Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of East Rock, New Haven

Sandwich shops

Made for those who prioritize a handheld meal that fits into a busy schedule without sacrificing their standards for a quality sandwich.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
M K Smoke Shop & Deli Grocery image 1
M K Smoke Shop & Deli Grocery image 2
M K Smoke Shop & Deli Grocery image 3
View all

Deli serves affordable breakfast sandwiches all day with fresh ingredients. It offers Philly cheesesteak and chopped cheese that taste great and cost less than nearby spots. Store stays clean and organized with a wide range of groceries and essentials.

Breakfast sandwiches stay available well into the afternoon, made with good quality ingredients. Options like Philly cheesesteak, chicken cutlet, and chopped cheese stand out for their affordable, fresh taste.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the delicious and affordable breakfast sandwiches."

"The coffee here is so warm and friendly."

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing, especially considering the price."

Good to know

1

The steak and cheese sandwich costs only $7.

2

Breakfast sandwiches are available all day for $4.99 each.

3

Drinks are included with breakfast sandwiches.

02
Sabor Sajoma Kitchen & Market image 1

Small market with a bodega vibe offers authentic Dominican and Cuban dishes. Cubano sandwich shines with pulled pork and classic flavors. Cozy spot filled with Spanish music and fresh food smells creates a warm, community feel.

Cubano sandwich stands out with pulled pork and classic flavors. Other options include a roast beef sandwich and a well-balanced cauliflower sandwich. Sandwiches can be customized easily.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has amazing, fresh, and tasty food."

"The food at this grocery store is delicious and authentically Dominican."

"You have to try the Cuban sandwich; it's the best."

Good to know

1

Expect a variety of vegan and meat options on the menu.

2

The lunch special offers large portions at a great price.

3

The market has a well-curated selection of grocery items.

03
Atticus Market image 1

Renovated space with high ceilings buzzes with remote workers and families. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant patio vibe. Breakfast sandwiches shine with fresh, store-made bread and balanced flavors, including steak and cheese and vegetarian options.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with fresh, store-made bread and well-balanced flavors. Options include steak and cheese, mushroom, and solid vegetarian selections on semolina rolls.

People are saying

"I thought the bread was incredible, with a nice char."

"The outdoor seating here is delightful when the weather is nice."

"I found the sandwiches here to be fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

There is very little inside seating at Atticus Market.

2

The prices are high, which may discourage frequent visits.

3

Good vegetarian options are available at Atticus Market.

04
THE CROokED GOAT KITCHEN & BAR image 1

Irish pub style meets New Orleans vibes for a welcoming atmosphere with lively music. Massive sandwiches feature fried shrimp and a tasty sauce, while the Wednesday Chicken cutlet adds variety. Modern updates keep the space clean and inviting for a friendly crowd.

Massive sandwiches come loaded with fried shrimp and a flavorful sauce. The Wednesday Chicken cutlet sandwich adds variety to the menu.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the fried chicken tenders, is outstanding."

"This new neighborhood bar is a perfect place to grab a drink."

"This sandwich is massive and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

The restaurant hosts a hot wing eating contest every month for charity.

3

Kids' meals are available, and plain fries can be requested.

05
Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac image 1
Hot dog restaurant

Hot dog spot shines with Nashville chicken sandwich and chili cheese dogs. Casual vibe with black wooden paneling and loud jukebox music keeps energy high. Comfortable booths and bright lighting make it a lively local favorite.

Offers a solid range of hotdog and sandwich choices including the Nashville chicken sandwich and chili cheese dogs. The chicken sandwiches come with a crunchy breaded chicken breast and pair well with sides like French fries.

People are saying

"I found the American food, especially the hot dogs, to be the best I ever had."

"The food here is flavorful and reasonably priced."

"The chicken sandwich was delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The meal cost $11.00, including a soda.

2

It was a BOGO day, so it didn't cost as much as it could have.

3

They have a large selection of hot dog styles to try.

