Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Indianapolis

Sandwiches

A stacked sandwich is the only thing that makes sense when the hunger is real.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
New York Gourmet deli image 1
New York Gourmet deli image 2
New York Gourmet deli image 3
View all

Traditional New York style deli offers a chill vibe and clean interior. Enjoy authentic atmosphere and unique meats. Sandwiches like chopped cheese and roast beef come fast and fresh with great flavor.

Large selection of sandwiches and wraps includes standout options like the chopped cheese and roast beef sandwiches. Sandwiches come fast, fresh, and consistently deliver great flavor.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and affordable."

"This deli's New York style made me feel like I was back in NYC."

"I found the Philly Cheesesteak flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

The deli is takeout only, with no seating available.

2

Breakfast dishes are served all day, a unique feature of the deli.

3

Platters are only available during breakfast hours.

02
Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop image 1

Sandwich shop offers fresh ciabatta bread and high-quality meats like prosciutto and Cajun turkey. Friendly staff serve warm sandwiches quickly at reasonable prices. Enjoy awesome views and a relaxing vibe in a clean, cute space popular with office crowds.

Fresh, toasted ciabatta bread forms the base for sandwiches like prosciutto and mozzarella and Cajun Turkey and Roast Pork. Friendly staff serve tasty, warm sandwiches quickly at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best downtown."

"I thought the food was really fresh and delicious."

"The staff here are the sweetest people during breakfast."

Good to know

1

The cafe is located inside the Regions Bank lobby.

2

The prices for breakfast sandwiches are reasonable.

3

They use high-quality Boar's Head meats for their sandwiches.

03
Don Juan V's Peruvian Sandwiches image 1

Sandwich shop serves authentic Peruvian cuisine with generous portions and unique sandwiches like Pavo and Lomo Saltado. Atmosphere is lively and family-friendly despite a modest setting. Food is made to order with flavorful options beyond typical fast food.

Peruvian sandwiches stand out with options like the Pavo and Lomo Saltado sandwiches, both rich and filling. The chicharrones sandwich offers a unique taste, and the vegetarian sandwich features sweet potatoes for a flavorful twist.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and loaded with fresh flavor."

"The Lomo Saltado sandwich is one of the tastiest things I've had."

"I found the ceviche to be amazing and fresh."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is only open on Saturdays and Sundays.

2

The food takes 15-20 minutes to prepare, as it is made to order.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere, especially around noon on weekends.

04
Tam's Sweet & Savory Café image 1

Cozy, eclectic vibe shines with vintage mix-and-match plates and a peaceful back patio. Sandwiches stand out with jalapeño jam and lox and bagel options, perfect for vegetarians. Intimate setting feels like breakfast at a friend's home, offering a quaint, inviting experience.

Sandwiches feature vegetarian options like a breakfast sandwich with jalapeño jam and a lox and bagel choice. Lunch specials include a chicken salad sandwich and a bacon egg and cheese variety.

People are saying

"The quiche crust is flaky and buttery, just like the eggs are fluffy."

"The strawberry salad with lemon vinaigrette is fantastic."

"I loved the egg salad sandwich with fig jam."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in an adjacent lot for visitors.

2

The café is open Wednesday through Sunday from 8am to 2pm.

3

The café accommodates dietary restrictions and offers a variety of options.

05
Broad Ripple Seafood Market image 1

Small seafood market offers a cozy vibe with outdoor patio seating and fresh, high-quality seafood. Fish sandwiches shine with blackened grouper that is tender and flaky, while standout dishes like fish tacos and chowder add variety. Atmosphere feels like a quiet coastline fish market.

Fish sandwiches stand out with blackened grouper that is tender, sweet, and flaky. The pork tenderloin and lobster roll sandwiches also deliver strong flavors with fresh toppings like lettuce, onion, and tomato.

People are saying

"I thought the seafood here was the best I've had in a long time."

"You have to try the blackened grouper sandwich; it's perfectly cooked."

"The chowder at this Lunch Spot is delicious and not fishy."

Good to know

1

The seafood market offers a variety of fresh seafood options daily.

2

The seafood is sourced directly from boats, ensuring freshness.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of seafood offered.

