Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Illinois

Unique consignment shops

You want to shop for items that are truly unique. You prefer the hunt of a consignment store over the predictability of a standard retailer.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Born Again Consignment Parlor image 1
Born Again Consignment Parlor image 2
Born Again Consignment Parlor image 3
View all

Two-level consignment shop with color-coordinated layout creates a soothing, curated atmosphere. Cozy downstairs lounge offers a BYOB space and event area, attracting those who appreciate unique vintage finds and a boutique vibe.

Many items stand out for their unique and fun qualities. The selection offers a variety of distinctive gifts.

Consignment here offers amazing vintage finds and an exceptional experience. It elevates the neighborhood with a great selection and quality.

People are saying

"I found a great selection of fun women's clothing and accessories."

"I found so many cool clothes, purses, and unique stuff here."

"I found so many unique and fun gifts here."

Good to know

1

The store is organized by color, making shopping easier and more enjoyable.

2

Prices are reasonable, catering to all budgets and making items accessible.

3

The shop features a diverse selection of vintage clothing, accessories, and home goods.

02
Elite Repeat image 1
Consignment shop

Huge, beautifully organized space showcases an extensive collection of vintage fur coats and designer clothing. Atmosphere feels genuine and trustworthy, with a cozy, glamorous fur room that invites careful browsing. Multi-generational women ownership adds a family-run, curated vibe distinct from typical resale shops.

Selection features unique vintage clothes and high-quality accessories not found elsewhere. The shop offers a friendly, user-friendly environment with an assortment of distinctive pieces.

High-end consignment items come with personality and integrity here. The vintage fur selection stands out as refined and well-maintained, far above typical resale stores.

People are saying

"I found amazing vintage designer clothing and incredible fur items."

"Margy's curated picks feel like advice from a friendly, honest expert."

"You'll find unique vintage fur coats in amazing condition here."

Good to know

1

The store features a curated selection of vintage clothing, shoes, and accessories.

2

Expect a wide range of sizes from small to XXX.

3

Prices are fair for the high-quality vintage pieces available.

03
ReNew Family Consignment image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers high quality products with a wide variety of unique items including designer purses and costume to fine jewelry. Items sell quickly, encouraging prompt purchases. Prices remain reasonable throughout.

Lots of unique items fill the shelves, offering fun and unusual gifts for nearly every holiday or birthday.

Offers a wide selection of wonderful items at fabulous prices. Known as a favorite local consignment shop with a strong focus on quality and value.

People are saying

"I absolutely loved this consignment store."

"It's unique how the owner always says thank you for coming."

Good to know

1

Items sell quickly, so buy what you like when you see it.

2

ReNew Family Consignment offers a variety of unique and high-quality items.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of items available.

04
McShane's Exchange Consignment image 1

Bright, beautifully curated consignment shop with an artful layout and upbeat music sets a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. Offers a great mix of designer and affordable items, including unique vintage pieces and well-sized selections. Dressing rooms add convenience to a calm, well-organized shopping experience.

Offers a wide range of unique pieces from various designers that are hard to find in one spot. Clothing stands out for its high quality and interesting selection.

Offers a great selection of designer clothes with a wide range of styles and price points. The store is well organized and carries sizes up to L and XL, making it easy to find quality items and luxury consignment pieces.

People are saying

"I found really cute women's clothing in great shape."

"I found so many unique, quality designer pieces at this consignment shop."

"I found so many unique pieces and great deals here."

Good to know

1

The store offers a great selection of designer and affordable items.

2

Items are well-organized and easy to browse.

3

The store frequently updates its inventory with new stock.

05
Village Treasure House image 1
Consignment shop

Small consignment shop offers ever-changing inventory of high-quality antiques and home furnishings across varied price ranges. Atmosphere suits those who enjoy the thrill of the hunt for unique pieces. Proceeds support charitable causes, adding a benevolent mission to the shopping experience.

Items show great unique quality and cover any price range. The selection includes unique holiday gifts.

Small size defines the shop, filled with antiques big and small. Staff help with purchases, consignments, and donations.

People are saying

"I found unique, upscale home furnishings at great prices in this consignment shop."

"I found their items to be of great unique quality."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a unique selection of items for various price ranges.

2

All net proceeds support charitable causes.

3

Their website is updated regularly for online shopping and pickup.

06
Evilena's Red Dresser image 1
Consignment shop

Small consignment shop offers unique and eclectic items including clothing, vintage pieces, and furniture, all in excellent condition. The space feels very organized and curated with a variety of sizes and styles for all ages. Prices remain reasonable despite the high quality and careful selection.

Offers unique and eclectic items with a focus on one-of-a-kind pieces. Features high quality vintage home decor that adds character and personality.

A very organized consignment shop with a variety of items to choose from. Rules and regulations for consignment are clear and well set. Not all items are high-end despite the shop's claim.

People are saying

"I always found unique, high-quality items here."

"I found a great variety of items at this consignment shop."

Good to know

1

All items sold here are in excellent condition and often like-new.

2

The shop offers a variety of clothing, shoes, purses, and vintage home decor.

3

Expect a curated selection of unique and eclectic items.

07
Jane Pabon Consignment Boutique image 1

Luxe boutique space offers an immaculate, high-end retail vibe with one-of-a-kind designer pieces. The atmosphere feels glamorous and chic, with items well-organized and easy to browse. It serves as a go-to for investment wardrobe pieces and unique fashion finds.

Merchandise features a fun, unique mix that balances seasonal trends with classic styles. Clothing and accessories offer selections not found elsewhere.

An amazing consignment store with a strong focus on designer pieces. It stands out as a favorite among many consignment boutiques in the Midwest.

People are saying

"I highly recommend this boutique for unique and beautiful designer pieces."

"This is the best designer consignment shop around."

"The staff here is so helpful and kind."

Good to know

1

The boutique offers both new and gently used items at great prices.

2

You can find unique, one-of-a-kind clothing and accessories here.

3

Clients can sell their clothes for cash or store credit.

08
Debbie's Darn Good Deals image 1
Consignment shop

Huge warehouse filled with unique vintage items and furniture from all eras creates a maze-like, cluttered atmosphere. Overcrowded aisles and disorganized displays make browsing a slow, detailed process. Pricing follows eBay listings, reflecting a consignment store vibe rather than thrift deals.

A wide variety of unique pieces and vintage items fill the store. Furniture and odds and ends from all eras create a diverse and interesting collection.

Focus lies on consignment and estate sale items, not typical thrift or antique goods. Customers expect top dollar for their items, reflecting a resale model rather than donation-based pricing.

People are saying

"This consignment shop prices items based on eBay's highest listings."

"This furniture store has tons of unique pieces from all eras."

"It's a warehouse full of unique odds and ends and furniture from all eras."

Good to know

1

Items are priced based on the highest eBay listings, not actual sales.

2

The aisles are disorganized, making it hard to navigate.

3

Street parking is available, but the store is not wheelchair accessible.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...