Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Tampa

American and Italian Food

Navigating the overlap between American food and Italian food is the only way to satisfy a craving for both comfort and tradition.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
NY TO PHILLY image 1
NY TO PHILLY image 2
NY TO PHILLY image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small restaurant with Rocky Balboa theme and unique interior design creates an old-school, family atmosphere. Warm, welcoming energy fills the space, enhanced by great background music and personal ownership. Guests enjoy an inviting, authentic vibe with high chairs available for families.

Philly cheesesteak stands out with rich flavor and generous portions. The menu also features calzones, Stromboli, and a variety of sandwiches like the Chicken Parmesan Grinder and chicken wings.

Homemade pasta sauce delivers authentic Italian flavor. Chicken parm sandwich comes crispy and tender, smothered in rich marinara with melted mozzarella. Cannolis stand out as incredibly tasty and a must-try.

People are saying

"Their pizza is amazing with great, generous toppings."

"The American Food here, especially the cheesesteak, is insanely delicious."

"The cheesesteak here is insanely delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and easily accessible for visitors.

2

Prices are very reasonable compared to similar establishments.

3

The restaurant specializes in authentic New York pizza and cheesesteaks.

02
Doormet: Gourmet Cafe, Delivery & Catering image 1

Cafe offers a clean, modern space with a quiet, chill atmosphere. It serves gourmet entrees with generous portions and a wide variety of options, excelling in sandwiches, pizza, and salads. Delivery is quick and reliable, with food arriving hot and well-packed.

Lobster rolls stand out with consistent quality, paired well with the fresh caprese salad. Other notable dishes include the Bavarian, Rustico, grilled salmon, and a generously sized Cobb salad.

Pasta dishes feature mushrooms, pine nuts, sun-dried tomatoes, and chicken in a garlic olive oil base. Chicken Saltimbocca and chicken marsala pasta stand out alongside focaccia bread and rustico sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and consistently excellent."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta and subs, is always great."

"I loved their American Food, especially the lobster roll."

Good to know

1

Delivery is quick and food arrives hot and fresh.

2

You can customize any menu item to manage allergies.

3

Doormet offers monthly rotating specials to keep the menu interesting.

03
Henderson's image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill with cowboy-themed atmosphere and high ceilings featuring a large bar area and many TVs for games. The vibe is comfortable and casual with a lively crowd and fun games like pool and foosball. Cold drinks and a jukebox add to the energetic, friendly environment.

Pork nachos and spicy buffalo wings stand out with bold flavors. The menu also features Mac and cheese bites, flatbread pizzas, chicken wings, and classic burgers with fries.

Prosciutto, fig, and goat cheese pizza stands out as a key dish. The combination of fig and prosciutto draws attention for its flavor.

People are saying

"This sports bar has tons of TVs to catch any game."

"You have to try the bar food; the nachos and mac and cheese bites are amazing."

"You have to try the prosciutto and fig pizza; it's amazing Italian food."

Good to know

1

Henderson's offers happy hour every day with two-for-one beers.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

3

Karaoke night is on Wednesdays starting at 10pm with a two-drink minimum.

04
Home Slice Pizza Co. image 1
Pizza restaurant

Hole-in-the-wall pizza spot channels old school New York slice shop vibe with cozy atmosphere and baseball-themed decor. The place fills with friendly energy, offering plenty of seating and multiple TVs. It serves authentic New York-style pizza with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

New York style pizza stands out with its authentic taste and respect for tradition. The menu also features a meat lovers calzone and a Philly cheesesteak.

Huge anti-pasta salad serves 2-3 people. Stromboli comes with plenty of marinara sauce. Lasagna layers cheese and meat with the right amount of sauce. Cheese and lasagna slices both taste amazing.

People are saying

"This New Jersey style pizza has a perfect crust."

"The Italian food portions here are massive and tasty."

"The American Food here, especially the pizza, has a perfect crust and divine cheese."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $7 for a specialty slice.

2

The restaurant is open until 8 pm, even if the website says otherwise.

3

They offer a two-slice special during lunch hours.

