Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in West Haven

Pizza

A hot, thin crust with melted cheese and sauce is the only thing that will do.

Based on 444 Opinions
+441
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Salty Tomato Pizza image 1
Salty Tomato Pizza image 2
Salty Tomato Pizza image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with authentic flavor and bold sauce. Space feels homey and service is fast. Large slices suit family dinners and takeout, all at fair prices.

Authentic, flavorful taste stands out with pizzas cooked to absolute perfection. Options like the House Sicilian and the Nutella with Strawberry pizza offer unique flavors, all served quickly with minimal wait.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was really authentic and flavorful."

"The sausage on the meat lovers pizza was really good."

Good to know

1

Salty Tomato Pizza is takeout only.

2

The pizza is made quickly, so the wait time is minimal.

3

A large cheese pizza costs $16.

02
CRISPY PIZZA image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with handmade dough and fresh toppings, served hot and fast. Friendly staff create a cozy atmosphere that feels welcoming. Prices stay affordable, and ample parking makes visits easy.

Pizza features a perfectly cooked crust with fresh ingredients and handmade dough. It arrives hot and quickly, consistently delivering a delicious and gourmet experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was absolutely delicious."

"The food here is fresh, hot, and delicious."

Good to know

1

There is good parking available at CRISPY PIZZA.

2

The pizza is made quickly for fast service.

3

Prices are affordable, making it budget-friendly.

03
Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs image 1

Old school pizza spot buzzes with family-friendly atmosphere and tight seating. Sicilian slices shine with exceptional flavor and come with freshly made bread and garlic knots. Takeout rules here, keeping energy busy and lively all day.

Sicilian slices stand out with plenty of leftovers and exceptional flavor. The broccoli and cheese stuffed bread pairs well with hot, ready pizza and garlic knots for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was among the top options."

"The food here is amazingly good and the portions are a good size."

"Their stuffed breads are amazing and freshly baked."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead is recommended.

2

Expect a line on Friday nights, especially during dinner hours.

3

The restaurant primarily offers takeout, with limited seating available.

04
West Haven Pizza and Deli image 1

Small pick-up spot with pink picnic tables offers a casual, friendly vibe near the beach. Well-made cheese and pepperoni pizzas shine with fresh ingredients and solid flavor. Quick service suits those who enjoy eating outdoors or grabbing takeout.

Cheese and pepperoni pizzas stand out with fresh ingredients and solid flavor. The Greek pizza offers a unique twist, and pizzas can be cooked well done on request.

People are saying

"This is my new favorite pizza place."

"The outdoor space has cute picnic tables near the beach."

"I found the sandwiches to be top-notch and the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Slices cost only $2.50, making it an affordable option for a quick meal.

2

The food is prepared quickly, usually within 20 minutes.

3

They offer delivery services for convenience.

05
Mike's Apizza & Restaurant image 1

Enjoy thin crust New Haven Style pizza with a light and crispy texture and authentic Italian flavor. The broccoli Rabe pizza offers a mild, fresh taste without greasiness. Cozy, casual vibe adds to the charm despite a slightly worn look.

Pizza features a light and crispy crust with a fantastic Italian taste. The broccoli Rabe pizza stands out with a mild flavor that highlights the ingredients without greasiness or excess salt.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was excellent, especially the thin crust."

"I found the pizza delicious and better than many other options."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay $4.50 for each additional topping on your pizza.

2

The restaurant has been a local favorite for over 30 years.

3

Mike's Apizza & Restaurant is known for its consistent quality over the years.

06
Tom & Pat's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Outdoor seating offers a beach view with picnic tables and easy parking. Known for pizza rolls and sausage pizza, it serves quick, casual bites by the ocean. Large cheese pizzas are affordable and service stays friendly.

Pizza rolls and sausage pizza stand out for their flavor and quality. Large cheese pizzas cost around $12.99, making them an affordable option with consistently friendly service.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be good and my go-to for a quick slice."

"Diane was always kind and willing to try off-menu items."

"The outdoor seating has a decent ocean view."

Good to know

1

Tom & Pat's Pizza only offers takeout with no indoor seating available.

2

Parking is easy with a small lot available free of charge.

3

A large cheese pizza costs $12.99, making it affordable.

07
Casa Bianca Pizza West Haven image 1

Offers fast delivery and a varied menu with halal and classic options. Pizza has a grilled flavor and crisp dough, topped with fresh cheese. Atmosphere is welcoming and friendly with booths for dining inside.

Pizza features a nice grilled flavor and crisp dough with fresh, cheesy toppings. Large pies with sausage and mushroom cost under $15, delivered hot and quickly.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be delicious and bursting with flavor."

"I thought the food here was amazing, especially the pizza."

"My delivery was fast."

Good to know

1

Expect quick wait times for wings and pizza orders.

2

They charge a fee for card payments on orders under $10.

3

Halal options are available on the menu.

08
Andy's Pizza Restaurant image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small hole-in-the-wall spot shines with outstanding crust and fresh toppings like onions and sausage. Family-owned vibe adds charm while reasonable prices and quick service make it easy to enjoy. Wings are tasty, complementing the thin crust pizza perfectly.

Outstanding crust and fresh toppings like onions and sausage stand out on the pizzas here. The Margherita pizza and classic New Haven style options deliver really good, delicious flavors consistently.

People are saying

"The pizza here is amazing and delicious."

"The salad was crisp with juicy chicken."

"The American Food here has great customer service."

Good to know

1

The menu board clearly lists cheese pizza at $3.00 per slice and sodas at $1.25 each.

2

The staff told me my total was $16.10, which did not match the sum of the prices on the menu.

3

The restaurant's policy requires customers to call the same day for a refund.

09
Pizza Works image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy buttery crust pizza with unique toppings like eggplant parmigiana and pepperoni. Calzones are a must-try and prices stay affordable. Feel the homey atmosphere while dining, though seating could be fresher. Delivery is always prompt and reliable.

Pizza features a buttery crust that stands out. Varieties like eggplant parmigiana and pepperoni come with great flavor and quality. Delivery is prompt and reliable.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was superior to most other places."

"The delivery here is so fast!"

"This calzone is the best I've ever had on the planet."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash at Pizza Works.

2

The prices at Pizza Works are very affordable.

3

The restaurant is very clean.

Discover more

West Haven, Connecticut

Area guide
Loading Map...