Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Fishers

Sandwich spots

You want a sandwich that is built with care and doesn't cut corners on the ingredients.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Vicious Biscuit image 1
Vicious Biscuit image 2
Vicious Biscuit image 3
View all
Brunch restaurant

Brunch shines with massive fresh biscuits and a unique jam and butter bar. Sandwiches impress using biscuit bases and hearty fillings like the Viscous and Gravy Train. Bright, industrial space feels lively but can get noisy and crowded.

Sandwiches feature biscuit bases and hearty fillings like the Viscous and Gravy Train. Options include breakfast styles and the Fat Boy, all with solid flavor.

People are saying

"The food here was surprisingly excellent and fresh."

"I had the best gluten-free biscuit Iโ€™ve ever had."

"I thought the sandwiches here were huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; arrive early to avoid long wait times.

2

Parking is limited due to ongoing construction in the area.

3

The menu features a variety of unique biscuit options and generous portions.

02
Reem Mediterranean Grill image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Cozy spot glows with warm golden light and hums with classic Mediterranean music. Lamb gyro and chicken shawarma sandwiches offer tender, seasoned meat. Plenty of seating invites lively chats over falafel platters.

Lamb gyro and chicken shawarma sandwiches feature tender, perfectly seasoned meat. Falafel sandwich platters come well presented and are a popular choice for gatherings.

People are saying

"I drove an hour for this fresh, rich Mediterranean food."

"The falafel here is so delicious and fresh."

"The falafel sandwich platter was delicious and perfectly presented."

Good to know

1

Reem Mediterranean Grill offers a build-your-own menu for items like pitas and wraps.

2

The restaurant is affordable with large portions.

3

The prices at Reem Mediterranean Grill are very affordable.

03
AlBasha of Fishers โ€“ Mediterranean Kitchen image 1

Small Mediterranean spot offers authentic halal dishes in a cozy, homey setting with a welcoming vibe. Known for falafel and shawarma sandwiches, each bite bursts with fresh, flavorful ingredients. Lighting is dim and noise rises when busy, adding to the lively atmosphere.

Falafel and shawarma sandwiches stand out as the best here. The menu also features a Philly steak sandwich and a Chicken Souvlaki Pita Sandwich, all well made.

People are saying

"I found the food to be absolutely delicious."

"This grocery store has a wide selection of delicious Mediterranean foods."

"I found the falafel and shawarma sandwiches to be the best."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of halal options for diners.

2

Expect fresh ingredients and authentic Middle Eastern flavors.

3

Prices are reasonable, but some items may have increased recently.

04
CM Korean Fried Chicken image 1

Small spot with K-pop memorabilia and music videos sets a lively, cozy vibe. Spicy chicken sandwiches shine with sweet coleslaw on the side. Seating feels tight but the energy stays upbeat and clean.

Spicy chicken sandwiches come with chicken tenders on a bun and a side of slightly sweet coleslaw that pairs well when mixed in. Options include a spicy garlic chicken sandwich and sweet chili sauce on drumsticks.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"I thought this was the best fried chicken I had in ages."

"This chicken sandwich is super crispy, juicy, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

All chicken options are halal, including wings, tenders, half, and whole chicken.

2

Prices are on the higher side; check the menu before ordering.

3

Water is not free; drinks must be purchased.

05
Hotel Nickel Plate Fishers, Tapestry Collection by Hilton image 1

Boutique hotel blends railroad heritage decor with modern style for a moody vibe. Quiet rooms offer downtown views while a lively bar attracts locals. Sandwiches like the buttermilk fried chicken are flavorful but pricey, around $29 with a drink. Amenities include a large fitness center and free garage parking.

Offers a buttermilk fried chicken sandwich and a spicy grilled chicken sandwich, both noted for strong flavor. Sandwiches come with a higher price point, around $29 when paired with a mixed drink.

People are saying

"The hotel staff here are the best I've ever experienced."

"The bathroom was huge and amazing, with a gorgeous soaking tub."

"The buttermilk fried chicken sandwich was amazing."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available in the garage next to the hotel.