06
East Rock Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Sunlight warms worn wooden floors and tin ceilings, creating a home-style atmosphere that invites conversation. Paisley's Pesto sandwich on house-made sourdough offers a lasting flavor that complements the device-free vibe. Small seating for a dozen keeps it cozy and connected.

Paisley's Pesto sandwich on house-made sourdough stands out with its lasting flavor. The breakfast sandwich pairs fresh greens and smoked salmon for a simple yet poetic start to the day.

People are saying

"I found the cold brew to be fantastic and strong."

"The cafe staff here are super friendly and amazing."

"The sandwich on house-made sourdough was so good I daydreamed about it."

Good to know

1

Seating is limited to about a dozen people, so arrive early to avoid long waits.

2

There is no Wi-Fi available, so plan accordingly if you need to work.

3

The coffee prices are reasonable, making it an affordable option for daily visits.

07
East Rock Market image 1

Spacious eatery offers gourmet sandwiches alongside fresh sushi and tacos. Cool, casual vibe with an open seating area fits groups well. Wine and whiskey bar adds a relaxing touch to the high-quality food experience.

Gourmet sandwiches come from Meat & Co and other spots in the market. Options include sushi, tacos, and pizza, but sandwiches stand out for their variety and can be expensive.

People are saying

"You can get pizza and so much more here."

"I found the sushi here to be epic, with high quality fish and rice."

"I picked up great sandwiches from here."

Good to know

1

The market offers a coffee shop, pizza, tacos, sandwiches, and sushi.

2

Prices at the market are on the pricier side for some items.

3

There is plenty of seating available, even during off-peak hours.

08
P&M Fine Foods image 1

Classic Italian deli offers fresh chicken cutlets for sandwiches and a homey atmosphere with outdoor seating. Friendly vibe suits breakfast or lunch, with a drive-thru option for quick takeaway. Small size hides a broad grocery selection.

Fresh chicken cutlets get made right out back for sandwiches. Focaccia sandwiches come well made and tasty. Hot sandwiches like the Chicken Santore stand out for their quality.

People are saying

"The food here is always hot, fresh, and delicious."

"I thought the focaccia sandwiches here were delicious and well made."

"The staff at this grocery store always had a smile."

Good to know

1

They offer a discount if you pay in cash.

2

Pricing for hot food items can vary on different days.

3

Watch out when purchasing meats for potential inconsistencies.

09
Meat & Co. image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers bold flavors like tuna melt with hot pepper and steak with cabbage slaw. Located in a quiet communal space, it serves quickly but hours vary. Fries can be soggy due to packaging, and cheese has a strong taste that may overpower some sandwiches.

Sandwiches offer bold flavors like the tuna melt with hot pepper and a steak and cheese with cabbage slaw. Some sandwiches feel small and pricey, with cheese sometimes overpowering the taste.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches to be unbelievable."

Good to know

1

Verify hours before visiting, as they may not be accurate.

2

The sandwich shop is located in a communal space with limited activity.

3

Food is prepared quickly, making it a good option for a fast meal.

10
G Cafe Bakery East Rock image 1

Spacious coffee shop offers buttered brioche sandwiches with quality eggs and cheese for about $6. Friendly vibe fills the air, though music can get loud. Plenty of charging ports support laptop users at long wooden tables, but no Wi-Fi is available.

Egg and cheese sandwiches stand out with buttered brioche, Swiss and mozzarella cheese, and options like scrambled or over medium eggs. Prices hover around $6, offering high-quality breakfast sandwiches that pair well with coffee.

People are saying

"The coffee here is served by the sweetest, friendliest staff."

"I thought the bread here was amazing and super high quality."

"This sandwich is the best I have ever had."

Good to know

1

There is no Wi-Fi available at the cafe.

2

A latte costs $8.

3

The cafe usually closes by 5 PM.

Discover more

East Rock, New Haven

Area guide
Loading Map...