo Pizza Restaurant image 2
Mateo Pizza Restaurant image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with cozy indoor and outdoor seating offers a warm, inviting atmosphere filled with traditional Turkish hospitality. The space features simple decor and a comfortable vibe, attracting those seeking authentic Mediterranean and New York style pizza experiences.

Thin, crispy lahmacun offers perfectly spiced and authentic Turkish flavors. New York style pizza and pastries also deliver genuine tastes true to their origins.

Thin crust stands out with an authentic New York style. Mediterranean influences mix with classic New York pizza flavors.

People are saying

"I've never had pizza this delicious before."

"The lahmacun here is perfectly spiced and truly authentic."

"I loved the authentic, thin, crisp New York style pizza."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers only HALAL food with no pork.

2

The restaurant remains open late for dinner.

3

It is just a few steps from downtown, making it easily accessible.

02
Bloom pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small eatery with old school ovens and authentic New York-style pizza offers a quaint, relaxing vibe enhanced by a well-chosen playlist. The space is cozy and unassuming, with limited seating and a family-owned feel. Pizza slices serve until mid-afternoon, followed by whole pies, with options including vegan and local beer.

Pizza features a New York thin crust that closely matches the authentic style. The slices deliver a perfect and very good taste that stands out in the city.

Chewy, flavorful crust defines the New York style pizza here. Pies come very close to authentic New York pizza, offering a genuine taste that matches what you'd find in NYC.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza is the closest I've found to authentic."

"I found the pizza here to be authentic and very good."

"This Italian food has that classic New York tang and chew."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers slices only until 2 pm and serves whole pies afterward.

2

There isn't much seating, but the area is adequate for dining.

3

There is easy parking available in Oakland.

03
Pit Stop Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Outdoor seating with picnic tables and umbrellas creates a hip and comfortable vibe. A drive-through window offers quick pizza slices, while games like cornhole add casual fun. The atmosphere stays peaceful and chill, welcoming families and casual diners alike.

Pizza features a crispy, flavorful New York style crust with fresh ingredients. Pasta and pizza come across as authentic and unpretentious.

Crispy and flavorful New York style pizza crust stands out here. Slices come huge and deliver an authentic taste close to what you'd find in New York.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was the best in town."

"This New York Style Pizza has a huge, delicious crust with the perfect crunch."

"I found the New York style pizza crust to be authentic, crispy, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru is for slices only and takes about 3 minutes after ordering.

2

You can order online and pick up at the drive-thru window.

3

One pizza costs $30 and typically feeds two adults and one child.

04
Bronx Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic New York-style pizzeria with old boxing photos and subway-themed decor creates an authentic, old-school family business atmosphere. Space includes takeout window and modest dine-in seating, with a lively, no-frills energy. Cash-only policy and a small step at the entrance are notable features.

Offers authentic New York-style pizza with a thin crust and classic flavors. Captures a genuine New York City atmosphere in both food and service.

Offers authentic New York style thin crust pizza that closely matches the traditional taste. Recognized consistently as the best New York style pizza in the area.

People are saying

"I found the New York style pizza to be authentic and amazing."

"You have to try their calzone; it's chef's kiss perfection."

"It's the most authentic New York-style pizza I've had."

Good to know

1

Bronx Pizza only accepts cash payments; an ATM is available inside.

2

The entrance has a half-step, which may be challenging for those with mobility issues.

3

Parking is limited, so plan accordingly when visiting.

05
Bollini's IL Forno image 1
Italian restaurant

Massive wood-fired brick oven anchors a cozy, laid-back atmosphere with soft lighting and great music. The space feels small and lively, drawing a crowd that enjoys freshly made Italian dishes and generous portions. Cash-only policy and onsite ATM add a practical note to the experience.

Tiny spot serving authentic Italian recipes with delicious traditional flavors. Focus stays on genuine Italian cuisine without shortcuts.

Crisp crust and vibrant tomato sauce define the New York style pizza here. Melty mozzarella with a wood-fired smoky edge completes the flavor.

People are saying

"The food here tastes like Nonna used to make."

"I experienced delicious, authentic Italian food here."

"The New York Style Pizza has a perfect crisp crust and vibrant sauce."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash payments, so bring cash.

2

There is an ATM onsite for convenience if you forget cash.

