Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Colorado Springs' best

Jewelry stores

Made for those who view jewelry as a permanent investment and refuse to settle for anything less than high-quality craftsmanship.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Legacy & Co. Jewelers image 1
Legacy & Co. Jewelers image 2
Legacy & Co. Jewelers image 3
View all

Store blends a relaxed vibe with charismatic knowledge and a friendly mascot dog. Jewelry shines in illuminated ring boxes. Known for trusted repair services, it meets all family jewelry needs.

Trusted for jewelry repair and family needs, this store serves as a reliable spot for all jewelry services. Many rely on it exclusively for jewelry care and recommend it widely.

People are saying

"They fixed and resized my rings, and it all fit perfectly."

"This Local Spot's staff is so knowledgeable and attentive to your needs."

"This jewelry store's staff is so helpful and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

They charged $134 for four repairs, including re-stringing a pearl necklace.

2

The repair process is quick and easy.

3

Legacy is a local business known for incredible customer service.

02
Jstar Jewelry Designs image 1

Bright, clean space offers handmade jewelry with affordable prices. Welcoming atmosphere includes a permanent jewelry station for custom fittings. Perfect for unique, well-made gifts in a cheerful setting.

Unique and handmade jewelry fills the shop, with a focus on permanent bracelets that are carefully fitted and welded. The store offers affordable pieces made by a local artist and provides attentive customer service.

People are saying

"I highly recommend this jewelry store for modern, trendy pieces."

"It's so kid friendly; the owner is patient and understanding with curious kids."

"The owner is so kind and helped me pick out permanent jewelry."

Good to know

1

A permanent jewelry station is available for quick and easy service.

2

The shop features a wide selection of unique, handmade jewelry.

3

Prices are reasonable, making it accessible for most budgets.

03
McNulty Jewelers image 1

Jewelry shop offers custom designs and expert ring sizing repairs with fair prices. Friendly dog adds charm, creating a local feel that welcomes visitors. Meticulous craftsmanship shines in watch battery replacements and jewelry polishing.

Repairs include ring sizing, opal replacement, and fixing badly damaged wedding rings. Jewelry cleaning and polishing restore heirloom pieces to look brand new. The store offers customized jewelry creation and a small, unique selection to browse while waiting.

People are saying

"I had my wedding rings resized and they look beautiful."

"I got my watch fixed fast, and the service was really kind."

"I had my wedding rings resized and cleaned at this jewelry store."

Good to know

1

Expect a quick turnaround time for most jewelry repairs.

2

They provide watch battery replacements with reliable service.

3

Customers should follow up regarding ring readiness for timely pickup.

04
Starlette by Tendeza Moda image 1

Jewelry shines with mossanite stones that stay bright and suit sensitive ears. Prices are affordable and shipping is fast. Popular engagement and wedding styles often sell out quickly.

Rings and earrings feature mossanite stones that do not tarnish or discolor. Jewelry looks very real and suits sensitive ears well. Quality stays intact for over a year, with excellent customer service available for questions.

People are saying

"I found the rings at the Ring Store to be gorgeous and pretty."

"This jewelry store's rings look so real, no one knows they aren't diamonds."

"This Necklace Store's jewelry stays beautiful even after years of wear."

Good to know

1

Shipping is very fast, with delivery typically within a week.

2

The jewelry from Starlette Galleria looks realistic and I feel proud when I wear it.

3

The quality of the rings is amazing, resembling real diamonds.

05
Meraki Springs image 1
Jewelry designer

Shop blends welded bracelets with local art and creative workshops. Visitors enjoy hands-on jewelry classes and find unique candles and home decor. Staff offers custom jewelry welding and personalized shipping in a peaceful, welcoming space.

Permanent jewelry includes welded bracelets and permanent bracelets crafted with care. Jewelry classes offer hands-on fun, and the shop sells affordable earrings and accessories.

People are saying

"I highly recommend taking their fun classes; they make them so enjoyable."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so kind and helpful."

"I found beautiful art and jewelry in their galleries."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for all classes to secure your spot.