05
TOMATO JOE’S NEW YORK PIZZERIA image 1

Open layout reveals pizza-making process in a clean, cozy space with homey atmosphere and fresh-baked aroma. Energy stays relaxed and welcoming, perfect for casual meals. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and crispy wings that stand out in the area.

New York style pizza features fresh daily dough and authentic preparation. Buffalo wings and boneless tenders offer a distinctive flavor alongside the pizza.

Pizzas come with mozzarella and a strong marinara flavor. Spaghetti and meatballs stand out alongside buffalo chicken pizza and wings. Pasta and wraps also feature on the menu.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"This New York style pizza is the best American food I've ever had."

"I found the Italian food here to be amazing, like pizza Picasso."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers affordable lunch specials that are ready in minutes.

2

Expect generous portions and great value for your money.

3

The pizzeria is known for its cleanliness and quality of food.

06
The Outside Kitchen image 1

Small restaurant with intimate seating and vibrant R&B music sets a chill, welcoming vibe. Live DJ energizes the space while the decor adds a cozy touch. The atmosphere feels spotless and inviting, creating a relaxed dining experience.

Rich, creamy shrimp mac and cheese stands out with juicy garlic shrimp. Lamb chops come glazed and pair well with grits. Pasta dishes feature Cajun creamy sauces, especially with shrimp and lobster or grilled chicken.

Seafood shines with shrimp, lobster tail, and crab cake featured in dishes. Pasta often pairs with Alfredo sauce and comes with generous portions like a huge lobster tail.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, flavorful, and cooked fresh."

"The lemonade here is so well balanced and delicious."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pasta."

Good to know

1

They have weekly food specials that change regularly.

2

The restaurant primarily focuses on takeout orders.

3

Expect a line for takeout orders during peak hours.

07
Riverside Seafood Fletcher image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers a bright, casual dining area with limited seating and a friendly, family vibe. Atmosphere stays calm and welcoming, resembling a simple storefront rather than a cozy spot. Occasional live music adds to the relaxed, community feel.

Fresh fish comes with good coleslaw and French fries. Hush puppies stand out more than fries. A shaker of Cajun seasoning adds subtle flavor without heat.

Shrimp pasta stands out with perfect seasoning and a tasty blend of flavors. Chicken pasta comes with garlic bread and pairs well with other seafood like oysters and grouper.

People are saying

"The food portions here are huge and satisfying."

"The shrimp pasta here is amazing."

"The American Food here, especially the fish, is super fresh."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is a quick-serve establishment, ideal for take-out.

2

Prices for meals are very affordable, with many options under $15.

3

Expect a line at the counter during peak hours, especially on weekends.

08
Madame Fortune Dessert + HiFi Parlour image 1

Speakeasy-style space with a secret entrance behind a bookshelf creates a unique setting. Live music and a jazz vibe fill the room, offering outstanding entertainment and ambient tunes. Cocktails like espresso martinis and rum punch complement the warm, inviting atmosphere that draws people in and keeps energy lively.

Lobster and Shrimp Grits stand out with rich flavors. The oxtail pairs well with shrimp and grits. The cornbread offers a unique, unmatched taste.

Chicken and shrimp pasta stands out with rich flavors. The menu also features rigatoni oxtail, seafood rice, and a curry pasta that offers a tasty twist.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented."

"You have to try the sweet potato cornbread with the American Food."

"The rigatoni oxtail was delectable and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary to ensure entrance, especially for special events.

2

Happy hour features special drinks and appetizers, typically from 4-7pm.

3

Live music nights occur regularly, enhancing the atmosphere.

09
Bella Roma NY Pizza image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers cozy, welcoming atmosphere with outdoor tables and a lit fireplace enhancing the space. It attracts those seeking authentic New York style pizza with fresh ingredients and a tasty crust. The place suits relaxed meals and late-night cravings with reasonable prices.

Philly cheesesteak features tender, juicy meat with a crispy skin on the chicken wings. The red velvet stands out as rich and flavorful.

Spaghetti meatballs come tasty and satisfying, served with plenty of marinara for dipping. Pizza slices include pepperoni and cheese, paired with mozzarella sticks and calzones for variety.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be incredibly delicious."

"This Italian food's pizza is baked well and tastes amazing."

