Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Potato salad spots in St. Petersburg

Potato salad that tastes like it was made in a kitchen rather than scooped from a plastic tub.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Side Door Deli & Restaurant image 1
Side Door Deli & Restaurant image 2
Side Door Deli & Restaurant image 3
View all

Classic deli setup evokes old school New York with colorful floral decor and a cozy, casual vibe. Atmosphere stays relaxed and friendly during breakfast and lunch hours. Family-run feel with fresh, made-to-order food and reasonable prices.

Food comes out fresh and hot with a diner-style vibe. Service stays consistently great, with owners checking in to ensure satisfaction.

Potato salad here is very delicious and pleasantly satisfying. It comes as a perfect side, especially with sandwiches and classic dishes like the Reuben.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has delicious, fresh food with large portions."

"The owners here treat you like friends and make the food feel special."

"I tried the potato salad; it was very delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as it can get very busy.

2

Prices are very reasonable for the portion sizes.

3

Breakfast specials include a beverage, which saves money.

02
Fatty's BBQ & Soul Food image 1
Southern restaurant (US)

Hole-in-the-wall spot with colorful artwork and a welcoming vibe creates a sense of community and camaraderie. The atmosphere feels like ordering from family, with mouthwatering aromas drawing people in. Known for top-notch barbecue and perfectly cooked sides, it offers great prices and a cool, intimate setting.

Food here is tender, flavorful, and perfectly smoked with a fresh and affordable touch. The barbecue and soul food stand out as some of the best in the area, consistently delicious and satisfying.

Potato salad stands out with its delicious flavor and is clearly not your average side dish. It pairs well with ribs, chicken, and other classic sides, making it a very good choice.

People are saying

"The barbecue here is some of the best I've ever had."

"I thought this BBQ was the best I've had in Florida."

"Their potato salad was delicious and not your average."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available for $11, offering great value.

2

Portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

3

Takeout is a popular option due to limited indoor seating.

03
German Knodle image 1
European restaurant

Tiny European restaurant offers a cozy, homey atmosphere with light, relaxing decor and seating both inside and on a patio with umbrellas. The vibe is quiet and welcoming, ideal for small parties and people watching outside. Guests enjoy authentic German cuisine paired with great German beers on tap.

Authentic German cuisine shines with consistent quality and quick service. German staff and a skilled kitchen team ensure the food feels homey and genuine.

Potato salad here is very German with no mayo and a vinegary tang. It pairs well with schnitzel and sausages, offering a refreshing contrast to fried dishes.

People are saying

"The authentic German food here is amazing and flavorful and always amazing and flavorful."

"The German food here is authentic and delicious."

"The potato salad here is so refreshing."

Good to know

1

The menu features a variety of traditional German sausages and schnitzel.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to other downtown dining options.

3

Vegan and vegetarian options are available and well-received.

04
JO-EL'S Kosher Deli, Market & Café image 1

Warehouse-style exterior opens into a cozy space with nostalgic décor and homey atmosphere. Seating includes 8 booths that invite lingering over meals. The vibe recalls a classic Jewish deli kitchen, warm and welcoming.

Food here stays fresh, delicious, and strictly kosher. Quality runs high from deli sandwiches to desserts, making every bite stand out.

Creamy and tangy with loaded flavor, the potato salad stands out. The pastrami and Israeli versions add unique twists that impress.

People are saying

"I found it to be the best, authentic Jewish deli."

"Their matzo ball soup is authentically prepared and a Jewish favorite."

"The food here is always fresh, delicious, and kosher."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a wide selection of kosher groceries and prepared foods.

2

The on-site bakery provides fresh baked goods daily.

3

The deli has been family-owned for over 40 years, ensuring quality and tradition.

05
Athenian Garden image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers an easy-going, homey atmosphere with quiet Greek music and comfortable booths. The space feels inviting and authentic, with a focus on passion and pride in its service. Noise level can be typical for casual dining, but the overall vibe suits both family meals and date nights.

