Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indiana

Unique ice cream

Made for those who find standard flavors uninspired and actively hunt for unconventional, experimental frozen treats.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Danny's Mexican Ice Cream image 1
Danny's Mexican Ice Cream image 2
Danny's Mexican Ice Cream image 3
View all

Cute little ice cream shop offers unique Mexican flavors like corn and chili mango with generous portions and free samples for tasting. Cozy, welcoming atmosphere features festive music and a pet-friendly vibe. Customers find the ice cream thick, creamy, and unlike anything else around.

Creamy and thick texture shows high quality. Offers unique Mexican flavors like corn and tequila. Sampling before choosing lets you try many culturally unique options.

Unique flavors stand out with Mexican-inspired tastes not found elsewhere. The selection includes creative options alongside some familiar ones kids enjoy.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are amazing and unique."

"The ice cream has really unique flavors you won't find anywhere else."

"I consider this my favorite ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

Danny's Mexican Ice Cream offers unique flavors not found elsewhere.

2

The shop is pet friendly, allowing you to bring your furry friends.

3

Portions are generous, with two big scoops priced at $5.00.

02
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Small shop with cozy atmosphere and family-friendly vibe offers unique homemade ice cream flavors including dairy-free options. Customers enjoy voting on new flavors and sitting inside or outside on benches. The space feels welcoming and lively, perfect for casual visits.

Homemade ice cream offers rich, smooth, and perfectly sweet flavors. Unique options like cornbread, carrot cake, and peanut butter stand out, along with the rainbow chip featuring ground and freeze-dried Skittles for a soft crunch.

Small, cozy shop offers a wide selection of unique flavors like corn bread. These distinctive choices stand out from typical ice cream options.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here has unique, delicious flavors like cornbread."

"This Local Spot's ice cream is rich, creamy, and bursting with imaginative, balanced flavors."

"You have to try the unique cornbread flavor; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

All ice cream is made in store daily for freshness.

2

They offer a wide variety of ice cream options, including dairy-free choices.

3

New and unique flavors are regularly introduced.

03
Eiffel Waffle Creamery image 1

Ice cream shop with in-house made ice cream using natural ingredients and unique flavors creates a fun and clean atmosphere with ample seating. Fresh waffles complement the creamy ice cream, offering a balanced and enjoyable treat. The space feels adorable and elegant, inviting relaxed enjoyment.

Ice cream comes made from scratch daily using natural ingredients, resulting in a creamy and perfectly sweet texture. Unique flavors like Lotus (Biscoff) and Salted Caramel stand out for their taste and softness.

Unique flavors like Biscoff Lotus and Cookie Monster stand out. Fun options include mini pancake plates and bubble waffles with ice cream.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was awesome and creamy."

"I had the best coffee float, it was delicious."

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

All ice cream flavors are made in-house without artificial flavors or colors.

2

They make their ice cream from scratch in-house every day.

3

The establishment is very clean and well-maintained.

04
Howdy Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Bright, open space with fresh homemade ice cream and unique flavors creates a sweet, inviting atmosphere. Ample indoor and outdoor seating supports a lively, inclusive vibe with friendly, fun staff. Music plays softly, adding to the comforting, wholesome environment.

Homemade ice cream offers rich, delicious flavors like cookie dough and matcha sorbet. Staff provide exceptional service with a friendly, happy attitude, and prices are very reasonable.

Flavors stand out with Dr. Pepper Chocolate Chip, dragon tails, lychee, and ubeee among many unique options. The variety includes both classic and tempting, unusual tastes.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here is so good!"

"You'll find so many unique flavors here, like dragon tails and ube."

"They have tons of vegan options, especially coconut-based ones."

Good to know

1

You can sample any flavor and as many as you want.

2

They offer 3 small ice cream servings for $5, and you can get any ice cream you want with that.

3

Parking is available on the premises.

05
Ice Cream Cone image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with old school charm and family-run atmosphere offers unique Latin American flavors alongside traditional options. The space feels beautiful, clean, and quiet, creating a lovely setting for dates or small groups. Reasonable prices and great hours support a welcoming, relaxed vibe.