3

All dishes are made fresh to order with no freezers used.

06
Esco's New York Style Pizza image 1

Indoor space features a New York subway train car and graffiti art, creating a strong urban vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting with a casual, no-fuss energy. Small seating area contrasts with a lively outdoor patio and event space with a DJ booth.

Huge pies capture the authentic New York style with a thin crust and classic toppings. East Coast natives find the pizza tasty and true to NYC standards.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a focus on the margherita slice. Provides curbside pickup for convenience.

People are saying

"I thought their vegan pizza was the best I ever had."

"This New York Style Pizza is as close as you'll get to the real thing."

"This is the authentic New York pizza I was looking for."

Good to know

1

A slice of pizza costs $6.

2

There is a parking lot available, but it can be inconvenient due to traffic.

3

Esco's New York Style Pizza does not accept EBT Food.

07
Rozzi Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Window service connects kitchen with two bars, creating a casual, straightforward setup. Outdoor seating features cozy patio with checkered tablecloths, offering a relaxed vibe despite limited space. Energy builds with a steady line at a small kiosk, reflecting a focus on authentic New York-style pizza and efficient takeout and delivery.

Pizza features an authentic crust, toppings, and sauce that reflect New York style. Staff includes a native New Yorker who adds to the genuine vibe.

Pizza offers a very authentic New York style with a classic thin crust and traditional toppings. Staff consistently deliver delicious slices that capture the essence of New York pizza.

People are saying

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be super authentic."

"This place's Date Spots serve outstanding, NYC-style pizza."

"I found the New York-style pizza here to be the real deal."

Good to know

1

Finding parking on a busy night can be challenging.

2

The restaurant has limited seating in front.

3

They offer takeout and delivery services.

08
Big Oven Pizza Kearny Mesa image 1

Big Oven Pizza offers Detroit-style pizza in a clean, well-lit space with a cozy, laid-back vibe. The atmosphere feels friendly and relaxed, with table games adding casual entertainment. Large slices and reasonable draft beer prices complement the experience.

New York-style pizza and Neapolitan pizza both come through with authentic flavors. The restaurant offers a genuine Italian experience that matches traditional expectations.

Slices offer authentic New York style with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. Staff bring genuine NY pizza expertise, delivering a classic taste whether dining in or grabbing to go.

People are saying

"I found the pizza simple, delicious, and perfectly crusty."

"This authentic New York-style pizza has a thin, foldable crust."

"This New York Style Pizza is the real deal, taking me straight back to NYC."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers large pizza slices, perfect for sharing.

2

Prices for pizzas are reasonable considering the portion sizes.

3

They provide options for both 10-inch and 18-inch pizzas.

09
Upper East Slice image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers modern remodeled interior with a sweet, friendly vibe. It serves authentic New York style pizza with a variety of options, including Sicilian thick crust. The place features daily lunch specials and fresh dough sold on-site.

Slices serve authentic New York style pizza with a clear East Coast influence. The food consistently tastes genuine and traditional.

Great thin crust pizza captures the classic New York style. It offers an authentic taste close to what you'd find back east, standing out in the region.

People are saying

"I found this New York Style Pizza to be authentic, just like back east."

"The lunch special is a great deal for two slices and a drink."

"I found the pizza to be authentic New York style."

Good to know

1

The daily lunch slice special offers two slices and a drink for $9.

2

The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming environment.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for all purchases.

10
Mama's Boy image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious pizza restaurant with upstairs mezzanine seating overlooking a lively street scene. Atmosphere blends New York pizzeria vibes with a casual, chill energy and often loud music. Frequented during busy events, it offers a fun, social setting with friendly staff and classic arcade games.

Pizza features an authentic crust and homemade ranch. It captures the NYC slice vibe, similar to East Village and Bleecker Street styles.

Slices have a classic thin crust with a foldable structure typical of New York style pizza. Toppings spread evenly with a balance of sauce and cheese that matches the authentic New York flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best slice in the Bay Area."

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was the best I ever had."

"This pizza has an authentic, foldable NYC-style crust."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Meatball Wednesday features a special meatball sub available only on that day.

3

Pizza by the slice is available, making it a quick option for lunch.

