Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Chicago

Chicken tikka masala and butter chicken

Made for those who refuse to compromise on their order and want the best of both butter chicken and chicken tikka masala.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mr Tandoor image 1
Mr Tandoor image 2
Mr Tandoor image 3
View all
Restaurant

Tiny restaurant with warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly, family-oriented vibe. Tastefully furnished space features a unique art wall that adds character. Casual setting draws those seeking high-quality Indian cuisine in a peaceful environment.

Rich, creamy chicken tikka masala stands out with its smooth sauce and tender chicken pieces. It pairs well with garlic naan and is often enjoyed alongside samosas.

Creamy perfection defines the butter chicken here, rich with flavorful spices and a smooth texture. It pairs well with garlic naan and stands out alongside dishes like tandoori chicken and goat.

People are saying

"The food here tastes amazing and reminds me of home."

"I found the butter chicken to be really good and flavorful."

"I loved their Chicken Tikka Masala and butter chicken."

Good to know

1

Call ahead to order as wait times can be long.

2

The restaurant offers generous portion sizes, suitable for sharing.

3

Prices are reasonable compared to other Indian restaurants in the area.

02
Curry Kitchen image 1
Indian restaurant

Indian restaurant offers a cozy, homely atmosphere with soft lighting and great music creating a relaxing vibe. The space is beautiful and very clean, featuring a large bar area and views of downtown through front windows. It attracts those seeking authentic Nepali and Indian comfort food served in distinctive copper bowls.

Very flavorful and perfectly spiced chicken tikka masala pairs well with well-made naan and rice. Butter chicken also complements the dish nicely.

Rich, melt-in-your-mouth butter chicken stands out with deep flavor. It pairs well with Naan and offers a satisfying curry experience.

People are saying

"The food here is so flavorful and delicious."

"The butter chicken here is melt-in-your-mouth delicious and rich."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala here is so flavorful and perfectly spiced."

Good to know

1

The restaurant currently operates as BYOB until they obtain their license.

2

There is easy street parking available near the restaurant.

3

The restaurant can accommodate almost 100 people at once.

03
Cumin Restaurant - Lakeview image 1

Modern interior blends Nepali handmade arts and crafts with a spacious layout that feels both upscale and comfortable. Atmosphere stays calm and friendly with good music enhancing the relaxing vibe. Separate event space accommodates larger groups without crowding the main dining area.

Chicken tikka masala comes out rich and flavorful. It pairs well with garlic naan and is a consistent choice alongside dishes like chicken momos and palak paneer.

Butter Chicken features rich, creamy sauce with tender chicken pieces. Quality varies by location, with one spot offering authentic, flavorful Butter Chicken and another serving a watered-down version with just chicken breast cubes.

People are saying

"The chicken and lamb keema samosas were delicious, especially with the sauces."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala here is amazing and even better than expected."

"I found the butter chicken to be incredible."

Good to know

1

Cumin offers a flavorful Indian-Nepali dining experience within a warm and modern setting.

2

The portion sizes are a bit small, but they prioritize quality over quantity.

3

Reservations are recommended for larger groups.

04
Cumin Restaurant - Wicker Park image 1

Casual space with few tables and Nepalese paintings on the walls creates a simple, understated vibe. The atmosphere feels mixed, ranging from okayish to somewhat toxic. Known for spicy Pakistani-style biryani and flavorful North Indian dishes, it attracts those seeking vegetarian and vegan options.

Rich, creamy chicken tikka masala pairs well with basmati rice and garlic naan. It stands out among other dishes like vindaloo chicken and vegetable jalfrezi.

Chicken Makhani here comes with an extra spicy option and a rich, creamy sauce. The basic butter chicken is solid and stands out among other dishes like chicken madras and bhatura.

People are saying

"The Indian food here is so flavorful and perfectly charred."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala here is exceptional, especially with the basmati rice."

"I found the butter chicken here to be the best, with amazing flavors."

Good to know

1

Street parking is available right in front of the restaurant.

2

Main courses are priced around $18, with rice sold separately.

3

The restaurant offers a lunch special that is well-priced.

05
Adda Indian Cuisine image 1
Indian restaurant

Soft lighting and jazz piano create a cozy, antique atmosphere with a lively vibe. Spacious seating includes booths and a bar with a full display of drinks. The setting suits date nights and casual dining with a pleasant neighborhood view.