Extensive ice cream flavors include banana cream pie, Graham Central, and cookie monster. The ice cream tastes high quality and delicious with options like strawberry shortcake and protein shakes. Top notch service complements the family-run atmosphere.

Flavors combine Latin American flare with traditional ice cream styles. Unique options like rompope and mangonadas stand out for their authenticity and taste.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was amazing and delicious."

"The ice cream flavors here are unique, authentic, and delicious."

"The service here is excellent for Date Spots."

Good to know

1

The shop offers unique flavors like rompope and mangonadas.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality and variety offered.

3

Double scoops are available for those wanting more.

06
DeBrand Fine Chocolates image 1

Elegant chocolate shop offers a calm and welcoming atmosphere with a private sitting area featuring twinkling lights. The space feels clean and organized, inviting relaxation and indulgence in high-quality chocolates and coffee.

Ice cream features a smooth texture and bold vanilla bean flavor. Options include a chocolate dipped cone with rich bittersweet chocolate and a sundae blending rich ice cream, milk chocolate, and peanut butter.

Chocolate selections include unique flavors alongside classics. The Connoisseur selection offers distinct pieces. A private back room provides a special setting for events.

People are saying

"I thought the hot chocolate was the best I ever had."

"The ice cream here is excellent, especially with the raspberry sauce."

"Their hot chocolate is smooth, rich, and decadent."

Good to know

1

Reservations for the event space require a fee that acts as a credit for menu items.

2

DeBrand's store closes earlier on Thursdays but can accommodate later reservations.

3

The event space is suitable for hosting various gatherings like bridal showers and meetings.

07
Macizo Restaurant image 1

Cozy, minimalist space offers a homey, warm atmosphere with friendly, personable energy from owners. Casual, lived-in vibe contrasts with more upscale local spots. Bright, fruity cocktails and sangria complement exceptional Mexican dishes like tiradito and chorizo tacos.

Scoops of ice cream come with warm, moist desserts like pear pound cake and HIZO bread. Vanilla ice cream pairs with pistachios and pear bread for a sweet finish.

An incredible fusion of Peruvian and Mexican cuisine shapes the menu with original dishes. The coffee stands out as very unique and surprising.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and some of the best."

"Their homemade sourdough bread is fantastic and memorable."

"The mole enchiladas were delicious, with homey flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers a unique blend of Mexican and Peruvian cuisine.

3

Tamales are made in-house, showcasing a commitment to quality.

08
Mandy's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with bright colorful decor and kid artwork on walls creates a cheerful family vibe. Many unique flavors and friendly staff add to the welcoming atmosphere. Outdoor benches offer casual seating.

Unique flavors and absurdly delicious ice cream stand out here. Friendly staff provide phenomenal service alongside unbeatable shakes.

Bright and cheery atmosphere with unique and delicious flavors. Offers one-of-a-kind boba and a wide variety of distinctive sundaes and shakes.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."

"The staff here is so friendly and attentive to kids."

"I found the ice cream flavors here to be so unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

Mandy's Ice Cream has a wide variety of flavors to choose from.

2

Parking is easy at Mandy's Ice Cream.

3

They provide generous servings for the price.

09
Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Small dessert shop with a cozy, welcoming vibe and a lively, soda shop atmosphere. Offers a massive selection of homemade ice cream flavors with daily rotation and free samples. Attracts a wide range of ages, making it a popular spot for families and couples alike.

Ice cream here is made in-house with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, giving it a rich and creamy texture. The place offers a massive selection of flavors and the staff is consistently friendly and attentive.

Unique flavors stand out with award-winning and distinct tastes. Classic options get a twist, offering a wide variety that appeals to many.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best ice cream I had in town."

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

"I enjoyed the great coffee here."

Good to know

1

Sundae's offers free samples to encourage trying multiple flavors.

2

They rotate their flavors weekly, providing new options regularly.

3

The specialty sundaes are large enough for two people.

10
Baan Thai Bistro image 1
Thai restaurant

Quaint converted house offers a cozy atmosphere with beautifully decorated interiors and a spacious outdoor patio featuring solar lighting. The vibe encourages relaxed dining with friends and family in a clean, inviting space. Seating is somewhat cramped indoors, but outdoor options provide a pleasant alternative.

