Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Indiana

Pizza

A slice that respects the craft of the dough rather than treating it as a vehicle for cheap toppings.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The NY Slice image 1
The NY Slice image 2
The NY Slice image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small spot with a homey atmosphere and quiet vibe. One person handles all orders, making it feel personal. Known for authentic New York-style pizza with generous slices and reasonable prices. A true local favorite, not a busy chain.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste comparable to Queens or Manhattan. Serves generous slices that deliver more value than typical chain pizzas.

People are saying

"I found authentic New York style pizza here."

"You have to save room for the amazing cannolis."

"This pizza tastes like authentic New York style."

Good to know

1

The NY Slice is primarily a carry-out restaurant with limited dine-in options.

2

Prices are very affordable, with family meals available for around $30.

3

The restaurant is usually not busy, allowing for quick service.

02
Apna Desi Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Vibrant decor channels Amritsar vibes while comfy seating invites relaxation. Fusion pizzas like Achari Pizza and butter chicken shine with fresh dough and crispy crusts. Prices stay reasonable, making it a lively spot for flavorful dining.

Fusion pizzas stand out with options like Achari Pizza, butter chicken, and tikka masala. The crust uses fresh dough and quality ingredients, creating a tasty, hot pizza experience.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and very tasty."

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and very tasty."

"I thought the Indian Food here was amazing."

Good to know

1

Two large pizzas cost about $40, making them reasonably priced.

2

The restaurant offers a mix of pizza and Indian cuisine.

3

Expect plenty of other delicious food options to try.

03
Magoo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a casual vibe perfect for relaxed evenings. Homemade pizza shines with Indian chicken and pepperoni flavors that balance cheese and sauce well. Wings add a standout twist to the menu, making it a fresh choice beyond typical pizza places.

Pizza here has a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings with an authentic taste that stands out from typical chains. The Indian chicken pizza is a favorite, and the pepperoni pizza is notably flavorful.

People are saying

"This pizza is so tasty with an amazing cheese pull."

"They surprised us with free, warm cookies, a perfect sweet ending."

"It's a great, family owned pizza place."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during busy dinner hours.

2

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during weekends.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

04
INDY PIZZA PRO image 1
Pizza restaurant

Modern pizza spot offers fresh handmade dough with bold toppings like Paneer Tikka and Tandoori Chicken. Lively vibe with games keeps groups and couples entertained. Clean, relaxing space makes it great for casual dining.

Fresh pizzas come with a perfect crust and rich flavors. Unique options like Paneer Tikka and Tandoori Chicken pizzas stand out alongside classic sausage and garlic varieties.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was really delicious and fresh."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, was great!"

"The Indian food here is loaded with amazing fresh flavor."

Good to know

1

They make their own fresh dough and sauce every day.

2

The prices are reasonable for the quality of food.

3

There is handicapped parking available.

05
Al's Pub & Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza pub offers loaded toppings and unique options like breakfast pizza. Cozy space fills with down-to-earth patrons enjoying loud music. Calm atmosphere blends with a chill neighborhood bar vibe, making it a great spot for casual dining and socializing.

Loaded toppings make the pizza stand out. It serves excellent bar pizza with options like a breakfast pizza and a Wednesday pizza and salad special.

People are saying

"The food here is awesome."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had."

"The bar's food, like the bread sticks and wings, was delicious."

Good to know

1

Mobile food delivery is available with a tasty menu.

2

Daily specials are offered, making meals more affordable.

3

The tenderloin sandwich comes with toppings upon request.

06
Venice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school building creates a cozy, peaceful vibe with a friendly, Christian focus. Deep dish pizza features a thick crust loaded with sausage and fresh garlic. Prices stay reasonable while serving some of the best pizza around, perfect for party sizes.

Deep dish pizza stands out with a thick crust loaded with sausage, pepperoni, fresh garlic, and green peppers. Every pizza offers consistent quality and comes with friendly, last-minute service even near closing time.

People are saying

"The deep dish pizza here is amazing, especially the cheesy, crispy crust."

"The staff here are so friendly, they even gave my son candy."

"I thought the pizza here was amazingly delicious."

Good to know

1

Venice Pizza offers some of the lowest prices in town.

2

The pizza is made with high-quality ingredients and from scratch.

3

There is ample parking available for customers.

07
Dino's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic spot serves Chicago-style thin crust pizza topped with sausage and mushrooms. Friendly staff ensure prompt curbside pickup for a quick, no-frills experience. Locals love the well-regarded sauce and steady quality.

Pizza features a thin crust with cheese, sausage, and mushrooms. Staff deliver orders promptly and with a friendly attitude.

People are saying

"I thought Dino's Pizza was the best pizza around."

