Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Chicago's best

Pie American food

A slice of pie that tastes like it was baked for the meal rather than sitting in a display case for days.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Dunning Pour House image 1
Dunning Pour House image 2
Dunning Pour House image 3
View all

Neighborhood bar with a cozy, intimate atmosphere and laid-back vibe. Medium-sized space features multiple TVs and a dedicated darts back room, supporting casual games and socializing. Sound system balances lively music without overpowering conversation.

Burger specials on Wednesdays and pan chicken nachos on Thursdays stand out. The menu also features Chicken Caesar Salad, fish tacos, and banana whipped pie.

Banana cream pie stands out with its rich flavor and smooth texture. It ranks among the most delicious pies available.

People are saying

"The bar food here is delicious, especially the wings and burger."

"The American food, especially the wings and mac and cheese, was awesome."

"The banana cream pie here is the best."

Good to know

1

Wednesday features $14 buckets of domestic beer.

2

Enjoy $5 margaritas on special nights.

3

Bi-weekly blind draw events occur on Wednesdays.

02
Taste 222 image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers an elegant yet cozy atmosphere with old school R&B music and an open floor plan that suits large groups and events. Spaces include a private room, bar, and breezy patio, creating a versatile and inviting setup. The vibe balances charming decor with a relaxed, stylish energy.

Shrimp and grits stand out with their savory seasoning and generous portions. The menu also features a fried chicken sandwich and key lime pie that offer filling, well-prepared options.

Peanut butter mousse pie stands out with its creamy, flavorful mousse. The Key Lime Pie is surprisingly filling and worth trying.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful during Happy Hour."

"The American Food here, especially the peanut butter mousse cake, is amazing."

"The peanut butter mousse pie is insanely good and creamy."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with 13 food options and 9 drink options.

2

Reservations are recommended to avoid waiting during peak hours.

3

The happy hour menu offers good value for money with reasonably priced items.

03
Junebug Cafe Six Corners image 1

Small, cozy cafe with New Orleans vibe and tasteful decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Music choice leans heavily on loud country tunes, which contrasts with the jazz theme. Spacious tables and plenty of outlets support a relaxed, productive environment.

Gumbo stands out with its rich gravy and just enough kick to keep you coming back. Crawfish Pie and Cowboy Nachos taste authentic, matching New Orleans flavors closely.

Meat pies come packed with juicy, flavorful fillings and a creamy, spicy sauce on the side. Unique options like crayfish pie and a tasty breakfast pie stand out alongside classic dishes like gumbo.

People are saying

"These beignets are light, airy, and taste just like the ones in NOLA."

"I enjoyed the coffee, especially the tiramisu latte."

"The American food, especially the gumbo, is flavorful and hearty."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers unique Cajun dishes like crayfish pie and beignets.

2

Expect high prices, with empanadas costing $12 and biscuits $7.

3

Portions are generous; a rice and beans bowl can serve two.

04
Marge's Still image 1
Restaurant

Classic neighborhood tavern with a cozy pub atmosphere and dim lighting supports easy conversation and relaxed sports viewing. Mostly local crowd enjoys the old school vibe and friendly bar setting. Layout feels a bit wonky but remains roomy and accessible.

Chicken pot pie stands out with a crispy outside and a creamy inside. It contains chunks of potatoes, chicken, and snow beans and comes in a large portion.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its crispy outside and creamy inside. Portions come huge and the flavor is consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the pot pie."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was the best I'd ever had."

"This American food, the chicken pot pie, is huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a 45-minute wait during peak hours; no reservations are accepted.

2

The kitchen closes at 10 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4 PM to 6 PM on weekdays.

05
The Evie image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant occupies an elegant second-floor space with amazing views of Michigan Avenue. Atmosphere feels funky and cool yet allows easy conversation without yelling. Offers masterfully made exotic cocktails and a lively bar with sports TVs.

Lobster roll stands out with fresh lobster and buttery toast. Prime rib sandwich and Wygua hot dog also deliver strong flavors. Key lime pie offers a notable finish.

Key lime pie offers a perfect balance of zestiness and sweetness. It stands out as an incredible dessert alongside the Prime Filet Mignon.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the steak frites and lobster roll, is top notch."