Coconut ice cream pairs with fried bananas for a rich, sweet dessert. Presentation is beautiful and adds to the experience.

Menu features unique dishes not found at every Thai spot. The Crab Rangoon offers a distinct taste unlike others.

People are saying

"The Thai food here is fantastic and authentic."

"The menu has unique dishes with flavors reminiscent of northern Thailand."

"I found the Thai food to be some of the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

They have half off appetizers from 4-6pm Monday-Friday.

2

I should have made a reservation before visiting due to limited seating.

3

They are closed on Sundays.

11
Melt N Dip image 1
Creperie

Creperie offers a modern decor with cozy seating including cuddle couches and comfy chairs. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy with a lounge-like area, outdoor patio, and a fireplace. Chocolate fountains and luxurious desserts create a distinctive indulgent vibe.

Creative gelato flavors like matcha, pistachio, and strawberry cheesecake stand out. Options include unique combos such as the Dubai chocolate crepe and brownie and ice cream pairings.

Wide variety of unique treats stands out here. Rich chocolate pairs with fresh fruit and distinctive toppings for a different dessert experience.

People are saying

"The chocolate here is heavenly good and delicious."

"The ice cream here is exceptionally good and delicious."

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Prices for desserts can be high; expect around $60 for three people.

3

Sliced strawberries cost $15, which is significantly higher than grocery prices.

12
Lick Ice Cream Indy image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop offers unique flavors with a creamy, rich texture and vegan options always available. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, with a focus on creative ice cream selections that stand out from typical offerings.

Brown butter cookie dough and Honey Butter Pecan stand out with smooth, buttery texture and crunchy, caramelized pecans. Waffle cones add a crispy, flavorful touch to the locally made ice cream.

Unique flavors like lavender lemon and sweet corn stand out. The selection includes creative options not found at other shops.

People are saying

"This ice cream is the best I've ever had, seriously yummy."

"I loved their unique flavors like lavender lemon and sweet corn."

"The dairy-free ice cream is so creamy and yummy."

Good to know

1

Lick Ice Cream Indy offers a flight of three flavors for tasting.

2

Vegan options are always available at Lick Ice Cream Indy.

3

Follow Lick Ice Cream Indy on social media for specials and seasonal flavors.

13
Kwality Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Sharp, modern ice cream shop with a welcoming atmosphere and no seating. Offers an amazing variety of authentic Indian flavors and lets customers sample any flavor. The vibe is comfortable and inviting despite some cleanliness issues.

Desi-flavored ice cream offers a unique twist with many interesting and new flavors. Staff lets you try any flavor, and the ice cream is stored properly with no freezer burn, ensuring great quality and taste.

Offers unique ice-cream flavors including Indian specialties alongside regular favorites. The variety stands out for its distinctive taste options.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff were super kind and helpful."

"The malai kulfi here is rich, authentic, and perfectly creamy."

"I loved the unique ice-cream flavors and Indian specialties they offered."

Good to know

1

Kwality Ice Cream offers a wide variety of flavors, including unique Indian specialties.

2

You can sample any flavor before making a choice.

3

Prices for ice cream cones range from $4 to $5.

14
Hi mango dessert image 1
Dessert restaurant

Floral-themed cafรฉ offers a clean, calm atmosphere with beautiful decorations and private patio-style seating. The space feels like a tropical oasis ideal for photos and relaxed hangouts. It attracts those seeking unique mango desserts in a chic, cozy setting.

Mango ice cream stands out with a slightly sour note that balances sweetness well. Other options like matcha ice cream and sundaes with banana, vanilla, and chocolate drizzle add variety and texture.

Asian desserts stand out with unique flavors and presentation. The menu offers an Asian-forward twist that makes sharing with friends or family a special treat.

People are saying

"These Asian-forward desserts are a treat with real fruit toppings."

"The mango ice cream is delicious and not too sweet."

"Their Asian-forward desserts are a unique treat to share."

Good to know

1

Thereโ€™s a discount for paying in cash.

2

They offer drinks with 25% less sweetness.

3

Some desserts are best enjoyed at the restaurant due to juice or ice cream.

