Old school pizza spot with a no frills atmosphere and a vintage Pac-Man machine. The place feels cozy yet professional, focusing on takeout and delivery with a small waiting area. Known for authentic Italian cuisine and highly praised for its best pizza crust and unique spaghetti and meatballs.
Pizza features a crisp crust with a slightly soggy center that could use more cooking. The overall flavor is amazing, often considered among the best in the area and beyond.
Meatballs carry a unique spice that sets them apart from others. They follow a Greek recipe and come as a delicious side or part of main dishes.
"I found the pizza here to be delicious and amazing."
"The owner Pete is so friendly, he even threw in extra Nutella pizza slices with my takeout."
"Pete, the owner, is hilarious and super friendly."
Good to know
Pantaleone's is closed on Sundays.
The dining room is closed; only takeout or delivery is available.
Website prices may be outdated; check current prices before ordering.
Pizza spot combines family-friendly patio with a walk-up outdoor window and a coffee bar. Atmosphere stays chill and safe, welcoming toddlers and neighborhood gatherings. Pizza crust varies in thickness but ranks among the best, paired with a selection of lambic beers.
Pizza features a chewy crust with fresh mozzarella and Italian sausage on the South Sider variety. Staff customize orders freely and sometimes offer slices outside normal hours.
Thinly sliced meatballs come with a crisp crust and creamy, slightly sweet ricotta. The red sauce includes giardiniera, adding a kick of Chicago flair to the flavor.
Good to know
Carmella's operates as a grocery store where food can be ordered via phone.
Multiple meal options are available, including prepared meals in the market.
Expect a busy atmosphere during lunch hours, especially around 12:15 pm.
Neighborhood bar with horseshoe-shaped bar and wooden decor offers a warm, intimate atmosphere with dim lighting and lively vibes. Pool tables and TVs create a casual setting for watching sports, especially Bears games. The place serves Chicago-style pizza and features a unique duck vending machine.
Thin crust pepperoni and Chicago style deep dish pizzas stand out here. Prices stay reasonable even for large 18-inch pies, with options like pineapple pizza also available.
Meatballs come as a hearty appetizer that feels like a full meal. Options include a meatball sub with tots and a combo with deep dish pizza, both filling and satisfying.
Good to know
Wyman's offers $2 slice specials on Tuesdays.
Expect long wait times during busy hours, especially on Tuesdays and Fridays.
Self-seating is available, and orders must be placed at the bar.
Small space with an open kitchen and vintage decor creates a nostalgic vibe and cozy atmosphere. Warm, welcoming energy feels like a neighborhood spot with fun details like a Pizza Hut chandelier. Music and thoughtful touches add to a relaxed, inviting experience.
Pizza features a crust that stands out and a fresh, delicious taste. It pairs well with other items like stuffed peppers and prosciutto doughnuts.
Chicken meatballs come with little celery bits on top that add a nice crunch. Matza ball meatballs also appear as a notable option alongside the chicken ones.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.
The menu includes a variety of vegetarian options.
Gluten-free options are very limited.
Small, hole in the wall pizza spot with a classic east coast vibe and friendly atmosphere. Lunch hours attract local construction workers, creating a lively, casual energy. Offers generous portions and a large menu variety beyond pizza, catering to diverse tastes.
Thin crust pizzas have a nice crisp and are not greasy, with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Unique options like the Chicken Tikka Masala pizza stand out alongside consistently fresh and delicious wings.
Meatball sub stands out as a hot sandwich option with decent flavor. Spaghetti and meatballs also appear on the menu alongside various other dishes.
Good to know
Carry-out orders are ready quickly with minimal wait time.
Most menu items are priced under $15, making it affordable.
They do not serve alcohol, so no wine is available with meals.
Open space with a large bar creates a bar-like atmosphere featuring booth seats and large-screen TVs showing sports and news. A dog-friendly patio with an adjustable roof offers comfort with fans and heaters. The vibe blends New York imagery and a trendy, cozy setting that feels like being in NYC.
Slices come with a perfect crust, fresh toppings, and quality cheese. The pizza features great tomato sauce and arrives hot and ready to enjoy quickly.
Meatballs have a halal style and taste very good. They appear in dishes like spaghetti and a meatball sub, both well received.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.
Wine is half off every Wednesday, making it a great deal.
DJ nights occur every Saturday, attracting a lively crowd.
Old-fashioned pizzeria with vintage Italian decor and flickering lights creates a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere reminiscent of the late 60s. Classic tunes play softly, enhancing the old school Denver cool vibe. The place feels like a family-owned neighborhood staple with a strong sense of history and tradition.
Pepperoni and Sausage pizza stands out with a rich, satisfying flavor. The pizza has a classic Italian style that many find unmatched in the area. Families enjoy it together, with kids often devouring the slices.
Homemade spaghetti comes with meatballs in a red sauce that stands out. The meatballs pair well with the pasta and sauce, making the dish a solid choice.
Good to know
Carl's Pizza has been in business for 75 years on 38th Street in Denver.
They still deliver without the need for DoorDash.
Wine by the bottle is available for $20.
Italian restaurant offers large shareable portions with freshly made bread and imported quality ingredients. Atmosphere stays casual and lively, attracting those who appreciate East Coast-style sandwiches and pizza. Service operates efficiently like a fast casual takeout spot with a focus on product quality.
Massive pizza pies come with a thin crust that is light, airy, chewy, and crisp. The pizza offers great flavors and reasonable pricing when shared among four people.
Meatball hoagies stand out with provolone and broccoli rabe adding bold flavors. Specials often feature this combo, making each bite memorable.
Good to know
Expect large portions; a single pizza can easily feed three people.
Weekly pizza specials are available, offering great value.
A cheesesteak and fries combo is $20 on Wednesdays, perfect for sharing.
Traditional Italian restaurant with mint green walls, stained glass light covers, and wooden floors creates a cozy, old-school vibe. Atmosphere feels relaxing and homey, with touches like a payphone and gumball machine adding nostalgia. Self-service setup and simple, hearty food contribute to a casual, unpretentious experience.
Square pizzas come with thick, flavorful red sauce and a classic old-school vibe. Kids' pizzas and Denver-style cannoli add to the unique Italian experience here.
Spaghetti comes with really yummy meatballs and Italian sausage that stand out. Large buckets with meatballs, sausage, garlic bread, and salad feed six for around $40.
Good to know
Spaghetti night happens every Tuesday at 6 PM with a special menu.
Parking is available on-site, but it can be hit or miss during peak times.
Credit cards are accepted, but cash is recommended for smaller purchases.