06
Daisy Bar image 1
Restaurant

Indoor and outdoor dining create a big city feel with a pet friendly vibe. Burgers and wraps shine, especially the peri-peri chicken Caesar. Music like Tame Impala adds a top-tier vibe that draws a diverse crowd.

Burgers, sandwiches, and wraps stand out with tofu, steak, and peri-peri chicken Caesar options. All sandwiches come with a choice to be served as wraps, offering variety and flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the burger was amazing, maybe the best thing I had."

"I found the cocktails here to be bright, refreshing, and perfectly balanced."

"I found the steak sandwich to be divine."

Good to know

1

Table service is available during special events like New Year's Eve.

2

The snack bar deal is only offered from 3 to 4:30 pm on weekdays.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

07
Amore Mio Italian Subs and Espresso Bar image 1

Italian deli cafe offers huge sandwiches like Sicilian subs packed with authentic flavors. Cozy, spotless decor and authentic Italian music create a warm, inviting vibe. Quality espresso options add to the peaceful, friendly atmosphere.

Sandwiches come toasted and huge, packed with authentic Italian flavors. The Sicilian and Italian sub sandwiches are especially large and flavorful, enough to share or last for two meals.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are huge and packed with fresh meat."

"I enjoyed the true Italian espresso and gelato."

"I enjoyed an amazing cappuccino."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers authentic Italian beverages and desserts.

2

The portion sizes are very large, especially for sandwiches.

3

They have a loyalty program for frequent customers.

08
Sully's Grill at Sullivan Hardware & Garden image 1

Restaurant inside a hardware store offers a cozy vibe with hanging plants and outdoor seating. Neighborhood crowd enjoys bold steak and brisket sandwiches with a kick of heat. Relaxed, kid-friendly spot serves strong mimosas and quirky decor.

Steak and brisket sandwiches stand out with bold flavors and a kick of heat. The open face mushroom and Croque Monsieur breakfast sandwiches offer unique options alongside solid chicken sandwiches.

People are saying

"I was surprised by the high-quality food inside this hardware store."

"You can grab a beer and enjoy the ambiance."

"I found the brisket sandwich to be flavorful with a nice kick."

Good to know

1

Sully's Grill offers a French-inspired menu with expertly paired wines.

2

Reservations are recommended for special events like wine dinners.

3

The restaurant serves a three-course meal during special classes.

09
Movable FEAST image 1
American restaurant

Space blends bohemian decor with quirky art for a fun, cool vibe. Sandwiches like chicken and ahi tuna steak shine with great flavor and fair prices. Quick service and diverse food options make it a solid casual lunch spot.

Chicken and ahi tuna steak sandwiches stand out with great flavor and reasonable prices. Options like the New Orleans and Chicken Salad sandwiches add variety to a menu known for consistent quality.

People are saying

"I love supporting this small local business."

"You have to try the outrageous cookies here."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was the best I've had in years."

Good to know

1

Parking is simple and convenient for visitors.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to typical sandwich shops.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of takeout options and soup kits.

10
Slammyz image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers juicy chicken and affordable prices with a fun, rock-themed decor. Carryout only, some outdoor seating fits the artsy vibe. Sandwiches range from classic to innovative like My Chicken Romance with hot honey.

Juicy chicken and tender meat stand out in the sandwiches. Prices stay affordable, with options like the My Chicken Romance sandwich featuring hot honey and provolone.

People are saying

"I had the best pulled sandwich of my life here."

"The food here is great and reasonably priced."

"I'll definitely come back for the no-bake cookie."

Good to know

1

Slammyz is carryout only, with no seating available inside.

2

Expect to pick up your order in about 5-10 minutes.

3

The total cost for a sandwich and large Mac & Cheese is around $13.

11
Amberson Coffee & Grocer image 1

Small coffee shop in a repurposed gas station offers specialty coffee with a calm, friendly vibe and dog-friendly patio. Breakfast sandwiches feature fresh eggy fillings and creamy sauce for a rich taste. Rustic design and vintage signs add to the cozy, cool atmosphere.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with freshly made eggy fillings and a creamy sauce that adds rich flavor. These sandwiches consistently deliver a high-quality, satisfying bite.

People are saying

"The espresso here is always dialed in and delicious."

"It's a cool little coffee shop with a great vibe."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was one of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Amberson Coffee & Grocer uses reusable jars for to-go coffee instead of paper cups.

