Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to West Town

Pizza

Made for those who treat pizza as a serious pursuit and have no patience for anything but a well-executed pie.

Based on 505 Opinions
+502
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Milly's Pizza In The Pan image 1
Milly's Pizza In The Pan image 2
Milly's Pizza In The Pan image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with cozy atmosphere and fun pizza kitsch on the walls. Seating is minimal, featuring one booth and a few barstools, emphasizing a carry-out focus. The vibe is welcoming and low key, attracting those who appreciate quality and a relaxed setting.

Pan pizza stands out with fresh, high-quality ingredients and consistent taste. Food industry professionals praise the freshness and flavor of the offerings.

Perfect crust and fresh ingredients define the pizza here. It consistently delivers a Chicago-style pan pizza experience that stands out for its quality and flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the deep dish pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I thought this pizza was the best in the city."

"The food's crust is soft, airy, and perfectly crispy."

Good to know

1

They only make a limited number of pizzas per day, which sell out quickly on weekends.

2

You have to order ahead of time.

3

Milly's Pizza In The Pan is a pick-up only place with no in-person ordering available.

02
Rosati's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers authentic atmosphere with a cool, welcoming vibe. It serves fresh, hot pizza by the slice with a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful sauce. The place stays open late, making it a reliable spot for late-night snacks.

Food comes out fresh and flavorful, made with care. It works well as a late night spot with consistently delicious dishes.

Pizza comes out fresh from the oven with good quality ingredients. Service is fast and accommodating, even for late night orders.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and tasty."

"It's a great late night spot for pizza by the slice."

"I thought this pizza was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The portions are generous and prices are fair.

2

Slices are available for quick grab-and-go meals.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

03
PIZZ'AMICI image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, cozy space with dim lighting and tiled floor decor creates an intimate setting. Loud atmosphere with obnoxious music and shouting makes conversation difficult. The place fills quickly, attracting a lively crowd that values thin crust pizza and a casual vibe.

Excellent pizza and a blown-away Caesar salad show the food quality here. The menu goes beyond pizza and sandwiches, offering a great dining experience with friendly service.

Thin crust pizza stands out with its perfectly crispy cracker crust and balanced sauce and toppings. The tavern-style pies feature cupped pepperoni, giardineria, and a drizzle of Mikeโ€™s Hot Honey, offering a unique flavor combination.

People are saying

"The pizza crust is ultra-thin and crispy."

"The Caesar Salad here is massive, fresh, and full of flavor."

"I found the food here to be really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant fills up quickly.

2

Expect long wait times without a reservation, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant is BYOB, but there's a $20 corkage fee.

04
Acerra Italian Kitchen & Bar image 1

Outdoor patio with greenery and fountain offers a charming, intimate vibe ideal for casual, family-friendly dining. Indoor seating places diners close to the loud, chaotic kitchen atmosphere. The overall setting balances relaxed energy with a lively, unpolished feel.

Food here is consistently excellent and authentic with a focus on Italian cuisine. Service matches the quality of the dishes, making the overall experience incredible and friendly.

Neapolitan style pizzas feature a great crust and artisanal flavors. The Diavola pizza stands out for its perfectly spicy and flavorful profile. Gluten free options are available for pizza and pasta.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the burrata bread bowl, is fresh and incredible."

"The food here is simply amazing and authentic."

"The pizza crust here is spot on and great."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers, including Burrata and Prosciutto.

2

The restaurant has a nice outdoor patio for dining.

3

Gluten-free options are available for both pizza and pasta.

05
Enoteca Roma Ristorante image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian restaurant with a hidden garden patio that offers dim lighting and spacious outdoor seating. Atmosphere is generally warm and quiet, with friendly staff enhancing the experience. The front patio provides a spot for sidewalk people watching.

Food tastes homemade and consistently excellent. Dishes like Gnocchi and ravioli stand out for their quality and flavor.

Roma pizza with gorgonzola stands out as a unique choice. The menu also features a focaccia pizza paired with a reasonably priced wine selection.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta and arancini, is fresh and flavorful."

"The food here is delicious and amazing."

"The pizza here has a wonderful bread to topping ratio."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a family-style dinner for parties of six or more at 8:30 PM.

2

The price for the Mangia experience is $282 for six people.

3

Ordering individually would cost about $220, allowing for more customization.

06
Cleos Bar and Grill image 1

European style sports bar offers multiple TVs showing different games and a soccer-focused atmosphere with friendly door staff. Outdoor space includes a cool back patio and firepit, creating a cozy vibe. Music plays continuously, enhancing the casual, home-like feel.

