Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indianapolis

Cookie cakes

You aren't looking for a generic dessert, and you know exactly what you want when you crave a cake or a cookie.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 1
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 2
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 3
View all

Small shop with cozy atmosphere and family-friendly vibe offers unique homemade ice cream flavors including dairy-free options. Customers enjoy voting on new flavors and sitting inside or outside on benches. The space feels welcoming and lively, perfect for casual visits.

Carrot cake stands out with a moist texture and rich flavor, often featured in their ice cream cakes. These cakes combine baked carrot cake with creamy ice cream, creating a delicious layered dessert.

Cookies come in Lemon Cream, Snickerdoodle, and Cookies and Cream flavors. Lemon Cream stands out as very tart. Mint Chip, Coffee, Chocolate Cake, and dairy-free options also appear.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here has unique, delicious flavors like cornbread."

"The lemon cream cookie was tart and delicious."

"I loved the ice cream cake; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

All ice cream is made in store daily for freshness.

2

They offer a wide variety of ice cream options, including dairy-free choices.

3

New and unique flavors are regularly introduced.

02
Hazeables image 1
Bakery

Bakery with local artist murals and a pet friendly environment offers a variety of infused and gluten free treats. Atmosphere stays chill and welcoming, attracting families and dog owners alike. Pricing remains reasonable while maintaining a woman-owned business vibe.

Cakes come with creative designs and often include gluten free options like chocolate with strawberry filling. They are consistently moist and tasty, making them popular for birthdays and weddings.

Little pig cookies stand out for their charm and flavor, often disappearing quickly. Red Velvet giant cookies attract a lot of attention and satisfy cookie cravings with their size and taste.

People are saying

"The strawberry Tres Leches cake is insanely delicious."

"They're so dog friendly and offer tasty treats for your pupper."

"I could eat the little pig cookies every day."

Good to know

1

Hazeables is a dog-friendly shop.

2

Hazeables offers a variety of puppy treats and infused desserts.

3

The cake and desserts are very reasonably priced.

03
Vanilla Bean Bakery image 1

Cupcakes and cakes are crafted on site with exceptional craftsmanship and can be prepared quickly, even during last-minute orders. The bakery offers a wide variety of treats and includes options like sugar-free cupcakes. The atmosphere supports seamless, enjoyable service with a focus on beautifully designed, delicious baked goods.

Custom designs bring cake visions to life with exceptional craftsmanship. Cakes and cupcakes taste delicious and impress at weddings and birthdays.

Cookies come with personalized decorating and a complete decorating kit that keeps kids busy for hours. The cookies taste delicious and the staff is very friendly.

People are saying

"This cake was gorgeous and tasted even better than it looked."

"I found the bakery easy to work with and appreciated their quick responses."

"The cookie decorating kit had everything needed and entranced my grandkids."

Good to know

1

Sugar-free cupcakes can be made upon request.

2

Expect cupcakes to be ready in about 10 minutes.

3

The bakery can quickly prepare a dozen cupcakes for emergencies.

04
Heidelberg Haus image 1
German restaurant

German restaurant combines cozy, authentic atmosphere with a quirky gift shop filled with knickknacks and gnomes. Space feels tight and lively, with staff in fun outfits enhancing the energy. Offers unique German groceries and pastries alongside dining tables scattered through the store.

Cakes here include German chocolate and Black Forest, both not too sweet and flavorful. Custom cakes like wedding and birthday cakes are made exactly as described, with options like Mandarin cream and Bienenstich.

Cookies here are authentic German treats, often paired with affordable prices. Seasonal options like Christmas cookies stand out alongside classic favorites.

People are saying

"It's a unique place packed with quirky trinkets and German imports."

"I thought the German chocolate cake was delicious."

"I found the cookies here to be soft and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended to avoid sold-out baked goods.

2

Heidelberg Haus has about eight tables, so expect limited seating.

3

The bakery offers a variety of German pastries and desserts that are popular among locals.

