Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Connecticut

Unique jewelry stores

Made for those who find mass-produced accessories uninspiring and insist on wearing pieces that tell a distinct story.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Steven Fox Jewelry image 1
Steven Fox Jewelry image 2
Steven Fox Jewelry image 3
View all
Jewelry store

Boutique showcases vintage machines alongside precious metals and gemstones in beautifully curated displays. Warm, relaxed atmosphere invites browsing and custom design, welcoming even families with children. Jewelry ranges from contemporary designs to estate pieces, offering unique, high-end selections.

Exquisite pieces and a well-trained, friendly staff prioritize customer needs. Services include repairs, conversions, and modifications, with options for one-of-a-kind rings and jewelry adjustments.

An unparalleled assortment of jewelry stands out with carefully curated collections and distinctive, personally designed pieces. Estate items offer unique and exquisite designs that attract compliments.

People are saying

"Steven Fox's jewelry store has such knowledgeable and kind staff."

"They expertly resized my grandmother's engagement ring overnight."

"I found the curated collections and estate pieces to be unique and exquisite."

Good to know

1

Steven Fox Jewelry offers custom ring resizing services.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for purchases.

3

Appointments are recommended for personalized consultations.

02
Andria BarbonΓ© Jewelry image 1

Studio space feels intimate and welcoming with a beautifully arranged setting. Energy is personalized and professional, guided by a team known for exquisite craftsmanship and deep knowledge of antique and vintage rings. Selection stands out for unique, old-world style pieces that blend tradition with modern wearability.

Unique pieces feature antique and traditional cut diamonds with beautiful settings. The selection includes one-of-a-kind designs and vintage solitaires with original inscriptions.

Jewelry features unique and one-of-a-kind designs with antique and traditional mine cut diamonds. Rings stand out as creative works of art with breathtaking and beautiful details.

People are saying

"I love the vintage and antique jewelry selection at this jewelry store."

"The Ring Store team is so pleasant and wonderful to work with."

"Their attention to detail and craft make for a truly unique experience."

Good to know

1

Victor Barbone offers a 5-day return policy on all jewelry purchases.

2

The jewelry store is located in the GIA building in the diamond district.

3

Andria Barbone provides a wide selection of unique vintage and antique rings.

03
21C Designs image 1
Jewelry designer

Studio offers unique, modern designs with expert craftsmanship and fair pricing. Space feels warm and welcoming, encouraging collaboration on custom pieces. Designers use detailed CAD mock-ups to visualize jewelry before creation.

Creative designers transform old estate jewelry into wearable, meaningful pieces using heirloom stones. They offer custom engagement rings and unique styles with superior quality craftsmanship.

Jewelry here features unique and fresh designs that stand out. The craftsmanship is high level and the pieces make a clear statement with modern styles.

People are saying

"They repurposed my old jewelry into a stunning new ring."

"They transformed my old jewelry into a beautiful new necklace."

"I transformed my old jewelry into unique, modern pieces I wear constantly."

Good to know

1

They provide a detailed CAD mock-up of the ring to help visualize the final product.

2

The turnaround time for custom pieces is quick, ensuring timely delivery.

3

Pricing for custom jewelry is very reasonable compared to other options.

04
Water Street Jewelers image 1

Bright, inviting space feels like a spa with calming energy and relaxed atmosphere. Family-owned shop offers unique, high-quality jewelry and custom workshops without pressure to buy. Customers find a welcoming vibe that inspires personal style and care.

Staff provide valuable advice to match styles and budgets. Rings get perfect sizing and are ready before important events. Selection includes permanent jewelry options.

Unique lines and artists fill the space with gorgeous works of art. Beautiful, unique jewelry pieces appear within a range of budgets.

People are saying

"This jewelry store's ear piercings are done with skill and kindness."

"Daniela designed our wedding rings with her own vision."

"Daniela and the staff are so attentive and helpful."

Good to know

1

Water Street Jewelers offers a full menu of repair and refurbishment services for all jewelry needs.