2

Classes include soap making, candle making, and jewelry workshops.

3

The witch hat decorating class is a seasonal favorite.

06
Berges Jewelry Design image 1

Showroom offers custom jewelry with flawless craftsmanship and expert repair. Owner provides honest assessments and tailored advice. Family-run vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere with fair pricing and trusted service.

Custom jewelry creation and expert repair services stand out here. The owner personally examines each piece, offering honest assessments and tailored recommendations for long-term wear.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's staff is so kind and treats you with respect."

"The staff at this Ring Store treated me with kindness and respect."

Good to know

1

Berges Jewelry Design is a reliable family-owned jeweler known for quality service.

2

They offer in-house repairs, ensuring quick turnaround times for customers.

3

Prices are fair and competitive compared to other local jewelers.

07
Velez Galleries image 1

Gallery offers authentic Native American art and handcrafted silver jewelry with a welcoming vibe. Owner creates custom turquoise pieces with care. Friendly dogs add to the open, inviting atmosphere.

Thousands of unique pieces fill the store, focusing on silver and turquoise jewelry. The owner crafts jewelry by hand with love and care and offers custom creations with professional sterling silver mounts.

People are saying

"The Galleries here have beautiful art from all over the Americas."

"I found unique, unusual, and eye-catching jewelry here."

"I found unique, beautiful jewelry pieces here."

Good to know

1

The gallery accepts credit cards but charges an extra fee for their use.

2

Expect to find unique handmade jewelry and crafts from various indigenous cultures.

3

Prices vary, allowing for affordable options alongside high-end pieces.

08
Luisa Graff Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store shines with flawless craftsmanship on rings and necklaces. Staff create a warm family atmosphere with friendly, knowledgeable service. Visitors enjoy a pressure-free environment and thoughtful perks like drinks and a kids' play area.

Rings and fine jewelry show flawless craftsmanship and professional cleaning and repairs are available. Customers return for wedding and engagement rings, as well as earrings and necklaces.

People are saying

"The staff here helped me find the perfect ring with patience and expert advice."

"They offered me coffee and a warm cookie upon arrival."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and patient."

Good to know

1

Ladies Night events occur monthly, offering exclusive discounts and refreshments.

2

The store has a convenient location with ample parking available.

3

Reservations are not required for events, but arriving early is recommended.

09
Jack Miller Jewelry Designers image 1

Jewelry store shines with custom designs and expert craftsmanship. Offers wedding ring care and reliable repairs. Fair prices and quick service make it a great spot for jewelry needs.

Exquisite design and trustworthy service define this jewelry store. It offers custom pieces and expert care for wedding rings with dependable craftsmanship.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so kind and provide amazing service."

"The staff at this Ring Store are incredibly kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

They can create custom jewelry designs tailored to your preferences.

2

Expect reasonable prices for both jewelry design and repair services.

3

No appointment is necessary for consultations or repairs.

10
Matthew Thomas Jewelers image 1

Small shop offers affordable pricing and direct talks with jewelers. Repairs are fast and careful, with advice on ring care. Friendly vibe and high-quality craftsmanship make it a great local spot.

Jewelry repair happens fast and with care. Recommendations for maintenance and ring longevity come with every service, including sizing and soldering.

People are saying

"This jewelry store does fast, quality repairs while you wait."

"This local spot's custom jewelry design is honest, expert, and fairly priced."

"Matt rebuilt my grandmother's pearl necklaces to perfection."

Good to know

1

Jewelry repairs are completed at competitive prices and within a reasonable timeframe.

2

The shop offers a variety of services including repairs, sizing, and cleaning.

3

Most repairs are done at a fraction of the cost compared to big chain jewelers.

11
Johannes Hunter Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store shines with custom ring design and expert repairs. Staff offer clear advice and free cleaning. Atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming, perfect for relaxed browsing and learning about jewelry care.

Offers custom ring design and jewelry refurbishment services. Provides reliable jewelry repairs and expert advice on maintenance and solutions.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"They did an amazing job repairing and cleaning my ring."