2

The cafe has limited seating, so plan to visit during off-peak hours.

3

They charge $17 for two lattes, so budget accordingly.

12
Midday Deli & Catering image 1

Small shop offers bold flavors in sandwiches like brisket and Midday Melt. Lunch specials bundle sandwich, soup, and drink for about $15. Atmosphere feels like a small town spot with fresh, in-house made food and steady lunch energy.

Sandwiches come with bold flavors and are quite filling. Options like the brisket sandwich and Midday Melt stand out, with lunch specials bundling a sandwich, soup, and drink for about $15.

People are saying

"Their sandwiches are flavorful and filling."

"The chicken chili soup was just okay, kind of meh."

"The Southwest Salad is amazing for lunch."

Good to know

1

Daily specials are offered, providing a unique meal option each day.

2

Lunch specials are around $15, including a soup, sandwich, and drink.

3

Most items are made in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

13
Grill & Fried image 1
Restaurant

Food truck serves generous portions of fresh, flavorful dishes at great prices. Casual, welcoming vibe suits quick meals. Sandwiches shine with grilled vegetables and unique noodle Aloo Taki options, blending health and bold flavors.

The grilled vegetable sandwich stands out as a healthy option and suits vegetarians well. The noodle Aloo Taki sandwich offers a unique taste with a mix of veggies and paneer cheese.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and flavorful."

"The food trucks here serve fresh, flavorful food that's cooked to order."

"I thought the noodle Aloo Taki sandwich had a different taste."

Good to know

1

Grill & Fried offers flavorful, fresh, and comforting food at great prices.

2

Expect generous portions that provide good value for the price.

3

The menu features a limited selection but focuses on quality.

14
Taqueria El Barrigon image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small Mexican spot with a modern chic vibe and vivid art. Known for exceptional tacos like al pastor and carnitas, plus special salsas. Mexico City-style leg sandwiches offer bold flavors that satisfy.

Mexico City-style leg sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. The Spanish pork leg sandwich and tacos al pastor deliver bold, satisfying tastes.

People are saying

"I thought the tacos were out of this world, especially the pastor."

"I found the tacos here to be authentic Mexico City-style."

"I found the Mexico City-style sandwiches delicious and authentic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of homemade salsas.

2

The portions are generous, ensuring good value for money.

3

Expect a clean and welcoming environment.

15
SAMMICH SHOP image 1
Sandwich shop

Generous portions highlight exceptional corned beef and steak sandwiches with a tangy sauerkraut twist. Local, black-owned vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere. Classic sides like home fries and pickle chips round out the hearty meal.

Corned beef and steak sandwiches stand out with exceptional flavor and rich texture. Sauerkraut adds a surprising tangy twist that enhances the overall taste.

People are saying

"I found the corned beef Reuben to be fabulous."

"I highly recommend the food here."

"I had the most delicious sandwich ever!"

Good to know

1

The shop offers a variety of sandwiches with vegetarian options available.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for convenience.

3

Takeout is available, making it easy to grab a meal on the go.

16
CM Korean Fried Chicken (indianapolis) image 1

Cozy spot with crispy fried chicken shines for takeout and quick bites. Spicy garlic sandwiches offer balanced heat without overpowering flavor. Small seating and lively music create a simple, inviting vibe for a tasty, casual meal.

Spicy garlic sandwiches deliver a huge portion with a creeping balanced spice that does not overpower flavor. Chicken sandwiches and garlic soy chicken legs stand out as super tasty options.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and amazing."

"I thought the fried chicken here was the best I'd ever had."

"I found the spicy garlic sandwich really good and huge."

Good to know

1

This location is primarily a takeout restaurant, but it has a small dining area.

2

Expect food to be ready within 10 minutes after ordering.

3

CM Chicken offers affordable lunch specials, such as a 3-piece wing or tender meal with fries for $11.99.

17
Chai & Kathi Roll Lounge image 1

Spacious lounge with comfortable seating and a pool table offers a relaxed vibe blending modern coffee shop and desi hangout styles. Bold flavors shine in the chili paneer roll and aloo masala sandwich. A soundproof room provides quiet space for work or calls.