2

The ear piercing process is quick and easy, with in-house services.

3

During their recent 30% off sale, customers can find beautiful earrings.

05
Shreve, Crump & Low image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers a beautifully curated selection of fine watches and unique pieces, including vintage and limited editions. Atmosphere feels warm and homey with comfy seating and attentive, personalized care. Pricing is affordable for high-quality products, making it a standout on the avenue.

Owners Brad and Olivia source and craft the most beautiful jewelry with a great selection of fine watches and rings. Pricing on rings is surprisingly good, and craftsmanship by Jeffrey and service from Jessica stand out.

Selection includes vintage Tiffany tea sets and piece-unique watches. Offers timeless classics alongside items not found elsewhere.

People are saying

"The staff at this Watch Store is so knowledgeable and kind."

"The Jewelry Store staff provides attentive, personalized service for every customer."

"I got the exact limited edition watch I was seeking, gift-wrapped and overnighted."

Good to know

1

Shreve, Crump & Low offers high-quality jewelry and top-tier service.

2

Customers should ask for Meryl when visiting for personalized service.

3

They provide jewelry repair services without charge for certain repairs.

06
Sophia's Costumes and Gifts image 1

Costume and gift shop offers an extensive, meticulously curated collection of vintage clothing, authentic costumes, and unique gifts. Atmosphere feels like a treasure trove with well-organized, affordable items that invite exploration. Regulars find it a go-to spot for high-quality, movie-level costumes and distinctive accessories.

Offers vintage jewelry alongside dazzling pieces. Jewelry fits well with unique gifts and costumes. Shopping here feels fun and varied.

A collection of high-end costumes and unique masks stands out here, perfect for events like Venetian balls. The gift shop features vintage clothing, dazzling jewelry, and novelties you won't find elsewhere.

People are saying

"The staff here are so helpful and knowledgeable about vintage."

"You'll find unique costumes and gifts spanning different eras and characters."

"This jewelry store is amazing and full of treasures."

Good to know

1

Sophia's offers a vast selection of costumes for rent and purchase.

2

The shop features unique gifts, vintage clothing, and jewelry.

3

Costumes are well-priced and of high quality.

07
Polaris Crystals image 1
Metaphysical supply store

Meticulously arranged crystals and trinkets create a sparkly, clean space with a welcoming energy. A video plays useful information about crystals, adding to the thoughtful setup. The store offers unique, high-quality items that appeal to diverse spiritualities.

Quality crystals and jewelry stand out here with a wide variety of bracelets, rings, and necklaces. Staff assist with picking pieces for family, adding a personal touch.

Beautiful shop filled with one-of-a-kind finds and thoughtful gifts. Items are cute, trendy, and unique.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"I found so many unique gifts and one-of-a-kind finds here."

Good to know

1

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for purchases.

2

The store has knowledgeable staff available to assist with selections.

3

Expect to find unique gifts and items for various spiritual practices.

08
Fairhaven Furniture image 1
Furniture store

Showroom displays handcrafted furniture and unique artisan pieces in a relaxed, thoughtfully curated setting. Lighting and artwork create a pleasant, artistic atmosphere that invites slow browsing. The space draws those seeking high-quality, locally made furnishings and distinctive home decor.

Fun earrings stand out among the jewelry options. The store also offers handcrafted pieces alongside gifts and pottery.

Furniture and gifts show unique craftsmanship and design. The selection includes handcrafted art pieces and distinctive jewelry not found in typical stores.

People are saying

"The furniture store staff are so knowledgeable and friendly."

"I found so many unique, handcrafted items here, not just furniture."

"The artwork and furniture in this Jewelry Store are so special and well-crafted."

Good to know

1

The store offers expert in-house design consultation to help with selections.

2

Fairhaven Furniture features a unique selection of handcrafted art pieces.

3

Quality furniture pieces are available, made with attention to craftsmanship.

Discover more

Connecticut

Area guide
Loading Map...