Good to know

1

The resizing process takes about three weeks, with upfront communication on the timeline.

2

They offer quality repair work for jewelry, including custom pieces.

3

Prices are competitive, making it a good option for affordable jewelry.

12
Zales image 1
Jewelry store

Small store offers well-stocked jewelry with a laid-back atmosphere. Staff provide helpful, no-pressure service and lifetime warranties. Easy to access but has a subtle sign that can be missed.

Friendly team helps find the perfect piece without pressure. Services include ring resizing and personalized assistance for all jewelry needs.

People are saying

"The staff here are so patient and helpful when picking out a ring."

"The Watch Store staff were patient and knowledgeable when sizing my watch."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

They offer military discounts and rewards for previous purchases.

2

A lifetime warranty is available on rings purchased.

3

They clean all jewelry, not just new purchases, for free.

13
Helzberg Diamonds image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store shines with lab-grown diamonds and on-site resizing. Staff offer friendly guidance on rings and elopements. Transparent pricing and lifetime warranties make buying easy and trustworthy.

Beautiful rings and perfect diamond earrings are available here. Staff engage in friendly conversations about elopement plans and ring selection, making the experience personal and enjoyable.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so patient and helpful picking out rings."

"The staff here helped me pick out perfect rings for my future wife."

"The staff at this jewelry store patiently helped us pick out perfect rings."

Good to know

1

They offered financing with no interest.

2

Each piece purchased has a lifetime warranty and maintenance/cleaning.

3

Resizing rings can take a while, so plan ahead.

14
Geofossiles Rock Shop image 1

Shop features museum-quality specimens in clear cases and a calm setting. Jewelry includes unique crystal bracelets and options to create your own. Wide variety of fossils and geodes offers something special for collectors and gift buyers.

Offers a wide variety of beautiful, unique jewelry including premade pieces and options to make your own. Selection includes properly labeled crystal, stone, and wood bracelets along with fossils and geodes.

People are saying

"I found the jewelry and rocks here to be beautiful and well-priced."

"The staff here is so patient and friendly with kids."

"I found so many affordable stones and fossils here."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a bracelet making class for kids on weekends.

2

They have a great selection of crystals, fossils, and unique jewelry.

3

The store allows customers to make their own jewelry.

15
Idyll Manor image 1
Antique store

Luxurious European vibe creates a peaceful, homey atmosphere perfect for slow browsing. Gold jewelry features lasting quality and unique designs ideal for gifts or personal wear. Carefully curated gifts and non-toxic candles add a sophisticated, charming touch.

Gold jewelry stands out with pieces that last well and are worn often. The selection includes unique designs alongside lasting quality that makes them favorites for gifts and personal wear.

People are saying

"I found so many unique gifts and home goods to spice up my space."

"The owner of this jewelry store is the sweetest person I met."

"It feels so classy, like a peaceful escape to a European boutique."

Good to know

1

Idyll Manor offers a wide selection of unique gifts, home decor, and jewelry.

2

Workshops, like charm necklace making, are hosted regularly at Idyll Manor.

3

The owner personally curates each item, ensuring a unique shopping experience.

16
Security Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Shop offers quick repairs on rings and necklaces with friendly service. Prices are very low and turnaround is fast. Space has unusual ephemera adding character and nice items for sale.

Jewelry repairs include rings and necklaces with a quick turnaround time. Staff provide friendly service and deliver quality repairs.

People are saying

"I got my ring resized and repaired quickly and perfectly."

"The owner's amazing work at this Jewelry Store is so skilled and honest."

Good to know

1

Repair costs are significantly lower than at other shops.

2

Repairs are completed in under five minutes for a very low price.

3

Turnaround time for repairs is about a week.

17
Acme Pawn East image 1

Shop blends firearms and jewelry with a family-owned atmosphere. Staff are patient, especially with jewelry choices. Layaway policy makes purchases affordable for all.

Selections include jewelry alongside firearms and games. Staff show patience when helping with jewelry choices.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so knowledgeable and friendly."

"Steve was so helpful and willing to answer questions with a smile."