"The food at these dinner spots was outstanding and beautifully prepared."

"I thought the key lime pie was a great way to end the meal."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

3

The restaurant has a dress code; business casual is preferred.

06
Give Me Some Sugah image 1

Cozy bakery with whimsical cookie jars and a homey atmosphere filled with the aroma of sweets. The vibe feels warm and neighborhood-focused, attracting locals who appreciate unique, high-quality baked goods. Variety and passion in baking stand out, making it a community gem.

Chicken pot pie stands out with rich, satisfying flavors. Desserts like key lime pie and pecan pie offer perfectly balanced sweetness. Gumbo and soup add hearty, delicious options to the menu.

Sweet potato pie brings strong nostalgia and stands out as a favorite. The chicken pot pie impresses with rich flavor, while the key lime pie offers a perfectly balanced taste.

People are saying

"I found the caramel cake to be very good and rich."

"The American Food here, especially the key lime pie, was so darn good."

"I thought the sweet potato pie was the best pie I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of unique baked goods with different flavors.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it easy to enjoy a treat without overspending.

3

The bakery is known for its fantastic customer service.

07
Loaf Lounge image 1

Bright space combines classic bakery charm with a cute, trendy decor. Atmosphere shifts from laid-back and welcoming during weekdays to buzzing and crowded around late mornings. Seating options include comfortable tables and counters, with a small pleasant patio.

Chocolate chip cookies pack loads of chocolate chips and balance chewy, crispy, and soft textures. Grilled cheese stands out with its rich flavor, and the salmon open sandwich comes with a large portion of hash browns and cafe au lait.

The oatmeal cream pie stands out as a favorite, often described as the best or nearly the best ever had. It appears regularly on the menu and draws repeat orders for its unique flavor and consistency.

People are saying

"I thought the breakfast sandwiches were the best I ever had."

"The oatmeal cream pie is unreal, the best I've ever had."

"You have to try the chocolate chip cookies; they're insane."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 30 minutes during busy times.

2

There is a free parking lot adjacent to the location, with metered street parking available.

3

A 4% service charge is added to all bills without prior notice.

08
Southern Chicago image 1

Elegant space features beautiful dรฉcor and a warm, comfortable atmosphere with great music enhancing the vibe. Guests enjoy thoughtfully crafted cocktails and high-quality Southern-inspired dishes in a setting that feels both inviting and refined.

Fried chicken comes with mac & cheese, greens, and sweet potatoes. Complimentary cornbread starts the meal. Key lime pie finishes with a sweet touch.

Key lime pie stands out with its tart flavor and creamy texture. It delivers a delicious dessert experience.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and thoughtfully prepared."

"The cornbread and fried chicken are stars of this American food."

"The key lime pie had great flavor."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great prices on food and drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

3

Valet parking is available for guests.

09
Chicago Chop House image 1

Restored brownstone with early 1900s decor and photos of local celebrities creates a traditional steakhouse atmosphere. Live piano music plays softly, adding to the luxurious and old-fashioned vibe. Comfortable seating and personalized touches enhance a refined dining experience.

Prime rib stands out as tender and flavorful. Lobster Truffle Mac and Cheese offers a rich twist. Key lime pie finishes the meal with a perfect touch.

Cherry pie stands out with its rich flavor. Key lime pie offers a perfect tang and a balanced sweetness.

People are saying

"I found the steak to be tender and flavorful."

"The American Food here, especially the steaks, is perfectly cooked."

"The key lime pie had the perfect tang."

Good to know

1

During the 40th anniversary, all food ordered was 40% off.

2

Valentineโ€™s Day celebrations offer special menu items.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially during holidays.

10
3LP (3 little pigs chi) Bridgeport image 1

Tiny space with bench seats and a handful of tables offers a cozy atmosphere accented by colorful murals. A large patio out back provides casual outdoor seating, often favored by families. The vibe blends simple decor with a fun, lively energy despite occasional smoke from cooking.

Fried chicken sandwiches come with salt and pepper seasoning that adds great flavor. The chicken is juicy with a fantastic crunch, served on a brioche bun with fresh jalapeรฑos for a noticeable kick.

