Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Indianapolis

Cheesecake spots

A cheesecake that maintains its texture without being overly dense or cloyingly sweet.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Hazeables image 1
Hazeables image 2
Hazeables image 3
View all
Bakery

Bakery with local artist murals and a pet friendly environment offers a variety of infused and gluten free treats. Atmosphere stays chill and welcoming, attracting families and dog owners alike. Pricing remains reasonable while maintaining a woman-owned business vibe.

Baked goods stand out with incredible flavor and a vast variety including puppy treats and infused desserts. Prices stay incredibly reasonable while maintaining delicious quality.

Cheesecakes feature a graham cracker crust layer beneath the filling, offering a twist on the usual style. Mini cheesecakes and flavors like strawberry and Oreo stand out for their rich taste.

People are saying

"The strawberry Tres Leches cake is insanely delicious."

"I found the desserts here to be absolutely amazing."

"The strawberry cheesecake was bomb and so satisfying."

Good to know

1

Hazeables is a dog-friendly shop.

2

Hazeables offers a variety of puppy treats and infused desserts.

3

The cake and desserts are very reasonably priced.

02
Cafรฉ Babette image 1

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

An incredible selection of pies, croissants, and brownies makes choosing tough. Desserts come out gorgeous and worth arriving early for.

Basque cheesecake stands out with its dense and creamy filling and a pastry cream texture like a cloud. The menu also features a Basque-style cheesecake Danish alongside other baked treats.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"The baked goods here are beautiful and delicious."

"This Basque cheesecake is the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

03
Amore! Italian Kitchen image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a warm, relaxing atmosphere with old Italian charm and Edison bulb lighting. The vibe is calm and friendly, filling up without feeling crowded, though it can get loud. Live music and a thoughtful playlist add to the experience.

Italian desserts taste homemade with huge portions. The Turtle Cannoli stands out as a divine choice.

Turtle cheesecake stands out as a rich, satisfying dessert. Other options include raspberry and lemon cheesecakes, with the blueberry sauce on one cheesecake noted as less impressive.

People are saying

"The Italian food service here is fantastic and makes it an experience."

"The desserts here are charming and attentive."

"The cheesecake here is amazing, a perfect ending."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays, wine is half price and there are specials on bolognese.

2

Wednesdays feature live music at the restaurant.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

04
Commission Row image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers modern elegance with tasteful decor and an open kitchen that creates a lively atmosphere. Downstairs speakeasy features live music and a bustling bar scene. Space fills with background noise during dinner, balancing a super chill vibe for events.

Complimentary desserts arrive during birthday dinners, often paired with champagne and a variety of small sweets on a platter.

Desserts include a deep-fried wheel of Brie called Brie cheesecake and a lemon cheesecake. Presentation shows attention to detail.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the steaks cooked perfectly."

"The desserts here were absolutely breathtaking."

"Ben made our anniversary feel so special with his attentiveness."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch, especially on holidays like Father's Day.

2

Movie nights occur every Sunday, providing a fun weekly event.

3

Devour Indy offers a $65 four-course meal, a great deal during the event.

05
Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse image 1

Steakhouse offers a stylish interior with live piano and vocal music that creates an elegant atmosphere. The setting includes a small, quaint bar and options for private dining. The energy suits romantic dates and groups seeking a refined experience.

Meals end with a piping hot Butter Cake that fits well after a full meal. Bread, appetizers, and desserts all come out fantastic.

Cheesecake here comes as a free celebratory slice and a birthday treat. The flavor is over the top delicious and stands out among other dishes like wagyu meatballs and lobster mac n cheese.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be the best I ever had."

"You have to try the butter cake for dessert; it's piping hot."

"The cheesecake here is over the top delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

Dress code is business casual; avoid shorts and athletic wear.

3

Expect to pay around $200 for a meal for two, excluding drinks.

06
Eddie Merlot's image 1
Steak house

Steak house offers a warm and cozy atmosphere with live music enhancing the dining experience. Decor blends classic sophistication and modern chic, creating a setting that suits relaxed conversations and reunions. Guests enjoy high-quality steaks paired with carefully selected wines in a friendly, intimate environment.

Peanut butter cup dessert stands out as a popular choice. Staff often accommodate special dessert requests and offer free desserts for birthdays.

New York cheesecake stands out with a rich, creamy texture. The menu also features a unique turtle cheesecake and a popular carrot cake as dessert options.

People are saying

"The service at dinner spots was great and attentive."

"You have to try the peanut butter cup or crรจme brรปlรฉe desserts."

"Stephen made the night unforgettable; ask for him!"