Good to know

1

Their layaway policy helps customers afford items over time.

2

They have a wide range of items including jewelry, firearms, and games.

3

Expect a friendly atmosphere with helpful staff.

18
Kind Find Jewelry & Piercing image 1

Shop blends custom jewelry with a clean, sterile setting. Offers high-end design and professional piercing services. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with strong focus on ethical sourcing and comfort.

Custom jewelry stands out with high quality materials like titanium and gold. The shop offers a superb selection and a strong focus on piercing services.

People are saying

"Lance is patient and gentle with piercings at this jewelry store."

"The staff here made me feel so comfortable and cared for."

"It's so Kid Friendly; Lance was patient and gentle during my daughter's piercing."

Good to know

1

The studio emphasizes the importance of sterilization and cleanliness.

2

The appointment-only policy ensures personalized service and comfort.

3

The jewelry selection is stunning and ethically sourced.

19
Eclectic CO. image 1

Shop features over 70 local vendors with eclectic jewelry and unique handmade gifts. Prices suit every budget, especially for earrings and artisan pieces. Atmosphere is fun and diverse, perfect for finding pressed flower bookmarks and painted wall art.

A huge selection of eclectic jewelry by local artists fills the space. Earrings come at a great price, alongside other artisan pieces like pressed flower bookmarks and painted wall art.

People are saying

"This local spot has a huge variety of handmade crafts and gifts."

"This jewelry store has a huge selection of unique items."

"I found this store to be the coolest ever."

Good to know

1

Eclectic CO features over 70 local vendors with unique products.

2

The store offers a wide variety of items including clothing, art, and gifts.

3

Prices vary widely, ensuring options for every budget.

20
Banter by Piercing Pagoda image 1

Bright, clean store offers gentle ear piercing with skilled staff like Steven ensuring painless care for kids. Jewelry selection is broad, with experts like Megan providing personalized help and smooth warranty exchanges. Prices stay affordable for families.

Staff like Steve and Megan provide personalized help with picking and fixing jewelry. The store offers a variety of earrings and handles warranty exchanges smoothly.

People are saying

"They're so patient and amazing with kids' ear piercings."

"The staff here really helped me find the perfect jewelry."

"They made my needle shy daughter feel so comfortable."

Good to know

1

The store offers ear piercing services for children and adults.

2

Prices for ear piercings vary by jewelry choice and are competitive.

3

Reservations for ear piercings are recommended during busy times.

21
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Bright lighting reveals an amazing assortment of jewelry at various price points. Staff like Veronica and Jasmine offer attentive, knowledgeable service and free cleaning for rings. The atmosphere feels inclusive and low pressure, making shopping quick and easy.

Staff members like Veronica, Jasmine, and Kim provide attentive, knowledgeable service and help with selecting and repairing jewelry. They offer free cleaning for rings and chains and assist with finding options within various price ranges.

People are saying

"Veronica made finding my perfect ring so comfortable and memorable."

"The staff here is so helpful finding the perfect rings for your date."

"Veronica at the Jewelry Store was so patient helping me find my perfect ring."

Good to know

1

KAY Jewelers offers a lifetime warranty on most jewelry purchases.

2

Expect a turnaround time of three weeks for repairs.

3

Discounts may be available on select items; ask a sales associate.

22
EZPAWN image 1
Pawn shop

Offers a huge selection of tools with great loans and layaway plans. Jewelry includes forever rings and stunning pieces for special occasions. Staff is helpful and friendly, making it easy to find perfect gifts.

Selection includes forever rings and various beautiful pieces. Staff helps find jewelry for special occasions like Christmas or gifts for loved ones. The jewelry selection is consistently impressive.

People are saying

"Stephanie helped me find a lovely ring and was so patient."

"Stephanie at the Jewelry Store made my shopping experience so engaging."

Good to know

1

EZPAWN offers a great layaway plan for customers who can't pay all at once.

2

EZPAWN has a huge selection of tools and other quality products.

3

EZPAWN's jewelry selection is amazing.

Discover more

Colorado Springs, Colorado

Area guide
Loading Map...