Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Colorado Springs' best

Pie spots

A slice of pie is the only thing that feels like a proper reward at the end of a long day.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bread & Butter Neighborhood Market image 1
Bread & Butter Neighborhood Market image 2
Bread & Butter Neighborhood Market image 3
View all

Small grocery store offers local produce and organic options with a boutique liquor selection. Fruit pies shine, especially fresh baked cherry hand pies and Amish hand pies. Porch seating creates a relaxed spot to enjoy purchases in a warm, lively atmosphere.

Fruit pies stand out with fresh baked cherry hand pies and Amish hand pies among other baked goods.

People are saying

"This Local Spot has an amazing selection of local meats and produce."

"This small convenience store has a surprisingly good selection of local goodies."

"I always leave with exactly what I needed, especially the pie."

Good to know

1

The market offers a wide selection of organic, natural, vegan, gluten-free, and locally sourced options.

2

Expect a good deal on all bakery items available in the store.

3

The main entrance has stairs that could impact your visit if you are mobility challenged.

02
Homa Cafe + Bar image 1
Restaurant

Space blends natural light and plants with cozy seating for private talks or groups. Hand pies shine with apple filling and varied options like St. Ives Pie. Cocktails mix smoky and fruity notes while food features standout focaccia and quiche.

Hand pies stand out with delicious apple filling and a satisfying texture. Options like the St. Ives Pie and Rise and Shine Pie offer tasty variety alongside classic choices.

People are saying

"It's a great spot for a coffee and a chat."

"It's a quiet place with many comfortable spots to sit."

"The St. Ives Pie was delicious and recommended by the staff."

Good to know

1

Homa offers a variety of community events for all ages.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with half-price appetizers.

3

There is free parking in the back for two hours.

03
Porkbutt BBQ image 1
Restaurant

Small dining area offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a smoky aroma. Entire menu is gluten-free, perfect for allergy-sensitive diners. Pies shine here, especially the homemade apple pie with a special crust that tastes great.

Many pie flavors are available, including a standout apple pie made with a special method. Gluten-free options feature homemade pie crust and taste great.

People are saying

"This is some of the best BBQ I've had in Colorado Springs."

"The gluten-free food here is phenomenal, truly amazing."

"I loved their dazzling and delicious gluten-free pie."

Good to know

1

Porkbutt BBQ is a dedicated gluten-free restaurant, ensuring no cross-contamination.

2

Expect limited menu options on Sundays due to high demand.

3

They offer a food truck on Food Truck Tuesday for additional options.

04
Gold Star Bakery image 1

Small storefront offers rich pies with thick, light crusts and balanced fillings like bourbon pecan. Desserts are fresh and high-quality, including standout coconut custard and tart cherry pies. Atmosphere focuses on well-crafted, delicious sweets from a truck.

Pies here have perfect flavors and a light but thick crust. The coconut custard and pecan pies stand out for their rich taste and quality.

People are saying

"I thought the pie here had perfect flavors and was perfectly baked."

"The pies from this bakery were delicious and perfectly baked."

"The American Food pies here are incredible and perfectly baked."

Good to know

1

Pies range from $44.00 to $54.00 each.

2

The bakery offers a selection of pies, brownies, and cookies.

3

The storefront is small but has a good variety of baked goods.

05
Sheldon's Luncheonette image 1

Small diner with old-fashioned atmosphere offers a cozy, locals-only vibe. Open kitchen adds to the homey feel. Wide pie selection shines with banana cream pie that's tasty but modest in size.

Wide selection of pies includes banana cream and chocolate pie that tastes homemade. Banana cream pie is very tasty but served in modest portions.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal, especially the comfort food."

"I experienced classic American diner cuisine and great food here."

"I found the chicken fried steak so tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Parking is available nearby, but can fill up quickly.

3

Cash and credit cards are accepted; no personal checks.

06
The Ice Cream Mill image 1
Ice cream shop

Old west-themed shop offers rideable rocking horses and classic games for fun. Ice cream is made in-house with unique flavors, creating a nostalgic vibe. Apple pie pairs perfectly with vanilla ice cream, and pioneer pie Joshua is available to take home.

Apple pie pairs with vanilla ice cream for a classic combo. Pies are available to take home, including the pioneer pie Joshua.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing, with unique flavors."

"It's a cozy and inviting spot with a fun Western aesthetic."

"The ice cream here is fantastic, creamy, and homemade."

Good to know

1

The Ice Cream Mill is a mom-and-pop shop that makes all their ice cream in-store.

2

You can substitute flavors into your favorite treats.

3

The prices at The Ice Cream Mill are unbeatable.

07
Chicken Salad Chick image 1
Chicken restaurant

Cozy spot with country kitchen decor and fresh flowers sets a bright, welcoming mood. Pina Colada Pie offers balanced sweetness and rich flavor, perfect with savory meals. Booths and a shaded patio provide comfy seating for casual lunches or breaks.

The Pina Colada Pie stands out with its balanced sweetness and rich flavor. It pairs well with savory dishes and comes in various sizes for takeout.

People are saying

"I found the chicken salad here to be delicious and fresh."

"I found the soup here to be fresh, flavorful, and delicious."

"The piรฑa colada pie is out of this world."

Good to know

1

Prices for meals range from $10 to $15, depending on the selection.

2

Food safety is a concern; be cautious if you have allergies.

3

The menu features a wide variety of chicken salad options.

08
Village Inn image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Cozy diner with a modern remodel offers bright views of Pikes Peak and coffee carafes for relaxed breakfasts. Free pie Wednesdays feature banana cream and lemon meringue favorites, with pies available for takeout to keep them fresh.

Free pie Wednesdays offer a chance to enjoy pie without cost. Options like banana cream and lemon meringue stand out as favorites. Pies are available for takeout, keeping them fresh and accessible.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is really good and served hot."

"I found the pies here to be really good and reasonably priced."

"The American Food here is served by the friendliest, happiest staff."

Good to know

1

Free pie is offered on Wednesdays as a promotional event.

2

Kids eat free on Tuesdays, making it a great family option.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

Discover more

Colorado Springs, Colorado

Area guide
Loading Map...