Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Indiana

Makeup Stores

Made for those who treat their makeup collection as a curated inventory of professional-grade tools.

Based on 469 Opinions
+466
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01

Bright, clean salon offers an upbeat atmosphere with long-lasting makeup and bridal party services. Easy scheduling and thoughtful touches like water and mimosas create a relaxed experience. Use of Unite products leaves hair soft and styled to perfection.

Makeup applications here stay flawless all night with a long-lasting finish. Services include bridal party makeup and blowouts for formal events.

People are saying

"Kayla gives the best blowouts and always listens."

"I felt so beautiful after their amazing makeup."

"The service was relaxing and they did a terrific job."

Good to know

1

Scheduling appointments is easy and often available on short notice.

2

The salon uses high-quality Unite products for styling.

3

Complimentary beverages like water, coffee, and mimosas are offered during visits.

02
MAC Cosmetics image 1
Cosmetics store

Offers wide range of colors with long-lasting wear. Staff are patient and attentive, great for beginners. Shelves stay well-stocked, making shopping vibrant and easy.

Staff provide patient, attentive help, especially for beginners learning makeup. The store carries a well-stocked range of products that last long without touch-ups.

People are saying

"The makeup artist listened carefully and made me feel beautiful."

Good to know

1

MAC Cosmetics often has seasonal promotions on select products.

2

Makeup artists are available for consultations and product recommendations.

3

The store provides testers for most products to try before buying.

03
Supreme Hair Depot image 1
Beauty supply store

Massive beauty supply store offers huge selection of makeup, wigs, and hair care products. Friendly vibe with lively music keeps energy high. Well-organized layout and affordable prices make shopping easy and budget-friendly.

A wide selection of makeup, wigs, and hair care products fills the shelves. Options include human hair bundles and beauty accessories alongside makeup essentials.

People are saying

"The staff here makes you feel at home and appreciated."

"This haircare store has a huge selection of products."

"This makeup store has a huge selection of hair and beauty products."

Good to know

1

Supreme offers amazing prices on hair supplies during back-to-school events.

2

They provide food and a bouncy house for kids during events.

3

Parents can enjoy a break while kids participate in activities.

04
Ulta Beauty image 1
Cosmetics store

Offers personalized attention with precise makeup matching. Known for excellent blowouts and popular winter products. Plenty of parking and clean aisles create a calm shopping experience despite occasional security concerns.

Service stands out with personalized attention and precise makeup matching. Allison delivers exact replicas of requested looks, especially for special events like Prom.

People are saying

"Justin at the Makeup Store is so helpful and kind."

"The Hair Salon is amazing; Martisa was so helpful!"

Good to know

1

The store has plenty of parking available for customers.

2

The aisles are clean and well-organized for easy shopping.

3

Haircuts cost around $50, which may be higher than other local options.

05
SEPHORA image 1
Cosmetics store

Store offers wide selection of cosmetics with helpful staff for shade matching and special occasions. Layout feels confusing and space is small, causing frequent navigation around others. Popular items like Milk Makeup tint draw long lines.

Helpful staff assist with shade matching and makeup looks. Stock includes sought-after items like Milk Makeup tint/blush. Skilled team members support special occasions such as weddings.

People are saying

"Elexis at the Makeup Store made me feel confident trying products."

Good to know

1

Buying online for pickup is usually quicker than shopping in-store.

2

Expect long lines due to the store's increased popularity.

3

The store has a wide selection of products in stock.

06
SEPHORA at Kohl's image 1
Cosmetics store

Makeup artists provide personalized advice on foundation and eye shadow despite a disorganized layout with scattered products. Expired skincare items with visible dirt sit on end caps, while staff multitask by training and applying makeup in-store.

Makeup artists show strong knowledge and offer personalized advice on foundation, concealer, and eye shadow. Some associates try on makeup in-store, and the space can get messy with products scattered around.

People are saying

"The makeup store employees were so helpful and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Expect a cluttered shopping experience with products scattered around.

2

Staff may be preoccupied with personal tasks while assisting customers.

3

Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a better shopping experience.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...