Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Illinois

New York style pizza and American food

Made for those who want a classic New York slice alongside a reliable menu of American staples.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Da Pizza Company – Pizzeria & Food Trucks image 1
Da Pizza Company – Pizzeria & Food Trucks image 2
Da Pizza Company – Pizzeria & Food Trucks image 3
View all

Food truck serves fresh New York-style pizza with a crispy yet chewy crust and generous slices. Atmosphere feels like a local spot with friendly staff and a casual vibe. Popular for quick bites and catering, especially for events and parties.

Proper New York style pizzas come with a thin, foldable crust and classic toppings. A full pizza truck service offers these pizzas at events, making it a solid specialty pizza option.

New York style pizza stands out with its authentic flavor and classic thin crust. Philly cheesesteak sandwiches bring rich, savory taste, and loaded fries add a satisfying side option.

People are saying

"This pizza is so delicious, I'd return two days in a row."

"I enjoyed the New York Style pizza; it was fresh, light, and amazing."

"Their New York style pizza is just like I remembered from living in New York."

Good to know

1

Da Pizza Company offers catering for various events, including corporate and special occasions.

2

They provide a full pizza truck service for events, serving New York style pizzas.

3

The menu includes 9 pizza toppings, 5 specialty pizzas, garlic knots, and drinks.

02
Nemec Brother’s Pizzeria image 1

Small pizzeria with intimate seating upstairs and a quiet basement area featuring TVs. Atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, though music can be loud and the upstairs gets crowded. Offers halal pepperoni and a house lager brewed locally, pairing well with their highly regarded New York-style pizza.

Offers authentic New York style pizza that matches the quality found in NYC and New Jersey. Includes halal options and delivers an exceptional taste that stands out in the suburbs.

New York style pizza stands out with its authentic thin crust and classic flavors matching those from New York. Chocolate chip cookies come with a sprinkle of salt on top, adding a unique touch.

People are saying

"I found the best New York style pizza outside of New York."

"I thought the meatballs here were phenomenal."

"This New York style pizza is as good as back home."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers halal pepperoni and a variety of vegetarian options.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours due to high demand.

3

Pickup can be challenging as there is no dedicated drive-up space.

03
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 1

Pizza restaurant offers graffiti style artwork and retro NBA games on multiple TVs, creating a cozy, old school vibe. Comfy couches and a hand-painted mural add to the welcoming atmosphere. The space feels like a New York slice spot with a friendly, lively energy.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. Prices reflect the quality, including halal options, making it a rare find for genuine NY pizza in the Chicago suburbs.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a focus on traditional slices. Known for halal options that fill a niche in the area.

People are saying

"I loved the halal pizza with unique toppings like gyro and chicken tikka."

"You have to try the gyro over rice; it's flavorful and well-seasoned."

"This New York style pizza is truly authentic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Free pizza slices available until 5 PM on September 15, 2025.

2

The restaurant offers a late-night menu during Ramadan.

3

The restaurant is halal and serves zabiha halal options.

04
Gigio's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, hole-in-the-wall pizza spot with a classic, old-school charm and casual, family-friendly vibe. Atmosphere feels welcoming and chill, offering authentic New York-style pizza with affordable prices. Space is no-frills and intimate, with some outdoor seating available.

Pizza arrives hot with a thin crust and classic foldable slices. It captures the authentic New York style with a balance of sauce and cheese that stands out in Chicago.

New York style pizza arrives hot and delicious, standing out as a key offering. The cheeseburger comes with fries and a canned soft drink for $7.50, delivering solid flavor. Chicken wings are super crispy and tasty.

People are saying

"I believe Gigio's Pizzeria offers the best pizza."

"I'd say this is the best New York Style Pizza I ever had."

"I thought their New York style pizza was the best American food I ever had."

Good to know

1

Gigio's Pizzeria opens late until 2am for late-night bites.

2

Pizza by the slice is available for quick meals.

3

They charge extra for card payments without prior notice.

