Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cookie shops in New Haven

A cookie is only worth the calories if it is made with intention and hits the spot every single time.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Sweet Mary's image 1
Sweet Mary's image 2
Sweet Mary's image 3
View all

Charming bakery offers moist cupcakes and Boston Cream cookies that pair well with fudge brownies. The shop's pleasant atmosphere and classy decor create a cute, clean space with an amazing smell.

Cookies come in Boston Cream, red velvet, and peanut butter flavors. They taste good and pair well with other desserts like fudge brownies and coffee crumble.

People are saying

"I found the cupcakes here to be super flavorful and moist."

"The bakery's cupcakes were amazing, especially the Biscoff."

"I loved the moist and delicious cookies."

Good to know

1

Cupcakes cost $5 each, totaling $17 for three including tax and tip.

2

Parking is easy and quick, with no issues getting in and out.

3

The bakery offers a wide variety of cupcakes and desserts.

02
Olmo image 1
Bagel shop

Small bagel shop buzzes with a friendly atmosphere and modern kiosks. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs, making it a cute spot to relax. Chocolate chip cookies shine with a sea salt twist and great value, matching the best bagels in town.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their perfect texture and sea salt twist. They come at a low price and often surprise with their heavenly flavor.

People are saying

"I thought Olmo had the best bagels in New Haven."

"I had the greatest egg sandwich I ever tasted."

"The chocolate chip cookie here is heavenly and a must-try."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging, especially during peak morning hours.

2

Ordering ahead is advised due to high demand in the mornings.

3

The establishment has outdoor seating only, so dress accordingly for the weather.

03
East Rock Breads image 1

Fresh sourdough bagels and flaky croissants shine with unique flavors. Chocolate chip cookies feature a touch of salt and rich browned butter taste. Friendly owners add welcoming charm in a small, busy takeout spot.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a touch of salt and likely use browned butter for flavor. The cookie selection offers a nice variety alongside other baked goods.

People are saying

"The kolaches here are amazing and outstanding."

"The sourdough bread here is excellent, especially the Parmesan and pepper."

"Their chocolate chip cookies have a touch of salt."

Good to know

1

The bakery is takeout only, with street parking available.

2

Expect long lines, especially in the morning when they open.

3

Arrive early for warm, fresh-out-of-the-oven treats.

04
Apicella's Bakery Inc image 1

Small bakery shines with crusty Italian bread and soft chocolate chip cookies. Old school vibe feels warm and welcoming. Prices stay very good for fresh, traditional treats.

Soft, buttery chocolate chip cookies stand out here. Cookies come fresh daily alongside breads and pastries, all made with care.

People are saying

"I loved their amazing stuffed breads, especially the spinach and potato."

"The bakery staff always greet you with a smile."

"I was so impressed, the cookies were soft and buttery."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers authentic Italian baked goods and seasonal specialties.

2

Expect to arrive early as popular items sell out quickly.

3

They offer all their Easter-themed baked goods during the Easter season.

05
Little Dandelion image 1

Small space with a cozy vibe and warm cinnamon aroma invites you in. Enjoy banana coconut cookies paired with excellent coffee. Friendly owner often offers free cookies and shares personal service that feels like home.

Cookies come with excellent coffee and often include a banana coconut flavor. The owner offers free cookies sometimes, adding a friendly touch.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the great coffee here."

"It's such a cozy and charming little gem."

"The owner offered us free cookies and was super friendly."

Good to know

1

The cafe is located on Wooster Street, between Sallyโ€™s Apizza and Frank Pepeโ€™s Apizza.

2

Outdoor seating is limited to only two tables.

3

The cafe does not accept credit cards; cash is required.

06
Marjolaine Pastry Shop image 1

Cute interior creates a warm, family vibe with a playful touch from available games. Raspberry jam sandwich cookies dipped in chocolate are a standout treat. Pastries and cakes impress with delicious taste and beautiful presentation.

Raspberry jam sandwich cookies dipped in chocolate stand out here. Cakes and cookies come beautifully presented and are delicious enough to be eaten for dessert and breakfast.

People are saying

"The pastries here are absolutely delicious."

"I was thrilled with how delicious the birthday cake turned out."

"I found the cakes and cookies to be delicious and beautifully decorated."

Good to know

1

All items at Marjolaine Pastry Shop are made to order.

2

Cake orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.

3

You need to call ahead as they usually do not have much on the shelves.

07
Atticus Bookstore Cafe image 1

Small cafe offers a nutty chocolate chip cookie and fresh sandwiches. Cozy yet lively space filled with books and wide aisles invites reading and work. Crowded with laptops and sketch pads, it blends a library vibe with great food.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a nutty, brown-buttered flavor. The selection includes cookies, cakes, and savouries alongside sandwiches and muffins.

People are saying

"The Cafe's coffee and pastries are consistently great."

"This bookstore is super cute and cozy, a great place to unwind."

"I loved their cookies and sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Parking can be hard to find near the bookstore cafe.

2

Hygiene standards may not meet expectations, as cash handlers also prepare food.

3

Seating is often limited, especially during busy hours.

08
Libby's Italian Pastry Shop and Italian Ice image 1

Bakery offers a retro look and cozy cafe seating with friendly staff. Italian pastries and sfogliatella cookies stand out for quality. Cookie boxes include anginettes and coconut macaroons priced around $16 per pound.

Boxes include anginettes, coconut macaroons, and mixed Italian cookies. The selection features sfogliatella and pignoli cookies. Prices run around $16 per pound.

People are saying

"The espresso here is great, made with a state-of-the-art machine."

"I thought the cannolis here were amazing."

"The cannolis here are diverse and decadent."

Good to know

1

The shop is now accepting credit cards.

2

Libby's is closed on Tuesdays.

3

Parking can be tricky, but the visit is worth it.

Discover more

New Haven, Connecticut

Area guide
Loading Map...