Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Indianapolis

Hush puppy sandwiches

A sandwich shop that serves hush puppies without making you pay for the convenience with a parking ticket.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Broad Ripple Seafood Market image 1
Broad Ripple Seafood Market image 2
Broad Ripple Seafood Market image 3
View all

Small seafood market with a cozy, casual vibe and outdoor patio seating. Atmosphere recalls a coastline fish market but in a relaxed, quiet setting away from busy streets. Known for fresh, high-quality seafood and a compact kitchen serving standout dishes like fish tacos and chowder.

Crispy and light, the hush puppies have a smooth texture and a pepper finish. They come fresh and flavorful, pairing well with seafood dishes like blackened grouper sandwiches and tacos.

Fish sandwiches stand out with blackened grouper that is tender, sweet, and flaky. The pork tenderloin and lobster roll sandwiches also deliver strong flavors with fresh toppings like lettuce, onion, and tomato.

People are saying

"I thought the seafood here was the best I've had in a long time."

"You have to try the blackened grouper sandwich; it's perfectly cooked."

"The Hush Puppies here are fresh, light, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The seafood market offers a variety of fresh seafood options daily.

2

The seafood is sourced directly from boats, ensuring freshness.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of seafood offered.

02
Santiagoโ€™s Seafood Market image 1

Bright, clean space with an open concept and attractive decorations creates a welcoming, lively atmosphere. Casual setting where ordering happens at the counter and food arrives hot and fast. Family-run vibe adds lighthearted energy, with fresh seafood and generous portions defining the experience.

Homemade hush puppies stand out with a crispy exterior and soft interior. They pair well with fried shrimp and house-made sides like potato salad and coleslaw.

Fish sandwiches come blackened or fried and taste very fresh. Options include grilled walleye and catfish, served with sides like greens or fries.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh."

"The hush puppies were delicious and a bit sweet."

"The fish sandwich here is delicious and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

Bring cash as there is a service fee for credit card payments.

2

Expect generous portion sizes that provide good value for the price.

3

The seafood selection includes a variety of fresh fish and shellfish.

03
Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen at The AMP image 1

Seafood kitchen inside an industrial-style food mall offers outside dining and a functional atmosphere with music that can be loud. The menu features fried fish and oysters praised for quality, alongside satisfying sides like hush puppies and fries. It attracts diners before closing time, with some challenges around ordering online and entry visibility.

Fries, cornbread, and hush puppies stand out as the best sides. The hush puppies have corn mixed in and are consistently on point.

Fish sandwiches like chicken and perch come with flaky fish that often falls off the bread. Using a kaiser roll or similar bun helps keep the sandwich together better.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and well-portioned."

"The hush puppies had some corn in them."

"The cod sandwich was amazing as usual."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended to avoid being turned away.

2

The restaurant closes at 8pm, but customers may be turned away if they arrive close to closing time.

3

Expect to pay around $42 for two cod sandwiches, fries, and drinks.

04
Caplingers Fresh Catch image 1

Small seafood market with cozy indoor seating and a covered outdoor picnic area featuring fans and light jazz music. Atmosphere feels like a southern beach restaurant, warm and family-friendly but can get crowded at the counter. Offers a fresh seafood display reminiscent of coastal markets.

Great texture stands out in the hush puppies here. They pair well with the Caplinger's fish sandwich for a solid combo.

Fish sandwiches stand out with options like fried cod, catfish po boy, and haddock. The PoBoy Shrimp sandwich pairs well with round buffalo potatoes for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I thought the seafood here was the best in Indiana."

"The Hush Puppies here are sweet, flavorful, and cooked perfectly."

"The fish sandwich is seasoned perfectly and delicious."

Good to know

1

You can buy fresh seafood to take home or have it cooked for you.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Prices are reasonable considering the quality of seafood available.

05
Caplingers Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen image 1

Trailer-style setup with outdoor picnic tables creates a casual, family-friendly vibe. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, suited for groups including kids. Menu offers fresh, well-fried seafood with generous portions and fair prices.

Creamy and sweet hush puppies come served alongside seafood dishes. They pair well with fried catfish and gator bites, adding a comforting texture and mild sweetness to the meal.

Fish sandwiches include options like fried catfish, perch, and Basa fish. Some sandwiches come with sides like fried okra and cole slaw. Bread is sometimes not freshly toasted and fish can be rubbery.

People are saying

"I thought the food was excellent and always delicious."

"The seafood here is fresh, tasty, and some of the best I've had."

"I thought the fish sandwich was the best in town."

Good to know

1

The menu features a variety of fresh fish and seafood options.

2

Portions are generous and prices are considered fair.

3

Outdoor seating is available for guests.

06
Taste This Fish image 1
Restaurant

Small seafood spot offers fresh, flavorful fish with cornmeal breading and fried green tomatoes. Clean environment supports carry-out only service with TV trays for eating in. Portions are generous, and parking is available behind the restaurant.

Hush puppies come fried and sometimes soggy, with a mix of perfectly seasoned and less crisp batches. They appear alongside fried catfish and jumbo shrimp, adding a classic southern touch to the meal.

Pork chop sandwich hits the mark with solid flavor. Fried fish sandwiches come out crispy, well seasoned, and flaky inside.

People are saying

"I've had the best fish I've ever tasted right here."

"The hush puppies here are the best I've ever had."

"I found this sandwich to be a hidden gem."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the back of the restaurant.

2

Parking on 25th Street is busy and limited, so be prepared for challenges.

3

I never waited more than 10 to 15 minutes for my order.

07
The Good Spot image 1
American restaurant

Cozy spot with board games and multiple TVs creates a welcoming, chill atmosphere. Interior feels clean and friendly despite a rough exterior. Energy stays warm and unbothered, making it easy to relax and enjoy food or sports.

Hush puppies come out crispy and flavorful, though sometimes a bit hard. They pair well with fish dishes and fresh drinks.

Tenderloin sandwiches stand out with generous pickles and a tender, juicy texture. Other options include Philly cheese steak, beef Manhattan, Chicago dog, BLT, and grilled ham and cheese sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is really, really good."

"I found the tenderloin sandwich to be delicious."

"I thought the Hush Puppies were some of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

3

The venue is cashless and only accepts card payments.

08
City Barbeque image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue restaurant offers indoor booths and outdoor sidewalk seating with blues and juke joint music playing softly. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with a laid-back vibe suitable for casual dining. Drive-thru service adds convenience alongside comfortable, friendly surroundings.

Hush puppies come out with mixed results, sometimes wonderful and other times overdone. Staff shows care when issues arise with them.

Pulled pork and brisket sandwiches come generously stacked with smokey flavor and packed high. Sandwich options include the More Cowbell and turkey, which reheats well without losing taste.

People are saying

"The brisket and pulled pork here are tender and delicious American Food."

"I thought their pulled pork sandwich was very good."

"The hush puppies were incredible."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru option provides fast service for those on the go.

2

Expect to pay around $30 for a rib order, which may not be enough for larger groups.

3

They often run out of one or two menu items during busy hours.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...