Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Illinois

Lobster roll sandwiches

A lobster roll that stands up as a proper sandwich instead of falling apart at the first bite.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Brown Bag Seafood Co. image 1
Brown Bag Seafood Co. image 2
Brown Bag Seafood Co. image 3
View all
Seafood restaurant

Nautical-themed seafood restaurant with a clean, cozy atmosphere and friendly, welcoming vibe. Offers quick, flavorful meals with options like lobster rolls and fried shrimp, paired with good beers on tap. Outdoor seating and casual entertainment add to the relaxed experience.

Lobster rolls come nicely stuffed with fresh lobster and pair well with Parmesan Tater Tots. The rolls have a mouth-watering flavor and a rich Boss Sauce that adds a special touch.

Seafood sandwiches stand out with options like the panko cod sandwich, lobster roll, and blackened fish sandwich. The shrimp sandwich also offers a tasty choice, often paired with fresh salads.

People are saying

"The seafood here is delicious, fresh, and perfectly cooked."

"I thought the lobster roll was one of the best I ever had."

"The fish sandwich I had was very tasty."

Good to know

1

Brown Bag Seafood Co. offers a 3-6pm dinner deal for good value.

2

Loyalty program members can earn a free entree and side easily.

3

Expect small portion sizes, even for larger items like salmon.

02
Burhop's Seafood image 1
Seafood market

Quiet, cozy seafood market with a wide selection of fresh and frozen fish and unique items. Offers fresh lobster rolls and clam chowder that stand out for quality and flavor. Grill closes early, and the market stays open into the evening, attracting a loyal local crowd.

Super fresh lobster with perfect seasoning sits in a soft, buttery bun that has a slight sweetness. The rolls are pricey at $28 but stand out for their quality.

Grilled fish sandwiches feature fresh fish and come with options like red snapper with avocado. Lobster rolls and salmon sandwiches also appear on the menu.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, it's unreal."

"You'll love the fresh, high-quality seafood at this market."

"The sandwich was delicious and the fish was fresh."

Good to know

1

The grill at Burhop's Seafood closes at 4:30 or 5:00, depending on the day.

2

The fresh fish market at Burhop's Seafood stays open until 6:30.

3

The lobster roll costs $28.

03
The Evie image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant occupies an elegant second-floor space with amazing views of Michigan Avenue. Atmosphere feels funky and cool yet allows easy conversation without yelling. Offers masterfully made exotic cocktails and a lively bar with sports TVs.

Buttery toast holds a generous amount of fresh lobster in the roll. The lobster roll stands out for its rich, buttery flavor and fresh lobster chunks.

Prime rib sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and tender meat. Crispy fish and Grouper sandwiches offer fresh, satisfying options. The $25 lunch special pairs a sandwich or salad with fresh baked bread and a cookie.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the steak frites and lobster roll, is top notch."

"I loved the prime rib sandwich; it was insanely good."

"The lobster roll here is loaded with fresh lobster and buttery toast."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

3

The restaurant has a dress code; business casual is preferred.

04
Poor Phil's Bar and Grill image 1

Bar and grill with spacious indoor and outdoor seating including a large patio strung with lights. Atmosphere blends cozy warmth with a mix of Chicago, New Orleans, and European styles, featuring soft evening lighting and big windows. Multiple TVs show sports, and the bar offers an old school island style with plenty of booths.

Perfectly buttered and toasted bread holds a light lobster salad that does not drown in mayo. The roll matches the quality of those from Maine and pairs well with a side of tots.

Lobster'Boy sandwich stands out with rich flavors, often paired with mac & cheese. Other options include a crab sandwich and a cheese fish sandwich, both offering unique textures and tastes.

People are saying

"I loved the huge selection of draft and rotating craft beers."

"The lobster roll here is delicious, with a perfectly buttered and toasted bun."

"I felt like I was arriving back home with this sandwich."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6 pm with half-off appetizers and $2 oysters.

2

Beer specials and one cocktail special are available for $5 each during happy hour.

3

The bar is family-friendly, making it suitable for all ages.

05
The Hampton Social - Burr Ridge image 1

New England seaside style shapes a coastal-chic and airy atmosphere with live music enhancing the relaxed vibe. Spaces include walls as backdrops and a notable pizza oven, creating a setting suited for special occasions and casual gatherings alike.

