Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Orlando

New York style pizza and Italian food

A proper Italian meal that understands the specific, folded-slice geometry of a real New York pizza.

Based on 838 Opinions
+835
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Flame Pizzeria image 1
Flame Pizzeria image 2
Flame Pizzeria image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant inside a gas station offers a cozy atmosphere with smooth jazz and a well-decorated dining area. The space feels clean and authentic, creating a welcoming vibe that contrasts with its location. It attracts those seeking authentic New York-style pizza in a relaxed setting.

Thin crust and delicious flavor define the New York style pizza here. Service is solid, with A+ quality pizza that closely matches authentic New York pizza.

Pasta stands out with rich flavors and solid texture. The chicken parmigiana sub comes with fries and offers a hearty option. Wings and pizza also feature prominently in the menu.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was perfect, with a crispy undercarriage."

"This New York Style Pizza is the best I've ever had."

"I thought the pasta and wings were excellent Italian food."

Good to know

1

Flame Pizzeria is located inside a gas station, offering a unique dining experience.

2

Prices at Flame Pizzeria are very affordable, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment for customers.

02
Amore Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant image 1

Family-run Italian restaurant offers authentic New York-style pizza with a cozy, intimate vibe and comfortable seating. Atmosphere feels like dining at a relative's home, relaxed and welcoming without pretense. Fresh ingredients and carefully crafted dishes create a genuine, inviting experience.

Solid New York style pizza comes with classic pin wheels, showing an old school Italian touch. The pizza stands out alongside tasty subs, soups, and salads.

Bruschetta comes with a fresh garlicky crunch. Pasta fagioli soup offers rich flavor. Vodka pasta is creamy and perfectly cooked. The Amore baked trio pasta stands out as a favorite.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and authentic."

"The pasta dinners here are creamy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked."

"I enjoyed their delicious New York Style Pizza slices."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available for under $10 on weekdays.

2

Expect a 30-minute wait during weekend dinner hours.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but there's a 3% surcharge.

03
Pizza Paradiso image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, unassuming pizzeria with a cozy, family-oriented atmosphere and warm lighting. Offers fresh, New York-style pizza and other Italian dishes at reasonable prices. Feels like a hidden gem with a relaxed, welcoming vibe.

Crunchy crust stands out on the New York style pizza here. The pizza offers a classic thin, crispy base with a well-balanced sauce and cheese blend.

Fresh sauces coat amazing pastas like fettuccini Alfredo and Penne Ala Vodka. The menu also features delicious chicken Parmesan and bruschetta pizza, plus classic lasagna and garlic bread.

People are saying

"I believed their pizza was the best on the East side."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is the best."

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be the best, with a crunchy crust."

Good to know

1

Pizza Paradiso offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options.

2

A 20-inch cheese pizza costs $20, which is a good deal for its quality.

3

The drink is refillable for dine-in customers.

04
Pizzeria Valdiano image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small dining room offers a cozy, family vibe with casual, welcoming energy. Outdoor patio provides a cool, relaxed space. Atmosphere feels like authentic New York City pizza spots with friendly, polite staff.

Offers authentic New York style pizza that closely matches the quality found in New York. Recognized for its real NY pizza taste and considered the best option near UCF for this style.

Baked ziti delivers a flavor explosion with perfectly cooked pasta and melted cheeses. Chicken fettuccine Alfredo offers a creamy, rich sauce with tender, seasoned chicken. Pizza crust is crispy and chewy with tangy tomato sauce and melty mozzarella.

People are saying

"The Primavera pizza is juicy and full of flavor."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, is amazing and exactly how I like it."

"I felt like I was back in NYC with this authentic New York style pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead for pick-up is recommended.

2

The pizzeria offers both dine-in and takeout options.

3

Prices for pizza slices and drinks are very affordable.

05
Napoli Pizza Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers authentic New York-style pizza with generous toppings and fresh ingredients. Warm interior creates a pleasant, cozy atmosphere where a humble family runs the place efficiently. Busy spots inside reflect steady patronage without rush or noise.

Pizza here has a thin crust and a foldable slice just like classic New York style. The sauce and cheese balance matches what you'd find in New York, making it the closest taste to that style in the area.

Chicken Alfredo Pizza stands out with large portions served alongside salad and garlic knots. Pasta dishes like penne vodka and thick ravioli come highly recommended and are consistently good for delivery.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the pizza and pasta."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had in a long time."

"This New York Style Pizza tastes the closest to the real thing."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during busy dinner hours.

2

The restaurant charges an extra fee for additional sauces.

3

Delivery costs can be high compared to dining in.

06
Solorzano's Pizzeria & Poolside Bistro image 1

Pizza restaurant combines Brooklyn-style decor with an outdoor poolside patio featuring a DJ and hookah. Atmosphere stays upbeat and lively even in the morning, with a mix of indoor and outdoor seating. Amenities include a basketball court and pond, creating a relaxed yet energetic vibe.

Offers real New York style pizza that stands out in the area. The pizza features a classic thin crust and authentic flavors that match those from New York.

Shrimp fettuccine Alfredo and vodka penne stand out with their rich flavors. Garlic knots arrive large and soft, paired with homemade marinara sauce.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always 10/10."

"The pizza and garlic knots here are amazing."

"I found the pizza to be legit New York style."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 12 to 3pm with unlimited pizza and drinks.