2

The hotel is newly built in 2024, offering modern amenities.

3

Rooms are equipped with high-quality fixtures and furnishings.

06
Jimmy John's image 1
Sandwich shop

Casual spot known for Chicken Caesar wrap and fresh, quick meals. Potato salad adds a tasty side. Sandwiches vary, with some like Little John Turkey being light on meat. Regulars love the consistent quality and simple menu.

Pre-paid shelves hold sandwiches ready for quick pickup. The Chicken Caesar wrap stands out as a flavorful option. Some sandwiches, like the Little John Turkey, can be light on meat and inconsistent in portion size.

People are saying

"Shannon's sandwiches are the best, and she's always super friendly."

07
Bubba's 33 image 1
American restaurant

Large sports bar buzzes with rows of TVs showing games and music videos. Tenderloin sandwiches shine with crispy, juicy texture. Loud music fills the space, making it lively but tough for quiet chats.

Tenderloin sandwiches stand out with their crispy, tender, juicy texture and generous size. Chicken bacon avocado and parmesan chicken sandwiches offer rich, flavorful options alongside excellent burgers and Philly sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is consistently great and delicious."

"I had the best onion rings I have ever had."

"This tenderloin sandwich is crispy, tender, and juicy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant stays open until midnight during NFL season on Thursdays, Sundays, and Mondays.

2

Parking is plentiful and available on-site.

3

Expect a wait for food during busy events like NCAA basketball tournaments.

08
City Barbeque image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Roomy seating indoors and outdoors sets a comfortable atmosphere with blues music and a country barbecue vibe. Pulled pork sandwiches are large and tasty, with fire sauce adding a spicy kick. Condiment bar and ice cream keep the experience casual and fun.

Pulled pork sandwiches come in large portions and taste excellent. Options include a naked style and a fire sauce that pairs well with turkey sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and really tasty."

"The pulled pork and brisket here are so juicy and tender."

"The pulled pork sandwich here is awesome and quite large."

Good to know

1

Rib Tuesdays offer special pricing on ribs every week.

2

City Barbeque provides free cake giveaways on select days.

3

Expect smaller portion sizes than average for the price.

09
Penn Station East Coast Subs image 1

Fresh Philly cheesesteaks shine with quality ingredients and crispy fries complement the meal well. Smooth pickup keeps service efficient despite occasional line delays. Pricing stays reasonable for tasty sandwiches, balancing quality and cost.

Sandwiches come out freshly made with a focus on quality ingredients like in the cheesesteak. Prices run on the higher side, and wait times can stretch up to 30 minutes.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches to be amazing and freshly made."

"You have to try their amazing lemonade."

"The Philly Cheesesteak service is slow during busy times."

Good to know

1

Food is always ready when ordered online.

2

Penn Station East Coast Subs is accessible for all ranges of abilities.

3

Expect to spend over $60 for three people with two having smaller sandwiches and small fries.

10
Sahm's Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Industrial ceilings create a loud vibe, but cozy bars offer quiet spots. Steak sandwich features real steak, while pork tenderloin sandwich is legendary. Bold flavors shine in the buffalo chicken sandwich. Seating is comfy but some booths feel tight.

Steak sandwich uses real steak, not typical fast food cuts. Buffalo chicken sandwich stands out with bold flavor. Pork tenderloin sandwich has a legendary reputation.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was phenomenal."

"The bar area felt cozy and quiet."

"I had the best meatloaf sandwich I ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour specials are available 7 days a week until 5 pm.

2

The happy hour beer prices are $3 pints.

3

There is plenty of free parking available.

11
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Spacious seating offers a relaxed atmosphere. Sandwiches are often incorrectly made and staff may give inaccurate info. Coupons are accepted, adding a practical touch.

Sandwiches come with custom orders but often arrive incorrectly made. Staff may provide inaccurate information about ingredients.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was good enough."

"I enjoyed a great sandwich here."

Good to know

1

Coupons are accepted at this location, which can save you money.

Discover more

Fishers, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...