Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookie and pie shops in Georgia

Choosing between a warm cookie and a slice of pie is a dilemma that usually ends with both.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
D's Bon Appetit of Atlanta image 1

Cake shop offers a sweetly decorated and peaceful atmosphere with a varied selection of moist, flavorful desserts. Free samples invite tasting, and the space suits both quick grabs and relaxed visits. Affordable prices match the high-quality baked goods that draw in those seeking home-style treats.

Samples include cakes and cookies with a variety of baked goods like sweet potato pie and pumpkin praline brownie. The oatmeal cookie stands out for its flavor and texture.

Sweet potato pie stands out as a favorite among the pies available. Peach cobbler and strawberry pie also appear as notable options to try.

People are saying

"I loved the oatmeal cookie, it was a 10/10."

"I found the desserts here to be amazing and delicious."

"I will definitely be back for more pie."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including unique flavors.

2

Prices for slices range from $9 to $10 each.

3

Free samples are available for customers to try before buying.

02
Galette image 1
Bakery

Small bakery with intimate, family-run vibe and European charm offers beautiful indoor and expanded outdoor seating near a park. The air fills with mesmerizing baked aromas that draw people in. Pastries are artisan-quality and highly regarded, often selling out early.

Chocolate sugar cookies and brown butter cookies stand out among the variety of cookies offered. Cider donuts and peach galettes also complement the cookie selection.

Apple hand pies come stuffed with apples and stand out for their rich filling and flaky crust. They rank among the favorite items alongside almond croissants.

People are saying

"I loved their great pastries; the flaky crust was wonderfully delicious."

"You have to try their chocolate sugar cookies; they're divine."

"You have to try the apple hand pie; it's stuffed with apples."

Good to know

1

Parking is out front but fills up fast; side street parking is available.

2

Expect to spend around $13 per person for juice and a pastry.

3

If you arrive too late on weekends, they might sell out before closing.

03
Buttersweet Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with dรฉcor resembling grandmaโ€™s kitchen and vintage touches. The space feels like a community treasure filled with warmth and pride. Regulars enjoy sitting down with sweet treats and coffee in a friendly, hometown setting.

Chocolate chip cookies combine crispy, crunchy, and soft textures with nuts for added flavor. The Cookie Cheesecake Bar layers a cookie base with cheesecake topping and a unique middle, balancing sweetness well.

Sweet potato pies stand out with mini sizes that satisfy without overindulgence. Pecan pie also features as a sought-after option alongside cupcakes and brownies.

People are saying

"The chocolate chip pecan cookie was the best I ever had."

"I found the brownies here to be really enjoyable and moist."

"These mini sweet potato pies are divine little bites of heaven."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the street near the bakery.

2

The bakery offers a cozy seating area for enjoying desserts.

3

Buttersweet Bakery is a Black-owned business with a community focus.

04
Westside Creamery Sweet Spot image 1

Cozy family-owned dessert shop with a warm, welcoming vibe and a clean, visible kitchen. Offers artisan ice cream, fresh baked goods, and a wide sorbet selection. Outdoor seating and a book nook add to the inviting atmosphere.

A wide assortment of cookies stands out here, including pistachio cookies that are superb. Every cookie tastes fresh and homemade, not store-bought.

Blueberry pie features a buttery crust and fresh, perfectly sweet and tart homemade filling. Apple pie offers a flaky crust with a perfectly spiced filling and balanced sweetness. Key lime pie and pound cake stand out as divine options.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so rich, smooth, and bursting with flavor."

"This pound cake is OMG good and super moist."

"I was already digging into the cookies 20 minutes after returning home."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the garage with validation.

2

Street parking is free nearby, but may require a short walk.

3

They offer multiple vegan options upon request.

05
Evergreen Butcher + Baker image 1

Open bakery and butcher shop combines cozy interior design with high-end meat cuts and fresh baked pastries. Atmosphere feels lively and welcoming, with a strong sense of community and positive energy even during busy times. Outdoor seating adds to the casual, down-to-earth vibe.

Chocolate chip cookie and sesame nougatine cookies stand out with rich flavors. Brown sugar oatmeal raisin and cheese strands add variety to the outstanding cookies selection.

Braised oxtail hand pie stands out with its hefty, meat-loaded filling and rich taste. The apple pie ranks highly for flavor and value, often noted as exceptional. Freshly baked items include croissants, buns, and various hand pies.

People are saying

"I experienced some of the best pastries I ever had."

"The Sunday burgers here are flavorful and taste very fresh."

"I waited 40 minutes for this apple pie, and it was worth it."

Good to know

1

The burgers are only available on Sundays at 1pm.