Pie Goons stand out with their just right sweetness and impressive flavor. They offer a unique twist on traditional pies that catches attention.

People are saying

"This chicken sandwich is juicy, crispy, and huge."

"The American Food here, especially the fried chicken sandwich, is super crunchy and flavorful."

"The pie goons were particularly impressive and sweet."

Good to know

1

Seating is limited, but there is a large patio on Keely Street.

2

Portions are generous and filling, making it a good value.

3

Parking is easier to find than at their previous location.

11
Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop inside a church offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with peaceful background music. Customers enjoy endless free samples and unique flavors like vodka-infused ice cream. Setup focuses on takeout and delivery without traditional seating.

Key lime pie ice cream stands out with a unique flavor. Cheeseburgers and fries come fresh and made to order. Other notable flavors include strawberry shortcake and banana pudding.

Sweet Potato Pie stands out with an intense, slightly extra sweet flavor that many find delicious. Other pies like Key Lime and Black Walnut offer unique, tasty options alongside rich flavors such as banana and lemon ice box.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was rich and delicious."

"Their ice cream has a creamy texture with unique, layered flavors."

"The sweet potato pie is intensely sweet and amazing."

Good to know

1

They have weekly specials every Wednesday.

2

The ice cream shop offers a rotating selection of unique flavors.

3

Parking is available in the industrial park where the shop is located.

12
Chief O'Neill's Pub Restaurant Beer Garden image 1

Beer garden features twinkling string lights and lush greenery, creating an enchanting atmosphere with an authentic Irish pub feel. Large covered patio hosts live traditional music and special events, adding to the festive vibe. The space balances festive decorations with a cozy, lively energy.

Eggs Benedict stands out with perfectly poached eggs. The Guinness Pot Roast is fork tender and full of flavor. Other notable dishes include cheddar soup, chicken pot pie, and a flavorful burger.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its light texture and mouth-watering flavor. Chicken pot pie also features as a notable dish alongside a rich cheddar soup.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fantastic."

"The American food, especially the pot roast and corned beef, was outstanding."

"I swear, the shepherd's pie just made love to my taste buds."

Good to know

1

The Sunday brunch buffet is all-you-can-eat for $32.

2

Reservations are recommended for the Sunday brunch due to high demand.

3

Live Irish music is featured on Sundays from 5-7 PM.

13
First Slice Pie Cafe image 1

Pie shop offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with a homey, American style. Indoor and outdoor seating includes a loud patio due to traffic, while inside is generally quiet. Menu features large, affordable pies alongside sandwiches and quiches, attracting a steady local crowd.

Apple pie features a freshly made, not sweet filling with a flaky crust. Chicken pot pies and quiches have perfect, buttery, flaky crusts. Curry chicken salad and key lime pie stand out as flavorful options.

Rhubarb pie and apple pie come fresh daily with a memorable taste and texture. The Toffee Coffee Pie offers a mousse-like consistency topped with toffee coffee sprinkles, while the cherry pie stands out for its distinct flavor.

People are saying

"I loved the flavorful chicken and blue cheese sandwich."

"I found the Latin hip hop salad with chicken amazing."

"The American food here, especially the pies, has a perfect, buttery, flaky crust."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers both indoor and outdoor seating for guests.

2

The bathroom is located next to the back door, through the kitchen.

3

Pies are large for the price, making them a good value.

14
The Galway Arms image 1

Cozy Irish pub with multiple rooms featuring fireplaces and woodwork that evoke an authentic Ireland feel. Live traditional music most nights creates a lively, community atmosphere. Outdoor patio adds a relaxed space for gatherings.

Chicken pot pie stands out as a notable dish, though it can be a bit watery sometimes. The gluten-free grilled cheese pairs well with tomato bisque, and fish and chips offer a solid option to share.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its savory flavor and is consistently described as excellent and very good. The chicken pot pie also draws attention for being amazing and a favorite dish.

People are saying

"This bar has live Irish music and dancing sessions."

"The American food here is delicious, especially the chicken pot pie."

"I found the Shepherd's Pie to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Live Irish music sessions occur five nights a week, with the biggest on Sundays.

