Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cookie and pie spots in Chicago

Made for those who refuse to choose between a cookie and a slice of pie when they can have both.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Loaf Lounge image 1
Loaf Lounge image 2
Loaf Lounge image 3
View all

Bright space combines classic bakery charm with a cute, trendy decor. Atmosphere shifts from laid-back and welcoming during weekdays to buzzing and crowded around late mornings. Seating options include comfortable tables and counters, with a small pleasant patio.

Chocolate chip cookies come loaded with extra chocolate chips and are served warm. The oatmeal cream cookie pie offers a chewy, crispy, and soft texture with rich flavor, while the chocolate crinkle cookie blends brownie-like richness with varied textures.

The oatmeal cream pie stands out as a favorite, often described as the best or nearly the best ever had. It appears regularly on the menu and draws repeat orders for its unique flavor and consistency.

People are saying

"I thought the breakfast sandwiches were the best I ever had."

"The oatmeal cream cookie pie is unreal, the best I've ever had."

"The oatmeal cream pie is unreal, the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 30 minutes during busy times.

2

There is a free parking lot adjacent to the location, with metered street parking available.

3

A 4% service charge is added to all bills without prior notice.

02
Give Me Some Sugah image 1

Cozy bakery with whimsical cookie jars and a homey atmosphere filled with the aroma of sweets. The vibe feels warm and neighborhood-focused, attracting locals who appreciate unique, high-quality baked goods. Variety and passion in baking stand out, making it a community gem.

An extensive assortment of cookies includes chocolate chip with walnuts, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, and a unique potato chip cookie. The potato chip cookies are moist, melt in your mouth, and stand out for their rich flavor and texture.

Sweet potato pie brings strong nostalgia and stands out as a favorite. The chicken pot pie impresses with rich flavor, while the key lime pie offers a perfectly balanced taste.

People are saying

"I found the caramel cake to be very good and rich."

"The potato chip cookies are strange and delicious."

"I thought the sweet potato pie was the best pie I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of unique baked goods with different flavors.

2

Prices are reasonable, making it easy to enjoy a treat without overspending.

3

The bakery is known for its fantastic customer service.

03
Verzênay Chicago image 1

French patisserie cafe offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with beautiful decor and artistic dessert designs. Light and airy space features lovely piano music and a small sitting area suited for casual meetups or relaxed business conversations. Seating is limited but the ambiance remains pleasant and inviting.

Shortbread cookies stand out with a pecan flavor and a homemade texture. Rugelach and chocolate chip cookies also feature, with the latter offering a perfect texture and a truly homemade taste.

Savory pies feature a butternut squash, ricotta cheese, and spinach combo that stands out. Sweet options include warm apple pie with crumble and rich French silk pie.

People are saying

"The pastries here are so flaky and delicious."

"I loved their homemade chocolate chip cookies with perfect texture."

"The apple almond pie was dense and delicious."

Good to know

1

Private tea events can be arranged for small groups or pairs.

2

Expect long queues on weekends, especially during brunch hours.

3

All food options are 100% halal, catering to dietary preferences.

04
Not Just Cookies Wholesale Bakery image 1

Wholesale bakery known for exceptional cookies and delicious pies with a strong local presence at farmer’s markets. Atmosphere reflects a committed black-owned business with a focus on quality and community. Popular items sell out quickly, showing consistent demand and appreciation.

Butter cookies sell out before noon every week, showing their popularity. The turtle cookie has layers of texture with a crisp outer shell and a soft, chewy core. The oatmeal chocolate chip and Snickerdoodle cookies stand out as favorites.

Sweet potato pie stands out with a flavor that recalls homemade recipes. Peach cobbler also features as a popular choice, both offering a delicious, nostalgic taste.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I ever had."

"I loved their peach cobbler and sweet potato pie."

"This gluten-free vegan chocolate chip cookie is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

NJC is at the Daley Plaza farmer’s market every Thursday.

2

During winter, NJC may be found in the pedway.

3

The bakery offers easy online ordering for convenience.

05
The Drip Bakery By Chef Ced image 1

Bright, inviting bakery with a beautiful setup and diverse desserts like cheesecakes and peach cobbler pound cake. Energy feels warm and community-oriented, with a focus on Black-owned local business pride. Customers often seek out specialty cakes and cupcakes known for unique flavors and quality.