Warm lobster roll comes on a buttery brioche bun with super fresh and flavorful lobster. The Manhattan style lobster roll offers out of this world taste and pairs well with fries or chocolate donuts.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with candied bacon as a key highlight. Fish sandwiches can be inconsistent, sometimes turning out soggy. Lobster sandwiches come with tomato bisque that tastes like marinara.

People are saying

"The food here is well-prepared, flavorful, and thoughtfully presented."

"I found the lobster roll to be fresh and amazinglicious."

"I found the breakfast sandwich with candied bacon amazing."

Good to know

1

An 18% gratuity is added to every bill automatically.

2

Reservations are required for dining; bar seating is available without one.

3

Two tacos cost $23.00, which may be considered pricey.

06
3rd Coast Fish Bar (a DMK restaurant) image 1

Small, intimate seafood spot with quaint fish shop decor and patio seating. Atmosphere feels laid-back and fun, with a cool, quiet vibe enhanced by nearby train sounds. Offers fresh oysters and seafood in a casual setting.

The lobster roll offers a delicious taste with a good balance of flavors. It sometimes has less meat than expected but pairs well with sides like mac 'n cheese.

Fish sandwiches stand out with options like Codfish and grilled salmon. The seafood po boy and other sandwiches come delicious and filling.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fresh and amazingly flavorful."

"I loved my delicious codfish sandwich."

"The lobster roll was sweet, buttery, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations can only be made via OpenTable.

2

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday from 4 to 7 pm with great deals.

3

Draft beers cost $8 during happy hour and include two oysters.

07
Signature Steak image 1
Restaurant

Upscale sports bar with modern black-and-white decor and large screen TVs creates a lively, sometimes loud atmosphere. Dim, private lounge offers a contrasting intimate vibe with great music. Signature cocktails and well-crafted drinks stand out amid close seating and energetic crowds.

Maine lobster roll stands out with its outstanding flavor and generous portion. It pairs well with sides and is often described as delicious and satisfying enough to want a second.

Chicken sandwich comes out moist and juicy with a dill sauce unique to the bar that works great for dipping fries or adding on top. Burger and sides also stand out as excellent choices.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are thoughtful, indulgent, and expertly executed."

"The chicken sandwich was moist, juicy, and delicious."

"I wished I had two of their delicious Lobster Rolls."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

Expect small portion sizes relative to the price.

08
Port Edward Restaurant image 1
Seafood restaurant

Indoor dining on a floating boat over a koi pond creates a unique setting, complemented by a waterfront patio with views of boats on the river. The atmosphere stays relaxed and lively with live music that entertains without overwhelming. Outdoor and indoor spaces blend natural views with distinctive design elements.

Stuffed with quality lobster, the lobster roll offers a huge portion that can serve two people. It is rich and overflowing, often more affordable than similar options elsewhere.

Cod sandwich stands out for its flavor. Lobster roll, grouper, and Philly steak sandwiches also offer solid options.

People are saying

"The seafood here is delicious, especially the shrimp kabobs."

"The lobster roll is huge and stuffed with quality lobster."

"I had the best cod sandwich I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for special events like Buffet Night on the first Friday of the month.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait for tables if you RSVP'd and paid a deposit.

3

Wine tasting events are held regularly, providing a unique experience for guests.

09
Mesler Kitchen | Bar | Lounge image 1

Upscale American restaurant with classy ambiance and modern fireplace creates a cozy, elegant atmosphere. Live music and a DJ playing Old School R&B add to the vibrant yet relaxed vibe. Decor emphasizes black excellence and culture, enhancing the distinctive setting.

Maine Lobster roll features a distinct texture that differs from typical versions. It comes at a higher price point but pairs well with sides like fries and drinks to go.

Spicy fried chicken sandwiches come crispy, juicy, and packed with sweet, spicy, and tangy flavors. They hit the mark perfectly every time.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are amazing and on point."

"The lobster roll was loaded with flavor and worth the price."

"The spicy chicken sandwich was crispy, juicy, and perfect."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, Mesler Kitchen has a DJ playing house music.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy weekends.

3

Parking can be tricky, so arrive early to find a spot.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...