2

Everyone is welcome to join the music and dance sessions.

3

Reservations can be made online for larger parties.

15
Adalina Prime image 1
Steak house

Steakhouse offers a stunning build-out with indoor and outdoor seating and a warm, modern feel. Atmosphere feels elegant and refined, with exceptional service and playful touches like a salt library for customizing steaks. Bar features include top-notch martini service and a variety of strong, well-crafted cocktails.

Mac and cheese stands out with versions made from gnocchi noodles and tteokbokki, offering unique textures and flavors. Mashed potatoes come with a crunchy twist, adding an unexpected bite.

Lobster pot pie stands out with its unique flavor and rich filling. It costs more than typical pies but offers good value for the quality.

People are saying

"The food here was delicious and flawlessly executed."

"The American Food here is bar none, with incredible staff."

"I loved the lobster pot pie; it was amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended due to high nighttime traffic.

3

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

16
Let's Eat To Live image 1

Restaurant offers a beautiful interior with amazing artwork and comfortable seating. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with calm music enhancing a peaceful vibe. Dining area stays clean and inviting, creating a friendly and peaceful environment.

Tender, well-seasoned lamb chops stand out alongside creamy Mac and cheese and fresh asparagus. The Cajun pasta offers a nice kick, and the kitchen ensures dishes like Mac and cheese arrive fresh.

Bean pies stand out with their rich flavor and are a popular choice here. They pair well with other items like Navy Bean Soup for a hearty meal.

People are saying

"The food here is so delicious, especially the mac n cheese."

"The American food here, especially the mac and cheese, is so creamy and cheesy."

"You have to try the bean pie; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Street parking is widely available near the restaurant.

2

The restaurant is closed on Mondays.

3

They offer daily specials that change regularly.

17
The Walnut Room image 1
American restaurant

Dining room showcases historic decor and a stunning Christmas tree that creates a magical atmosphere. Fairy princesses visit tables, adding a whimsical touch to the experience. Space feels spacious and elegant with white tablecloths and a sense of Chicago history.

Chicken pot pie stands out as a traditional and popular dish here. The menu also features affordable options like the Walnut Room Club with garlic fries and a petite Caesar salad.

The chicken pot pie stands out with its generous filling and solid flavor. It comes in a signature size that is satisfying and pairs well with simple sides like a petite Caesar salad.

People are saying

"The holiday atmosphere and the Great Tree are just stunningly gorgeous."

"The salads here are a cherished part of Chicago's history."

"The American Food here is a beautiful, nostalgic experience."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for holiday dining at least two months in advance.

2

The Walnut Room hosts a popular drag brunch every Sunday at 11 AM.

3

Parking costs $28 for three hours, so plan accordingly.

18
Kleinโ€™s Bakery & Cafe (LakeviewEast) image 1

Elevated home bakery with cozy atmosphere and vibrant urban vibe offers several seating options including outdoor space. The place suits both quiet work sessions and casual chats, featuring lovely music and a welcoming environment.

Apple and pumpkin pies feature strong flavoring and consistent texture. Grilled cheese with tomato stands out as a delicious sandwich option. Large orders of cookies, brownies, and cakepops exceed expectations in quality.

Apple pie has a strong, well-loved flavor. Pumpkin pie offers a consistent texture and is popular at gatherings. The pecan pie has an off taste and is less favored.

People are saying

"I loved their pastries; they were always delicious and fresh."

"I loved the flavoring and consistency of their American Food pies."

"I loved the flavoring and consistency of their pumpkin pie."

Good to know

1

Limited seating is available, especially during busy times.

2

Expect a wait time during weekends due to high demand.

3

Prices for coffee and sandwiches can reach around $20.

19
Tortoise Supper Club image 1
American restaurant

Elegant supper club blends live jazz music with a cozy, lively atmosphere featuring dark wood and colorful jazz-inspired wallpaper. Dining spaces include a private room with a bar, creating intimate vibes amid a bustling crowd. The setting combines elements of a jazz club and restaurant for a unique experience.

Prime rib stands out for being cooked to perfection. Meatloaf serves as a definitive American classic. Other notable dishes include cobb salad, steak au poivre, and sea bass.