05
Taylor's Bakery image 1

Bakery filled with beautiful cake creations and delicious baked goods creates a fun, clean atmosphere packed with people. Known for best cakes and donuts in the area, it draws families and special occasions consistently.

Cakes come out beautiful and delicious with consistent quality. They serve as reliable choices for weddings and birthdays over many years. The taste and appearance stand out as top commercial cakes.

Cookies come with iced sugar decorations and custom designs for events. The chocolate chip cookie with icing in the middle stands out among the selection. Seasonal decorated cookies add variety and visual appeal.

People are saying

"I drive 1.5 hours for their Mardi Gras King Cakes."

"These cookies and cupcakes are delicious!"

"Their cakes are always moist, delicious, and perfect for any celebration."

Good to know

1

The parking situation at the 116th Street location can be problematic.

2

Expect limited stock later in the day; arrive early for best selection.

3

Taylor's Bakery does not offer gluten-free cookies.

06
Cafรฉ Babette image 1

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Cakes feature exceptional icing and artistic decoration that impress visually and in taste. Varieties like coconut and brown butter lemon curd offer balanced sweetness and elegant textures.

Cookies here stand out for their incredible taste and quality. Varieties like the sea salt chocolate chip and s'mores cookie offer rich, memorable flavors that keep people coming back.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"This bakery is the best I've had outside of Europe."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

07
Blondie's Cookies image 1

Cookie shop offers fresh, delicious cookies with a welcoming atmosphere and great energy. The space feels cute and lively, drawing a steady flow of customers who appreciate the quality and variety. Staff bring consistent enthusiasm, enhancing the overall vibe.

Cookie cakes come out quickly and are decorated nicely. Staff like Marcus and Teesha handle last-minute orders with ease, making cakes that look amazing and taste delicious.

Cookies come fresh and delicious with hand decorated shortbread die cuts standing out. Staff show great knowledge and enthusiasm about the treats and deliver fast, attentive service.

People are saying

"The cookies here are soft and baked fresh every morning."

"The staff at this Mall are always so friendly."

"The cookie cake looked amazing and was decorated really nicely."

Good to know

1

Prices for cookies are not clearly displayed, which may lead to unexpected costs.

2

The store offers a promotion: buy 6 cookies and get 1 free.

3

Customer service experiences may vary; some report better treatment than others.

08
Hart Bakery & Gifts image 1

Shop resembles a cozy grandma's house filled with vintage tchotchkes and tacky costume jewelry. Atmosphere invites slow browsing among nostalgic gifts alongside handmade baked goods. Regulars find pecan donuts and blueberry cake stand out for quality and size.

Custom cakes come out exactly like the picture sent, with options like an all-white three-tier cake featuring buttercream icing and rosettes. The cake-making process is impressively quick, often done in about an hour, and the cakes taste divine.

Toffee cookies stand out for their rich flavor and freshness. A wide variety of cookies includes thumbprint options, all offering great value and often accompanied by fresh doughnuts.

People are saying

"I ordered a custom birthday cake that guests loved."

"I've ordered birthday cakes from this bakery for years and they're always a hit."

"You have to try their cookies; they're amazing and huge!"

Good to know

1

Hart Bakery & Gifts accepts EBT for purchases.

2

Pre-ordering is recommended as they often run out of popular items.

3

The quarter sheet cake costs $30.00.

09
The Cheesecake Lady image 1

Small, colorful bakery with a bright, welcoming atmosphere and cheerful decor. The space feels quaint and charming, inviting visitors to enjoy a relaxed, picture-worthy setting. Known for offering a wide variety of cheesecake options with excellent value for the portion sizes.

Biscoff cookies come with cheesecake and caramel, offering a rich combo. Chocolate chip cookie slices sometimes lack flavor, but options like the cinnamon roll cookie and cheesecake cookies stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake was great."

"I tried the cheesecake and it was the best I ever had."

"I thought the cookies were very good."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $5 for small cups to nearly $10 for large cups.

2

A special promotion allows you to buy three cheesecakes and get one free.

3

The shop has a reward card program for repeat customers.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...