Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Chicago

Italian cookie spots

A sweet Italian cookie is the small, necessary indulgence that follows a hearty Italian food meal.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Zella's Catering And Dessert image 1
Zella's Catering And Dessert image 2
Zella's Catering And Dessert image 3
View all

Loft space offers a welcoming atmosphere with a friendly vibe and clean kitchen practices. Food features generous portions and includes standout items like jerk chicken Alfredo pizza and large eggrolls. Ordering is efficient with minimal wait times and a reliable pickup system.

Jerk chicken Alfredo pizza stands out with its crispy, flaky crust and well-blended alfredo sauce and jerk chicken flavors. Lamb chops Alfredo and pasta also feature as notable dishes with rich, creamy sauces.

Soft texture and rich flavor define the cookies here. The turtle cookies stand out as a staple, alongside strawberry cookies that earn high praise.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, always fresh and full of flavor."

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The jerk chicken Alfredo pizza has a crispy crust and blended flavors."

Good to know

1

Pizza day is on Wednesdays, a popular event not to miss.

2

The ordering system allows for easy call-in orders with specified pickup times.

3

Prices are reasonable and portion sizes are generous.

02
Zazas Pizzeria - Lincoln Park image 1

Cozy space with a family-owned warmth and Chicago neighborhood vibe creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays chill and lively, perfect for enjoying authentic thin crust pizza with rich, flavorful sauce. Unique pizza options and a refined ambiance set it apart from typical pizzerias.

Pizzas like the Pesto Pie and Meatball come packed with flavor and cook just right. The focaccia served with whipped ricotta and hot honey stands out and goes fast.

Cookies come with ice cream for a classic dessert combo. They stand out as a must-try finish to the meal.

People are saying

"The NY style pizza here has bold, unforgettable New York flavors."

"The Italian food, especially the pizzas, was amazing and full of flavor."

"The cookies here were worth the trip."

Good to know

1

Order by the slice is limited.

2

The pizza is reasonably priced.

3

Zazaโ€™s offers a variety of pizza styles.

03
IL Giardino Del Dolce image 1

Vibrant colors and wonderful aromas fill the space, creating an inviting atmosphere. The bakery draws a crowd with its authentic Italian desserts like cannoli and lobster tail pastries, known for their unique, legit flavor and freshness. Regulars appreciate the old world, Italian bakery experience combined with consistent quality and reasonable pricing.

Cannoli cream stands out with a unique, legit flavor and rich texture. The menu features a giant cannolo, amaretti, and options like cannoli filling inside lobster tail pastry.

Italian cookies stand out for their authentic flavor and freshness. They taste delicious and consistently impress at celebrations and online orders.

People are saying

"The bakery's desserts were delicious and amazing."

"These Italian cookies are authentic and damn good."

"Their Italian Food cannoli cream is amazing and has a legit flavor."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide selection of Italian desserts.

2

Special orders can be accommodated with advance notice.

3

Prices for cakes and pastries are considered reasonable.

04
Sugar Moon image 1

Small bakery with funky decor and a beautiful worm mural creates a cozy, zen atmosphere with chill vibes and music. Lines grow long as pastries sell out quickly, drawing a crowd eager for unique, highly praised baked goods. Packaging is standard, and seating is minimal with just a few bar stools.

Focaccia stands out with its airy and thick texture and flavors like giardiniera. Other Italian treats include sweet brioche and cloud cookies.

Chocolate chip cookies offer an excellent mixture of textures and stand out as a favorite. Sesame and espresso cornflake cookies provide surprisingly good and unique flavors.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be the most scrumptious."

"The bakery's pastries and cookies are beautifully crafted and flavorful."

"The focaccia here is so delicious and airy."

Good to know

1

Sugar Moon sells out by midday, so arrive early for the best selection.

2

Expect a long line on weekends; arrive 15 minutes before opening.

3

There is very limited seating available; everything is for takeout.

05
Crust Tap Room image 1

Spacious brewpub with tavern-style sports bar design and many TVs showing the same program. Atmosphere feels laid back and comfortable with a hidden gem patio that welcomes pets. Offers flavorful beer and top-notch pizza with gluten-free options.