11
Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market image 1

Small, busy pizzeria with a hole-in-the-wall vibe and NYC-style decor creates a cozy neighborhood atmosphere. Loud, blaring music fills the space, contributing to a fun, lively energy. Outdoor picnic tables offer additional seating beyond the limited indoor spots.

Large, authentic New York style pizza comes by the pie or slice. The menu includes New York style pasta dishes and ships in authentic black and white cookies from New York.

Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a true East Coast vibe. The crust, sauce, and cheese come together to deliver legit NY pizza that satisfies cravings for classic slices.

People are saying

"I found the most authentic New York style pizza here."

"I thought the meatballs were delicious and great."

"I found the authentic New York style pizza here."

Good to know

1

The place is mainly for takeout with limited seating inside or outside.

2

A staff member mentioned they shut off internet ordering when busy.

3

Order ahead on weekends as they can get quite busy.

12
Brooklyn Square image 1
Pizza restaurant

Square pies deliver authentic New York-style pizza with a perfect crust and fresh, sweet sauce. Stand-and-eat counters create a convenient, quick meal atmosphere with chill vibes. The menu includes high-quality toppings and notable items like spicy pepperoni and pastrami sandwiches.

Pizza here has a true authentic New York-style with a thin crust and classic toppings. It stands out as authentic New York-style pizza even though it's in Southern California.

Thin crust slices deliver a tasty and authentic New York pizza experience. The style stays true to classic Brooklyn flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I thought this New York Style Pizza was the best around."

"I thought it was the best pizza I'd ever had."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is available and easy to use.

2

Pizza is sold by the slice or as a whole pie.

3

Expect a wait time of about 15-20 minutes for fresh pizzas.

13
San Biagio's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Unassuming spot with New York-style pizza captures authentic flavors and family pride. Warm, welcoming atmosphere feels like a mom-and-pop neighborhood treasure. Outdoor seating and TVs add casual comfort to the experience.

Pizza dough, stromboli, and calzone are all authentic and homemade. The pizza serves New York-style thin crust with options like White Pizza without sauce that match East Coast flavors.

Slices deliver a real-deal, authentic New York pizza experience. The shop feels like a classic New York pizza joint with NY style pizza that stays true to its roots.

People are saying

"The owners make you feel right at home with their genuine hospitality."

"I enjoyed the authentic New York Style Pizza here."

"I always found the Calzone to be the best."

Good to know

1

The pizza costs around $40 for a full order.

2

Single slices and combo prices are very affordable.

3

The restaurant has a casual atmosphere and is family-owned.

14
Colosseum New York Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with New York memorabilia and old school vibe creates a casual, inviting atmosphere. Seating is limited with a no-frills setup and some TVs adding to the experience. The place offers an authentic East Coast pizza feel that stands out in the area.

Pizza here delivers authentic New York style with a real deal taste. It stands out as one of the few places offering genuine NYC slices outside the East Coast.

Slices deliver a legit New York pizza experience with a thin, foldable crust and classic toppings. This spot offers authentic flavor that feels like home for New York pizza lovers.

People are saying

"The pizza here has a perfectly baked crust and fresh toppings."

"I found the pizza to be authentic New York style."

"This New York Style Pizza really feels like home."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only, so bring cash for your order.

2

There is very limited seating available inside the restaurant.

3

Colosseum New York Pizza offers takeout only as of 03/13/23.

15
Brooklyn Brick Oven Pizza image 1

Pizza restaurant with old-style Brooklyn decor and arcade machines creates a cozy, authentic vibe. TVs show sports at low volume, fostering a friendly atmosphere. The place draws those seeking New York-style pizza in a casual setting.

Pizza serves authentic New York style with good quality and delicious taste. Atmosphere feels friendly and authentic.

Authentic New York style pizza shines here with every bite reminding why it's famous worldwide. Quality and flavor match what you'd find in New York, making it a reliable spot for genuine NY pizza.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I found this place delivers authentic New York Style Pizza."

"This New York style pizza is so authentic, it's like a delightful reminder of why it's renowned."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking in the open-air lot adjacent to PCH.

2

The cleanliness of the restaurant is very good.

3

The pizzeria uses all fresh ingredients and makes everything to order from scratch.

