Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian food spots in Greenwood

When you want Italian food, you are looking for a meal that respects the tradition of the cuisine without any shortcuts.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The NY Slice image 1
The NY Slice image 2
The NY Slice image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with a friendly, homey atmosphere and a quiet, welcoming vibe. One person handles all orders and cooking, creating a personalized experience. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and reasonable prices, it feels like a local favorite rather than a busy chain.

Food comes out hot and fresh with quick service. It offers delicious, budget-friendly pizza that beats national chains.

Phenomenal cannoli stands out alongside pizza and garlic knots. Sliced Italian sausage adds a perfect touch to many dishes.

People are saying

"I found authentic New York style pizza here."

"This Italian food is the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

"I found the food here to be authentic New York pizza."

Good to know

1

The NY Slice is primarily a carry-out restaurant with limited dine-in options.

2

Prices are very affordable, with family meals available for around $30.

3

The restaurant is usually not busy, allowing for quick service.

02
Chicago's Pizza Greenwood image 1

Buffet-style pizza restaurant with a comfortable casual dining area and private booths. Atmosphere stays relaxing despite being busy, with music and TVs enhancing the experience. Known for breadsticks with cheese and a dessert pizza that stands out.

Great food comes with fresh buffet options and timely service. Breadsticks stand out, and the salad bar offers variety.

Breadsticks with cheese stand out as a highlight, often bought in bulk for their flavor. The pizza and salad bar also deliver solid options, though breadsticks can be a bit doughy if not cooked longer.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was awesome."

"I found the lunch buffet to be fantastic and an amazing deal."

"The lunch buffet food was hot and fresh."

Good to know

1

The lunch buffet costs $12 and is an all-you-can-eat deal.

2

The buffet ends at 1:30 PM, with no new pizzas made after 1 PM.

3

The weekday buffet costs $13 and includes a drink.

03
The Haven at Hickory Stick image 1

Restaurant features modern design with a spacious, sparsely decorated interior that can feel loud during events. Atmosphere shifts from cozy and lovely to energetic when a DJ plays. Bar area lacks TVs, creating a quieter, less inviting space compared to the dining area.

Food arrives quickly and tastes incredible with consistently excellent quality. Service matches the food with a delicious and satisfying dining experience.

Steaks, salads, and pastas stand out with solid flavors. Chicken Parmesan comes thin and overdone, served with Alfredo pasta instead of marinara sauce.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and amazing."

"The filet was cooked perfectly and very tender."

"The Italian food here is fantastic, especially the mac and cheese bites."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Happy hour features half-price drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of gluten-free options on the menu.

04
Luca Pizza di Roma image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers authentic Italian flavors with pepperoni stuffed breadsticks and calzones standing out. Atmosphere stays casual and friendly with a relaxed pace and low crowd during weekdays. Prices remain affordable, making it a practical choice in a mall setting.

Homemade, handmade Italian food offers consistent, scrumptious taste at great prices. The menu stays simple but delivers quality that suits dining in, takeout, or delivery.

Pepperoni stuffed breadsticks come with cheese and appear often alongside pizza and calzones. Spaghetti and meatballs also feature on the menu. Pricing can be inconsistent at the counter.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be really great."

"You have to try the pepperoni stuffed breadsticks; they're a classic Italian Food."

"I thought the pizza here was the best ever."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is closed on Sundays due to staffing issues.

2

Luca Pizza di Roma is one of the longest-established places at this mall.

3

The price is better than other options in the food court.

05
La Trattoria Italian Restaurant image 1

Cozy space with outdoor seating and no background music creates a quiet, upscale atmosphere. The setting feels more like a coffee shop than a typical Italian restaurant, offering a relaxed vibe for conversation. It attracts diners looking for a charming, intimate experience away from crowded spots.

Food here is consistently delicious and Italian-inspired with a strong focus on quality. Service complements the meals well, making dining smooth and enjoyable.

Fettuccine Alfredo stands out with rich, creamy sauce and generous portions. The menu also features Chicken Alfredo and a sampler with lasagna and manicotti, all served alongside steaks that pair well with the pasta dishes.

People are saying

"I thought the steaks here were perfect and mouth-watering."

"Their pasta dishes, like the Alfredo and lasagna, are the best I've ever eaten."

"The Italian food here is authentic and fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not taken.

2

There was no wait for a table during my visit.

3

The meals are small for the prices charged.

06
Dave & Buster's image 1
Restaurant

Arcade games offer a wide variety for all skill levels with flashing neon lights and large screens showing sports and events. The atmosphere is noisy and energetic, suited for families and groups seeking fun and excitement. Seating areas include open spaces accommodating children alongside adults.

Food comes out hot and fresh with consistently amazing flavors. The menu suits groups of all ages, making it a solid spot for both kids and adults.

Chicken parm pasta features well seasoned, soft chicken with a light alfredo sauce that balances marinara. Other Italian-inspired dishes like flatbread pizza taste fresh and well prepared.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was really good."

"The games here are really fun for kids and adults."

"The chicken parm pasta here is a must-try Italian dish."

Good to know

1

Half-price games and food are available on Wednesdays.

2

Trivia night occurs on Wednesdays, adding to the fun.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere, especially on Wednesdays.

07
The Original Chicagoโ€™s Pizza image 1

Small pizza diner offers a roomy interior with pool tables and a huge sports screen for entertainment. Indian fusion pizzas feature bold spices and fresh toppings, blending traditional flavors with pizza styles. The atmosphere balances casual dining with lively energy from games and sports viewing.

Food here is consistently mouthwatering and quality. It blends Indian flavors with pizza well, offering tasty and visually appealing dishes.

Fish and pasta dishes stand out with solid flavors. The menu also features Paneer tikka masala pizza and Indian style garlic breadsticks, blending Italian and Indian tastes.

People are saying

"The Indian food, especially the butter chicken pizza, was awesome."

"I found the food here to be mouthwatering and awesome."

"Their pizza and pasta were delicious and yummy."

Good to know

1

Dine-in is recommended, but it closes at 9 pm.

2

The kitchen closes at 9:30 pm, so plan accordingly.

3

The restaurant offers both Indian-style and traditional American pizza toppings.

08
Gallagher's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Walk-in pizza spot with no sit-down area and a dingy interior featuring some charming decorations. Atmosphere feels casual and family-oriented, attracting locals who appreciate pizza that stands out from chain stores. Closing hours vary unexpectedly, so timing visits carefully is important.

Food stays consistently fresh and never greasy. The sink pizza stands out as a favorite with great flavor.

Stuffed breadsticks stand out with solid flavor and texture. Pizza and regular breadsticks also hold up well, but the marinara sauce tastes flat and lacks depth.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was top-notch and reminded me of home."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and not greasy."

"The Italian food here is loaded with abundant cheese and toppings."

Good to know

1

Gallagher's Pizza closes at 10 PM, but may close earlier due to high demand.

2

The app indicates they close at 9 PM, which may not be accurate.

3

Expect limited topping availability as they were out of several options.

Discover more

Greenwood, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...