Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Florida's best

Key lime pie and cookie spots

Made for those who demand the tart citrus punch of key lime pie alongside the satisfying crunch of a gourmet cookie.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sweet Lich's image 1
Sweet Lich's image 2
Sweet Lich's image 3
View all
Cookie shop

Cookie shop with Instagram chic decor and family-friendly design including a chalk wall and toy box for kids. Atmosphere feels warm and playful with seating by large windows and a cushioned sofa. Known for best cookies in town, creating a welcoming spot for families and cookie lovers alike.

Bright, tangy key lime flavor stands out in the pie. The texture is smooth and creamy, making it a delicious dessert option.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out as some of the best in the area. These cookies have a unique taste and texture that make them amazing and highly memorable.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing, soft, and chewy."

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and full of flavor."

"I found the Key Lime Pie flavor to be so amazing."

Good to know

1

Catering services are available for events like birthdays and corporate functions.

2

The shop maintains a clean environment for customers.

3

Sweet Lich's offers gluten-free cookie options.

02
Daniel's Miami image 1
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with tasteful decor and spacious seating creates a cozy, elegant atmosphere that balances liveliness with easy conversation. Bar area offers a compact, beautiful space for casual drinks or full meals. Attention to detail shows in impeccable service and carefully crafted experiences throughout.

Very tangy but balanced flavor defines the key lime pie. It often steals the show during meals.

The cookie skillet stands out as a rich dessert topped with vanilla bean ice cream. It offers a warm, gooey texture that pairs well with the cold ice cream.

People are saying

"The food here is exquisite, with incredible flavor and quality."

"The cookie skillet dessert was delicious with vanilla bean ice cream."

"The key lime pie totally stole the show."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 5-7pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

They participate in Miami Spice, offering a special menu at a great value.

03
Charlie's Bakery & Creamery image 1

Bright, modern bakery with old-fashioned charm and a newly renovated interior offers a family-friendly atmosphere and ample seating. Sweet bakery aromas and color-changing spoons create a lively, nostalgic vibe. The space balances clean, welcoming design with playful, memorable details.

Authentic Florida style shines in the key lime pie, which stands out as a go-to dessert. Variations include a key lime pie on a stick, and the pies consistently deliver delicious baked goods quality.

Chocolate chip and black-and-white cookies stand out for their rich flavor. Cookies here are consistently delicious and often paired with pastries and ice cream.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was award-winning and super premium."

"The cookies here are stunning and delicious."

"I considered their Key Lime Pie the best."

Good to know

1

Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery offers dairy-free ice cream options.

2

There is ample parking available at Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery.

3

Customers can sign up for a rewards program to receive discounts.

04
Sister Honey's image 1

Scratch bakery with an adorable shop and open display case lets customers watch baking in action. Atmosphere feels mom-and-pop and intimate, with award-winning cakes like Carrot Cake and Hummingbird Cake that sell out quickly. Flavors change daily, and full pies require advance orders.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious and amazing dessert here. It often tops the list alongside other favorites like coconut cream pie and hummingbird cake.

Ginger cookies stand out as phenomenal here. The magic cookie bar and other treats like cupcakes and cakes also offer a delicious variety.

People are saying

"You have to try the amazing cupcakes and cakes at this bakery."

"I heard the Key Lime Pie here was amazing."

"The ginger cookies here are phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Full pies are available only by order.

2

You need to plan a few weeks in advance to order a cake.

3

The cakes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

05
Fireman Derekโ€™s Bake Shop image 1

Bakery offers top-rated pies and cakes with distinctive flavors like Nutella and guava cookies. Atmosphere is busy and lively in a popular shopping area. Prices are notably high for small portions, reflecting a premium dessert experience.

Slices of Key Lime Pie come with a rich, tangy flavor that stands out. The pie is priced at around $10 per slice and offers a delicious balance of sweetness and citrus.

Large and decadent cookies come in standout flavors like guava and chocolate chip. Warm and dangerously good, these cookies offer a rich, indulgent treat.

People are saying

"The red velvet cake here is the best I've ever tasted."

"These cookies are dangerously good, especially the chocolate chip."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was even better than down in the Keys."

Good to know

1

The shop is open late, serving sweet treats until 11pm.

2

A slice of key lime pie costs $10, which may seem high.

3

The bakery offers a variety of cakes, pies, and ice cream.

06
The Pie Factory - Largo Florida image 1

Old school pie shop with great old Florida vibes and a wide variety of pies. Atmosphere is cute and dog friendly, welcoming pet owners with water bowls. Pies like key lime and peanut butter stand out for their flavor and quality.

Authentic recipe shines in the key lime pie, delivering a fantastic and delicious flavor. It stands out as a favorite with consistently positive feedback.

Cookies come in light and not very sweet varieties, pairing well with coffee. The gingerbread and banana cream cookies stand out for their flavor and texture.

People are saying

"The pie here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

"I loved their key lime pie; it was phenomenal."

"I had the best Key Lime Pie I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The price of $15 for a large pie is considered fantastic.

2

They offer a wide variety of pies to choose from.

3

The store is very clean and well-maintained.

07
Bright Ice Scoop Shop Water St image 1

Cozy ice cream shop with unique flavors and generous portions creates a welcoming vibe. Bright, clean space includes outdoor seating and offers reusable tasting spoons for samples. Atmosphere feels fresh and inviting, appealing to families and casual visitors alike.

Key Lime Pie ice cream stands out with a bright, tangy flavor. It competes closely with other unique options like lemon caramelized ginger and oat of this world.

Marshmallows, cookies, and caramel bring rich flavor to the ice cream. Cookies and cream flavor stands out, while oat cookie flavor leans a bit too sweet. Pieces of textured cookie appear unexpectedly in some flavors.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so creative and delicious."

"I found their cookies and cream ice cream to be very good."

"I found the Key Lime Pie ice cream to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

The shop offers many unique flavor options not found in typical ice cream shops.

2

Generous portions of ice cream are served at reasonable prices.

3

Dairy-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

08
Gramma's Bakery image 1

Cases brim with fresh pastries and varied cakes, creating a dessert wonderland filled with incredible aromas. Friendly chatter happens behind the counter, giving a casual, welcoming vibe. Specialty items like Key Lime Pie and seeded Italian bread stand out for their quality and flavor.

A slice offers a not too sweet flavor with a thin, crunchy crust. The pie combines great value and taste in one serving.

Raspberry Butter Cookies with red sprinkles and Rainbow Cookies stand out among a wide variety of cakes, cookies, and pastries. Rugelach and Sfogliatelle also add to the impressive cookie selection.

People are saying

"The cakes at this bakery are delicious and beautifully made."

"I thought the key lime pie was the best I had ever tasted."

"I thought their Key Lime Pie was tremendous and tasty."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult on holidays due to the busy shopping area.

2

There is a parking lot in front of the bakery, but it can fill up quickly.

3

The bakery offers fruit desserts only on Wednesdays and Saturdays.

Discover more

Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...