Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Tampa

Pizza spots with New York style pizza

Real New York-style pizza that tastes like it came from a neighborhood shop, not a mass-produced chain.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Home Slice Pizza Co. image 1
Home Slice Pizza Co. image 2
Home Slice Pizza Co. image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Hole-in-the-wall pizza spot channels old school New York slice shop vibe with cozy atmosphere and baseball-themed decor. The place fills with friendly energy, offering plenty of seating and multiple TVs. It serves authentic New York-style pizza with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Slices feature thin, foldable crusts with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The pizza stays true to authentic New York style, honoring its tradition and history.

New York-style pizza stands out with its original homemade Italian dough that tastes like magic. Consistent quality makes it a go-to spot for authentic New York pizza with great service.

People are saying

"This New Jersey style pizza has a perfect crust."

"This salad is huge, enough for the whole family."

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be absolutely authentic."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $7 for a specialty slice.

2

The restaurant is open until 8 pm, even if the website says otherwise.

3

They offer a two-slice special during lunch hours.

02
TOMATO JOE’S NEW YORK PIZZERIA image 1

Open layout reveals pizza-making process in a clean, cozy space with homey atmosphere and fresh-baked aroma. Energy stays relaxed and welcoming, perfect for casual meals. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and crispy wings that stand out in the area.

Authentic New York style pizza features a thin, foldable crust with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The pizza tastes phenomenal and captures the true flavor of classic New York slices.

New York-style pizza stands out with its hot, flavorful slices. Large pepperoni pizzas come prepared exactly as requested, showing attention to detail and very good quality.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"This New York Style Pizza is the real deal."

"I thought the pizza here was the best."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers affordable lunch specials that are ready in minutes.

2

Expect generous portions and great value for your money.

3

The pizzeria is known for its cleanliness and quality of food.

03
Baba Dough image 1
Restaurant

Open kitchen and large sit-down bar create a cozy, vibey atmosphere with a friendly, welcoming vibe. Small number of tables and clean, well-designed interior add to the intimate feel. TVs show sports, and the place has a family-owned, non-chain character.

Great thin and crispy crust defines the pizza here. Options include both classic and creative toppings, paired with garlic knots.

New York style pizza features a classic thin and crispy crust that stands out. Pizzas like the pistachio pie and steak come fresh with excellent quality meat and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and really good."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"I loved the crispy New York Style Pizza and garlic knots."

Good to know

1

Prices for pizzas start at $4.50 for a slice before 4pm.

2

All chicken, beef, and pepperoni options are halal.

3

The pizzeria uses fresh ingredients like tomatoes and peppers.

04
NY TO PHILLY image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small restaurant with Rocky Balboa theme and unique interior design creates an old-school, family atmosphere. Warm, welcoming energy fills the space, enhanced by great background music and personal ownership. Guests enjoy an inviting, authentic vibe with high chairs available for families.

Authentic New York style pizza features thin, foldable slices with a crisp crust. Wings often accompany the pizza, adding to the classic New York meal experience.

Pizza here features exceptionally proportional toppings and a next level taste that stands out. White pizza with ricotta and classic Philly styles show variety and quality in every slice.

People are saying

"Their pizza is amazing with great, generous toppings."

"I found the Philly Cheesesteak to be amazing and insanely delicious."

"I thought this New York Style Pizza was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and easily accessible for visitors.

2

Prices are very reasonable compared to similar establishments.

3

The restaurant specializes in authentic New York pizza and cheesesteaks.

05
Bella Roma NY Pizza image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers cozy, welcoming atmosphere with outdoor tables and a lit fireplace enhancing the space. It attracts those seeking authentic New York style pizza with fresh ingredients and a tasty crust. The place suits relaxed meals and late-night cravings with reasonable prices.

Authentic New York style pizza offers great taste with a classic thin crust and flavorful toppings. Prices stay reasonable while service remains friendly and efficient.

Authentic NY style pizza offers a taste that transports you to Italy. The stuffed crust and supreme pizza stand out for their rich flavors and consistent quality.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be incredibly delicious."

"The Late Night Spot staff are always super friendly and accommodating."

"I thought the New York style pizza here was the best."

Good to know

1

They are open until 3AM on Sunday.

2

The late-night hours are convenient for those craving good food after a long day.

3

The prices at Bella Roma NY Pizza are very reasonable.

06
Pizza & Gyro Express image 1

Nondescript restaurant offers authentic New York style pizza with a crust made from New York water. The atmosphere is casual with halal food served, including standout gyros and chicken dishes. Sodas are self-serve without ice, and wait times for pizza can reach about 20 minutes.

Authentic tasting cheese pie features a golden crispy crust with a fair amount of sauce. The pizza delivers a real New York flavor and texture.

Quick to serve, the pizza offers an authentic New York style experience with a golden crispy crust and a good balance of cheese and sauce. The halal pepperoni pizza stands out for its perfect balance of flavors and crispiness.

People are saying

"I thought the food, especially the pizza and gyros, tasted amazing."

"I thought the gyro wrap was amazing and 10/10."

"I found their New York style pizza to be the real deal."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves halal food.

2

Expect a 20-minute wait for pizza during peak hours.

3

The restaurant is located where the old Sbarro was in Westshore Mall.

07
Hot Rocks Pizza (Town n Country) image 1

Small pizza restaurant with brick oven baking and open kitchen creates a cozy, family-oriented atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a comfortable, clean environment with friendly vibes. Known for consistently high-quality pizza and welcoming energy.