Pizza crust stays immaculate with toppings like fig, prosciutto, and pistachio pesto standing out. The Fig Is In pizza blends spinach, mushrooms, and a light white sauce with a sweet fig flavor.

Cookie skillet melts in your mouth and serves as a satisfying end to a meal. Some drive from nearby areas just to order it.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the pizza and steak sandwich."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, has a unique savory-sweet flavor."

"I sampled a few pizzas and each one was delicious."

Good to know

1

Crust Tap Room offers a variety of cocktails and beers along with a diverse food menu.

2

All pizzas can be made on gluten-free crust, catering to dietary needs.

3

The venue is spacious and suitable for larger groups.

06
Conte Di Savoia image 1

Italian deli with classic checkerboard floors and a tin pan ceiling creates an old school cool vibe. Atmosphere feels like a step back in time to a neighborhood shop with rich, authentic character. Sandwiches stand out as some of the best, complementing the genuine, nostalgic setting.

Fresh Mozzarella cheese, Prosciutto Di Parma, and homemade pastas stand out here. Italian subs come loaded with ham, salami, capocollo, and provolone, alongside fresh focaccia and Italian sausage that rivals those from Italy.

Italian cookies stand out with butter cookies that rank among the best. The selection includes cannolis and other classic treats served alongside coffee.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and really good."

"The Italian Food here, especially The Contessa, is fantastic."

"I loved the focaccia, cookies, and sandwiches here."

Good to know

1

Prices are very reasonable compared to other sandwich shops in the area.

2

The deli has about four tables available for dining.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during peak lunch hours.

07
Sicilian Bakery Inc image 1

Old-school Italian bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with a traditional vibe and authentic Sicilian pastries. Family-run with recipes from the old country, it draws people seeking genuine Italian breads and cannoli.

Cannoli stands out as a signature item, paired with focaccia bread that draws consistent praise. Desserts like tiramisu and amaretti offer soft, fresh textures, while savory options include arancini and Italian pizza.

Italian cookies stand out with authentic flavors like lemon and fig. The bakery offers a wide selection including cannoli and sfogliatelles, all consistently fresh and delicious.

People are saying

"Their Italian cookies are so tasty, you'll understand what great cookies should taste like."

"These cannoli are delicious and taste like the ones in Sicily."

"Their cannoli are the best Italian pastries I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery accepts only cash payments, so plan accordingly.

2

Special orders for cakes require at least 48 hours notice.

3

They charge an extra 4% fee for credit or debit card payments.

08
The Staley image 1
Sports bar

Large sports bar with huge projector screens and plenty of TVs creates a strong focus on watching games. Atmosphere feels like a dark basement man cave with a mix of upscale gastropub dรฉcor. Free arcade games and a mini game room add casual entertainment beyond sports viewing.

Mozzarella sticks stand out for their large size and crispy texture. Pizzas come in options like vegan and sausage-topped, paired with classic sides like Caesar salad and mac & cheese.

Skillet cookie stands out with its warm, gooey texture and rich flavor. It often comes as a sweet finish after meals and pairs well with other dishes like wings and pizzas.

People are saying

"The food here is unique, delicious, and top-notch."

"The staff here are gems, always attentive and helpful."

"The Italian food here has huge, crispy mozzarella sticks."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted on game days; plan accordingly.

2

A 20% service charge is automatically added to bills on game days.

3

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

09
D'Amato's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with old-school charm and narrow aisles creates a cozy but sometimes crowded atmosphere. Friendly staff and great tunes add to the inviting vibe, while a covered outdoor patio offers extra seating for a quick bite.

Cannolis stand out with authentic flavor and texture. The menu features eggplant parmesan sandwich and prosciutto and burrata sub with arugula, alongside fresh sourdough, focaccia, and amaretti cookies.

Italian cookies stand out with amaretti, lemon ricotta, and butter cookies featuring chocolate and caramel. These cookies offer a fresh, delicious taste that pairs well with pastries and breads.

People are saying

"This bread is the best sandwich bread I've ever had."

"The Italian food, especially the cannoli, is really good."

"I loved the cookies; they melted in my mouth."

Good to know

1

D'Amato's Bakery only accepts cash payments.