"The pizza crust here is light yet sturdy, baked to golden perfection."

Good to know

1

They are open until 3AM on Sunday.

2

The late-night hours are convenient for those craving good food after a long day.

3

The prices at Bella Roma NY Pizza are very reasonable.

10
Sam's Pizza & Deli Café image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small dining area offers a clean, cozy atmosphere with easy parking nearby. Energy feels friendly and welcoming, enhanced by halal, pork-free pizza made from fresh dough. Regulars appreciate unique, homemade flavors and great lunch specials.

True New York style pizza stands out here. The buffalo wings come highly recommended and the Philly cheesesteak is great.

Specialty pizzas feature pesto with a balanced spicy and sweet drizzle of honey Sriracha. Marinara sauce offers a great flavor that complements the toppings like pepperoni well.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be fresh and delicious."

"The pizza here is 10/10 with a perfect crust."

"This New York style pizza is perfectly cooked and crisp to perfection."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is completely halal and offers no pork products.

2

They use fresh dough instead of frozen dough for their pizzas.

3

There is an easy parking situation available.

11
Bazille at Nordstrom image 1
American restaurant

Whimsical secret society vibe blends with relaxed atmosphere and elevated but unpretentious style. Bar seating is intimate with 7 seats, offering some of the best cocktails in the area. Dining spaces balance quiet and lively, making it suitable for casual meals or celebrations.

Hamburgers cooked medium rare come out perfectly. Brunch offers steak and eggs with three eggs and toast. Salads include a Cobb with roasted chicken and a roasted cauliflower option.

Mushroom ravioli and gnocchi stand out with good flavor and presentation. Chicken meatballs come with a spicy Bolognese sauce that balances well.

People are saying

"The calamari here is expertly prepared."

"The American Food, like the Cobb salad, was incredible."

"The Italian food here is delicious and reasonably priced."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure a table, especially during busy hours.

2

The restaurant is located inside Nordstrom on the second floor.

3

Sodas cost $4 each, and no bread or salad is included with entrees.

12
Walk-On's Sports Bistreaux - Tampa (Midtown) image 1

Multiple TV screens show various sports, creating a lively, upbeat atmosphere ideal for game days. The space balances crowd energy with enough room to feel comfortable, welcoming both groups and individuals. A full bar complements the sports-focused environment, enhancing the overall experience.

Double bacon cheeseburgers come juicy and perfectly seasoned. Dishes like butter lemon chicken with mashed potatoes and shrimp and grits offer classic American flavors.

Bayou pasta stands out with its rich seasoning and bold flavors. Blackened Chicken Alfredo comes with broccoli, and the menu includes sweet chili salmon alongside classic Alfredo pasta.

People are saying

"I thought the food was really good."

"The American Food here is great for game days with TVs everywhere."

"Our server Abbey was great and super helpful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily with great deals on appetizers and drinks.

2

Expect a lively atmosphere during major sports events.

3

Reservations are recommended for large groups, especially on weekends.

13
Wright's Gourmet House image 1

Large dining space with self-service setup and plentiful seating creates an inviting environment. Atmosphere blends nostalgic charm with a lively, relaxing vibe ideal for lunch or professional gatherings. Fresh bread and desserts add to the welcoming sensory experience.

Club sandwich stands out with fresh turkey, thousand island dressing, and crisp sides like coleslaw and dill potato salad. Bakery offers a strong selection including red velvet cake and a notable pecan pie.

Shrimp pasta stands out with its rich flavor and is a popular choice despite being quite expensive. Other Italian options include pesto pasta, deli style sandwiches, and various pasta salads like veggie and shrimp pasta salad.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches were delicious and made with high-quality ingredients."

"This American food, especially the turkey club, is so fresh and huge."

"I got hooked on the shrimp pasta; it's worth every penny."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited, so consider arriving early to secure a spot.

2

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended due to limited seating.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

14
LALA Tampa image 1
Restaurant

Private karaoke rooms offer exclusive entertainment with an extensive music library for all ages. The space combines lively, elegant atmosphere with distinctive themed decor like Gatsby and Moulin Rouge rooms. Well-crafted cocktails and standout dishes complement a vibrant social setting.

