Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Indianapolis' best

Pizza

A pizza made with traditional methods and honest ingredients is the only thing that satisfies.

Based on 456 Opinions
+453
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Magoo's Pizza image 1
Magoo's Pizza image 2
Magoo's Pizza image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Cozy, clean space with a family-friendly atmosphere and thoughtful design creates a welcoming environment. Casual vibe suits relaxed evenings with friends or family. Known for homemade pizza featuring unusual toppings and standout wings, it offers a fresh alternative to typical pizza spots.

Gourmet style pizzas deliver an authentic taste that stands apart from typical chains. Top quality ingredients create a flavor profile that feels genuine and distinct.

Pizza here has a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings with an authentic taste that stands out from typical chains. The Indian chicken pizza is a favorite, and the pepperoni pizza is notably flavorful.

People are saying

"This pizza is so tasty with an amazing cheese pull."

"They surprised us with free, warm cookies, a perfect sweet ending."

"I found the pizza to have a top quality, authentic taste."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during busy dinner hours.

2

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during weekends.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

02
Velly Pizza & Indian street food image 1

Space combines clean, orderly design with a calming, inviting atmosphere enhanced by good music and welcoming energy. Crowd enjoys authentic Indian-inspired pizza and street food with customizable spice levels and halal options. Setting suits quick, flavorful meals with a friendly vibe.

Authentic Punjabi street food shines here with perfectly balanced spices in the fish curry. The pizza tastes well-cooked and genuine, capturing real, authentic flavors.

Tandoori chicken pizza and achari paneer pizza stand out with authentic, well-cooked flavors. The pizzas offer reasonable pricing and include tasty vegetarian options that appeal to all ages.

People are saying

"I've never tasted pizza this good; it's the best I've ever had."

"I tasted authentic street food from Punjab, perfectly cooked."

"I received the best service I've ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer halal options and allow you to customize the spice level.

2

The pricing is reasonable with a 2 large pizza, 3 toppings deal.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

03
Mia pizzaria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-owned pizza restaurant offers New York style pizza in a cozy atmosphere with a huge TV for sports. The place serves both meat and plant-based options, with food made from scratch and handled delivery. Cleanliness and friendly staff contribute to a welcoming environment.

Crust strikes a balance between not too thin and not too thick with an authentic taste. Pizza captures the true New York-style flavor found rarely outside the city.

Thin crust stands out with its authentic Italian style and homemade pizza sauce that pairs well for dipping. Pepperoni and other toppings come halal, making the menu versatile and flavorful.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza has a perfectly thin, flavorful crust."

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and flavorful."

"This pizza has that authentic New York-style crust."

Good to know

1

They currently have a $10 lunch special that includes a slice of NY pizza, 3 breadsticks, and a 20 oz drink.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

3

Mia Pizzaria is a family-owned local business with a focus on quality.

04
PUNJABI SWEET SHOP/SPICY DONER image 1

Small, cafe-style space with large booths and an open kitchen view creates a cozy, welcoming vibe. Contemporary Indian music plays loudly, adding energy to the atmosphere. The setting feels like dining at a friend's house with family-owned warmth.

Offers authentic North Indian flavors with recipes true to the region. Combines top quality food with warm hospitality in a family-friendly setting.

Butter chicken pizza stands out as hot, fresh, and really good. The menu includes chicken and Paneer pizzas and offers desi-style pizzas considered better than those in GTA.

People are saying

"The lamb shawarma here is so flavorful and tender."

"I found the butter chicken pizza to be amazing and awesome."

"The food here has authentic North Indian flavors and tastes homemade."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for a meal for two.

2

Takeout is recommended as dine-in conditions are not ideal.

3

Food quality has been inconsistent recently.

05
Jay Bhavani (Indian Vegetarian Street Food) - Indianapolis image 1

Indian vegetarian street food spot offers a clean, polished interior with a modern touch and a family-friendly atmosphere. The vibe is vibrant and welcoming, capturing the energy of India's street food culture with a casual dining pace. A selfie corner adds a creative, playful element to the space.

Food offers authentic Indian flavors with great quality. Dishes like vada pav and chole bhature deliver fresh, crispy, and flavorful street-food taste.

Bhakri pizza with cheese stands out with its street style vibe. Flavors like vada pav and Indo Chinese dishes taste just like back home.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"I found the food here to be authentic and full of flavor."

"This bhakri pizza tastes just like Mumbai street style pizza."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a wide variety of vegetarian options.

2

Prices are very reasonable, making it budget-friendly.

3

The menu includes south Indian, fast food, and Indo-Chinese cuisine.

06
Red Tacos Taqueria and Birrieria image 1

Mexican restaurant offers a vibrant atmosphere with clean, welcoming interiors and sports on mounted TVs. The space includes an ice cream section attached, adding variety to the experience. Friendly people and a pleasant environment create a lively, inviting vibe.

Tacos deliver authentic Mexican street food flavors with fresh ingredients. The menu offers good quality, bursting with flavor dishes that stay true to traditional recipes.

Birria pizza stands out with its rich, savory taste and a good level of spiciness. Some pizzas deliver strong flavor, while others can lack taste.

People are saying

"The birria here is insanely good; I wished I'd gone sooner."

"The food here is authentic and bursting with flavor."

"The birria pizza here is flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

The menu does not clearly indicate the credit card fee.

2

There is a fee for using credit cards.

3

The tacos now cost $4 each instead of $3.

07
Honest Indianapolis Restaurant image 1

Bright, clean space offers a cozy, authentic vibe with a welcoming atmosphere. The energy ranges from relaxed to lively when crowded. Families find it accommodating with thoughtful touches like a top-screen TV for children.

Food offers authentic North Indian flavors with a focus on vegetarian dishes. The menu captures the essence of Mumbai-style Indian cuisine accurately.

Bakhri pizza stands out with great taste and fresh toppings. Other pizzas like cheese can be bland or overbaked, and sizes vary with some feeling small for the price.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic, flavorful, and delicious vegetarian Indian street food."

"I loved how authentic the food tasted here."

"I definitely recommend ordering the bakhri pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dosa night events to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers customizable dishes for dietary restrictions.

3

Takeout is preferred for a better food experience than dining in.

08
Paco's Taqueria at Fashion Mall image 1

Mexican restaurant offers authentic tacos with corn tortillas and a self-serve salsa bar. Atmosphere feels lively but can be sterile and unwelcoming with loud music and spacious seating. Micheladas stand out as a top drink choice.

Tacos feature corn tortillas, cilantro, onions, and lime for an authentic Mexican style. Family-run with consistently good and authentic flavors across burritos, chips, and queso.

Birria pizza features a crispy shell with a wonderful flavor and is loaded with tender, flavorful meat and cheese. Some versions can be overpacked with non-melting processed cheese, affecting the overall quality.

People are saying

"The burritos here are massive and delicious."

"I found the tacos here to be authentic and well-seasoned."

"I discovered the birria pizza here; it's amazing and tasty."

Good to know

1

Taco Tuesdays offer special pricing on tacos every week.

2

Prices for tacos are around $4 each, which may be considered high by some.

3

The restaurant does not offer fountain drinks, only bottled options.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...