2

Karaoke nights are held on Mondays and Tuesdays for guests to enjoy.

3

The restaurant hosts Sunday Football games for sports fans.

07
John & Johnโ€™s - A Pizza Shop image 1

Small pizza shop with a cozy retro vibe and limited seating inside and out. Music plays softly, creating a pleasant atmosphere that gets noisy during busy times. Known for thin New York style pizza, it offers a comfortable, casual dining experience.

Authentic New York style pizza comes with a thin, foldable crust and a balanced sauce to cheese ratio. The slices are large and flavorful, capturing the classic New York pizza experience.

Pizza comes by the pie or slice with hot honey and Italian sausage adding bold flavor. The mozzarella plank is a gigantic fried cheese block that oozes goodness. Sauces like marinara and vodka come on the side and are rich enough to drink.

People are saying

"I found the New York style pizza I was looking for."

"This Philly Cheesesteak is the best I've ever had."

"This Italian food's pizza has a crust to die for."

Good to know

1

The Friday night freestyle performance starts at 8pm.

2

Parking is available nearby, but can be limited during busy hours.

3

Seating is limited, so arrive early to secure a table.

08
Proccolino's Ristorante & Pizzeria image 1

Small Italian restaurant offers an authentic New York style pizza experience in a cozy, family-oriented setting. Walls display original paintings and sculptures, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere with quiet comfort and intimate decor.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a delicious taste and affordable prices.

Pizza stands out with options like Philly Pizza and Alfredo Carbonara Pizza that deliver rich flavors. The chicken parmesan features super cheesy layers and a fresh-out-of-the-oven crunch, while pasta dishes come with braided garlic bread that complements the meal.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza and pasta, is amazing."

"I found the authentic Italian food here tasted just like Italy."

"I found the New York style pizza to be very good and authentic."

Good to know

1

Proccolino's offers authentic New York style pizza.

2

The menu features a diverse range of freshly made options.

3

No side salad is included with the entree.

09
Panino's Pizza & Grill image 1
Pizza restaurant

New York style pizza dominates with authentic crust and large slices that fill up diners. Bright, clean space offers a sit-down vibe reminiscent of classic East Coast pizzerias. Prices balance well with generous portions, attracting groups and casual eaters alike.

Selection of specialty New York style pizzas stands out. Feels like stepping into a New Jersey or New York style pizza place.

Pizzas come with fresh Buffalo mozzarella, basil oil, and savory sauce. Lunch specials include fettuccine Alfredo at a good price. Slices feature toppings like thin-sliced tomatoes, fresh spinach, ricotta, and classic pepperoni.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked."

"The pizza here really hits the spot, especially late night."

"It felt like a real New York style pizza place."

Good to know

1

The lunch special is available from Monday to Friday before 3pm.

2

The pizza slices cost $7.50 each.

3

The restaurant stays open late on weekends.

10
I LOVE NY PIZZA image 1
Restaurant

Small, cozy pizza joint with New York-style decor and sports-themed photographs creates an authentic vibe. Friendly, busy atmosphere feels like a classic mom-and-pop spot with affordable prices and quick service. Regulars enjoy thin crust pizza and organic sauce that capture true New York flavor.

Offers very tasty New York-style pizza with lots of toppings and unbeatable prices. The pizza quality stands out as above average and exactly what you expect from NY style.

Lasagna pizza stands out with rich flavors. Chicken parmesan heroes come stacked and satisfying. Pasta options like homemade ravioli and calzone Stromboli deliver solid Italian tastes.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza tastes like the real deal."

"It's so Kid Friendly; even picky eaters loved the pizza."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

The specials include two slices and a drink for under $9.

2

The lunch special pricing is the best around at $8.99.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred.

11
Ferrara Pizza & Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy dining room with a recent remodel and a cool Yankees mural sets a welcoming scene. Warm, family-oriented atmosphere with classical instrumental music creates a relaxed, energetic vibe. Known for authentic, consistently delicious pizza and great family atmosphere.

Pizza features a gooey texture and authentic New York style taste. It closely resembles classic New York pizza in flavor and style.

Creamy chicken Alfredo pasta comes with generous portions and rich sauce. Large rigatoni Palermo serves two, and pizza features crispy, melted mozzarella. Pasta dishes arrive hot and fresh, including a standout vodka sauce.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always fresh."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is packed with flavor."

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was outstanding and really good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers takeout service for quick meals.

2

Prices for pizza can exceed $40, depending on the order.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but check for any additional fees.

12
Bronx Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant with New York City style and Bronx street sign decor creates a homely, cozy atmosphere that feels welcoming and lively. The space suits families and casual outings, often getting a bit noisy inside. It offers counter service with pizza by the slice and a simple, family-friendly layout.

Pizza here captures authentic New York style with a thin crust and classic toppings. It offers a true New York flavor that stands out in Florida for its value and quality.

Bruschetta and fried ravioli stand out with fresh flavors. The menu features pizza, lasagna, and Philly cheesesteaks alongside pasta and cannolis.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, just like homemade Italian."

"I found their New York Style Pizza to be truly authentic."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 20-30 minutes for fresh pizza orders.

2

Pizza is available by the slice, making it easy to try different flavors.

3

The restaurant operates as a counter-service, so no tips are required.

Discover more

Orlando, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...