15
Prufrock Coffee Company image 1

Space combines unique design with warm, inviting atmosphere that suits both relaxing and working. Decorations include a pour over setup displayed on the wall, adding to the aesthetic appeal. The vibe is spacious and welcoming, attracting those who want to read, study, or catch up with friends.

The ice cream croissant stands out with its perfect blend of soft serve sweetness and buttery, flaky croissant texture. Flavors like mango matcha add a unique twist to this novel and fun treat.

Unique drinks feature a sweetener from sweet potatoes and inventive flavors like the Purple Haze Frost. The menu offers versatile options alongside great coffee and matcha in a beautifully designed space.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be delicious and exceptional."

"I loved the unique, tasty drinks with sweet potato sweetener."

"The ice cream croissant is amazing and buttery."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tricky in the area, especially during busy hours.

2

The menu offers a limited selection of coffee options, primarily drip coffee.

3

They are dog friendly, making it a nice spot for pet owners.

16
Redefined Hope Boutique & Coffee Shop image 1

Boutique and coffee shop combine airy, relaxing atmosphere with magical holiday decorations and a cozy seating area. Visitors find a friendly, calm vibe with diverse offerings including a salon and unique gifts. The space supports a meaningful cause, creating a sense of warmth and purpose.

Delicious ice cream recently returned to the menu, served alongside coffee in a spot with a peaceful ambiance and seating to relax and enjoy the sunshine.

A wide range of unique clothing, adorable sweaters and vests, and distinctive gifts fills the boutique. Shelves hold many little trinkets and miscellaneous items to explore.

People are saying

"I found the boutiques here to be so cute."

"The coffee and ice cream here are delicious and unique."

"I found the ice cream to be delicious."

Good to know

1

All proceeds go to an amazing cause supporting battered women and children.

2

The boutique offers a wide variety of clothing, candles, and accessories.

3

Every purchase supports the Hope Centerโ€™s mission.

17
The Garage Food Hall image 1

Old warehouse space transformed into a historic food hall with a museum feel and revitalized industrial design. Atmosphere is lively and chaotic, filled with live music, pinball machines, and multiple bars offering tastings and mixed drinks. Crowds gather for a family-friendly vibe and diverse activities like sim racing, creating a bustling social hub.

Wide variety of ice cream flavors includes some unique options not commonly found elsewhere. The ice cream stands out as a top choice among many diverse food options available.

A wide variety of unique food choices stands out here, mixing typical food court vendors with some distinctive restaurants. The atmosphere adds to the cool and fun experience.

People are saying

"It's a cool spot with great vibes."

"It's a unique place with an incredible variety of food options."

"I enjoyed the ice cream and all the choices available."

Good to know

1

Parking at The Garage Food Hall is difficult, especially on weekends.

2

The Garage Food Hall closes at 10 pm.

3

It is best to grab a table first before ordering food.

18
Kura Revolving Sushi Bar image 1
Sushi restaurant

Robots deliver drinks while sushi moves along conveyor belts with protective domes in a compact, lively space. The atmosphere feels fun and unique, blending Japanese quirks with automation. Seating is close, favoring small groups and creating a busy, energetic vibe.

Taiyaki Ice Cream stands out with a fresh, homemade flavor and a cute presentation on the conveyor belt. The ice cream offers a nice contrast to the otherwise average food options.

Food arrives on revolving belts and robots, creating a unique sushi experience. The atmosphere feels fun and different, with no wait thanks to the revolving options.

People are saying

"The revolving sushi bar experience here is next level fun."

"It's a fun and unique dining experience with food delivered by belts and robots."

"The fish ice cream was really good and cute."

Good to know

1

A plate costs $3.75, which is considered expensive for the portions.

2

Arriving when they open is recommended as the restaurant fills up quickly.

3

It's important to get on the wait list before you're ready to eat.

19
Shoya Revolving Sushi (All You Can Eat) image 1
Conveyor belt sushi restaurant

Rotary sushi service features a conveyor belt with robotic delivery adding a playful touch. The interior is modern and beautifully themed, creating an inviting and family-friendly atmosphere. Plates move quickly, offering a fresh and flavorful sushi experience with a creative vibe.

