Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Pizza spots in Shelton

A pizza that is crafted with real attention to the crust and toppings instead of being mass-produced.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Porky's Cafe image 1
Porky's Cafe image 2
Porky's Cafe image 3
View all
American restaurant

Cozy spot with a warm atmosphere and lively vibe. Known for underrated pizza that stands out alongside tasty wings. Friendly locals enjoy sports on many TVs and controlling the jukebox, blending family fun with an upscale old-school pub feel.

Pizza stands out as underrated and awesome with a pie style that gets recommended. Wings often share the spotlight, but the pizza holds its own as a top choice.

People are saying

"The pizza here is amazing, a must-try."

"I enjoyed the beer and snacks here."

"I loved the pizza and wings at this local spot."

Good to know

1

Parking is available nearby, making it easy to visit.

2

Expect a full house during Sunday football games.

3

The cafe offers a secret menu known to locals.

02
Artans Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Known for excellent pizza quality, this spot offers quick takeout with delivery under 30 minutes. Simple atmosphere with minimal seating keeps focus on food. Prices stay reasonable while serving tasty options like buffalo chicken pizza and veggie with extra garlic.

Offers fast and delicious pizza with options like veggie pizza with light mozzarella and extra garlic and buffalo chicken pizza. Pizza quality stands out as excellent and affordable.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and delicious."

"I would order this Italian food again; it was so great."

"Delivery usually arrived within 30 minutes, hot and fresh."

Good to know

1

Delivery usually arrives within 30 minutes.

2

They only recently started closing on Mondays.

3

Artans Pizza is take out only.

03
Antonio's Italian Style Pizza image 1

Spacious dining room and separate take-out entrance create smooth flow. Traditional thin crust pizzas like honey bacon and veggie deluxe are consistently delicious. Casual vibe with a visible pizza oven adds authentic charm and value.

Traditional thin crust pizzas come out perfectly cooked and consistently delicious. Varieties like honey bacon, veggie deluxe, and seafood options offer solid choices with fast, accurate service.

People are saying

"The pizzas here are absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked."

"The Italian food here feels like family, it's so warm and friendly."

"Their delivery is always faster than they estimate."

Good to know

1

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza is takeout only; no dine-in options available.

2

The restaurant has relocated to 12A Bridgeport Ave, previously at 151 Center Street.

3

Parking is plentiful at the new location, but limited on the pizza side.

04
Pier131 Kitchen + Bar image 1
American restaurant

Large bar and outdoor patio offer river views and plenty of seating. Hot oil pizza shines with crispy crust and bold flavor, including a classic pepperoni pizza. Live DJ and band fill the space with club-like music for a lively vibe.

Hot oil pizza stands out with its crispy crust and bold flavor. The pepperoni pizza also offers a classic taste, and personalized pizzas start at $9.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be hot and full of flavor."

"The outdoor space offers gorgeous views of the river."

"You've got to try the hot oil pizza; it's the best in the Valley."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and fills up quickly during busy hours.

2

Happy hour features $5 drinks and discounted appetizers.

3

The restaurant has a mandatory 20% tip for parties of 7 or more.

05
Square Peg Pizzeria Shelton image 1
American restaurant

Small restaurant offers a relaxed vibe with comfortable lighting and live entertainment. Wood-fired pizzas feature creative toppings like burrata and arugula, delivering a crispy crust and fresh flavors. Plenty of seating keeps it chill without crowding.

Creative toppings and a crispy crust define the pizzas here. Fresh ingredients like creamy burrata, arugula, and cherry tomatoes make pies light yet flavorful with perfect cooking and airy texture.

People are saying

"The pizza here has an amazing thin crust and great toppings."

"The staff here are so welcoming and chill."

"The salads here are fresh with delicious vegetables."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on drinks and bites from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 8pm, hosted by a separate company.

3

The restaurant is known for its extensive menu, featuring high-quality pizza and Italian dishes.

06
Legends Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy thin crust pizza with a perfect sauce to cheese balance and unique toppings like mashed potato. Cozy, family-owned spot feels like a friend's kitchen. Efficient service offers speedy pickup even on busy weekends.

Thin crust pizza features a perfect sauce to cheese ratio and balanced toppings. Specialty options include a unique hot oil pizza and a mashed potato pizza that consistently impress.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great, especially the thin crust."

"The pizza takeout here is really good, like the city's."

"I found it hard to find such good quality salads."

Good to know

1

Legends Pizzeria offers a wide variety of specialty pizzas.

2

They provide speedy pickup even on weekends.

3

Delivery options are available through their own drivers and third-party services.

07
Fire Engine Pizza Company 3 image 1

Elevated pizza spot offers crunchy crust pies with unique toppings like mashed potato. Warm, lively vibe suits families and groups. Large bar with multiple TVs keeps sports fans entertained.

Pizza comes out fast with a crunchy crust and a deliciously greasy but balanced flavor. Options include gluten-free and vegan cheese pizzas, plus unique toppings like mashed potato and bread and butter pickle.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was delicious and perfectly greasy."

"The house salad here is top notch with amazing dressing."

"The bar's TVs make it a great spot for sports fans."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 10 PM, so no food orders after that time.

2

They offer a discount to firemen.

3

Vegan cheese costs an extra $5 on pizzas.

08
Vincents Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Small family-run Italian spot offers very good pizza with solid cheese and sauce, though some pies can be doughy. Cozy atmosphere creates a family vibe perfect for quiet meals. Generous portions and reasonable prices make it a great value.

Pizza here is mostly very good with solid cheese and sauce. The Margherita pizza differs from the menu description, missing fresh basil and tasting like a plain cheese pizza. Some pizzas can be doughy.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and flavorful."

"The dinners here are delicious and flavorful."

"I thought the pizza here was very good."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, Vincents Restaurant offers 50% off bottles of wine.

2

The prices at Vincents Restaurant are very reasonable.

3

With almost every entree, you get bread and salad.

09
Matto Wine Bar image 1
Italian restaurant

Spacious Italian spot buzzes with lively energy and sleek modern decor. Wood-fired pizzas shine with quality crust and bold flavors like Short Rib Pizza. Enjoy well-crafted cocktails such as pistachio martinis while dining outdoors under heat lamps.

Wood-fired pizzas stand out with a quality crust and balanced sauce to meat to cheese ratio. The Short Rib Pizza and gluten-free options offer distinct flavors, with hot oil adding a perfect heat.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the short rib dishes and pizzas, is amazing."

"Our server Alexa was amazing and gave great recommendations."

"The gluten-free pizza here is actually good."

Good to know

1

A fixed-price three-course lunch menu is available on weekdays until 2 pm for $17.98.

2

Happy hour features half-off bottles on Tuesdays and various drink specials.

3

The restaurant has ample parking available for guests.

Discover more

Huntington, Shelton

Area guide
Loading Map...