"I found Dino's Pizza's thin crust pizza to be exceptional."

"The food here is pretty great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Dino's Pizza is take-out only.

2

Dino's Pizza is available for takeout or delivery only.

3

Dino's Pizza is only available for pick-up.

08
Velly Pizza & Indian street food image 1

Space blends clean design with a calming vibe and good music. Guests enjoy authentic Indian-inspired pizza like tandoori chicken and achari paneer, with halal and vegetarian options. Quick, flavorful meals come with a friendly atmosphere perfect for all ages.

Tandoori chicken pizza and achari paneer pizza stand out with authentic, well-cooked flavors. The pizzas offer reasonable pricing and include tasty vegetarian options that appeal to all ages.

People are saying

"I've never tasted pizza this good; it's the best I've ever had."

"I tasted authentic street food from Punjab, perfectly cooked."

"I received the best service I've ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer halal options and allow you to customize the spice level.

2

The pricing is reasonable with a 2 large pizza, 3 toppings deal.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

09
Last Chance Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Offers a casual vibe with a small seating area perfect for families. Pizza shines with thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce, especially the pepperoni. Prices stay reasonable, making it a solid spot for both dining and pizza lovers.

Pizza comes out hot with a thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce. Pepperoni tastes good and cheese pizzas sometimes get extra sauce.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was really good and delicious."

"I found the food to be delicious."

"I experienced the best food at this bar."

Good to know

1

The entrance to Last Chance Pizza is in the back corner of the parking lot.

2

Expect a small seating area, which may lead to wait times.

3

Prices at Last Chance Pizza are reasonable for a pub and family restaurant.

10
Mr A Pizza & Wings image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza parlor shines with toasted soft crust and unique fusion pizzas like Indian-style options. Cozy indoor seating creates a family atmosphere perfect for locals. Fast delivery and a $6.50 lunch special add great value to the flavorful menu.

Pizza features a toasted and soft crust that stands out. Fusion options include spicy butter garlic chicken and vegetarian Indian pizzas with well-flavored toppings. Delivery is fast and the lunch special offers pizza with soda for $6.50.

People are saying

"The pizza here has delicious, well-flavored toppings and a unique crust."

"The delivery was super fast and the driver was polite."

"The salad was beautiful with a great selection of items."

Good to know

1

The lunch special includes pizza and soda for $6.50.

2

They offer a wide variety of pizza options, including Indian-style pizza like chicken tikka masala.

3

Expect fast delivery from the restaurant.

11
Mia pizzaria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-owned spot serves New York style pizza with a thin crust and halal pepperoni. Cozy vibe with a huge sports TV and friendly staff makes it great for groups. Food is fresh, made from scratch, and offers both meat and plant-based choices.

Thin crust stands out with its authentic Italian style and homemade pizza sauce that pairs well for dipping. Pepperoni and other toppings come halal, making the menu versatile and flavorful.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza has a perfectly thin, flavorful crust."

"The lunch special here is a great value for the price."

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and flavorful."

Good to know

1

They currently have a $10 lunch special that includes a slice of NY pizza, 3 breadsticks, and a 20 oz drink.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

3

Mia Pizzaria is a family-owned local business with a focus on quality.

12
Fraternal Order of Eagles image 1
Fraternal organization

Fraternal spot offers a family-friendly atmosphere with generous portions and notably good burgers. Huge pizzas boast excellent flavor and plenty of toppings, worth the price despite being a bit pricey. Casual vibe makes it welcoming for all.

Huge pizzas come with plenty of toppings and sauce. The pizza stands out for its excellent flavor and is considered worth the price despite being a little pricey.

People are saying

"The food here was great, especially the fish and pizza."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

3

Kids eat free on Sundays with the purchase of an adult meal.

13
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza image 1

Take 'N' Bake Pizza offers crispy, generously topped pizzas with options like New York style thin crust and crustless keto-friendly varieties. Customers enjoy a grab and go system with affordable prices and easy timed pickup.

Pizzas come generously topped and cook up nice and crispy. Options include a crustless pizza with only 33 carbs, perfect for keto or low-carb diets, and pizzas are assembled exactly how you want them.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was really good."

Good to know

1

The Tuesday special offers a unique deal every week.

2

Prices for large specialty pizzas start at $23 plus tax.

3

Ordering ahead is easy and allows for timely pickup.

14
Jet's Pizza image 1
Pizza delivery

Detroit style pizza shines with its crispy deep dish crust and three types of pepperoni. Quick service and easy online ordering make for a smooth experience. Specialty pies like BBQ chicken stay hot and fresh even after delivery.