2

Arrive early to avoid long lines for the burgers.

3

Expect a line if you arrive after 12:30pm on Sundays.

06
For Five Coffee Atlanta image 1

Spacious cafe with a modern aesthetic and high ceilings creates an airy, open environment filled with natural light. Loud, varied music sets an energetic tone that can challenge conversation and focus. Multiple seating options accommodate both casual visits and remote work.

Chocolate chunk cookies stand out with rich flavor and texture. Warm rainbow cookies come from Sugar Shane's bakery and add a unique touch.

Cheese and spinach pies stand out with their tasty, creamy fillings. Sweet cream pie offers a delicious, smooth texture alongside other pastries like chocolate chunk cookies.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be really good."

"I did not want to miss these shockingly good cookies."

"George was super friendly and helpful with the pie."

Good to know

1

Validated parking is available for one hour in the adjacent Google parking deck.

2

Parking costs $4.00 an hour in the garage next door.

3

Expect high prices, with a small coffee costing $8.

07
Andy's Frozen Custard image 1

Garage-like design sets a casual, fun atmosphere with clean, comfortable seating mostly outdoors on benches. Loud sound system echoes off concrete, creating a lively vibe. Quick drive-thru and dog-friendly patio attract a steady flow of visitors.

Cookies come with custard or cookie butter, but some are clearly stale. The Cookie Jackhammer features a thin line of hot fudge, less than a centimeter, which falls short of the expected filling all the way down the center.

Pumpkin Pie Concrete blends freshly baked pumpkin pie with creamy vanilla custard for a spiced, fall-flavored treat. The apple pie sundae features hot apple pie paired with vanilla custard, creating a warm and satisfying dessert.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever tasted."

"The custard with cookie butter was delicious."

"I loved the Pumpkin Pie Concrete with its fall-flavored taste."

Good to know

1

The line moves quickly, even during busy hours.

2

Parking is spacious and easily accessible.

3

There is no indoor seating; only a few benches are available.

08
B-Side image 1
Coffee shop

Small space with vintage mural and green decor creates a cozy yet energetic atmosphere. Loud music featuring 80s jams adds to the lively vibe, attracting a crowd that enjoys a bustling, downtown feel. Seating is limited, with some spots along the bar, making it a tight but inviting spot.

Oatmeal cookie sandwich features homemade cookies with vanilla cream frosting inside. The fried chocolate chip cookie offers a unique twist, while the chocolate chip cookie keeps a classic taste.

Savory pies feature grainy potatoes, overcooked eggs, and feta in the filling. Oatmeal cream pies stand out as a sweet option alongside the meat pies.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be perfect and delicious."

"The oatmeal creme pies are so delicious."

"I loved the high-quality bagels with a nice char and crunch."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Parking can be expensive, with rates around $16 for one hour.

3

Seating is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

09
McEntyre's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with colorful displays of cakes, cookies, and donuts creates a homey, Southern charm atmosphere. The space feels welcoming and family-run, offering a patio area for guests. Regulars enjoy a variety of baked goods and deli sandwiches in a cozy setting.

Cookies come in a colorful display with options like moist oatmeal raisin and custom iced cookies for parties. The cookie cake stands out as a popular choice for events.

Pies here often have minimal fruit filling, with peach pies mostly bread and tiny peach bits. Chocolate silk ice box pie stands out as a notable exception among the offerings.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be top notch and delicious."

"Their cookie cake is amazing and our go-to for events."

"I found the pies here to be wonderful and yummy."

Good to know

1

Kids meals cost less than $6 and include a sandwich, cookie or chips, and a drink.

2

The bakery has been in business since 1947, indicating a strong reputation.

3

Custom iced cookies for parties can be ordered here.

10
International Bakery image 1

Small bakery with old world charm and a family-owned feel offers a wide variety of authentic Greek pastries and imported products. Atmosphere reflects love and creativity in cake decoration and dessert variety. Prices remain reasonable despite quality and selection.

Variety of sweets and cookies fills the bakery. Cookies stay fresh but can soften with a quick spray of water and microwave.

Pies come in large sizes with three main types: cheese, mushroom, and spinach. The mushroom pie is very filling and tastes like protein, while the spinach pie is flavorful. Cheese pie stays pretty basic.

People are saying

"The cakes from this bakery are amazing and beautifully decorated."

"I found the cookies and pastries here to be excellent."

"The spinach pie is flavorful and the pastries are flaky."

Good to know

1

Bakery items are available at reasonable prices, with slices starting at $3.50.

2

The bakery offers a variety of authentic Greek pastries and imported products.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere, especially during peak hours.

Discover more

Georgia

Area guide
Loading Map...