Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in St. Petersburg

Pie spots

Made for those who view a slice of pie as a non-negotiable treat and dedicate their time to tracking down the most authentic crusts and fillings.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
St. Pete Bakery Café image 1
St. Pete Bakery Café image 2
St. Pete Bakery Café image 3
View all

Small bakery offers a warm, cozy vibe with Middle Eastern décor and calming music. Spinach pie shines with its crisp, fluffy texture, while meat pies add hearty options. Space is intimate yet accessible, blending authentic Kurdish and Mediterranean flavors uniquely.

Spinach pie stands out with its warm, fluffy, and crisp texture. Meat pies also appear regularly, and the key lime pie earns praise for its flavor.

People are saying

"Their gluten-free options, like the chocolate cake, are amazing."

"The bakery staff is so warm and welcoming."

"I found the spinach pie to be fantastic, warm, fluffy, and crisp."

Good to know

1

The café offers vegan, organic, and gluten-free options.

2

They sell interesting items, including a clove necklace.

3

The macaroons are dairy free, which is helpful for those with allergies.

02
Fire Water image 1
Restaurant

Cozy hippie vibe with bright colorful seating invites relaxed chats. Menu shines with vegan and gluten-free dishes that please all eaters. Desserts like key lime pie and whoopie pie offer sweet, memorable finishes.

Key lime pie stands out as a consistently delicious dessert here. The whoopie pie also appears as a notable treat, sometimes offered free for special occasions.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with the fresh, delicious vegetarian food here."

"I loved the kale Caesar salad; it was beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the key lime pie was the best I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to high demand.

2

Expect higher prices, with entrees averaging $22.

3

The entire menu is vegan and gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

03
Rumba Island Bar & Grill image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Caribbean restaurant shines with live guitar music on a large patio and cozy indoor seating warmed by lamps. Guests savor handmade cocktails alongside fresh seafood dishes. Don't miss the authentic Key Lime Pie with lime rind bits and homemade texture, a flavorful treat often ordered whole to go.

Authentic Key Lime Pie features lime rind bits in the meringue and a homemade texture. The pie stands out for its amazing flavor and is often ordered whole to go.

People are saying

"The seafood here is great; the staff is attentive and friendly."

"The outdoor space has an enjoyable island-like atmosphere."

"You have to try the amazing key lime pie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day, every day with 2 for 1 drinks.

2

The restaurant closes at 9 PM, so arrive early.

3

The early bird lunchtime specials offer great value.

04
Sonata Restaurant image 1

Waterfront views and a live pianist create a romantic atmosphere. Key lime pie offers an excellent flavor as a divine finale. Staff mix formal and casual wear, adding to a relaxed yet elegant vibe.

Key lime pie stands out with its excellent, delicious flavor and often serves as a divine finale. Pecan pie also appears as a tasty option alongside cheesecake.

People are saying

"It's a no-brainer to grab dinner here before a show."

"The waterfront views here are gorgeous and second to none."

"The key lime pie here is excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 7 PM with discounted drinks.

2

The restaurant may start a buffet-style brunch soon.

3

Validated parking is available nearby for theatergoers.

05
Kopper Kitchen image 1
American restaurant

Old-school diner offers a cozy small town feel with nostalgic golden oldies playing. Classic American comfort food shines alongside rich peanut butter pie and smooth coconut cream pie. Spacious interior creates a laid-back vibe perfect for regulars and newcomers alike.

Peanut butter pie stands out as a favorite, rich and creamy. The coconut cream pie offers a delicious, smooth texture. The chocolate pie impresses with deep, satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"This diner serves great home cooking, made from scratch."

"I found the lunch specials here to be the best weekly."

"You have to try the peanut butter pie."

Good to know

1

The entrance to Kopper Kitchen is from the courtyard off 1st Street south.

2

Parking can be inconvenient, especially during lunch hours.

3

Kopper Kitchen offers vegan options on the menu.

06
Village Inn image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Adorable 50s decor sets a retro diner vibe with a warm, welcoming feel. Free pie on Wednesdays offers incredible flavors that draw many in. The place stays pleasantly quiet, creating a friendly atmosphere that feels vibrant yet smooth.

Free pie on Wednesdays draws many in. Pies are simply grand and incredible with excellent flavors.

People are saying

"Our server Ellie made our breakfast feel so welcoming and special."

"I loved their amazing, delicious pies."

"It's a quiet spot for a great late evening."

Good to know

1

An automatic 18% gratuity is added to all checks.

2

Free pie is offered every Wednesday.

3

Bingo night takes place on Thursdays.

07
The Irish Pub on 4th image 1

Irish pub offers a lively atmosphere with live music and cozy decor. Pies like hearty Shepherd's pie and chicken pot pie are standout dishes. Proper Guinness pours complete the authentic experience.

The pies include a Cottage pie made with all beef and a chicken pot pie that comes with mashed potatoes on top. The Shepherd's pie features good mashed potatoes on top and offers a hearty option.

People are saying

"This pub has amazing Scotch Eggs and great pub grub."

"The Bar staff here are so friendly and attentive."

"The cottage pie was very tasty."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited, so consider taking an Uber to avoid issues.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 7pm; arrive early for seating.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

Discover more

St. Petersburg, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...