05
Dough Bros Pizzeria & Sub Shop image 1

Small pizzeria with a walk-up window and brick oven creates a rustic, cozy atmosphere. Seating fits solo diners or small groups, with a few tables and ESPN on TV adding a retro vibe. Weekend nights bring a chaotic energy, while police presence adds security but a slightly sketchy feel.

Authentic New York style pizza stands out with its melt-in-your-mouth texture and delicious flavor. It offers a quality experience that rivals pizzas from New York itself.

New York style pizza stands out with its quality and flavor. Late night options include tacos, elote, and hot dogs.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was amazing and really legit."

"I found the New York style pizza here to be authentic and amazing."

"You have to try their New York style pizza; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is not available nearby, so consider alternative transport options.

2

Pizza slices are available for $4.50 each, which is a good deal.

3

The pizzeria is open late, making it a great option for night owls.

06
Volo Quality Meats image 1

Bright, cozy deli with homey table arrangements and a market-style layout offers a welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of an Italian cafe. In-house butcher and deli provide high-quality meats alongside a hot bar and fresh pizza, creating a unique blend of shopping and dining experiences.

Slices feature a thin crust typical of New York style pizza. The pizza offers a classic cheese and sauce combination that aligns with traditional New York flavors.

Smoked beef brisket stands out for its quality and flavor. Handcrafted sandwiches and daily hot bar specials add variety to the American food offerings.

People are saying

"I loved the sandwiches; the ingredients were amazing."

"Their New York Style Pizza has amazing flavor and a great crust."

"The pastrami sandwich here is amazing and moist."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available in the back.

2

The menu offers a wide selection of high-quality sandwiches and meats.

3

Prices range from $75 to $100 for a meal, making it a premium option.

07
Rocket Slice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Strictly takeout setup with a ledge but no seating creates a quick, in-and-out vibe. Atmosphere feels laid back and welcoming, with a cozy, warm environment despite occasional smokiness. Known for kosher Chicago deep dish pizza, it draws a busy crowd seeking authentic, highly praised flavors.

Floppy crust defines the New York style pizza here, capturing the classic texture. The slices deliver a great balance of flavor true to the style.

Chicago deep dish pizza stands out with its tremendous sauce and thick, hearty style. Detroit style pizza offers a crispy crust topped with cheese and a dab of marinara, resembling cheesy bread.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and flavorful."

"I found the New York Style Pizza to be great and delicious."

"The Chicago deep dish pizza is among the best."

Good to know

1

Rocket Slice Pizza opens at 7am on Saturdays.

2

Parking is limited near Rocket Slice Pizza.

3

Prices for cheese slices start at $4.

08
Pizza Lobo Logan Square image 1

Outdoor seating includes a heated patio with fire pits and a gravel floor, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Music plays loudly, adding energy but making conversation difficult. The space welcomes groups, kids, and dogs, blending modern and retro design elements.

Offers casual dining with a DJ playing music. Serves New York style pizza that some find delicious while others disagree on its authenticity.

Buffalo wings stand out with homemade sauce and a $1 special. New York style pizza adds a casual American touch.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was great, especially the crust."

"I thought the buffalo wings were some of the best I ever had."

"The New York Style Pizza has a huge patio with fire pits."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays and Wednesdays, they offer $1 wings.

2

Trivia night happens on Wednesdays with a fun atmosphere.

3

Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.

09
New York Slices image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small tables and a high counter with bar stools create a cozy mom-and-pop atmosphere with New York graffiti decor. The place offers affordable New York-style pizza by the slice with a thin, crisp crust and varied toppings. It attracts people looking for a quick, casual meal with a local, family-owned vibe.

Classic thin crust dough matches traditional New York style pizza. Best served straight out of the oven or by the slice for authentic texture and flavor.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out as a highlight. The pizza tries for a New York style but does not match the original.

People are saying

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was great and legit."

"I'd never eaten a chocolate chip cookie that was so good."

"It's a great Kid Friendly option for feeding kids on the go."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a 2-for-1 large pizza deal on Mondays and Thursdays for $20.

2

Pizza is available by the slice with different varieties offered daily.

3

Prices are very affordable, making it a good option for families.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...