Chili paneer roll and aloo masala sandwich stand out with bold flavors. Options include paneer sandwich, chicken roll, and spinach corn sandwich, offering a mix of classic and Indo-Chinese tastes.

People are saying

"I loved their Masala Chai, it reminded me of home-cooked food."

"The food here is fantastic and delicious."

"The paneer grilled sandwich is delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers unique kathi rolls and wraps, perfect for a quick snack.

2

Expect smaller portion sizes, providing about 75% filling in wraps and rolls.

3

No napkins or spoons are provided, so plan accordingly.

18
WildFyre Tap image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill offers a laid-back vibe with unique art and pinball machines. Sandwiches like pastrami and buffalo chicken come fresh with crispy fries. Lighting and music keep conversations private, making it both chill and fun.

Pastrami, pulled pork, and buffalo chicken sandwiches stand out here. The kitchen crafts solid sandwiches like the WildFyre Chicken and curry chicken salad, all served fresh with crispy fries.

People are saying

"The pinball machines here are so well maintained and fun to play."

"The American food here, especially the tater tots, is amazing."

"I thought the pulled pork sandwich was the best on the planet."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drinks are available with special pricing from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Karaoke night starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of customizable entrees for all dietary needs.

19
Fitzgerald's Lunch House image 1

Sandwich shop shines with perfectly grilled Cuban and fresh meats. Light, artful vibe with owner-created art sets a welcoming tone. Outdoor patio offers shady seating for relaxed lunches amid a friendly, lowkey energy.

Sandwiches come with fresh cuts of meat and are grilled perfectly, especially the Cuban. The Rooster and chicken salad sandwiches offer great texture and flavorful, quick lunches.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and made fresh to order."

"This lunch spot's food is excellent and flavorful."

"The Cuban sandwich was grilled perfectly with actual cuts of meat."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is only open for lunch from Monday through Friday.

2

Expect a crowd during lunch hours as the restaurant is getting more popular.

3

The menu offers a variety of flavorful options for all taste preferences.

20
Luna & Sol Breakfast and Lunch Restaurant image 1

Small space with intimate seating and an open kitchen creates a cozy vibe. Fried chicken torta with fried cheese and a perfectly sauced Reuben shine among sandwiches. Seating fits small groups, making it feel like a welcoming kitchen setting.

Fried chicken torta sandwich features fried cheese on the bun. The Reuben sandwich has the right amount of sauce on toasted bread. Club sandwich and eggs come out perfectly cooked.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is perfection, especially the cinnamon roll pancakes."

"It's a small space, which makes it feel really cozy."

"I thought the Reuben sandwich was perfect, with the right amount of sauce."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the back of the restaurant.

2

There is parking available in front and back of the restaurant.

3

The restaurant has limited seating.

21
Super Pollo Restaurant image 1

Small space with beautiful decor and a cozy vibe invites easy conversation. Hawaiian torta shines as a mammoth sandwich with plenty of seasoned fries. Friendly atmosphere and subtle music make dining relaxed and enjoyable.

The Hawaiian torta stands out as a mammoth sandwich with a generous portion and comes with plenty of seasoned fries. The buffalo chicken sandwich offers a tasty option but could use a bit more sauce.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has fresh, delicious food like amazing chilaquiles."

"These fish tacos are unbelievably flavorful and delicious."

"The sandwich portions are huge and come with seasoned fries."

Good to know

1

The menu includes a wide variety of options, from Mexican to American dishes.

2

Prices are very affordable, with meals averaging around $50 for a family.

3

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and organized facilities.

22
Tsaocaa Indianapolis image 1
Bubble tea store

Cozy layout with spiral staircase and loft seating invites relaxation or study. Fried chicken sandwiches are amazing and affordable at about $6.50. Playful touches like a cotton candy machine add fun to the family room feel.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with fried chicken that tastes amazing and costs about $6.50. Large sizes are available, making them easy to share.

People are saying

"I thought the bubble tea here was the best I ever had."

"I thought the fried chicken was crunchy and life-changing."

"Their chicken sandwich is so crunchy and delicious."

Good to know

1

On weekends, they have mochi doughnuts.

2

The fried chicken sandwich costs $6.50, which is a great deal.

3

You can order online using the posbank machine.