2

The bakery has limited seating inside but offers outdoor seating with tables.

3

Expect longer wait times during peak hours due to a small kitchen.

10
Daeji Dough Company image 1

Modern, cozy space with a minimalist Korean-inspired vibe and thoughtful design creates a calm atmosphere. Large windows bring in natural sunlight, and an open kitchen adds a dynamic touch. The bakery draws a crowd with its unique Korean pastries and creative flavors.

Fresh, large enough to share, and varied focaccias stand out here, including Korean BBQ, Kimchi, and dill pickle flavors. The focaccias pair well with unique items like the black sesame iced matcha.

Miso cornbread cookie shows up with a dry texture and a heavy miso flavor. It tastes plain and could use additions like candied ginger or dried fruit to boost its flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the matcha was top notch and tasted authentic."

"Their focaccia is fresh and large enough to share."

"The miso cookie was good."

Good to know

1

The bakery sells out of popular pastries early, so arrive early.

2

Expect a short wait for coffee as they make syrups in-house.

3

Alternative milks are available at no extra charge.

11
GoodTimes Brewery + Kitchen image 1

Massive bar and large open space with oak detailing create an inviting setting. Atmosphere feels warm and friendly with brewing equipment visible, adding to the vibe. Multiple TVs and games make it a chill spot for groups and events.

Chicken Alfredo stands out with rich, creamy sauce and tender chicken. Pizzas like the truffle pesto mushroom and pesto pizza come loaded with cheese and bold flavors. Pasta options include Cajun and Fettuccine Alfredo, both adaptable for vegetarian preferences.

Skillet chocolate chip cookie serves warm and tastes like homemade. The cookie skillet stands out as a popular dessert choice.

People are saying

"The German and Czech style beers here are some of the best I've had."

"The chicken alfredo and Cajun pasta here are so good."

"You have to try the cookie skillet; it's warm and delicious."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

3

On Mondays, the BYO pizza is half off.

12
Butcher and the Bear image 1

Steakhouse offers a dark intimate atmosphere with sophisticated, elegant vibe and beautiful decor. Live singer performances add to the swanky bar area ambiance. High-quality steaks and expertly crafted cocktails define the experience.

Mezze rigatoni pasta stands out with rich flavors, paired well with a fresh butternut squash salad. The Wagyu cheek pasta offers a tender, deeply cooked taste that feels crafted with care.

Wagyu tallow features in the chocolate chip cookies, creating a rich and unique flavor. Cookies come with vanilla-infused milk or vanilla ice cream, adding a creamy touch to the dessert.

People are saying

"The steak here is cooked perfectly and full of flavor."

"The Italian food here is cooked to perfection."

"You have to try the Wagyu tallow chocolate chip cookies."

Good to know

1

Expect a 15-20 minute wait for a table on Saturday nights.

2

Happy Hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers; don't miss it.

3

The 'Girl Dinner' special on Sundays includes two martinis and caviar fries for $29.

13
Del Sur Bakery image 1

Small, beautifully curated bakery with cozy ambiance and thoughtful floral arrangements. Offers unique Filipino-inspired pastries alongside coffee, teas, and specialty items. Lines form early due to highly sought-after, photogenic treats and a warm, inviting vibe.

Light and fluffy focaccia stands out with its sweet and savory balance. Rice croissant and seasonal focaccia with prosciutto and peaches add variety to the Italian pastries offered.

Ube oatmeal cookies offer a unique flavor with a perfect texture and balanced saltiness. The Ube Oatmeal cream pie evokes nostalgic childhood snacks but with an elevated twist.

People are saying

"The pastries here are so creative and delicious."

"The focaccia here is sweet, savory, and exceptional."

"The Ube oatmeal cookie is delicious and has a perfect texture."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to avoid long lines, especially on weekends.

2

There is no seating available; all orders are to go.

3

Pastries are priced around $10 each, with some items costing over $8.

14
New Paradise Bakery image 1

Old school Italian bakery with a 21st century vibe offers authentic Italian goods and top quality ingredients. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting with a clean, modern layout and beautifully decorated exterior. Known for outstanding gelato and pastries, it attracts those seeking genuine flavors.

