Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
South Montebello's best

Pizza spots

Made for those who view pizza as a non-negotiable food group and prioritize finding the right crust and toppings above all else.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Hole in One bar and grill image 1
Hole in One bar and grill image 2
Hole in One bar and grill image 3
View all

Bar and grill combines split seating areas with plenty of TVs and an AMI jukebox to create a lively yet comfortable atmosphere. Music, comedy, and sports entertainment keep energy varied, while covered patio seating offers a relaxed option. Locals gather here for a mix of chill vibes and spirited sports viewing.

Food here stands out for its delicious taste and large portions. The menu consistently delivers excellent quality that pairs well with drinks.

Fresh pizza features pepperoni, onion, and mushroom toppings. The pizza looks delicious and tastes great.

People are saying

"The hospitality at this Local Spot is so rare and exceptional."

"I found the food here to be super delicious."

"I loved eating delicious pizza here."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays, they offer $3 beers with chips and salsa.

2

Live music happens every Saturday night.

3

Karaoke takes place on Wednesdays and Sundays.

02
Rio's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers arcade machines, TVs with games, and ice-cold beer in a family-friendly setting. Atmosphere is casual with good music and a vibe suited for watching games. Pizza stands out as consistently flavorful and highly regarded.

Food arrives fresh and hot with a punch to the taste buds. Staff delivers timely service and goes the extra mile to create a welcoming atmosphere.

Pizza here has a crisp crust with great flavor and texture. Sauce is used sparingly, avoiding the heavy, soggy feel common elsewhere.

People are saying

"I thought Rio's Pizza had the best pizza in town."

"I found the food here to be great."

"The beer here is ice-cold and enjoyable."

Good to know

1

Calling ahead to order usually results in the pizza being ready in 20 minutes.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The menu is a bit pricey, but portions are good for families.

03
BJ's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant combines sports bar vibe with flat-screen TVs and arcade games creating a lively, noisy atmosphere. Families and sports fans gather to enjoy Philly/New York style pizza alongside cold beer and games. Multiple TVs often show the same game, enhancing the communal energy.

Food here is consistently delicious and very good, with the Mexican Pizza standing out as especially tasty.

Philly/New York style pizza stands out with a slightly burned, crunchy crust that adds flavor. The Margherita pizza and wings pair well, and the staff know their pizza well.

People are saying

"I thought BJ's Pizzeria had the best tasting pizza."

"It's a great place to watch live sports with lots of TVs and arcade games."

"The food here is delicious and freshly made."

Good to know

1

They add a $5.00 delivery charge upfront.

2

A two slices of pizza and a drink cost $9.00 plus tax on weekdays.

3

They estimated a 40-minute delivery time for local orders.

04
JC's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Local neighborhood pizzeria offers family-owned charm with reasonable prices and fresh, tasty pizza. Atmosphere feels quiet and laid-back, suited for casual dining or takeout. Known for specials and quality ingredients without shortcuts like cheap plastic cheese.

Food here ranges from good to just okay with no standout dishes. Expect simple flavors without much excitement.

Pizza here is really fresh with excellent quality and delicious flavor. Prices stay reasonable while service remains fast and friendly.

People are saying

"I've had the best pizza here for 12 years."

"The food here was just okay, nothing special."

Good to know

1

JC's Pizza offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly choice.

3

Look out for daily specials that provide great value.

05
Gina's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizza restaurant with vibrant music and good seating arrangement creates a welcoming atmosphere. Offers both thin and thick crust pizza with a reputation for authentic pizzas. Open late, attracting those seeking fresh, satisfying pizza in a clean setting.

Food comes out freshly made and delicious with fast service. Ravioli with pink sauce stands out as a notable dish that captures authentic Italian flavors.

Offers both thin and thick crust pizzas with fresh oven-baked quality. The Margherita pizza stands out, alongside satisfying options like wings and bread sticks.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be extremely good and delicious."

"I heard the pasta here is amazing, just like the pizza."

"The pasta sauce here is exactly how I like it."

Good to know

1

Gina's Pizzeria is open late, making it a great after-hours option.

2

They stopped delivering after a certain time at night, so plan accordingly.

3

The price of a large pizza has increased to over $30.

06
Paradise Buffet Montebello image 1

Large dining hall with ample seating hosts loud, busy atmosphere filled mostly with families. Mongolian grill and fresh sushi bar offer interactive food experiences amid clean, well-organized layout. Decor is simple but functional, supporting big groups and casual occasions.

Food offers an awesome variety with amazing quality that stands out from typical buffets. Dishes consistently taste great and satisfy different preferences.

Buffet includes pizza alongside sushi, fried chicken, and a Mongolian grill. Pizza appears as a common and enjoyed option among the variety of foods.

People are saying

"This buffet has amazing food and is great for the money."

"I found the food to be good and fresh."

"The buffet had pizza alongside sushi and other Asian foods."

Good to know

1

The buffet offers a two-hour time limit for dining.

2

Birthday celebrants receive a free meal with a minimum group of three.

3

Dinner costs $20 per person, providing good value.

07
AWSOM Wings Pizza & Burgers image 1
Chicken wings restaurant

Chicken wings restaurant with loud explicit music and many TVs for games creates a lively weekend atmosphere. The menu features extra crispy large wings and unique items like garlic parmesan wings and ranch blasted fries. Prices are high, and the air conditioning runs very cold inside.

Food arrives quickly and stays consistently great. The menu features wings, pizza, and burgers with a solid reputation for delicious flavors.

Perfect crust and great seasoned breading stand out on the pizzas. The Godfather pizza is amazing and the pies arrive warm and delicious.

People are saying

"The pizza crust here is great and the toppings are fresh."

"I thought the food tasted great."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy and free.

2

They also offer delivery.

3

The menu is diverse with a good selection of toppings.

08
Redwood Pizza and Wings image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with limited seating and a focus on takeout offers crispy thin crust and gourmet pastrami pizza. Atmosphere is quiet with no crowd, and wait times average around 15 minutes. Prices lean toward the higher side compared to typical small business pizza places.

Food shows good quality and great taste consistently. Prices match the quality, but customers should check their food before leaving.

Pizza comes out hot and fresh with a perfectly cooked crust that highlights the quality of toppings. Unique options like the gourmet pastrami pizza with mustard and pickles stand out alongside well-balanced veggie lovers pizza.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I'd had in a long time."

"I thought the food was awesome, especially the pizza."

"I tried their special potato rounds, which tasted homemade."

Good to know

1

The wait time for pizza is about 15 minutes on average.

2

There are two tables for customers, but the inside is very small.

3

The large pizza costs about 30 dollars and has 3 toppings.

Discover more

South Montebello, Montebello

Area guide
Loading Map...