Butter cookies have a rich, nostalgic flavor that stands out. Pecan lunchroom cookies come highly recommended by Chef Ced and are popular enough to be eaten quickly.

Variety includes sweet potato pie, peach cobbler cheesecake, and key lime pound cake. Sweet potato pie is served warm and tastes good.

People are saying

"I loved the strawberry crunch pound cake; it was so good."

"Chef Ced helped me get the pecan cookies."

"I settled on a slice of sweet potato pie that they warmed up for me."

Good to know

1

The Oreo drip cake costs $80.

2

The bakery is black owned and local.

3

The owner is not always open at the specified times.

06
Le French Patisserie image 1

Elegant bakery with European decor and marble interiors creates a bright, luxurious atmosphere. Outdoor patio offers a quiet escape with comfortable seating and soft music. Pastries and desserts stand out as artfully crafted and authentic.

Warm, buttery, and tender describes the pistachio strawberry cookie. The pistachio cookie is not overly sweet and pairs well with other pastries and ice cream.

Spinach pie and feta pie stand out with flaky dough and creamy, tangy filling. Greek pies get heated in a microwave, which affects texture but flavors stay authentic.

People are saying

"I thought the desserts were awesome and yummy."

"The pistachio strawberry cookie was warm, buttery, and tender."

"You have to try the spinach pie and bougatsa; they're genuinely authentic."

Good to know

1

Parking costs $21 at Navy Pier, where the bakery is located.

2

Cash payments may offer discounts compared to credit card transactions.

3

The bakery often runs out of popular pastries early in the day.

07
Pie, Pie My Darling image 1

Bakery space combines cozy vibes with a grab-and-go setup and a perfect aesthetic. Vegan cakes and sweets taste fresh and traditional, impressing even non-vegan palates. Pricing leans toward the higher side but matches the exceptional quality of baked goods.

Soft and flavorful cookies stand out here, especially the Chocolate Chip Cookie and NutterButter slices. A rotating menu offers a variety of cookie options alongside cakes and cupcakes.

Oatmeal cream pies stand out as decadent and nostalgic treats. The apple pie ranks highest among the pies ordered, while the cookies and cream cake slice offers a delicious twist.

People are saying

"These dairy-free cakes are the best I've ever tasted."

"These desserts are insanely delicious and blew me away."

"I thought the vegan sweet treats and cakes were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Everything at the bakery is vegan, making it suitable for those with dairy or egg allergies.

2

The bakery offers a rotating menu of cake flavors, cupcakes, and cookies each month.

3

Pre-ordering is recommended to secure your favorite items, as they can sell out quickly.

08
Let's Eat To Live image 1

Restaurant offers a beautiful interior with amazing artwork and comfortable seating. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with calm music enhancing a peaceful vibe. Dining area stays clean and inviting, creating a friendly and peaceful environment.

Chocolate chip and peanut butter cookies offer a tender texture and well-seasoned flavor. These cookies complement hearty dishes like lamb chops and fried chicken.

Bean pies stand out with their rich flavor and are a popular choice here. They pair well with other items like Navy Bean Soup for a hearty meal.

People are saying

"The food here is so delicious, especially the mac n cheese."

"The chocolate chip cookie was tender and perfectly seasoned."

"You have to try the bean pie; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Street parking is widely available near the restaurant.

2

The restaurant is closed on Mondays.

3

They offer daily specials that change regularly.

09
Letizia's Natural Bakery image 1

Rustic bakery with cozy Italian vibe and wood-heavy interior offers a calm, quiet atmosphere ideal for breakfast or reading. Back and front patios provide garden seating and a peaceful oasis, especially in warmer months. The space feels inclusive and comfortable, blending old-school charm with inviting outdoor areas.

Cookies come freshly made in house with options like thick chocolate chip loaded with chips and sugar cookies. Lemon cookies and jam cookies also appear among the varied pastry selection.

Mini pies stand out with their tasty crust and enjoyable size. Cherry pie has a gluey pastry and a bland filling, which affects its overall appeal.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the excellent coffee here."

"I loved the thick chocolate chip cookie with lots of chips."

"I thought the mini pie was to die for."

Good to know

1

The patio is open from spring through early fall.

2

Street parking is convenient when available.

3

There is ample seating available for customers.

10
Chicago Sweet Connection image 1

Bakery offers Greek sweets, wide variety, and exceptional cakes with a strong baked goods aroma upon entry. It attracts those seeking European-style desserts like Red Velvet and tres leches cakes. The atmosphere is straightforward with an active street setting outside.

