Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Ice cream sandwich shops

Finding a sandwich shop that actually takes its ice cream seriously, rather than treating it like an afterthought.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mashti Malone’s image 1
Mashti Malone’s image 2
Mashti Malone’s image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers unique flavors with natural ingredients and vegan options. Outdoor seating creates a cozy, inviting vibe perfect for people watching and enjoying the neighborhood atmosphere. Inside feels warm but simple, while music and small activities add to the fun experience.

Offers Persian flavors like rosewater, saffron, and pistachio that stand out from typical ice cream shops. The shop feels unique and delivers a tasty experience.

Signature Mashti sandwich features ice cream nestled between two crisp wafers. Saffron ice cream sandwich stands out as a lighter alternative to traditional options.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."

"The ice cream shop's unique Persian flavors are rich and memorable."

"I loved the Mashti wafer sandwich; it's a lighter alternative."

Good to know

1

Mashti Malone’s offers a variety of unique ice cream flavors, including vegan options.

2

Parking is available on the street near Mashti Malone’s.

3

Mashti Malone’s closes at 11 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

02
Lana's image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Bright, clean space with classic diner vibe and cute color stools creates a relaxed atmosphere. Music adds to the welcoming, nostalgic energy. Known for smash burgers and top-tier ice cream, it draws locals seeking quality and comfort.

Super cute shop offers unique and traditional flavors with a large serving size that equals 2-3 scoops elsewhere. Staff are friendly and the vibe blends old-fashioned charm with a modern twist.

Crispy, well-seasoned chicken thighs with amazing batter define the fried chicken sandwiches here. Smash burgers and juicy Deluxe Fried Chicken Sandwiches also stand out for their flavorful punch.

People are saying

"Their unique rotating ice cream flavors are top tier."

"The fried chicken sandwich is crispy, juicy, and fire."

"You have to try the banana Oreo ice cream; it's the best."

Good to know

1

Lana's offers dairy-free options for those who are lactose intolerant.

2

Expect to pay around $55 for a meal for four without drinks.

3

The restaurant is known for its large serving sizes, equivalent to 2-3 scoops at other shops.

03
Manhattan Beach Creamery image 1

Ice cream shop offers colorful decor and small outdoor seating with a nostalgic ambiance. It features a wide variety of flavors and creative ice cream sandwiches. Atmosphere is lively and pleasant, attracting those seeking a sweet treat near the beach.

Lines form often at this cute ice cream shop that also features a mini gift shop. The space feels adorable and inviting for ice cream lovers.

Made-to-order ice cream sandwiches stand out with the Salted Caramel Sandwich being a popular choice. These sandwiches are delicious but can get messy when eating.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was rich and smooth."

"I loved the cheesecake flavors and chocolate-covered bananas."

"I loved the ice cream sandwich, especially the cookie dough flavor."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and products.

2

Expect long lines, but they move quickly.

3

Ice cream sandwiches can be customized with any cookie and ice cream.

04
Curbside Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Tiny ice cream shop with outdoor seating in a quaint alley creates a familial, jovial atmosphere. Offers a wide selection of vegan and dairy options, including on-site waffle cones and rotating soft serve flavors. Lines form during warm weather, and the place stays open late into the evening.

Ice cream sandwiches feature brilliant cookies like ginger snaps and vanilla shortbread. Creative flavors include Earl Grey with English shortbread and mint chocolate chip with chocolate cookies. Many options are vegan-friendly.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so delicious and flavor forward."

"Their ice cream sandwiches have brilliant cookies and creative flavors."

"The ice cream shop has delicious vegan butter pecan and creative Mexican chocolate flavors."

Good to know

1

Every Thursday, they create a new soft-serve ice cream flavor.

2

Expect long lines during the summer months.

3

Curbside Creamery does not allow samples of their ice cream.

05
Handel's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Old school style window kiosk creates a small town vibe with over 20 homemade flavors offered. The atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, drawing a friendly local crowd despite limited shaded seating outside.

Homemade ice cream stands out here, with the shop known for its clean environment. It opens at noon and offers a variety of flavors in a local favorite setting.

Ice cream sandwiches come with two large Oreo cookies and a half scoop of ice cream, making them surprisingly small. They arrive individually wrapped and can feel like a waste of money due to their size.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was outstanding and delicious."

"This ice cream shop has the best, most delicious flavors I've ever had."

"They wrapped the ice cream sandwiches individually for me."

Good to know

1

Handel's Ice Cream offers over 20 homemade flavors to choose from.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Handicap parking is available, along with additional parking options.

06
Kulfi Me image 1
Ice cream shop

Modern ice cream shop with a trendy atmosphere and cozy vibe featuring sunset views and beautiful music. The space is tastefully decorated and clean, seating is limited but the environment feels spacious. Regular impromptu dances add a fun, lively touch to the experience.

Paneer sandwich stands out with rich flavors, paired well with the samosa sandwich that packs a bold taste. The menu also includes various Chaat street food bites alongside these savory sandwiches.

People are saying

"The Malai Kulfi is so creamy and rich with authentic flavor."

"I loved the paneer sandwich and rose kulfi."

"The ice cream flavors here are great and unique."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the back of the establishment.

2

The place is dog-friendly, offering a special doggy Kulfi.

3

Expect limited seating, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

07
Knudsen's Restaurant-Ice Creamery image 1

Old-fashioned ice cream parlor with spacious seating and 50s diner vibe offers a family-friendly atmosphere filled with quarter machines for kids. The mood stays casual and welcoming, making it suitable for group celebrations. Ice cream stands out as the main attraction, known for being rich and creamy.

Offers a truly old school ice cream experience with diner food available. The parlor is one of the biggest around, serving ice cream that stands out from others.

Sandwiches feature crab, Dijon artichoke, and classic options like club and BLT. Combos often include fries and soup, with prices around $18 for a half crab sandwich and soup.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so delicious and creamy."

"The ice cream servings here are huge, easily feeding two."

"I highly recommend this ice cream shop; it's the best!"

Good to know

1

The ice cream is $8 per cup, which some find expensive.

2

They allow sampling of ice cream before ordering.

3

Parking can be challenging to find nearby.

08
Hans' Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Old-school ice cream parlor with a 1950s vibe and cozy, tight seating. Atmosphere feels dated and musty but retains a charming, nostalgic quality. Crowded with people drawn by a wide variety of unique flavors.

Ice cream here has an old-school vibe like a 1950s parlor. They do not offer samples, which is unusual for an ice cream shop.

Egg salad sandwich on rye and house salad come as a filling combo. Some sandwiches like the Rueben are tasty, but wait times can reach 40 minutes and prices feel high for the quality.

People are saying

"The ice cream has such interesting and unique flavors."

"I found the sandwiches here to be very tasty and delicious."

"The ice cream shop has great pricing and a wide variety of flavors."

Good to know

1

Hans' Homemade Ice Cream does not offer samples, which may affect your choice.

2

The shop has a variety of unique flavors worth trying.

3

Parking is readily available around the shop.

Discover more

California

Area guide
Loading Map...