Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Pompano Beach's best

Italian pizza spots

A slice of pizza or a classic Italian meal to satisfy a specific hunger.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Peter’s Pizzeria image 1
Peter’s Pizzeria image 2
Peter’s Pizzeria image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Open kitchen with vintage gas-fired ovens and temperature-controlled dough room creates an authentic New York-style pizza experience. Cozy, lively atmosphere feels like a family-run neighborhood spot with modern marble accents. Small space offers bar seating and outdoor tables, blending old-school charm with contemporary comfort.

Slices come with options like a broccoli garlic pinwheel and fried ravioli. Mozzarella sticks appear even when not on the menu. Cannolis use some imported ingredients and follow a great grandmother's recipe.

New York style pizza stands out with its authentic taste and texture. It ranks among the best pizzas in Florida and is a consistent family favorite.

People are saying

"I found the best New York Style Pizza in Broward."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've ever had."

"I thought the Italian food, especially the pizza, was delicious and crispy."

Good to know

1

The pizza costs $34 for a three-topping pizza.

2

They do not accept pickup orders for slices.

3

You must come in and wait for the slices.

02
The Doughfellas - Pompano Beach image 1

Small pizza restaurant with cozy, welcoming atmosphere and clean, updated interior seating about 20. Serves high-quality, homemade pizzas with care and no seed oils. Open only on weeknights, offering a friendly, home-like environment.

Freshly made pizzas feature a crisp crust and mozzarella cheese that stands out. Focaccia breads, including a unique zucchini and Brie option, complement the menu alongside tasty burrata and white pizzas with arugula and prosciutto.

Pizza here stands out for its phenomenal flavor and amazing quality. It consistently ranks as the best pizza in the area with a taste that impresses deeply.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was the best I had ever tasted."

"The in-house smoked sausage here is crazy good."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, has a perfect crispy crust."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers pick-up and delivery via a delivery service.

2

Customers can stop and dine in at The Doughfellas.

3

They are now open on Sundays.

03
MarToni Lounge image 1

Large bar space hosts a laid-back atmosphere with live music and a pool table that draw a friendly crowd. Lighting and tunes create a cozy vibe ideal for relaxing or casual hangouts. New York-style pizza and drinks complement the easygoing energy.

Spaghetti and eggplant parmigiana stand out with rich flavors. Pasta dishes like Carbonara with ricotta and baked cheese ravioli show solid variety. A small cheese pie with pesto and cannolis add some sweet and savory touches.

New York style pizza features huge slices with a crispy yet soft crust and fresh ingredients. The sauce tastes delicious and the pizza has a bit of grease to boost flavor.

People are saying

"This is a great late night spot for pizza with a crunchy crust."

"This thin crust pizza is the best I've had in years."

"This New York-style pizza has a delicious crunchy crust."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4:00 to 7:00 PM with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Open mic night occurs weekly, providing a platform for local talent.

3

Poker night is hosted every Monday, starting at 7 PM.

04
Nick's Pizza Pompano image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small family-owned pizza restaurant offers authentic New York style pizza with high-quality cheese and perfect crust. The atmosphere feels immaculate and welcoming, attracting those seeking genuine NYC flavors. Large, flavorful slices and a broad menu make it a standout spot in the community.

New York-style pizza and pasta dishes stand out here, especially the penne alla vodka and chicken Alfredo pizza. Eggplant parmigiana and chicken with penne ala vodka also feature prominently on the menu.

Pizza here has a perfect flop with excellent sauce and crust that nails authentic New York style. Slices like pepperoni and buffalo chicken come huge and loaded with toppings.

People are saying

"I found the best New York Style Pizza in Florida here."

"I thought the pizza here was really good and authentic NYC style."

"The pizza here is on point and absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Nick's Pizza Pompano offers a vast selection of dishes including specialty pizzas and pasta.

2

The delivery time is fast, ensuring your food arrives promptly.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere on Friday evenings, so plan accordingly.

05
Italia Station Cafe image 1

Small, authentic Italian restaurant with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that feels like an Italian household. The space is beautifully remodeled and exudes family vibes and authenticity. It offers table service and delivery, creating a relaxed spot for casual meals.

Hearty dishes like Rigatoni Bolognese and homemade lasagna showcase rich, authentic flavors. Fresh baked bread, pecorino cheese, and perfectly sauced spaghetti and meatballs add to the genuine Italian experience.

An authentic old school pizza features a great mix of veggies, capers, and olives. The pepperoni pizza includes only 12 pieces of pepperoni and costs $13.99.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is wonderfully authentic and made fresh."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is hearty, rich, and incredibly flavorful."