23
Café 251 image 1

Bright, clean space offers hearty Club sandwich with quality ingredients and a variety of healthy options. Busy lunch crowd enjoys quick service and a lively atmosphere perfect for people watching. Menu also features balanced breakfast sandwiches and fresh salads.

Hearty and well-made, the Club sandwich offers a filling meal with good quality ingredients. Breakfast sandwiches feature bread that balances well without overpowering, though some find them a bit dry and bland.

People are saying

"I found the salads and produce to be really fresh."

"The staff really understood my breakfast sandwich order perfectly."

"It's a great lunch spot with plenty of options."

Good to know

1

Café 251 is located in the Capitol Center building on the first floor facing New York Street.

2

The breakfast burrito costs only $5 for a reasonable size.

3

The place can be busy during lunch hours, but the line moves quickly.

24
Harrison’s image 1
Restaurant

Renovated bank building offers a unique dining setting with a preserved vault room. Chicken parm sandwich delivers rich flavor and pairs well with soup. Spacious outdoor patio provides a quiet spot with water served in upcycled liquor bottles.

Chicken parm sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Italian panini comes with crispy fries on the side. Sandwiches pair well with soup for a simple meal.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is terrific, especially the chicken dishes."

"My steak was perfectly cooked and delicious."

"I found the Italian panini sandwich delicious and very good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially for larger groups.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Tuesday is steak night with special pricing on steak dishes.

25
Tinker Coffee on Market image 1

Modern space with comfortable seating and a warm vibe draws those seeking inventive coffee flavors. Breakfast sandwiches shine with herb mayo and fresh ingredients, making it a great spot to work or meet friends.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with herb mayo and fresh ingredients. The Cheapside sandwich offers a flavorful, satisfying start to the day.

People are saying

"The coffee here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

"I thought their breakfast sandwiches with different sauces were great."

"I had the best breakfast sandwich I ever had."

Good to know

1

Tinker Coffee opens at 6 a.m., perfect for early workers.

2

The coffee shop offers free Wi-Fi, making it a good spot for working.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

26
Guggman Haus Brewing Co. image 1

Brewery shines with standout IPAs and a lively atmosphere featuring live music and community vibes. Sandwiches impress, especially the BBQ Tofu with rich flavor and the pulled pork with generous portions. Spacious indoor and outdoor seating, including a patio area, invites relaxation and fun.

BBQ Tofu sandwich stands out as a favorite with rich flavor. Pulled pork sandwich offers ample portions and pairs well with fries. Chicken sandwich features a peppercorn aioli that adds a tasty kick.

People are saying

"The IPAs here are top tier, with a distinctive flavor."

"The food here is fantastic and pretty good."

"I considered the BBQ Tofu sandwich one of my favorite items."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy with plenty of space available at the brewery.

2

The brewery is kid and pet-friendly, making it a great family spot.

3

Trivia nights are held weekly, providing a fun evening activity.

27
IndyMeat Wrap and Over Rice image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Food truck offers halal Middle Eastern dishes with generous portions in a quiet atmosphere. Steak sandwiches deliver rich flavor and satisfying texture, while chicken wraps provide a full flavor experience. Perfect for late-night cravings with authentic gyro and rice plates.

Steak sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and a satisfying texture. Chicken wraps also offer a full flavor experience, making sandwiches here consistently tasty and well-prepared.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"I found the falafel wrap packed with fresh veggies and sauce."

"The steak sandwich was very good and juicy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead is recommended as they may open later than 3PM.

2

The food truck serves halal and kosher options, including chicken, steak, gyro, falafel, fries, and rice.

3

Expect generous portions; one dish can often provide two meals.

28
Shani’s Secret Chicken image 1
Chicken restaurant

Super comfy and quiet atmosphere sets a relaxed mood. Fried chicken dishes are incredibly flavorful and fresh. Chicken sandwich offers rich flavor and satisfying texture for an amazing taste.

Chicken sandwich stands out with its rich flavor and satisfying texture. It consistently delivers a very good and amazing taste experience.

People are saying

"I found the food outstanding, especially the fried chicken."

"I thought the fried chicken here was the best I ever had."

"I found the chicken sandwich here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Dishes cost around $4 for a small serving of plain rice.

2

Expect a longer wait time as food is made fresh.

3

Shani’s Secret Chicken is located inside a place called Chapati.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...