Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Orlando

Key lime pie

Key lime pie that hits the right balance of tart and sweet without being buried under a mountain of whipped cream.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Winter Park Pie Company image 1
Winter Park Pie Company image 2
Winter Park Pie Company image 3
View all

Pie shop shines with light, flaky crusts and exceptional flavor. Key lime pie delivers a fresh, sweet, tart taste with a thin crust that stays satisfying. Family-owned vibe and easy ordering make it a local favorite.

Key lime pie offers a fresh, sweet, and tart flavor with an old fashioned homemade taste. The crust tends to be on the thinner side, but the pie remains delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"I loved their cherry pie; it reminded me of grandma's baking."

"This American food's pie crust is buttery, flaky, and delicious."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be phenomenal, sweet, and tart."

Good to know

1

Ordering from Winter Park Pie Company is easy and communication is seamless.

2

Delivery is very convenient and can be arranged for special occasions.

3

Expect to pay a premium price for high-quality, homemade pies.

02
Sister Honey's image 1

Scratch bakery offers an intimate, mom-and-pop vibe with an open display case showing baking in action. Award-winning cakes like Carrot and Hummingbird sell out fast. Key lime pie shines as a delicious dessert alongside coconut cream pie. Flavors change daily, and full pies need advance orders.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious and amazing dessert here. It often tops the list alongside other favorites like coconut cream pie and hummingbird cake.

People are saying

"You have to try the amazing cupcakes and cakes at this bakery."

"This pistachio cake is amazing; I ate it for breakfast, lunch, and dinner."

"I heard the Key Lime Pie here was amazing."

Good to know

1

Full pies are available only by order.

2

You need to plan a few weeks in advance to order a cake.

3

The cakes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

03
Charlie's Bakery & Creamery image 1

Bright, modern bakery blends old-fashioned charm with a family-friendly vibe and ample seating. Authentic Florida key lime pie shines, including a unique pie on a stick. Sweet aromas and playful details like color-changing spoons create a lively, nostalgic atmosphere.

Authentic Florida style shines in the key lime pie, which stands out as a go-to dessert. Variations include a key lime pie on a stick, and the pies consistently deliver delicious baked goods quality.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was award-winning and super premium."

"I've been going to this bakery for over 30 years."

"I considered their Key Lime Pie the best."

Good to know

1

Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery offers dairy-free ice cream options.

2

There is ample parking available at Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery.

3

Customers can sign up for a rewards program to receive discounts.

04
Bruster's Real Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop shines with freshly made waffle cones and a cozy atmosphere featuring shaded outdoor seating. Fruit lovers enjoy the Key Lime Pie flavor, a standout among options like strawberry and banana pudding. Friendly vibe and sweet aromas draw a diverse crowd.

Offers a Key Lime Pie flavor alongside other fruit-inspired options like strawberry and banana pudding. The pie flavor stands out as a favorite among the fruit lovers' selection.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was delicious and top-notch."

"The staff at this ice cream shop are so kind and attentive."

"I loved the Key Lime Pie and mango sorbet."

Good to know

1

On the day I visited, they were not accepting credit cards.

2

They offer free ice cream for kids under 40 inches.

3

Bruster's prices are higher compared to other locations.

05
Fish On Fire image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood shines in a lively Florida dive bar with inside/outside bar and live music on Saturdays. Outdoor seating suits families well. Don't miss the authentic Key Lime Pie, a tart, homemade treat that steals the show.

Authentically tart and homemade, the Key Lime Pie stands out with a delicious flavor that often becomes the highlight of the meal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the crispy fried shrimp."

"The live music here has talented musicians and a great vibe."

"The Key Lime Pie here is authentically tart and so delicious."

Good to know

1

Fish On Fire hosts trivia nights every Tuesday at 8pm.

2

Live music is featured on Thursday nights with a special menu.

3

The restaurant offers a full slab of ribs and chicken wings special for $21 on Thursdays.

06
Bahama Breeze image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Caribbean-themed spot shines with live island music and a spacious outdoor patio that feels lively on weekends and calm on weekdays. Key lime pie is a phenomenal dessert that pairs perfectly with seafood like Mahi Mahi tacos. Cozy fire pits add warmth and charm.

Key lime pie stands out as a phenomenal dessert with a fabulous flavor that pairs well with seafood dishes like Mahi Mahi tacos and seafood medley.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and served in a reasonable time."

"The happy hour service is friendly and attentive."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

3

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during peak dinner hours.

07
The Oceanaire Seafood Room image 1
Fine dining restaurant

Upscale seafood spot offers a romantic ambiance with subdued lighting and elegant decor. Enjoy exceptional cocktails alongside dishes like Chicken Fried Lobster. Don't miss the Key lime pie, a standout dessert perfect for special occasions.

Key lime pie stands out as a great dessert here, often recommended alongside dishes like Chicken Fried Lobster.

People are saying

"The seafood here, especially the oysters, is excellent."

"The dinner spots here have super friendly and accommodating staff."

"I should try the Key Lime Pie here."

Good to know

1

Parking is validated if you drive yourself.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during special events.

3

The restaurant participates in the Magical Dining event.

08
Bites & Bubbles image 1
Restaurant

Rooftop seating creates a cozy atmosphere with romantic lighting. Cocktails are expertly crafted, matching the lively yet relaxed vibe. Key Lime Pie shines with natural color and a perfectly balanced sour and creamy taste.

Incredible natural color and balanced sourness and creaminess define the Key Lime Pie. The crust offers a firm bite, complementing the pie's real Key Lime flavor without being too tart or sweet.

People are saying

"The staff here makes dinner spots so delightful and attentive."

"The cocktails here are creative, well-balanced, and enjoyable."

"The Key Lime Pie is tart and sweet, a perfect combination."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available on Saturdays at the rooftop bar.

2

Monthly wine dinners offer a unique dining experience.

3

Reservations for special events are recommended to secure a spot.

Discover more

Orlando, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...