Cherry pie stands out as a signature dessert here. The tortoise pie also offers a unique twist on classic sweets.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots was spectacular and delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the prime rib, is cooked to perfection."

"The cherry pie here has bright, tart cherries and a thick crust."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for private events and should be made well in advance.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Valet parking costs $16 for three hours, making it convenient for guests.

20
King Crab House Chicago image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small seafood restaurant offers nautical charm with epoxy tables embedded with seashells and a coastal retreat vibe. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and kitschy, with a chill music selection enhancing the mood. Limited seating and a cozy outdoor patio create an intimate setting.

Maryland-style crab cakes steal the spotlight with rich flavor. Ribeye steak comes well seasoned and juicy, often paired with Cajun butter for extra kick.

Key lime pie stands out as a refreshing and delightful dessert option. Staff often present it with a Happy Birthday song, adding a special touch.

People are saying

"The oysters here are top quality and unbeatable."

"The American Food, especially the crab legs and key lime pie, was excellent."

"I loved the key lime pie; it was refreshing and delightful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available on Sundays with appetizer specials at the bar.

2

There is a two-drink minimum for the oyster bar special.

3

Parking is not available near the restaurant, so plan accordingly.

21
Oak and Honey image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers a cozy, upscale boho vibe with tasteful decor including a standout zebra print. Space feels deceptively large but tables sit close together, creating a lively, vibrant atmosphere. Bar seating suits solo diners, and a dog-friendly patio adds to the welcoming energy.

A fat, juicy beef patty cooked with sautรฉed mushrooms, caramelized onions, and melted cheese defines the patty melt here. Portions come big, and the key lime pie stands out as a sweet finish.

Fresh pies stand out with big portions and a memorable key lime pie. The French Silk pie also offers a rich, satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"Our server Sharon was incredible and made our brunch experience better."

"I wished I had room for their awesome homemade pies."

"The American Food here, especially the patty melt, is juicy and cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Wine Wednesday features special deals on select wines.

3

Reservations can be made through Open Table.

22
Bakers Square image 1
Family restaurant

Cozy family restaurant with a relaxing atmosphere and an 80s vibe. Seating arrangements are great, and the smell of fresh pies adds to the welcoming feel. The place has a slightly outdated interior but maintains its iconic look.

Pot Roast and Reuben Sandwich stand out as strong dishes. The Cobb salad features fresh vegetables and grilled chicken. Eggs Benedict, hamburgers, chicken, and club sandwiches also appear regularly. Pumpkin and apple pies are popular holiday choices.

French silk pie stands out alongside a perfect balance of roasted coconut cream and whipping cream in the coconut pie. Pumpkin Pie comes with whipped cream on request, and Key Lime pie also rates very good. Whole pies cost less than slices.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the delicious French silk pie."

"I found the food here to be excellent."

"I thought the American Food pies here were scrumptious."

Good to know

1

Free pie Wednesday offers a complimentary slice with any entree.

2

Smash Burger Mondays feature special pricing on burgers.

3

The menu has been pared down with fewer options since pre-COVID.

23
Truth Be Told image 1
Restaurant

Traditional English pub with spacious layout and a comfortable interior featuring booths, tables, and a fireplace. Atmosphere feels magical and cozy, suitable for family, friends, or date nights. Bar area offers chilled vibe with a focus on well-crafted cocktails and a gastropub experience.

Roast Chicken Pot Pie stands out as a highlight with rich, savory flavors. The menu also features Lamb Shepherds Pie and a Sunday Prime Rib Dinner, both hearty and satisfying. Mac and cheese appeals to family tastes.

Roast Chicken Pot Pie stands out with unique flavors of mustard and herbs. Lamb Shepherds Pie also features as a solid choice, both praised for their fantastic taste.

People are saying

"The Seafood here is wonderful, and the service is excellent."

"The American food, especially the pot pie, has a light and flaky crust."

"The chicken pot pie's biscuit topping was light and flaky."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is not offered, but wine selection is half off on Wednesdays.

2

Parking is very limited, so arrive early or consider alternative transport.

3

Expect high prices, with beers costing $10 or more.

Discover more

Chicago, Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...