Food quality stays consistently high with every item on the menu. Late-night options stand out with bar food that matches high standards and pairs well with drinks.

Pepperoni pizza stands out with a fantastic taste. The pizza overall is excellent and often better than expected.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are great for watching live sports."

"The food here is delicious and flavorful."

"I thought the pizza here was surprisingly better than I expected."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3 to 6 PM with half-off drinks.

2

Bocce ball leagues are held from 6 PM to 11 PM, Monday through Thursday.

3

Bingo night takes place every Tuesday at 7 PM.

07
D'Amato's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with old-school charm and narrow aisles creates a cozy but sometimes crowded atmosphere. Friendly staff and great tunes add to the inviting vibe, while a covered outdoor patio offers extra seating for a quick bite.

Food features authentic American Italian dishes served in a quick takeout format. The offerings are consistently delicious and well-prepared.

Unique pizza stands out with a dairy-free pan crust and a sausage topping that recalls classic family recipes. The pizza pairs well with authentic crusty bread and desserts like eclairs and cannoli.

People are saying

"This bread is the best sandwich bread I've ever had."

"I found the food here to be awesome and fresh."

"I highly recommend the subs here; they're great."

Good to know

1

D'Amato's Bakery only accepts cash payments.

2

The bakery has limited seating inside but offers outdoor seating with tables.

3

Expect longer wait times during peak hours due to a small kitchen.

08
Danteโ€™s Tavern image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy bar with small TVs showing horror movies and a punk music playlist creates a relaxed vibe. Frequented by service industry workers and known for thin crust pizza and strong margaritas, it offers a casual, friendly atmosphere with occasional events like karaoke and pub quizzes.

Food here ranges from incredible to just okay. Many dishes come with delicious flavors that pair well with drinks in a friendly setting.

Large slices with Vegas-style pizza stand out here. The pepperoni on tavern style pizza is notable, and pizza deals offer good value. The pizza pairs well with wine and feeds groups comfortably.

People are saying

"I waited forever at the bar for a menu and water."

"I really enjoyed the pizza here; it was extremely good."

"I thought the food here was really good."

Good to know

1

Danteโ€™s Tavern hosts a pop-up karaoke event on Saturdays.

2

The comedy show happens every Thursday night.

3

Pizza is available in both vegan and meat options.

09
Fatpour Wicker Park: Ultimate Chicago Sports Bar image 1

Sports bar offers many TV screens and an open patio for watching games. Atmosphere is loud with music videos and great for sports hangouts. Crowd tends to be light, creating a relaxed vibe even during game days.

Food offers great flavors and nice portions at reasonable prices. Specials on food and drinks get quick attention from servers.

Pizza features a Music City Melter with Nashville hot fried chicken, sweet and spicy pickles, and a buttermilk ranch drizzle. Options include a BYO white sauce pizza and combos that serve multiple people with plenty of food under $20.

People are saying

"I'd come back for the white sauce pizza."

"It's a great spot to watch live sports on plenty of TVs."

"I'd come back for their white sauce pizza."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday through Friday from 5 PM to 7 PM.

2

Trivia night is on Mondays, and bingo is on Tuesdays.

3

Draft beers are $5 on Monday nights.

10
Wolf & Company image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant combines upscale vibe with neighborhood coziness in a gorgeous space featuring a patio right off a popular trail. It offers creative craft cocktails praised for balance and presentation. The venue includes a market and butcher shop, adding a unique grocery element to the dining experience.

Food comes with consistently great service and a pleasant atmosphere. Every visit delivers solid quality dishes that suit a casual date night.

Homemade pillowy crust stands out and can convert crust skeptics. Pizzas like the Full Moon and 606 offer rich, next-level flavors that pair well with other dishes like burgers and pasta.

People are saying

"I found the burgers to be incredibly tasty and flavorful."

"The burgers here have tremendous flavor and are worth the extra charge."

"You have to try the pizza; the spicy sausage has a nice kick."

Good to know

1

The establishment has had issues with food safety, including unrefrigerated ingredients.

2

Dishes were washed in the hand washing sink, raising health concerns.

3

The bathroom is located far from the patio, which may be inconvenient.

11
Professor Pizza Slice & Pie - West Town image 1

Rooftop space offers fantastic city views and a trendy tavern-style decor filled with nostalgic art and family photos. Atmosphere shifts from chill and cozy indoors to a loud, day club vibe with DJs on weekends. The place attracts lively crowds enjoying excellent music and spacious seating.