Detroit style pizza stands out with its crusty, deep dish base and an overload of three types of pepperoni. The BBQ chicken and all meat specialty pizzas come out hot and crispy, maintaining quality and flavor even after delivery.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious, like a dream."

"I found the deep dish crust to be the best and very crispy."

"My pizza delivery was hot and crispy."

Good to know

1

Carryout is available at Jet's Pizza.

2

The online ordering process is very easy.

3

Jet's Pizza offers a variety of four different pizza options.

15
Pizza and Chicken Express image 1

Freshly made dough creates highly praised pizza like BBQ and Supreme combos with beef pepperoni and turkey ham. Takeout focus suits quick meals, while clean, spacious interior offers seating for order waiting. Great value comes from buy one get one free deals and EBT acceptance.

BBQ and Supreme combos stand out with fresh, hot, and well-cooked pizza. Options include beef pepperoni, beef sausage, and turkey ham, with no pork. The pepperoni and chicken pizzas are popular choices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and well cooked."

"I found the calzone to be really tasty and cheesy."

"You have to try the chocolate cake pizza; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

The place is only for carryout and has no dine-in options.

2

They accepted EBT.

3

The portions were good and provided great value for the price.

16
Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine image 1

Italian spot shines with homemade crust and life-changing meatball pomodoro. Kids love the calzone pizzas in a family-friendly vibe. Service is smooth, especially for curbside pickup and takeout.

Pizza and breadsticks taste excellent and look great. Calzone pizzas appeal to kids, and the pizza consistently impresses with its flavor.

People are saying

"Their pizza looks and tastes excellent."

Good to know

1

The restaurant currently offers only drive-up service due to COVID-19 restrictions.

2

Curbside pickup is available on Thursday evenings, affecting dining options.

17
Rockville Station image 1
Shopping mall

Shopping mall has a cute shape and offers several good places to eat. Yummy pizza at Monicals Pizza attracts both kids and adults. Quick service keeps the vibe family-friendly and easy for grabbing a slice.

Yummy pizza draws both kids and adults. Quick service makes grabbing a slice easy and frequent.

People are saying

"I loved their pizza; I tried to eat it every week."

"I enjoyed the good food here."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at Sidelines bar with free pool.

18
Pizza King Of Mooresville image 1

Pizza shines with crispy crust and square slices topped with sausage and pepperoni. Take-out only service keeps things simple, while the family-friendly vibe makes it welcoming. The dining room feels warm but outdated, using paper plates without table service.

Pizza arrives hot with a crispy crust and is cut into trademark square slices. The sauce and toppings like sausage and pepperoni balance well, making the pizza consistently fresh and delicious.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had in Mooresville."

"I thought the food here was delicious and phenomenal."

"I always got half sausage and half pepperoni pizza."

Good to know

1

This location only offers carry-out; no dine-in service is available.

2

The total cost for two small cheese pizzas and one medium pizza is around $60.

3

The Monday special makes pizza more affordable for customers.

19
Xtrordinary Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Carryout-only spot offers hot, generously topped pizzas with a garage-like setup and small parking lot. Known for amazing flavor and consistent quality, it features unique options like Take and Bake pizzas and a pizza bowl. Prices stay low for large portions.

Pizza here stands out for its amazing flavor and consistent quality. Options include Take and Bake pizzas and a unique pizza bowl that adds variety to the menu.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was the best in the city."

"I thought the pizza was really good and satisfying."

"This Italian food is heavenly, loaded with great toppings."

Good to know

1

Xtrordinary Pizza is carry out only.

2

A 10-inch pizza will easily feed 3-4 people for $15.

3

To have the pizza delivered at a certain time, order at least 1.5 hours ahead.

20
Fisher's Pizza Fish & Chicken image 1

Small spot in an old strip mall serves handmade halal food with generous portions. Veggie around the world pizza offers a perfect spread of vegetables while fried fish and chicken bring fresh, flavorful taste. Atmosphere is unpolished but welcoming with a passionate owner.

Veggie around the world pizza features a perfect spread of vegetables. Cheese pizza stands out with fresh ingredients and great flavor. Every bite delivers a taste reminiscent of an Italian fiesta.

People are saying

"The fish here is always hot and fresh."

"The food here is delicious and fire."

"I found the pizza delicious and made to perfection."

Good to know

1

The serving sizes are generous, often bordering on excessive.

2

Prices are very reasonable, with meals costing under $20.

3

All food served is halal, catering to dietary restrictions.

21
Big Walt's Wings & More image 1

Grab & go setup creates a quick, casual vibe with a welcoming spirit. Supreme pizza scores a perfect 10, while burgers and meat lovers pizza offer soul-warming flavors. Fair prices make it a top spot for flavorful meals and a homey atmosphere.

