Small joint serves incredible New York style pizza with a homey atmosphere that welcomes locals and dog walkers. Limited seating and outdoor tables create a lively, casual vibe. Known for excellent crust and high-quality ingredients, it draws fans for special occasions.
Incredible New York style pizza with a simple, classic approach. Known for serving some of the best NY style pizza in the city, it draws fans who order multiple pies for special occasions.
"This East Coast-style pizza is the best I've had in Chicago."
"The sausage here has a perfect crust with a good chew."
"I believed this New York style pizza was some of the best in Chicago."
Good to know
Parking is best done by parking right in front; avoid the lot next door.
Order early on Fridays as they can get busy.
The restaurant often sells out on busy nights.
Cozy spot serves authentic New York style pizza with a unique taste. Bright, clean space offers a family-friendly vibe and chill neighborhood feel. Friendly staff and Serie A games on TV create a welcoming atmosphere for all.
Offers legit New York style pizza with a unique taste. Recognized for great quality and awarded Best New York Pizza in Chicago by Foxcito Peña.
Good to know
Lusha Pizza is family-owned and offers authentic Italian pizza.
The pizza is a bit more expensive than competitors.
Expect a clean environment with limited seating available.
Urban train station lobby offers a minimalist vibe with a four-item menu focused on cheese pizza slices. Pizza boasts a thin, crisp crust and balanced sauce and cheese, capturing true New York style with foldable texture. Perfect for commuters seeking quick, easy bites.
Slices feature a classic thin crust with a foldable texture. Toppings balance well with the tangy tomato sauce and melty cheese typical of New York style.
Good to know
The place specializes in pizza by the slice, with a minimal four-item menu.
It's conveniently located inside the 18th Street Station for commuters.
The pizza is easy to eat on the go, perfect for a quick lunch.
Cozy spot with a family-owned warmth and lively Chicago vibe serves authentic New York style pizza with a classic thin crust and rich sauce. Unique pizza options and a refined ambiance make it stand out from typical pizzerias.
Delicious slices capture the essence of New York style pizza with a classic thin crust and balanced toppings. This spot stands out as a favorite for those seeking authentic NY style pizza.
Good to know
Order by the slice is limited.
The pizza is reasonably priced.
Zaza’s offers a variety of pizza styles.
Small pizzeria offers authentic New York style pizza with melt-in-your-mouth texture. Cozy brick oven setting fits solo diners or small groups. Weekend nights bring chaotic energy with police presence adding security but a slightly sketchy feel.
Authentic New York style pizza stands out with its melt-in-your-mouth texture and delicious flavor. It offers a quality experience that rivals pizzas from New York itself.
Good to know
Parking is not available nearby, so consider alternative transport options.
Pizza slices are available for $4.50 each, which is a good deal.
The pizzeria is open late, making it a great option for night owls.
Small spot with authentic New York-style pizza offers hot, thin crust slices that fold perfectly. Casual, family-friendly vibe makes it welcoming and chill. Affordable prices and classic old-school charm complete the intimate, no-frills space with some outdoor seating.
Pizza arrives hot with a thin crust and classic foldable slices. It captures the authentic New York style with a balance of sauce and cheese that stands out in Chicago.
Good to know
Gigio's Pizzeria opens late until 2am for late-night bites.
Pizza by the slice is available for quick meals.
They charge extra for card payments without prior notice.
Small spot offers authentic NY slices with a crisp crust and classic toppings. Casual vibe and quiet atmosphere make it great for relaxed meals. Steady takeout flow adds to its neighborhood feel.
Slices come with a nice crisp crust and classic New York style toppings. The shop focuses on serving authentic NY pizza by the slice in a small setting.
Good to know
A slice of pizza costs between $5 and $6.
Pazza Pizza is not a dine-in place; it's mainly for takeout.
The shop has limited indoor seating and is more of a to-go place.
Small, bright spot with covered outdoor seating offers a cozy vibe. Enjoy classic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and truffle oil pepperoni. Regulars rave about best sandwiches and exceptional chicken Parmesan in a casual, bustling setting.
Slices come in classic New York style with a thin, foldable crust. The truffle oil pepperoni adds a unique twist to the traditional flavor.
Good to know
They accept cash, credit, and debit cards for payment.
The restaurant only offers takeout options with no indoor seating.
Expect busy lunch hours, which may lead to longer wait times.
Heated patio with fire pits offers a cozy spot for groups, kids, and dogs. Loud music from the DJ adds energy but hinders conversation. New York style pizza is served, with opinions varying on its authenticity.
Offers casual dining with a DJ playing music. Serves New York style pizza that some find delicious while others disagree on its authenticity.
Good to know
On Tuesdays and Wednesdays, they offer $1 wings.
Trivia night happens on Wednesdays with a fun atmosphere.
Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.
Rooftop space offers fantastic city views and a trendy tavern-style decor with nostalgic art. Thin crust slices deliver authentic New York style pizza with standout toppings like mushroom and leek. Atmosphere shifts from chill indoors to a loud day club with DJs on weekends.
Thin crust slices define the New York style pizza here, with toppings like mushroom and leek standing out. The pizza tastes authentic and delivers a perfect balance of flavors.
Good to know
Expect a 40-minute wait for a table during peak hours.
Only online orders for pickup are accepted; no dine-in or curbside service.
A QR code is required to order and pay upfront.