Greek food stands out for its freshness and flavorful quality. The dishes consistently deliver great taste alongside reliable service.

Salads come with a small scoop of potato salad right in the middle. This special twist adds a creamy, flavorful touch that stands out from typical potato salads.

People are saying

"The gyro meat here is so tender and flavorful."

"The Greek food here is so fresh and flavorful."

"I thought the potato salad in the seasoned salad was the best."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended for larger groups.

2

The lunch special offers a good value compared to dinner prices.

3

Expect higher prices than average for Greek cuisine in the area.

06
Harvey's 4th Street Grill image 1
American restaurant

Dark wood bar and grill with historic decor featuring local artifacts creates a quaint, neighborhood tavern vibe. Atmosphere feels fun and welcoming, with live entertainment on some nights and a steady local crowd. Seafood stands out as fresh and consistently excellent amid solid food and drink options.

Food here is consistently excellent with great service. The dining experience combines tasty dishes and enjoyable drinks, making it a reliable spot for meals with friends.

House-made potato salad stands out with its excellent flavor and pairs well with sandwiches and burgers. It consistently complements meals like the bacon cheeseburger and Florida Gold sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and tastes great."

"You've got to try the grouper sandwich at this Local Spot."

"I found the house-made potato salad to be phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to high demand.

2

Parking can be challenging; consider arriving early or using nearby lots.

3

Live music is featured every Saturday night, enhancing the dining experience.

07
Berlins Doener image 1
European restaurant

Simple, modern setting offers a cozy, authentic German vibe with a small patio welcoming dogs. Atmosphere feels like a delicatessen with a relaxing, welcoming energy. Regulars enjoy authentic Döner sandwiches and dark German beers that capture true flavors.

Food features authentic German cuisine with dishes like curry brats that come out freshly prepared and delicious.

Creamy yet chunky texture defines the German potato salad here, offering a flavorful and satisfying side. It pairs well with dishes like schnitzel and doner, reflecting authentic German flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was really delicious and flavorful."

"They have a great selection of German beers."

"I enjoyed the German potato salad; it was flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy to find near the restaurant.

2

Expect a 4% fee for credit card payments, despite menu prices being cash-only.

3

The night shift on Thursdays features live music.

08
Fire Water image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers cozy hippie vibe with bright, colorful indoor and outdoor seating. Atmosphere stays relaxed and friendly, encouraging easy conversation. Menu focuses on vegan and gluten-free dishes, attracting both vegans and non-vegans with flavorful, creative options.

Vegan food stands out with top notch quality and is done right here. Comfort-food style potato salad offers a delicious, hearty option beyond typical vegan dishes.

Mashed potatoes with some chunks, seasoning, and celery make up the potato salad. It blends smooth and chunky textures with a mix of flavors.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with the fresh, delicious vegetarian food here."

"The food here is delicious and made with fresh, whole ingredients."

"I found the potato salad to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to high demand.

2

Expect higher prices, with entrees averaging $22.

3

The entire menu is vegan and gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

09
Williams Sub Shop image 1
Sandwich shop

Classic sandwich shop with a mom and pop atmosphere and nostalgic 90s vibe. Casual and serene setting features classic sodas and old-school music. Known for consistent, reasonably priced subs with unique touches like tomato onion spice oil and hot pepper relish.

Food here is amazingly fresh and consistently good. Prices stay just right while the taste stays delicious every time.

Red Potato Salad stands out as a favorite among the variety of salads offered. The potato salad ranks among the top 3 best ever tasted and pairs well with other options like Greek and macaroni salads.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic and the portions are great."

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best ever."

"I thought their potato salads were the best."

Good to know

1

Williams Sub Shop has been around for nearly 60 years, making it a local staple.

2

Most of their business is for takeout, with limited seating inside.

3

They only serve Cubans on Fridays, a special menu item.

Discover more

St. Petersburg, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...