Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Illinois' best

Pudding and pie

A slice of pie followed by a bowl of pudding provides the kind of comfort that only a double dose of dessert can offer.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream image 1
Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream image 2
Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream image 3
View all

Ice cream shop inside a church offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with peaceful background music. Customers enjoy endless free samples and unique flavors like vodka-infused ice cream. Setup focuses on takeout and delivery without traditional seating.

Banana pudding stands out with its exceptional flavor and strong impact. Rum and banana pudding adds a unique twist to the classic taste.

Sweet Potato Pie stands out with an intense, slightly extra sweet flavor that many find delicious. Other pies like Key Lime and Black Walnut offer unique, tasty options alongside rich flavors such as banana and lemon ice box.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was rich and delicious."

"I found the banana pudding to be extremely good."

"The sweet potato pie is intensely sweet and amazing."

Good to know

1

They have weekly specials every Wednesday.

2

The ice cream shop offers a rotating selection of unique flavors.

3

Parking is available in the industrial park where the shop is located.

02
The Evie image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant occupies an elegant second-floor space with amazing views of Michigan Avenue. Atmosphere feels funky and cool yet allows easy conversation without yelling. Offers masterfully made exotic cocktails and a lively bar with sports TVs.

Bread pudding stands out with a crispy top and a texture that is not soggy. It is homemade and consistently described as incredible and divine.

Key lime pie offers a perfect balance of zestiness and sweetness. It stands out as an incredible dessert alongside the Prime Filet Mignon.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the steak frites and lobster roll, is top notch."

"The bread pudding was warm, creamy, and packed with heavenly flavors."

"I thought the key lime pie was a great way to end the meal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

3

The restaurant has a dress code; business casual is preferred.

03
Brown Shuga Bakery image 1

Bakery offers homemade desserts with classic flavors and expert execution. Atmosphere feels cold and unwelcoming. Cakes and pies stand out as moist and flavorful, often described as some of the best available.

Banana pudding offers a taste of the south and stands out from other options in the area. It pairs well with caramel cake and red velvet cake, all delivering solid flavor.

Slices of Brownie-Cheesecake-Graham Cracker Crust and peach pie stand out for their flavor. The sweet potato pie also offers a rich, satisfying taste.

People are saying

"The caramel cake is so moist and not too sweet."

"These cookies are so moist and melt in your mouth."

"I found the sweet potato pie and peach pie to be so delicious."

Good to know

1

They can take cake orders a few days in advance.

2

A sugar-free option is needed for dietary preferences.

3

A printed menu would improve readability over the digital one.

04
My Just Desserts Alton, LLC image 1

Old building with river views creates a cozy, vintage vibe. Friendly local crowd enjoys a quaint, comfy cafe atmosphere with plenty of sunshine. Menu features sweet treats and daily specials in a relaxed downtown setting.

Bread pudding stands out as a delicious and really good dessert option. The portion size includes a quarter-inch slice that satisfies dessert cravings.

Pies here stand out for their rich flavor and unique textures, like the pecan pie that tastes almost like baklava. Varieties such as ozarkberry and chicken pot pie offer comforting, well-seasoned options.

People are saying

"You have to save room for their delicious homemade desserts."

"This pie was legit and excellent."

"I found the bread pudding to be really good."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers a fresh specials menu that changes weekly.

2

Prices for lunch items are generally on the higher side.

3

Parking is available along the street or in a nearby lot.

05
Jackman & Co. image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant combines old school 60s vibe with modern design, featuring dark wood decor and white tablecloths. Atmosphere feels cozy and lively, with low lighting that creates a warm but sometimes dim setting. Bar area offers spacious seating and a variety of drinks, attracting a mix of diners and bar-goers.

Sticky toffee pudding has a moist, cake-like consistency and comes with buttermilk ice cream and a toasted sesame seed caramelized wafer on top. Banana foster and sticky caramel pudding cake also appear as rich dessert options.

Frozen mud pie stands out as a dessert option, often praised for its flavor. The menu also features savory pies like chicken pot pie and short rib and marrow pie, offering hearty choices.

People are saying

"The food here is great and worth the price."

"The sticky toffee pudding is moist, sweet, and cake-like."

"You have to try the frozen mud pie for dessert."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs weekly with great drink and appetizer options.

2

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

3

Street parking is available nearby, as there is no dedicated parking lot.

06
Classic Cobbler Baked Goods Company image 1

Pie shop offers a warm and cozy space with cute, bright decor and a clean atmosphere. Desserts like blueberry and peach cobbler and banana pudding draw steady interest, often selling out quickly. Seating is available alongside coffee and tea, with most business focused on orders and pickups.

Banana pudding stands out with its perfect creaminess and rich flavor. Peach cobbler and bread pudding also deliver strong, delicious flavors that satisfy cravings.