Chicken wings stand out with flavors like garlic parmesan and lemon pepper. The menu also features black truffle mac and cheese and crispy fried chicken.

Risotto dishes stand out with options like grilled octopus mushrooms risotto and wild mushroom risotto. Duck linguini and mushroom risotto with blackened chicken also feature prominently.

People are saying

"I had a blast with these fun activities!"

"The Italian food, especially the truffle mac and cheese, was delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the chicken wings, is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations for karaoke rooms are recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Parking is very limited and can be chaotic around the venue.

3

There is a 20% discount on food and drinks every Tuesday.

15
District South Kitchen & Craft image 1
New American restaurant

Small, chic space with a luxurious interior and quirky décor creates a comfortable, airy atmosphere. Low music and games add a relaxed vibe, while full service bar offers unique craft cocktails and bar seating with plugs. Outdoor seating is available but can feel muggy.

Prime rib sandwiches stand out with tender beef, onions, and cheese on toasted bread. The meatloaf and exceptional mac and cheese also feature prominently on the menu.

Pork belly gnocchi features tender meat with a crunchy exterior but the sauce can overpower the dish. Burrata Caprese salad includes nearly invisible tomatoes, and the gnocchi is generally decent.

People are saying

"The brunch food here is excellent, flavorful, and beautifully presented."

"The American Food here, especially the meatloaf, is incredible."

"I loved every Italian food dish I tried; I drooled over them."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features $5 drinks, $7 wines, and $8 cocktails.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner after 4:30pm due to high demand.

3

Parking is limited, so arrive early or consider alternative transport.

16
Pita Plus + image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers clean, cozy interior with a family-friendly atmosphere and Middle Eastern background music. It features a drive-thru and serves a wide variety of flavorful dishes including Mediterranean specialties. The vibe is warm and inviting, suitable for casual meals or family gatherings.

Philly cheesesteaks come with rich flavor and cheeseburgers have a zingy taste. The Tilapia and shrimp platter pairs well with fries and hush puppies, while the Cajun pasta offers a spicy kick.

Alfredo Penne and Cajun Pasta stand out with rich, creamy sauces and bold spices. Shrimp Alfredo adds a seafood twist to classic Italian flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and flavorful."

"Their cheeseburgers and Philly cheesesteak are delicious."

"The Italian food here is always fresh and packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

Pita Plus + offers a variety of options from carne to vegan dishes.

2

Expect large portions filled with flavor at Pita Plus +.

3

Pita Plus + is known for quick and efficient service.

17
Tampa Burgers and Pirates image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Pirate-themed hamburger restaurant with dim lighting, live music, and numerous TVs creates a lively and fun atmosphere. Decor includes pirate flags and wooden barrels, embracing Tampa's Gasparilla spirit. Outdoor seating offers a river view, enhancing the dining experience.

Mac and cheese burger stands out as a signature dish. The menu also features fried chicken sandwiches like The Flying Dutchman and loaded nachos. Sides include fries, tater tots that taste like McDonald's hash browns, and truffle fries.

Bacon chicken Alfredo stands out with its crispy, creamy, and juicy texture. Pasta dishes like meatball pasta and shrimp tacos also feature, with pasta overall described as great.

People are saying

"The burgers here are amazing, especially the pineapple jalapeño."

"The American food, especially the burgers, is cooked to perfection."

"The Italian food here is fantastic, everything was 10/10."

Good to know

1

Happy hour lasts until 7 PM with great drink specials.

2

On Thursdays, appetizers are half price during happy hour.

3

$1 wing Wednesdays offer a fantastic deal for wing lovers.

18
Front Porch & Bart's Tavern image 1

Old house converted into a restaurant and bar offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with a wraparound porch and dog-friendly areas. Live music plays regularly, creating an awesome atmosphere that draws a friendly crowd. The space combines vintage decor with modern food and drink options.

Meatloaf stands out with a nice glaze and has been voted best of the bay. The Gumbo rivals New Orleans quality and is considered the best in Tampa. Large, satisfying nachos serve as an entree for 3-4 people.