Good to know

1

Happy Hour is available with special menu items from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

3

Expect a 10-15 minute wait for dinner reservations during peak hours.

07
Slim Chickens image 1
Chicken restaurant

Industrial decor with guitars on walls sets a clean, chill atmosphere. Southern rock and blues music play, creating an upbeat vibe. Outdoor patio offers a relaxed space with string lights enhancing the mood.

Brownie jars stand out as a popular dessert choice, often served in mason jars. Other options include an Oreo milkshake and a birthday cheesecake in a jar, which is tasty but a bit pricey.

Cheesecake comes in mason jars that you can keep. Options include a brownie cheesecake jar and a birthday cheesecake that is tasty but a bit pricey.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was excellent and remarkable."

"I loved their desserts, especially the jar ones."

"The cheesecake in a jar is amazing."

Good to know

1

The price for a basic chicken sandwich meal is over $13 with tax.

2

Expect a 15+ minute wait time during peak hours at the drive-thru.

3

The restaurant is generally clean and well-maintained.

08
The Cheesecake Lady image 1

Small, colorful bakery with a bright, welcoming atmosphere and cheerful decor. The space feels quaint and charming, inviting visitors to enjoy a relaxed, picture-worthy setting. Known for offering a wide variety of cheesecake options with excellent value for the portion sizes.

Cheesecake cups, slices, and stuffed cookies stand out as amazing desserts here. The dessert table service shows exceptional professionalism.

Cheesecakes come in light and airy no-bake fillings and rich baked varieties. Options include cheesecake cups with flavors like strawberry and pumpkin caramel, priced reasonably for their size.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake was great."

"This Woman Owned spot has the freshest, most delicious cheesecake ever."

"I love the make-your-own cheesecake cups, they overflow with goodness."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $5 for small cups to nearly $10 for large cups.

2

A special promotion allows you to buy three cheesecakes and get one free.

3

The shop has a reward card program for repeat customers.

09
Bynum's image 1
Steak house

Rustic lodge interior with charming old-fashioned design and separated bar area creates a cozy setting. Atmosphere varies from quiet and accommodating to occasionally disrupted by loud groups or kitchen noise. Private room offers an excellent option for large parties or intimate gatherings.

Desserts here stand out for their quality and taste. Staff sometimes offer a surprise dessert for celebrations, adding a nice touch.

Cheesecake comes with personalized messages in chocolate for celebrations. Options include white chocolate berry cheesecake. It pairs well with prime rib and steak.

People are saying

"The service at this dinner spot is phenomenal, with great timing and refills."

"The desserts here were a nice end to the meal."

"I was lucky enough to get a bite of the cheesecake, it was superb."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended for larger groups.

2

Parking is extremely limited, so plan to arrive early.

3

Sharing a steak option is available for about $15 with a salad and side.

10
His Place Eatery - Chicken & Waffles, Ribs & Soul food (30th & Shadeland) image 1

Cozy space with a Grandma's kitchen feel and southern soul food style creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere like a family reunion. Bright and clean but with a slightly dated, early 90s look. Busy and lively, it offers a genuine, homey vibe without any frills.

Sweet potato cheesecake stands out with its unique flavor and careful presentation. It offers a dessert experience that feels thoughtful and different from typical cheesecakes.

People are saying

"The American Food here is delicious, with tons of flavor."

"The sweet potato cheesecake was beautiful and topped everything off."

"You have to try the banana pudding for dessert."

Good to know

1

Meals cost at least $20, making it a pricier lunch option.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but check for mobile payment options.

11
Gordons Milkshake Bar image 1
Ice cream shop

Tiny ice cream shop offers high-quality vegan options and unique milkshake presentations that draw attention. Atmosphere feels quiet and intimate but carries a somewhat morbid vibe. Outdoor seating provides space to stand or sit, accommodating small crowds.

Desserts here include milkshakes served in a busy, hectic setting. Wait times can reach 30 minutes, but the spot draws frequent visits for its sweet offerings.

Milkshakes come topped with a real slice of cheesecake, often frozen. Flavors include OREO cheesecake and New York Cheesecake, sometimes paired with mix-ins like peanut butter or brownie cheesecake ice cream.

People are saying

"I thought the milkshakes were thick and delicious."

"The cheesecake milkshake had a frozen slice of cheesecake on top."

"This shake was anything but regular; it was the bomb."

Good to know

1

The milkshakes cost between $7 and $13, and they are very rich and large.

2

Expect a 25-minute wait even with few customers ahead.

3

The menu has unique items, but they often run out.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...