Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indiana

Whiskey bars

A pour of whiskey that feels like a genuine discovery rather than just another bottle you could find on any grocery store shelf.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Net Par image 1
Net Par image 2
Net Par image 3
View all
Golf club

Indoor golf uses TRACKMAN simulators for all skill levels in a family-friendly space. Whiskey events offer tasting paired with golf and a diverse bourbon selection at the bar. Atmosphere stays relaxed and private, perfect for fun and focus.

Events pair whiskey tasting with golf activities for a unique experience. The selection features good whiskey that complements the setting well.

People are saying

"I had a ton of fun playing golf here."

"I had a great time at this awesome Bar."

"The whiskey here really complements the experience."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the Sip and Swing Whiskey event.

2

Golf club rentals are available for a fee; check in advance for availability.

3

Food delivery from Danny Zโ€™s is available for a flat fee of $5.

02
Commission Row image 1
Restaurant

Modern elegance shines with an open kitchen and lively vibe. Whiskey lovers enjoy a standout Old Fashioned and expert staff. Downstairs speakeasy offers live music and a bustling bar scene, perfect for a chill yet vibrant night.

Old Fashioned stands out as a key whiskey option. Staff know the whiskey list well and offer solid recommendations.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the steaks cooked perfectly."

"The staff's hospitality and menu knowledge made our steak dinner special."

"The whiskey knowledge of the staff here is outstanding."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch, especially on holidays like Father's Day.

2

Movie nights occur every Sunday, providing a fun weekly event.

3

Devour Indy offers a $65 four-course meal, a great deal during the event.

03
Big Red Liquors image 1
Liquor store

Old bank building hosts a liquor store with a historic bourbon vault in the basement. Whiskey lovers find a great selection in the Whiskey Vault downstairs. Atmosphere is unique and gritty, fitting groups used to rough urban spots.

A vault full of whiskey sits in the basement, offering a great selection of whiskey and bourbon. The Whiskey Vault stands out as a unique feature downstairs.

People are saying

"The old bank building housing the whiskey vault is really cool."

"I found the whiskey vault in the basement to be awesome."

"I was impressed by the wine cellar downstairs."

Good to know

1

The liquor store is located in a historic federal reserve building.

2

Expect a unique shopping experience in a former bank setting.

3

The area has a noticeable presence of homelessness and open drug use.

04
SNUG image 1
Pub

Cozy Irish pub offers an intimate vibe with authentic decor and a quiet neighborhood setting. Largest Irish Whiskey selection shines alongside a welcoming whiskey club for enthusiasts. Unique touches like photo-printed beer foam add charm.

An exceptional whiskey collection stands out here, especially the largest Irish Whiskey selection in the region. The whiskey club offers a welcoming spot to explore and learn about a wide variety of whiskeys.

People are saying

"This bar feels like home, with friendly staff and a genuine community vibe."

"I was impressed by the beautiful whiskey selection here."

"This local spot feels like a special neighborhood place for conversation."

Good to know

1

Live traditional music happens every Tuesday night at SNUG.

2

Mondays feature a great drink special, making it a quiet night.

3

Thursdays are busier, perfect for mingling with locals.

05
Broken Barrel โ€” Carmel image 1

Speakeasy-style bar offers a cozy atmosphere with excellent whiskey selection. Comfortable seating invites quiet chats while enjoying local bourbon flights and classic cocktails like whiskey sour.

An excellent whiskey and bourbon selection stands out here. The menu includes classic cocktails like the whiskey sour.

People are saying

"Peggy made us feel right at home and offered great suggestions."

"Peggy makes you feel right at home with her cocktail suggestions."

"The whiskey selection here is excellent."

Good to know

1

Prices are reasonable for cocktails and food.

2

The place offers a variety of cocktails and local bourbon flights.

3

Expect slower service during peak hours.

06
SoBro Spirits. Wine. Craft Beer image 1

Shop offers a huge selection of bourbon and whiskey with many store picks. Friendly vibe feels like visiting a friend's house. Tastings and a transparent lottery for rare bottles make it special.

A wide selection of bourbon and whiskey fills the shelves, including numerous store picks. The variety covers many interesting whiskies alongside local beers.

People are saying

"The staff here is super friendly and knowledgeable about beer."

"I found a huge variety of wine and interesting selections."

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful with the whiskey."

Good to know

1

They offer a discount for cash payments.

2

Prices are affordable for a wide selection of spirits.

3

The store has a huge variety of wine and whiskey.

07
Burn by Rocky Patel Indianapolis image 1

Full-service cigar bar boasts a vast cigar selection and two floors of leather seating. Whiskey choices like Dalmore and Crown come at premium prices. Live jazz and DJ music create a sexy, relaxing vibe in spacious indoor and outdoor areas.

Whiskey selection includes Dalmore and Crown, with shots priced at $50 and $17 respectively. Prices for whiskey are notably high alongside a strong cigar pairing.

People are saying

"Greg's encyclopedic knowledge makes buying cigars an education."

"Greg Otterman's hospitality at the bar is unmatched; he's the gold standard."

"The whiskey vibes here are amazing."

Good to know

1

They charge a 20% gratuity for parties of two.

2

A cover fee is required in the evening; cash is needed to pay it.

3

No food is available at the bar, so plan accordingly.

08
Hotel Tango Distillery image 1

Cozy seating and a warm fireplace create a welcoming vibe. Whiskey flights feature funky flavors perfect for sipping. Classic board games and a house cat add a homey touch to the relaxed, pet-friendly space.

Flights include multiple funky, different whiskeys and liquors. Flavored whiskies stand out as the least worst options. The whiskey offers a chill atmosphere for sipping and trying bar bites.

People are saying

"The cocktails here feel like a warm, welcoming hug."

"It's dog friendly, so you can bring your pup inside."

"You can get a great whiskey flight in this chill, welcoming atmosphere."

Good to know

1

They do not serve food on-site, but they allow delivery or carry-in food.

2

Hotel Tango is pet friendly, allowing dogs in the indoor area.

3

The distillery is combat-disabled, veteran-owned, and the first in Indiana after Prohibition.

09
The Whistle Stop Inn image 1

Dive bar with old-time charm offers a cozy, friendly space where people sing and dance. Busy during games thanks to stadium proximity, it boasts a stellar bourbon selection and a large whiskey variety rivaling high-end bars. Unique train whistle adds character.

A large selection of whiskey stands out here, rivaling those at high-end bars. The whiskey and tequila choices rank among the most exciting in the city despite the dive bar look.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the brisket fries."

"This local spot's staff makes you feel welcomed like family."

"The bartenders here are so pleasant and passionate about their whiskey."

Good to know

1

Karaoke happens every Friday night, attracting many regulars.

2

Parking is not free, so plan accordingly.

3

Expect to pay extra if using a credit card for transactions.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...