Supreme pizza stands out with a solid 10 out of 10 rating. The chicken pizza and meat lovers pizza with extra sauce, sausage, and cheese offer rich, soul-warming flavors.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be always fresh and seasoned right."

"I thought the pizza here was the absolute best."

"I thought the burgers here were the best in town."

Good to know

1

This location is a grab & go with no indoor seating.

2

The wait is generally 20 minutes or less.

3

Call in your order to avoid waiting.

22
Pasquales image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school spot with a cozy small town vibe and lively atmosphere. Stuffed pizza is a standout highlight, especially during the lunch buffet. Unique strombolis with pickle and onion add a tasty twist to classic flavors.

Stuffed pizza stands out as a highlight, often described as the best ever. The fresh pizzas come out great during the lunch buffet, and the strombolis with pizza sauce, pickle, and onion add a unique twist.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and delicious."

"I loved the pizza buffet; the cheese was so good."

"The pasta here is wonderful."

Good to know

1

The buffet offers four pizza options, spaghetti, and a salad with four dressings.

2

The buffet for two adults and a child costs $40.

3

Expect a wait for fresh pizza as they sometimes serve leftovers.

23
The Rook image 1

Small bar with a retro style and a back patio offers a friendly local vibe where regulars form a close-knit community. Gluten-free pizza shines with generous toppings and well-seasoned flavors, alongside solid wings and cheese balls.

Gluten-free pizza stands out with generous toppings and well-seasoned flavors. Wings, burger, pizza, and cheese balls all make solid choices here.

People are saying

"The food, especially the wings and cheese curds, is amazing."

"I found it to be a great local bar with a friendly vibe."

"I found the gluten-free pizza here to be very good."

Good to know

1

Taco Tuesday features special pricing on tacos and drinks.

2

Expect a lively atmosphere with a mix of regulars and newcomers.

3

Prices are considered reasonable for both food and drinks.

24
Squigi's Pizza of Highland image 1

Offers hand-tossed crusts with both thin and deep dish options that are always great. Casual, takeout-only spot with reasonable prices and a menu featuring calzones, sandwiches, and wings. Pizza arrives hot with evenly spread toppings showing real craft.

Pizza features a thin crust and a deep dish option, both consistently great. Bosco sticks stand out as a popular side, and the pizza shows a clear love of the craft in its preparation.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I'd ever had."

"I loved the chunk sausage and pepper pizza here."

Good to know

1

Squigi's Pizza is takeout only, so plan accordingly.

2

They do not accept American Express; cash and other cards are fine.

3

Prices are very reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option.

25
Twin Peaks image 1
Sports bar

Sports fans enjoy a loud, energetic vibe with many TVs and a fire pit patio for outdoor games. Flatbread pizzas like the BBQ brisket and jalapeรฑo popper offer bold, smoky, and spicy flavors. Scantily clad staff add to the distinctive, lively atmosphere.

Flatbread pizzas stand out with options like Italian Flatbread and hottie jalapeรฑo popper. The BBQ brisket pizza offers a rich, smoky flavor and a spicy kick with jalapeรฑos.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the bacon."

"The beer here is ice cold and delicious."

"I loved the spicy flatbread pizza here."

Good to know

1

There is a $5 cover charge for fight night events.

2

Bikini and beanie night is a popular themed event.

3

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

26
Marks Pub image 1
Restaurant

Neighborhood bar offers a chill vibe with free pool tables and sports on TVs. Thin crust pizza shines with ample cheese and hearty toppings. Affordable prices and a patio space make it perfect for casual hangouts.

Thin crust pizza features ample cheese, sausage, and pepperoni. The crust and toppings hold up well, making for a really good pizza.

People are saying

"The bar food here is pretty good and a great value."

"It's a great local bar with a comfortable atmosphere."

"I believed that this pizza was the best."

Good to know

1

Half-priced appetizers are available on Tuesdays from 3 to 10 pm.

2

$3 burger and fries special on Thursdays.

3

Karaoke happens on Saturdays with a fun atmosphere.

27
Hilltop Tavern image 1

Cozy dive bar buzzes with live local music on weekends and welcomes a diverse, friendly crowd. Thick, party-cut pizza offers great value and pairs well with a fresh house salad. Outdoor seating adds a pleasant touch to this cash-only spot.

Thick, party-cut pizzas offer a filling meal at a great price. The pizza pairs well with a house salad and stands out for its generous portions and affordable value.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be very good."

"Peggy at the bar makes the experience so enjoyable."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Hilltop Tavern accepts only cash payments; plan accordingly.

2

The tavern is open from 0700 to 0400, offering 20 hours of service.

3

Karaoke happens on Saturday nights, attracting a lively crowd.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...