Vodka ravioli and Tuscan ravioli stand out with great sauces. The chicken Alfredo offers a good portion size, and the saffron risotto adds a unique touch to the Italian options.

People are saying

"The Outdoor Seating is great for delicious, eclectic menu options."

"I tried the meatloaf; it was delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Brunch is served from 8 AM to 2 PM on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays.

2

Live music starts at 5 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

3

Saturdays feature $3.50 mimosas from 8 AM to 2 PM and all day on Sundays.

19
Haven image 1
American restaurant

Large restaurant offers a beautiful outdoor patio with tropical plants and a walk-in cheese refrigerator. Atmosphere feels upscale yet laid back, combining cozy indoor spaces with a warm, inviting garden setting. Cocktails and steaks attract a crowd seeking refined but relaxed dining.

Beef spare ribs stand out as a key dish. The menu also features octopus, hearty meat options, and mac and cheese.

Pasta features a unique flavor blend with lemon, pistachios, and pecorino Romano creating a rich but balanced taste. Appetizers include exceptional sashimi and pasta options.

People are saying

"The steaks here are cooked perfectly for a great date spot."

"The American Food mac and cheese was scrumptious and delicious."

"The Italian food's pasta was next level, rich and decadent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially for outdoor seating.

2

Happy hour runs until 7 pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

The menu changes seasonally, offering new dishes regularly.

20
Three Coins Diner image 1

Classic American diner with old-school charm and a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere reminiscent of family gatherings. The space is small and intimate, often packed with joyful chatter and hot coffee. Open 24/7, it serves as a reliable late-night spot with a familiar, welcoming vibe.

Meatloaf comes tender and flavorful with mashed potatoes. Biscuits and gravy, shrimp and grits, and steak and eggs arrive in generous portions. Patty melt is properly executed and tasty.

Spaghetti comes with meatballs and holds up well even at 4am. Lasagna is freshly made and served in a large portion, often enough to take half home.

People are saying

"This diner's food is delicious with large portions."

"I told my wife the American Food biscuits and gravy were top 5 ever."

"The Italian food here, especially the lasagna, is so good and freshly made."

Good to know

1

Three Coins Diner is open 24/7 for all meals.

2

Expect a wait of up to two hours during peak breakfast hours.

3

Gratuity is automatically added to your bill at checkout.

21
The Rez Grill (in Seminole Hard Rock Tampa) image 1

Elegant dining room offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with rich decor and live band music creating a lively vibe. Guests enjoy well-crafted cocktails and bottomless mimosas alongside high-quality dishes like short ribs and steak tartare. The space balances relaxed yet vibrant energy, welcoming lively conversation without feeling crowded.

Crab cakes come out meaty and flavorful. Main dishes like Snapper and meatloaf arrive well-presented and tasty.

Seafood fettuccine features crab, scallops, shrimp, and clams with plenty of protein. Pasta quality is average.

People are saying

"The dinner menu here never failed to impress me."

"The American Food here, especially the oysters and short ribs, is amazing."

"I loved the seafood fettuccine with plenty of protein."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating and high demand.

2

Latin night on Thursday features live music and a vibrant atmosphere.

3

On Sundays from 11am to 4pm, enjoy bottomless mimosas during brunch.

22
Cru Cellars - Wine Bar image 1

Wine bar offers a wine cellar ambiance with a chill house DJ creating a lounge vibe. Space includes a cozy indoor area and an intimate outdoor patio. Wine flights and thoughtfully paired food like charcuterie and flatbreads define the experience.

Sausage gumbo from the specials offers a super tasty option. The menu features filet omelet, crab and filet eggs Benedict, Croque Madame, and a spicy egg sandwich.

Bucatini carbonara features a creamy sauce leaning more toward Alfredo than traditional carbonara. Shrimp carbonara pairs well with house white wine, offering a tasty twist on the classic pasta.

People are saying

"Their wine selection is unique and always has something worth trying."

"The American Food here is seasoned and cooked to perfection."

"I loved their unique Italian Food wine selections."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half off on select house wines and appetizers.

2

Parking is easy with a dedicated lot available for guests.

3

Cru Cellars has a $15 monthly dining credit for club members.

Discover more

Tampa, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...