16
Graziano's Pizza Oceanside image 1

Red and black booth chairs fill a clean space with lots of seats and plugs. The vibe stays cool and family-friendly, with a chill but diligent staff. Expect a casual atmosphere suited for quick meals rather than intimate dining.

Everything features fresh ingredients and stays true to authentic Italian recipes. The flavors reflect classic Italian cooking without shortcuts.

Slices have a thin, crisp crust and a classic New York flavor. The pizza offers a balanced cheese and sauce ratio that matches what you'd find in New York.

People are saying

"This is the best New York Style Pizza I've had in California."

"I thought the pasta dishes were amazing and delicious."

"This pizza is the best I've had in California."

Good to know

1

A pizza can take 30 to 45 minutes to be ready during busy times.

2

I recommend ordering ahead or expecting to line.

3

Dining in may not be ideal due to lack of air conditioning.

17
A Brooklyn Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot offers authentic New York-style pies with thin, crispy crusts and high-quality cheese. Atmosphere suits takeout-focused, cozy vibes rather than dine-in. Known for fresh ingredients and fair prices.

Tiny New York-style pizza comes with delicious toppings and a crisp crust. Service feels friendly and authentic.

Thin and crispy slices capture the authentic New York style perfectly. The plain slice keeps it simple and true to the classic New York pizza experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"This New York Style Pizza is the best I've had in California."

"The food here is delicious with generous portions."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers a deal of two slices and a drink for $10.

2

A slice costs $4.25, making it affordable for a quick meal.

3

Be mindful, it is a small place with limited seating.

18
Weirdoughโ€™s image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers a family vibe with a home kitchen atmosphere and a groovy R&B playlist playing softly. The space feels welcoming and neighborhood-focused, inviting relaxed conversations alongside carefully crafted pies. Fresh ingredients and a brick oven create distinctive New York and Sicilian-style pizzas with notable crunch and flavor.

Food reflects authentic Sicilian Italian cuisine with a focus on homemade pizza. New York-style pizza by the slice is rare and often differs from true East Coast flavors.

Slices offer a classic New York style with a thin, foldable crust and simple toppings. The pizza tastes well-seasoned but leans toward milder flavors compared to authentic New York pies.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've ever had."

"I found it hard to find authentic New York style pizza sold by the slice."

"I found the best New York Style Pizza in Burbank."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, and seating is limited due to the small size of the restaurant.

2

Expect a $1.15 credit card fee added to your bill.

3

The price for a pizza is around $25, but check your total against the menu.

19
Brooklynz Pizza Rancho Cucamonga image 1

Small space with sports on TV and a mini pool table creates a chill, inviting vibe. Atmosphere feels like authentic Brooklyn, though it can get hot inside. Known for excellent New York style pizza that stands out in the area.

Pizza crusts here tend to be thicker than authentic NYC style. The flavor does not match the classic NYC taste many expect from New York-style pizza.

Slices have a thin crust with a bit of chew and a slight flop when held. The pizza captures the classic New York style well, offering a taste close to what you'd find in the city.

People are saying

"I finally found authentic New York style pizza here."

"The pizza here is a flavor explosion, perfect for date spots."

"It's the only truly New York style pizza in the area."

Good to know

1

They sell pizza by the slice for $3.50, but only have one very large size.

2

The 2 slice combo comes with a drink for $8.50, and the slices are decently sized.

3

The restaurant offers plenty of parking and has a spacious seating area.

20
Bonello's New York Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school New York pizza parlor with a family-run feel and lively atmosphere. Interior and vibe evoke an authentic New York style experience. Known for large slices and quality ingredients, it offers some of the best pizza in the area.

The pizza has a doughy, buttery crust that differs from authentic New York style. The place offers a family-run, casual vibe reminiscent of a neighborhood spot but lacks the true New York pizza feel.

A humble spot with family owned roots serves pizza that feels like an old school New York slice. The pizza hits most marks of New York style but falls just short of full authenticity.

People are saying

"This family-owned spot offers amazing New York Style Pizza."

"I found the chicken salad to be very tasty."

"I felt like I was back in NYC with their authentic pizza."

Good to know

1

The pizza slices cost only $3.5 each.

2

The menu on the board is hard to see; no other menus are available.

3

Bonello's is family-run and extremely friendly.