Fresh Peach Cobbler Pie comes straight from the oven. Options include pecan pie, lemon cream pie, cherry pie, blueberry cobbler, and a walnut brownie pie.

People are saying

"I found the peach cobbler here to be delicious and warm."

"The strawberry mango cobbler had delicious chunks and a perfect crust."

"The peach cobbler and banana pudding were perfect."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended to avoid sold-out items.

2

Daily specials are posted near the register and in the cold case at the entrance.

3

Expect to wait in line for order pickups as customers must wait in the retail line.

07
Yasemi, A Modern Mediterranean Restaurant image 1

Spacious restaurant with modern, elegant decor and airy layout that avoids crowding. Atmosphere feels casual but chic, with loud music creating an energetic vibe. Tables require personal light to read menus due to dim lighting.

Rice pudding stands out with its amazing price and signature Greek style. It pairs well with tangerine ice cream and leaves a strong impression.

Cheese pie features a salty feta filling with a honey drizzle and truffle honey and seeds on top, wrapped in crispy pastry. It stands out as a favorite dish alongside beef kofta and crispy potatoes.

People are saying

"The Mediterranean food here is fresh and delicious, especially the hummus."

"You have to try the cheese pie; it's phenomenal."

"The rice pudding here is so good, I almost cried."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 4-6pm with unique cocktails at reasonable prices.

2

Enjoy $2 oysters during happy hour, a great deal for seafood lovers.

3

The restaurant adds a 4% surcharge to all bills, so plan accordingly.

08
Sweet Mandy B's Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an authentic interior and a relaxed atmosphere that feels like home. Known for famous cupcakes and a varied selection including vegan options, it draws families and casual visitors alike. The space is smaller and less trendy, focusing on simple, honest baked goods.

Banana Carmel Cabinet pudding combines yellow cake, banana slices, and caramel topping for a moist, tasty treat. The banana pudding stands out as a top notch dessert option here.

Key lime pie has a very minimal lime flavor and tastes extremely sweet. The recipe does not deliver an authentic key lime pie experience and the price is relatively high for the quality.

People are saying

"I thought the devil's food cake was the best cake I ever had."

"It's a calm, comforting place that feels like home."

"I found the key lime pie to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Prices for baked goods are not clearly marked, so ask before ordering.

3

The bakery is open seven days a week for your convenience.

09
Golden Corral Buffet & Grill image 1

Buffet restaurant offers a spacious setup with an organized layout and bright, clean facility. Atmosphere varies from quiet mornings to loud, crowded evenings with children running and shouting. Self-service features include making your own plate and ice cream, with a fresh grill serving burgers.

Bread pudding comes hot, sweet, and gooey with a rich texture. Banana pudding stands out as a sweet classic, while a no sugar added chocolate pudding offers a diabetic-friendly option.

Pumpkin pie stands out with a surprising flavor that impresses even sweet potato pie fans. The pie station offers a variety of options, including pecan pie with soft serve ice cream, though some desserts lack clear labels.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"The banana pudding here is the best."

"This pumpkin pie is the best I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for adult entry, with extra charges on holidays.

2

Reservations are not accepted; expect long wait times during peak hours.

3

Children under 12 must be accompanied by an adult to get food.

10
Matt's Barbecue and Bourbon Bar image 1

Barbecue restaurant with outdoor patio featuring live music and picnic-style seating creates a relaxed, welcoming vibe. Smoky aroma and Texas-style barbecue set a distinctive atmosphere. Evenings bring a lively energy with music and social outdoor gatherings.

Banana pudding appears as a classic dessert alongside BBQ and traditional sides. It shares the menu with other sweets like pecan pie, rounding out hearty meals.

Pecan pie stands out with its rich flavor and perfectly sweet filling. It serves as a satisfying dessert after hearty meals.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the amazing barbecue; it was tender and full of flavor."

"I found the pudding here to be super delicious and very tender."

"I found the barbecue here to be among the best."

Good to know

1

Live music happens every Thursday at Matt's Barbecue and Bourbon Bar.

2

Open mic night on Thursdays features local talent and is very popular.

3

The beef dino rib is only available on Sundays, so plan accordingly.

11
Famous Dave's Bar-B-Que image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue restaurant offers a cozy, relaxing vibe with a sports bar atmosphere and big screen TV. The space feels family-friendly and clean, with a quiet, respectful noise level. Ribs and BBQ stand out as popular choices among the menu.

Bread pudding stands out as a favorite dessert, often described as delicious and highly rated. The banana pudding also draws attention as a recommended choice.

A small selection of Baker's Square Pies is available, including French Silk, Country Apple, Pecan, and Lemon Meringue. Pecan pie and Key Lime Pie stand out as good dessert options.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the ribs and fried chicken, is delicious."

"You have to try their bread pudding; it's delicious."

"You can get Baker's Square pies here, even whole ones."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, and seating is first-come, first-served.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant has a clean dining area but some reports mention dirty bathrooms.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...