Cannoli stand out with freshly filled shells that stay crunchy and fillings that are creamy like Nutella, not pastry cream. The pistachio cream and gelato offer a rich, nutty flavor, while the focaccia is soft, pillowy, and buttery. Tiramisu and pistachio tarts also impress with balanced sweetness.

Pistachio cookies stand out for their flavor and quality. Italian-style cookies like biscotti and butter cookies come highly recommended alongside other pastries.

People are saying

"Their custom cakes are works of art, truly stunning."

"The Italian food here, especially the cannoli, is phenomenal and unbelievably good."

"The cannoli shells are crisp, rich, and delectable."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of authentic Italian baked goods and gelato.

2

Parking is easy and convenient near the bakery.

3

All baked goods are made fresh daily with high-quality ingredients.

15
Cafe L'Appetito image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with a true deli vibe and a dog-friendly outdoor patio offers a calm, family-friendly atmosphere. The place feels like a grocery store food court with an affordable menu focused on Italian sandwiches and coffee. It suits quick bites and casual meals rather than cozy dining.

Tiramisu stands out as an outstanding dessert here. The meatballs and marinara impress with rich flavor, while the tortellini salad and shell pasta offer tasty options. Traditional dishes like spaghetti and meatballs are not available.

Italian cookies come out perfect here, with a delicious taste that pairs well with coffee and gelato.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be excellent."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the gelato."

"I found the cookies to be perfect."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during lunch hours; arrive early for full service.

2

The cafe closes at 6:20 pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Affordable meals are available, typically around $10.

16
Kleinโ€™s Bakery & Cafe (LakeviewEast) image 1

Elevated home bakery with cozy atmosphere and vibrant urban vibe offers several seating options including outdoor space. The place suits both quiet work sessions and casual chats, featuring lovely music and a welcoming environment.

Lasagna stands out, especially the Venezuelan style and the Thursday special. Tiramisu offers a solid classic dessert option.

Custom branded logo cookies stand out for events and large orders. Cookies often impress with amazing taste and presentation, though alfajores have a crumbly texture that some may not prefer.

People are saying

"I loved their pastries; they were always delicious and fresh."

"These cookies were a huge hit and absolutely delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Limited seating is available, especially during busy times.

2

Expect a wait time during weekends due to high demand.

3

Prices for coffee and sandwiches can reach around $20.

17
Scafuri Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with Italian decor and a quiet, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of small cafes in Italy. Fresh ingredients support a wide selection of traditional pastries enjoyed in a simple, homey setting. Soft music adds to the warm, comforting vibe throughout visits.

Pesto chicken delivers great flavor. Desserts include pistachio amaretti, chocolate spice, and pignoli cookies, though they lean a bit sweet.

Italian cookies stand out with their freshness and variety, including a unique green avocado cookie. Cookies arrive in excellent condition and have a rich, sweet flavor that appeals to many.

People are saying

"The pastries and croissants at this bakery are light, flaky, and delicious."

"The Italian pastries, like sfogliatella and cannoli, were delicious."

"The Italian cookies here are amazing and a must-try."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay a premium for high-quality, fresh ingredients.

2

The bakery offers a variety of pastries, including King Cakes during Mardi Gras.

3

Bring cash, as some vendors may not accept cards.

18
Ferrara Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with a clean, inviting atmosphere and generations of family ownership. Offers exceptional cannoli and classic Italian pastries alongside a small, focused selection. Seating allows for a relaxed experience in a well-run, venerable space.

Marinara sauce stands out with a slightly sweet flavor that removes bitterness. Sandwiches come with flaky bread and excellent house-made meatballs. Desserts like cannoli and tiramisu are tasty and well-portionned.

Cookies here taste fresh and melt in your mouth. Chocolate chip cookies have a brown butter or toffee flavor with a hint of salt balancing the sweetness.

People are saying

"The service at this bakery is always friendly and prompt."

"These cookies are outstandingly fresh and delicious."

"The marinara sauce for the Italian food is rich and tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect a busy lunch crowd, especially on weekends.

2

Parking is limited; consider arriving early or using public transport.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is preferred for small purchases.

Discover more

Chicago, Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...