21
Johnny's The Bronx Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with old-school New York vibe and cozy seating, including some tables with umbrellas outside. Atmosphere stays super chill and welcoming, even when busy with people and street activity. Known for quality, fast service and reasonably priced pizzas that offer a lighter, fresh taste.

Pizza features a thin crispy crust and top-quality cheese that matches authentic New York style. Garlic and oregano on the table add classic touches, and pizzas come on paper plates like in New York.

Slices come thin, crispy, and chewy, matching authentic New York pizza closely. The pizza offers a genuine New York style experience that many find worth the drive.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza tastes like the real thing from the Bronx."

"This lunch spot's pizza is cheesy, delicious, and never floppy."

"This pizza is the authentic New York style I've been looking for."

Good to know

1

Parking is street parking with plenty of spots around.

2

Expect a wait time of up to 1 hour for delivery.

3

The restaurant has limited dine-in seating available.

22
Brooklyn Boyz Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small rectangular space decorated with New York and Brooklyn paraphernalia creates a cozy, calm vibe. Music and sports on TV add to a fun atmosphere reminiscent of East Coast pizza spots. Known for authentic Brooklyn-style pizza with fresh toppings and a crust that matches New York standards.

Slices feature authentic Brooklyn-style crust and toppings. The pizza delivers classic New York flavor with every bite.

Authentic Brooklyn-style pizza shines here with ingredients from Roma distributor. Eggplant and chicken rolls match the classic New York flavor closely.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza tastes like it came straight out of Brooklyn."

"I found authentic New York pizza with a thin, crisp, foldable crust."

"I've been getting their meatballs for years and they're still the best."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, and seating is limited to three small tables.

2

The restaurant is currently closed for renovations but will reopen soon.

3

You can buy pizza by the slice, which is a convenient option.

23
Freddy's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small family-owned pizza spot offers East Coast-style pizza with thin crust and fresh toppings. Atmosphere suits family and friends, though some areas feel underused. Locals appreciate its authentic Italian flavors and variety beyond typical chains.

Authentic New York style pizza and calzones feature high quality ingredients and perfect cooking. Staff greet with NY flair, calling customers "boss."

Pizza here matches authentic New York style closely with thin crust and classic toppings. Calzones also follow the same New York style tradition.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and authentic."

"I thought the pizza here had authentic New York style."

"I thought this was supposed to be authentic New York style pizza."

Good to know

1

Freddy's Pizza offers a 20-inch pizza for large groups.

2

Expect large portion sizes, ideal for sharing.

3

Freddy's Pizza serves pizza, subs, and calzones.

24
Slice House by Tony Gemignani image 1

Spacious pizza restaurant with plenty of seating and a Brooklyn vibe. Atmosphere is loud and lively, often filled with families and kids. Offers Detroit style and deep dish pizza with a focus on quality and variety.

Pizza features a crispy thin crust and stays true to NY style. Chef Tony Gemignani brings award-winning expertise to authentic recipes.

Crispy thin crust stands out as a key feature of the authentic New York style pizza here. Opinions vary, with some finding it impressive and others less so.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best pizza I had ever eaten."

"The NYC-style pizza is authentic with a thin, crispy crust."

"I thought the New York style pizza was authentic with a crispy thin crust."

Good to know

1

The slices cost $6.95 each, which may affect your decision to return.

2

Parking is easy because the malls have garages nearby.

3

The lunch special offers a slice, salad, and drink at a reasonable price.

25
Mike's New York Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Understated storefront with limited seating and parking creates a casual, welcoming vibe suited for families and coworkers. Pizza offers authentic New York style crust and large portions, often enjoyed as takeout. Wings stand out with juicy, flavorful heat that draws praise.

Pizza features a New York-style crust that some find authentic and true to East Coast tradition. Opinions vary, with some noting it does not fully match the authentic NYC pizza experience.

Thin crust and good sauce define the pizza, with a slight oiliness from the pepperoni that matches New York style. Prices run higher than typical New York slices.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza is truly authentic and has a thin crust."

"The parking here is really tight."

"It's authentic New York style pizza with a thin crust."

Good to know

1

Parking is available and free, making it convenient for visitors.

2

Seating is limited, so most customers likely order takeout.

3

They offer gluten-free pizza options for those with dietary restrictions.

Discover more

California

Area guide
Loading Map...