Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Indiana

Thrift Stores

Made for those who find more value in a pre-loved furniture piece than anything sitting on a showroom floor.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Market Vintage image 1
Market Vintage image 2
Market Vintage image 3
View all
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers an authentic, well-curated selection of clothes, home goods, and art with frequent stock updates. The space feels adorable and welcoming, with fun sidewalk displays and a cozy fitting room. Visitors navigate overstuffed racks in a charming, nostalgic atmosphere.

An extensive range of vintage furniture fills the space, perfectly curated alongside housewares and home decor. Pieces blend style and history, offering unique options for furnishing.

A wide variety of vintage clothing and home goods fills the shelves, all carefully curated for unique finds. The shop offers charming treasures perfect for gifts, home decor, or updating your wardrobe.

People are saying

"I found so many cute vintage clothes and home decor treasures here."

"The owner here is the sweetest gem, making the thrift store feel like home."

"I found the furniture and other curated pieces to be extensive."

Good to know

1

Market Vintage showcases a wide selection of vintage clothing, home goods, and unique decor.

2

The stock changes frequently, ensuring new treasures are available with each visit.

3

Items are reasonably priced, but some vintage clothing can be on the pricier side.

02
Logan Village Mall image 1

Fake village facades and a mid-century modern room with vintage furniture create a charming, creative layout. Shops offer a blend of vintage and mass-produced items, including handmade and repurposed goods. The atmosphere invites exploration with unique finds and niche boutiques under one roof.

Several pieces showcase 1960s furniture with a neat style. Handmade items and repurposed, refinished furniture fill the room alongside vintage tech.

Rooms hold lots of vintage furniture and vintage tech. Many booths feature repop vintage-looking signs and items lean more vintage than antique.

People are saying

"This thrift store has unique vintage furniture and retro items."

"This furniture store has unique, neat vintage and retro items."

"I found so much cool stuff, especially the unique vintage items."

Good to know

1

The mall features a mix of boutiques and antique shops under one roof.

2

Expect to find unique handmade items and repurposed furniture.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly on weekends.

03
Audrey's Place Thrift Store image 1

Space fills with vintage pieces, eclectic collections, and architectural salvage arranged in lovely vignette settings. Atmosphere feels cool and inviting, with a clean and organized layout. Pricing stays reasonable, attracting those seeking diverse and interesting furniture finds.

Furniture here is diverse and nice, with options suitable for replacing old pieces. Staff help with loading purchases into cars, making the buying process easy.

Shelves hold a wide range of vintage pieces, antiques, and architectural salvage. The store stays clean and organized, making it easy to browse through eclectic collections and some new products.

People are saying

"I found the most interesting items and vintage pieces here."

"The staff at this Furniture Store were so helpful and patient."

"This thrift store is brimming with awesome vintage finds and antiques."

Good to know

1

Parking is conveniently located in the rear, south of the store.

2

Prices are generally affordable, with some items bundled for discounts.

3

The store offers a wide variety of items, including antiques and vintage products.

04
Audrey's Place Furniture image 1

Small, family-owned furniture store offers unique vintage pieces and quality new furniture at affordable prices. The space feels like a maze of rooms filled with carefully curated collections, inviting slow browsing. Delivery is generally timely, and financing options are straightforward.

Offers a mix of new and gently used vintage furniture with reasonable prices compared to big stores. Staff provides knowledgeable and friendly service about furniture details and origins.

Loads of vintage furniture and gently used items fill the first building. The thrift store offers a variety of antiquities that make every visit a chance to find something unique.

People are saying

"I loved the beautiful, great quality furniture here."

"The delivery was prompt, friendly, and efficient."

"I always find treasures at this thrift store; it's amazing what I find."

Good to know

1

Financing options are easy to understand and access.

2

Quality furniture is available at affordable prices.

3

Delivery process is fast and efficient.

05
etc...Thrift Store image 1
Thrift store

Space feels peaceful and clean, with items well-organized by size and color. Selection includes clothing, furniture, and home decor, all offered at reasonable prices. Donations drop off easily through a back door, supporting a local school.

Offers a nice selection of second-hand furniture and lamps at great value prices. Includes various styles across all furniture categories alongside home decor and small appliances.

Offers a well-organized and clean space with reasonable prices on used items. Finds include books, clothes, games, craft supplies, and shoes, all in good quality.

People are saying

"This thrift store is so clean and organized."

"I found this furniture store had a nice selection and great value."

"I loved finding personal items and gifts for others."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide range of clothing, furniture, and home decor.

2

Clothes are organized by size and color for easy browsing.

3

Prices are very reasonable, with many items being quite cheap.

06
Amanda's Exchange image 1
Consignment shop

Large retail space divides women's clothing and home decor, creating a well-organized and spacious environment. Atmosphere feels fun and clean, with a curated selection of high-quality, designer resale items. Pricing trends toward the higher side, reflecting the premium quality and variety available.

A wide selection of consigned furniture fills one side of the store, paired with household items and home decor. Quality pieces include household furniture alongside other items like rugs and bags.

Offers a beautiful selection of vintage and modern style items including clothing, accessories, and home decor. Features incredible bargains on designer pieces that make browsing rewarding.

People are saying

"I found so many unique and beautiful women's clothing pieces here."

"I found a wide selection of furniture and household items here."

"The Thrift Store employees are so helpful and welcoming."

Good to know

1

Parking at Amanda's Exchange is easy, but it can fill up quickly.

2

The selection includes high-quality items in excellent used condition.

3

Clothes are marked down every 30 days, offering great deals.

07
Hearts In Motion Resale Shoppe image 1

Homely atmosphere blends with organized racks and a mix of new and vintage items. Prices range from very good bargains to some retail-priced goods. Dedicated staff support a charitable cause while offering a wide selection including formalwear and household goods.

Most furniture for sale is pretty old. The front area features newer and vintage kitchen dishes, household appliances, linens, furniture, and decor items. No assistance is available for moving furniture.

Offers a mix of new and vintage kitchen dishes, household appliances, linens, furniture, and decor. Includes many items sold at retail price, so it blends thrift with new merchandise.

People are saying

"This thrift store is organized and has great prices."

"I found nice new items and helpful workers at this Furniture Store."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally very good, with many items at bargain rates.

2

Everything is organized and easy to find, making shopping efficient.

3

The selection of formalwear is ample, often with discounts available.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...