"The pizza here is amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

2

Expect generous portions at reasonable prices.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

06
Ruby's by the Sea image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with red checkered tablecloths and fun lights creating a family-owned, village-like atmosphere. The vibe is casual and quiet, resembling an Italian grandma's kitchen or a quaint Italian village. It serves authentic Italian food with a focus on pizza and homemade soups.

Authentic Italian dishes like Penne Alla Vodka, Chicken Piccata, and Tortellini with Alfredo sauce stand out for their rich flavors. Desserts include tasty cannolis that complement the savory meals well.

Pizza features a thin and crispy crust with a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The chef brings Sicilian expertise, delivering slices that rival New York style with consistent freshness and flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and perfectly made."

"The outdoor seating here is delicious, just like the pizza."

"The Italian food here is so delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $3 beers before 7pm, making drinks more affordable.

2

Parking is free and easy, but can be limited during busy times.

3

The menu features a large pizza for $16, with meat toppings for $3 each.

07
Pasquales Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy, classic interior offers a friendly, family atmosphere with a neighborhood gem feel. The vibe is comfortable and welcoming, suited for casual meals with loved ones. Known for authentic Italian-style pizza and generous portions at affordable prices.

Lasagna stands out as excellent and amazing. Pasta dishes like pasta faggioli and spaghetti with meat sauce are solid choices. Mozzarella sticks have a gummy texture and a burnt-tasting sauce.

Authentic, old-school pizza shines with fresh dough, sauce, and bread made daily. The New York style influence stands out, especially in the white pizza, which many find top of the line.

People are saying

"I found the food to be top of the line and authentic."

"This pizza is delicious, like old-school perfection."

"The Italian food here is just okay, nothing special."

Good to know

1

Expect a 10-15 minute wait for pizza during busy hours.

2

Takeout is popular, and orders are ready in about 15 minutes.

3

Prices are reasonable, with large portions for families.

08
Rotelli Pizza & Pasta image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, rustic Italian restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with a family relaxed vibe and authentic Italian music. The space feels clean and homey, creating a tranquil and comforting setting. Guests often enjoy hearty, well-prepared dishes like homemade pasta and flavorful pizza.

Homemade pasta stands out with perfect texture and rich flavor. Dishes like veggie lasagna, ravioli filled with cheese, and penne alla vodka offer distinct tastes. The marinara sauce and garlic knots are also notable for their strong, tasty profiles.

Rotelli special and Buffalo chicken pizza stand out for their fresh, delicious flavors. The pizza pairs well with garlic knots and comes with fast, courteous service.

People are saying

"The homemade Italian food, especially the marinara and garlic knots, is amazing."

"The seafood here is delicious, especially the blackened shrimp."

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

The restaurant closes at 9 pm sharp, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Credit card payments are not accepted; bring cash for your meal.

3

Prices for pizzas start at $20, with $5 for each additional topping.

09
Big Louie's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old-time pizza parlor vibe fills the cozy dining room with Italian music that enhances the authentic atmosphere. Energy stays chill and welcoming, perfect for relaxed nights out. Regulars enjoy fresh, outstanding pizza and classic Italian dishes in a setting that feels like a trip to Naples.

Lasagna stands out with fresh sauce and solid execution. Tiramisu comes homemade and rich. Other highlights include bruschetta, chicken fettuccine, Caesar salad, mussels, meatballs, and spinach pizza.

Pizza features a fantastic thin crust with gooey cheese and high-quality toppings. Options include half cheese and pepperoni, fire pizza, and sides like garlic rolls, all fresh and fairly priced.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be amazing and fresh."

"The homemade tiramisu was delectable and reminded me of my grandmother's cooking."

"The lunch specials here are excellent and a great deal."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited; be cautious to avoid being towed.

2

The restaurant caps DoorDash orders at $100, including taxes and fees.

3

Lunch prices are reasonable, making it a good value for families.

10
Pompano Pizza & Italian Eatery image 1

Small space with heavily Italian-fun decor creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Quiet and peaceful vibe suits relaxed dining. Offers thin-crust and thick-crust pizzas praised for their deliciousness.

Fettuccini Alfredo stands out with a rich, creamy sauce. Spaghetti comes with just two meatballs, which feels sparse. Pizza orders can get mixed up, like receiving chicken instead of shrimp pasta.

Argentinian pizza stands out with a unique flavor and is served both thin and thick crust. Vegetarian options and pizzas with faina and wings add variety, while whole pizzas taste better than slices left out.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the absolute best."

"It's so Kid Friendly, the food is great for low prices."

"I thought the Italian food, especially the pizza, was very good."

Good to know

1

Expect a long wait for food during busy hours.

2

Prices at the register may differ from those online.

3

Staff hygiene practices raise serious concerns about food safety.

Discover more

Pompano Beach, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...