Staff bring regular ice cream promptly when mochi ice cream is not liked. Presentation includes an adorable setup with a tiny spoon.

Revolving belt with food in closed containers offers a unique dining style. Modern, inviting interior adds to the experience while serving many unique foods.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and super fresh."

"The revolving belt with food in closed containers felt truly unique."

"The staff here are so attentive and always busy improving things."

Good to know

1

The all-you-can-eat option is priced at $20, offering good value.

2

Expect a one-hour wait during lunch hours, especially on holidays.

3

Customers must eat what they take or face charges for leftovers.

20
Paradise mx image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant offers a modern aesthetic with indoor and outdoor seating and board games for families. Atmosphere stays peaceful and welcoming, featuring photo-op spots and a calm vibe. Desserts stand out with unique flavors and beautiful presentation.

Ice cream features balanced sweetness and a variety of delicious flavors like coffee, Pina Colada, and chocolate Oreo. It suits both families and date nights well.

Many unique ice cream flavors and dessert options appear here, not found elsewhere. The menu includes distinctive dishes alongside classic treats, all served in a clean, beautiful atmosphere.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious ice cream and its amazing variety of flavors."

"I loved the variety of delicious crepes and sweet treats."

"The ice cream flavors here are so unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

They offer ice cream, Mangonadas, Crepes, Aรงaรญ bowls, and more sweet treats.

2

A large agua fresca costs almost 10 dollars.

3

The shop has bagel sandwiches and hot dogs for a quick bite.

21
LiftOff Creamery - Irvington image 1

Tiny ice cream shop with airplane-themed decor and few tables creates a cozy, bright atmosphere. Friendly energy fills the space, often loud from customers, with a small play area adding to the vibe. Offers generous portions, vegan and no sugar added options, and a variety of unique flavors.

Offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors including vegan options. The ice cream is consistently high quality and popular with families.

Many flavors come with a good selection but lack particularly unique or unusual qualities.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the delicious ice cream here."

"This ice cream shop is a great little spot."

"I loved the wide variety of unique flavors here."

Good to know

1

LiftOff Creamery offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and options for customization.

2

They have several vegan options available, including no sugar added flavors.

3

The shop is known for its clean environment and generous ice cream portions.

22
Mi Sueรฑo Upscale Mexican Cuisine & Cocktails image 1

Upscale Mexican restaurant with stylish decor and a well-stocked bar creates a cozy, lively atmosphere. Live music and DJs keep energy high while offering a friendly, welcoming vibe. Bold, refined flavors complement the vibrant setting.

Desserts feature a trio of ice cream and unique flavors like pina colada ice cream. Chocolate ice cream appears as a complimentary treat with raspberries and special occasions get a scoop with a sparkler.

Grilled salmon comes with coconut rice and a salad featuring a unique dressing that blends flavors well. Drinks stand out as refreshing and inventive, offering a wide variety of choices.

People are saying

"The Mexican food service was excellent, attentive, and inviting."

"The food here is unique, with flavors that explode and dishes that are beautifully plated."

"The complimentary chocolate ice cream was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 3 pm with discounted appetizers.

2

Taco Tuesday offers half-off discounts on most tacos.

3

The venue hosts a popular sip and paint experience.

23
Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream image 1

Liquid nitrogen freezes ice cream instantly, creating a dry ice steam effect that draws attention. Families enjoy watching the interactive ice cream making process, which adds a fun, family-friendly vibe. The shop also offers vegan options and serves espresso coffee alongside the ice cream.

Ice cream freezes with liquid nitrogen right in front of you, creating a unique and flavorful taste. Watching the process adds a fun and engaging element to enjoying the cold treat.

Nitrogen ice cream offers a distinct taste and texture. Watching the ice cream freeze with liquid nitrogen right in front of you adds a unique experience to the process.

People are saying

"This ice cream is the coldest, greatest, and most excellent thing ever."

"The coffee here is super delicious and amazing."

"I loved the unique experience of watching them freeze ice cream with liquid nitrogen."

Good to know

1

The ice cream is made instantly using liquid nitrogen, creating a unique experience.

2

Vegan options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Expect to pay around $10 for a small portion of ice cream.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...