Slices come in an 18-inch size that feeds four people. Meat lovers with mushrooms is a popular choice. The pizza tastes very close to authentic New York style with a classic flavor and texture.

Pizza always perfect with a welcome and a smile. Wings also available alongside the best pizza in town.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be super tasty and amazing."

"The food was amazing, and we ate it outside."

"I thought it served the best New York Style Pizza I ever had."

Good to know

1

Hot Rocks Pizza offers a lunch special with two slices and a drink for under $10.

2

Gluten-free options are available on the menu.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean environment for dining.

08
New York New York Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza shop with outdoor seating nestled between a building and a gas station creates a charming, casual vibe. The atmosphere feels like authentic New York, with large, crispy slices served quickly in a modest setting.

Perfect dough and tasty sauce create a classic New York style pizza experience. The cheese pizza stands out with its cheesy richness similar to Whole Foods but with a distinct New York flavor.

New York-style pizza here features perfect dough and tasty sauce with fresh ingredients. The pizza is cheesy, authentic, and priced reasonably.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"This New York Style Pizza is the closest thing to authentic NYC pizza."

"I found the food here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

This location is small and does not offer inside seating.

2

The parking lot has only about three spots and is quite small.

3

The pizza is priced very reasonably.

09
Alba Pizza & Cafe - Tampa image 1

Small pizza restaurant with New York-themed decor and outdoor seating offers a peaceful, cozy atmosphere. Walls display large photos of New York, creating a distinct vibe. Music plays consistently, enhancing the low-key energy.

Slices feature a classic thin crust with a balanced sauce and generous cheese. The pizza holds a solid New York style, offering a familiar and satisfying taste.

New York-style pizza stands out with a super delicious taste and amazing quality. Garlic knots also impress as a notable side.

People are saying

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be the best I've had in a while."

"The service here is amazing for date spots."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

They offer a lunch special with two slices and a free can of soda.

2

Pizza prices start from $8, with toppings costing three dollars each.

3

They provide pizza by the slice and have specials on slices.

10
Villa Rina Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers New York style pizza with generous slices and affordable lunch specials. Atmosphere suits casual dining with family and friends, featuring a clean and inviting space. Regulars appreciate the authentic taste and friendly vibe.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste close to a real New York pizza parlor. Consistently delivers excellent quality that stands out in the area.

NY Style Pizza stands out with fresh, delicious slices that capture a classic New York parlor feel. The menu includes barbecue chicken pizza and steak sandwiches, all served in a welcoming atmosphere.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has really good pizza, I enjoyed it."

"I thought the New York style pizza here was amazing."

"I thought the pizza here was fantastic and delicious."

Good to know

1

The lunch special of two cheese slices and a soda costs $6.

2

Villa Rina Pizza offers pizza by the slice or a 28-inch pizza.

3

Ordering To-Go automatically includes a lid for your food.

11
Pizza Pino one (حلال) image 1

Pizza restaurant offers 100% halal menu with no pork, featuring freshly made, authentic pizza known for its perfect crust and foldable slices. Atmosphere stays friendly and clean, creating a comfortable dining experience. Prices remain affordable compared to chains while maintaining high quality.

Slices feature a classic thin crust with a foldable structure typical of New York style pizza. Toppings spread evenly with a balanced sauce and cheese ratio that captures the authentic taste.

Foldable crust with orange cheese and a bit of grease creates a classic New York style pizza. Large slices come in an 18-inch size that impresses with its perfect crust and affordable price compared to chains.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and always hot."

"I thought their pizza was the best I ever had."

"I thought their New York style pizza was the best."

Good to know

1

All ingredients are halal, and there is no pork on the menu.

2

They accept cash on delivery and credit cards.

3

Prices are affordable compared to chain pizza restaurants, with good portion sizes.

12
3 Corners Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with extensive outdoor seating and large TVs showing sports creates a lively atmosphere. Full bar offers diverse drinks including unique beers and cocktails. New York-style pizza aroma fills the air, drawing a crowd that enjoys a relaxed, fun vibe near the riverwalk.

Slices come huge and thin, capturing the classic New York style. The pizza offers a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, making it a solid choice for those craving authentic New York flavor.

New York-style pizza stands out with hot, fresh slices served quickly. The place offers affordable prices that satisfy a hungry crowd under $10 per person.

People are saying

"I found the white pizza to be amazing and flavorful."

"I thought the pizza was great."

"This New York Style Pizza is fantastic and huge, just like in NYC."

Good to know

1

Expect busy times after events at the arena.

2

Fridays feature a live DJ from 9:30 to 12:30pm.

3

The lunch special includes 2 slices of pizza and a soda for $9.99 or $11.99.

13
Best NY Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers Italian American decor with red and brick accents creating a calm, relaxed atmosphere. Background features great music and Trivial Pursuit cards for entertainment. Seating is ample and comfortable, supporting a quiet dining experience with a friendly vibe.

Crispy borders and strong slice integrity give the pizza an authentic New York feel. Pepperoni with extra sauce stands out as a favorite, delivering a big and tasty experience close to true NY style.

Big slices come with a thin crispy crust that holds up well even after delivery. The sauce stands out as authentic and flavorful, paired with perfectly melted cheese for a true New York style pizza experience.

People are saying

"The pizza, wings, and salads were all large in portion size."

"This New York Style Pizza tastes so authentic, it's like the real deal."

"I found the pizza to be really good and tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect wait times of 12 to 15 minutes for pizza orders.

2

Prices for pizzas are high, with a 16-inch margarita costing $28.

3

The fries cost $7 for a small portion.

Discover more

Tampa, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...