Rich, creamy sauce defines the Chicken Tikka Masala here, standing out as a highlight. It pairs well with garlic naan and offers a satisfying, flavorful experience.

Rich, creamy sauce with perfect spice balance defines the butter chicken here. It comes with a thick, heavily spiced sauce that stands out from plain versions.

People are saying

"The food here is so delicious, I'm still thinking about it."

"The Butter Chicken here is creamy and full of flavor."

"I found the Chicken Tikka Masala to be the best I had in years."

Good to know

1

Adda Indian Cuisine offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

2

Gluten-free friendly dishes are available at Adda Indian Cuisine.

3

Parking is plentiful and available on the street near the restaurant.

06
Rangoli Indian Cuisine image 1
Indian restaurant

Spacious interior features simple, elegant decor with authentic artwork and plush pillows creating a cozy, pleasant atmosphere. Music adds to the vibe, and copper and brass glassware enhance the dining experience. The place is BYOB and suits quiet dinners or family meals.

Chicken tikka masala features a semi-sweet, semi-buttery sauce that stands out from typical versions. Portions are generous, with a creamy, rich gravy that pairs well with butter chicken.

Creamy and comforting, the butter chicken features an awesome gravy that stands out. It sometimes comes served on a fresh homemade dosa with delicious chutney and sambar.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, delicious, and perfectly seasoned."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala is rich, creamy, and delicious."

"The butter chicken here is creamy, comforting, and exceptionally good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite drink.

2

Dosa night is a popular event, so arrive early for a good seat.

3

The menu offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan options.

07
Oberoi's Authentic Indian Food Is temporarily closed. image 1

Indian restaurant offers a cozy, inviting atmosphere with a semi fine dining style suited for family meals and casual occasions. The space feels peaceful and welcoming, with a variety of authentic dishes that appeal to diverse tastes.

Creamy sauce and tender chicken define the chicken tikka masala here. It comes with lots of rice and pairs with garlic naan or lachha paratha.

Creamy texture and fresh flavors define the butter chicken here. It pairs well with basmati rice and naan, and sometimes comes with a BOGO deal.

People are saying

"I'm obsessed with how delicious and well-seasoned this Lassi is."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala is delicious with a creamy sauce."

"I thought the Butter Chicken sauce tasted only of tomato."

Good to know

1

They now offer a top-notch buffet on Saturday and Sunday starting from 11 am.

2

The food is reasonably priced and portions are big.

3

Oberoi's is a perfect spot for family lunch.

08
Gorkha Kitchen Indian and Nepalese Restuarant image 1

Cozy space with authentic Nepalese vibe and peaceful atmosphere enhanced by Nepali music and a fish tank. Laid-back energy with welcoming owners creates a warm, relaxed environment. Unique as a BYOB Indian restaurant offering a genuine, non-pretentious dining experience.

Chicken tikka masala here varies in taste. Some versions are bland with no spice, while others are absolutely delicious but look different from traditional tikka masala.

Offers a two-for-one deal on butter chicken that makes it easy to try. The butter chicken is particularly delicious and often paired with garlic naan or momos for a full meal.

People are saying

"The Nepali food here is so flavorful and authentic."

"I thought the Butter Chicken was particularly delicious."

"I thought the Chicken Tikka Masala was especially good."

Good to know

1

The lunch special before 2 pm is $13.95, including two curries, naan, soda, and dessert.

2

Gorkha Kitchen is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

3

Expect to park about 10 minutes away from the restaurant.

09
Indian Dhaba image 1
Indian restaurant

Small restaurant with a mom and pop vibe and 1950s diner theme offers a colorful, cozy atmosphere that feels welcoming and inviting. The space is clean and bright, capturing the essence of a true Indian roadside dhaba with hearty portions and a chill neighborhood energy.

Chicken tikka masala features a tomato-based gravy similar to Walmart's version. It pairs well with garlic naan and comes alongside dishes like butter chicken and basmati rice.

Butter chicken comes with a tomato-based gravy similar to common store-bought sauces. It is sometimes prepared fresh but can also be served frozen. Naan often accompanies it, though it may be frozen as well.

People are saying

"The food tasted fresh and was perfectly spiced."

"I thought the Butter Chicken was so good and delicious."

"The Chicken Tikka Masala here is hot, fresh, and delicious."

Good to know

1

They have a weekend lunch buffet available.

2

The restaurant is all vegetarian with soy and plant-based options.

3

Prices are comfortable compared to other Indian restaurants.

Discover more

Chicago, Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...