Greek cookies and a wide variety of butter cookies stand out among the sweet treats. Options include coffee cakes in many flavors and assorted cakes in all shapes and flavors.

Cheese pies and spinach pies stand out among the variety of pies offered. The bakery also features banana creme pies alongside cakes and cookies.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful, moist, and delicious."

"I loved the great variety of cakes and cookies they offered."

"I found their banana creme pies to be good."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of cakes, pastries, and cookies.

2

Prices for baked goods are generally low and reasonable.

3

No overnight parking is available near the bakery.

11
Del Sur Bakery image 1

Small, beautifully curated bakery with cozy ambiance and thoughtful floral arrangements. Offers unique Filipino-inspired pastries alongside coffee, teas, and specialty items. Lines form early due to highly sought-after, photogenic treats and a warm, inviting vibe.

Ube oatmeal cookies offer a unique flavor with a perfect texture and balanced saltiness. The Ube Oatmeal cream pie evokes nostalgic childhood snacks but with an elevated twist.

Ube matcha and ube oatmeal cream pie stand out with rich, hearty centers. The seasonal hand pie offers a crispy, savory bite filled with elote, while the turon Danish and handmade pork pie add unique flavors to the selection.

People are saying

"The pastries here are so creative and delicious."

"The ube oatmeal cream pie had a hearty and satisfying center."

"The Ube oatmeal cookie is delicious and has a perfect texture."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to avoid long lines, especially on weekends.

2

There is no seating available; all orders are to go.

3

Pastries are priced around $10 each, with some items costing over $8.

12
Bake image 1
Bakery

Space resembles a quiet vintage eccentric bookstore with colorful, fun decor and sweet gift options. Atmosphere feels dreamy and charming, inviting relaxation and lingering. Pastries sell out early, drawing a crowd that values high-quality baked goods and a cozy vibe.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their exceptional salt balance and crispy texture. Cookies taste homemade and are perfectly baked through, making them a favorite alongside cookie cream pies.

Cookie cream pies stand out as the must-get items here. The oatmeal pie is large with a light vanilla scent but has a raw-ish, eggy taste and lacks strong flavor.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and so delicious."

"I thought their cookies tasted homemade and were perfectly baked."

"I highly recommend the oatmeal pie."

Good to know

1

Bake is not open on Mondays or Tuesdays.

2

Arrive before 10 a.m. on weekends for the best selection.

3

Things tend to sell out by late morning.

13
Sweet Mandy B's Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an authentic interior and a relaxed atmosphere that feels like home. Known for famous cupcakes and a varied selection including vegan options, it draws families and casual visitors alike. The space is smaller and less trendy, focusing on simple, honest baked goods.

Softness stands out in the cookies here, with options like confetti cookies, sugar cookies, and a gluten-free cookie that impress. Cookies come in large sizes and include flavors like lemon raspberry and snickerdoodle.

Key lime pie has a very minimal lime flavor and tastes extremely sweet. The recipe does not deliver an authentic key lime pie experience and the price is relatively high for the quality.

People are saying

"I thought the devil's food cake was the best cake I ever had."

"I found the key lime pie to be amazing."

"I thought the gluten-free cookie here was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Prices for baked goods are not clearly marked, so ask before ordering.

3

The bakery is open seven days a week for your convenience.

14
Klein’s Bakery & Cafe (LakeviewEast) image 1

Elevated home bakery with cozy atmosphere and vibrant urban vibe offers several seating options including outdoor space. The place suits both quiet work sessions and casual chats, featuring lovely music and a welcoming environment.

Custom branded logo cookies stand out for events and large orders. Cookies often impress with amazing taste and presentation, though alfajores have a crumbly texture that some may not prefer.

Apple pie has a strong, well-loved flavor. Pumpkin pie offers a consistent texture and is popular at gatherings. The pecan pie has an off taste and is less favored.

People are saying

"I loved their pastries; they were always delicious and fresh."

"These cookies were a huge hit and absolutely delicious."

"I loved the flavoring and consistency of their pumpkin pie."

Good to know

1

Limited seating is available, especially during busy times.

2

Expect a wait time during weekends due to high demand.

3

Prices for coffee and sandwiches can reach around $20.

Discover more

Chicago, Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...