Food features a grandma style deluxe pepperoni that stands out with a unique twist. Dishes consistently deliver fantastic flavor and a distinct approach that feels fresh and satisfying.

Chicago tavern-style and Grandma style pepperoni pizzas stand out with unique flavors and high quality. Multiple pizzas offer distinct tastes, all prepared and delivered with care.

People are saying

"The pizza here is insanely delicious with fresh, flavorful toppings."

"The city views from the rooftop patio are fantastic."

"The pizza here is fantastic, especially the New York style."

Good to know

1

Expect a 40-minute wait for a table during peak hours.

2

Only online orders for pickup are accepted; no dine-in or curbside service.

3

A QR code is required to order and pay upfront.

12
Naty's Pizza #2 image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-run corner pizza joint with a big menu and good prices offers Chicago-style and tavern-style pizza in a clean, no-frills setting. Atmosphere feels like a generic video game building, quiet and not busy. Known for solid wings and a comfortable, casual vibe.

Food here is consistently tasty and really good. The spot feels like a family-run corner joint that serves solid meals.

Offers Chicago-style pizza with options like deep dish and thin crust Supreme. Pizza cooks perfectly with fast service and a big menu at good prices.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be really great."

"I thought this pizza was the best in the city."

"I experienced quick and courteous delivery."

Good to know

1

Naty's Pizza #2 has a big menu with a variety of options.

2

The restaurant is family-owned and operated, creating a homey atmosphere.

3

The restaurant was clean from front to back during my visit.

13
Pizza Hut image 1
Pizza delivery

Pizza delivery spot offers fresh, well-made pizza with a balanced sauce and gooey cheese that reheats well. Service and food quality can be inconsistent, but some locations present pizza and breadsticks better than others. Prices tend to be on the expensive side with large portion sizes.

Food comes out fresh and made upon request with little wait time, usually under 15 minutes. Staff work quickly and accurately to prepare orders, keeping the experience smooth and reliable.

Large stuffed crust pepperoni pizza comes out fresh and balanced, not greasy or dry. Staff work hard to prepare pizzas quickly and correctly, delivering crispy edges and great presentation.

People are saying

"The food here is always delicious and fresh."

"Fernando's attentiveness and care made ordering pizza a breeze."

"The delivery food was surprisingly good and tasty."

Good to know

1

Delivery typically takes around 40 minutes, which may be longer than expected.

2

Online specials are available, so check the website before ordering.

3

Prices for pizzas can be on the higher side, with two cheese pizzas costing $47.

14
Pie-Eyed Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with vintage, gothic-like chill vibe and metal posters decorating the interior. Atmosphere stays laid-back and consistent, attracting a crowd that appreciates late-night hours and tavern-style pizza.

Exceptional pizza stands out with consistently delicious flavors. Staff create a pleasant atmosphere while food warms, making it a solid spot for comfort food.

Tavern-style pizza comes with a crunchy crust and soft dough, baked to perfection. Sausage and mushroom pizzas offer generous portions and balanced sauce, while the Veggie Gourmet stands out as a solid veggie option. Homemade ranch pairs well with the pies.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was delicious and nicely portioned."

"The pizza delivery here is amazing; I've never had better mozzarella sticks."

"I thought the food, especially the pizza, was delicious."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria is open late, until around 4 or 5 in the morning.

2

Pizza costs $6 per slice for plain cheese.

3

Parking can be difficult when picking up food.

15
The Beetle Bar and Grill image 1

Dark space with a large bar dominates the room, creating a dive bar vibe. Music from a live DJ sets a laid-back atmosphere that shifts from quiet to lively on weekends. Regulars gather around the pool table and fireplace, making it a casual spot for drinks and socializing.

Steak sandwiches stand out as a satisfying option alongside hard kombucha and bar food. The menu offers excellent, delicious dishes that pair well with a glass of red wine.

Wild mushroom pizza with sausage stands out with great flavor and perfect crispiness. The menu includes vegetarian options like Wild Shroom Pizza and Mushroom Bahn Mi, plus kid-friendly pizzas.

People are saying

"It's a great neighborhood bar with a casual, friendly vibe."

"I found the food here to be excellent."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and outstanding."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday from 4-6 PM with draft beer specials.

2

Trivia night is hosted every Monday evening.

3

The kitchen stays open until 1 AM for late-night dining.

Discover more

West Town, Chicago

Area guide
Loading Map...