Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Castleton

Sandwich spots

A sandwich made with fresh, substantial ingredients that actually holds together instead of falling apart after the first bite.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Super Pollo Restaurant image 1
Super Pollo Restaurant image 2
Super Pollo Restaurant image 3
View all

Small space with beautiful decor and a relaxed, cozy vibe. Friendly atmosphere supports easy conversation with subtle background music. Clean and well-organized environment enhances the welcoming feel.

Food offers excellent flavor with fresh ingredients. Menu includes Mexican, Italian, and Spanish cuisine plus comforting mac and cheese.

The Hawaiian torta stands out as a mammoth sandwich with a generous portion and comes with plenty of seasoned fries. The buffalo chicken sandwich offers a tasty option but could use a bit more sauce.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has fresh, delicious food like amazing chilaquiles."

"I thought the food here was delicious."

"The sandwich portions are huge and come with seasoned fries."

Good to know

1

The menu includes a wide variety of options, from Mexican to American dishes.

2

Prices are very affordable, with meals averaging around $50 for a family.

3

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and organized facilities.

02
Bugambilias Mexican Cuisine image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small dining room offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with colorful, festive decor and authentic character. Background features quiet Spanish music and TVs showing sports, creating a warm, welcoming vibe. Tables sit close, encouraging a lively but comfortable energy.

Food here offers authentic Mexican flavors with consistently amazing taste. The menu delivers delicious dishes that satisfy every time.

Huge sandwiches serve as full meals with soft Cemita rolls that hold up well to avocado, tomato, beans, and sauces. The Milanesa with steak stands out as a popular choice, often recommended by waiters.

People are saying

"I thought their Mexican food was the best I've ever had."

"I thought the food here was amazing."

"Their Cemita sandwiches are huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bugambilias is closed on Tuesdays.

2

There was hardly any parking at Bugambilias.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred for tips.

03
Mr. Shawarma image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Middle Eastern restaurant offers a clean, inviting space with relaxed, positive vibes and moderate music volume. The atmosphere feels authentic and warm, reminiscent of urban shops in Amman or the UK. It attracts those seeking family-friendly dining with a welcoming environment.

Food centers on shawarma and falafel with a focus on high pride in quality and service. The dishes come across as delicious and straightforward, emphasizing authentic flavors.

Juicy sandwiches pack a nice kick with beef and chicken shawarma options. Coleslaw comes with the box but can make the sandwich a bit soggy, and only two pieces of french fries are included inside the sandwich.

People are saying

"I found the Mediterranean food's shawarma to be the best I've ever had."

"This shawarma food is the best I have ever had."

"I thought the chicken shawarma sandwich was the best."

Good to know

1

Mr. Shawarma offers generous portions at fair prices.

2

The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming dining area.

3

Mr. Shawarma is open on Thanksgiving for those looking for a meal.

04
Chai & Kathi Roll Lounge image 1

Spacious lounge with comfortable seating and a pool table creates a relaxed environment. Warm, inviting atmosphere blends modern coffee shop style with a desi hangout vibe. Separate soundproof room offers quiet space for work or calls.

Food features authentic Indian street flavors with options to adjust spice levels. Quality is consistently excellent and the menu includes delicious chai alongside savory dishes.

Chili paneer roll and aloo masala sandwich stand out with bold flavors. Options include paneer sandwich, chicken roll, and spinach corn sandwich, offering a mix of classic and Indo-Chinese tastes.

People are saying

"I loved their Masala Chai, it reminded me of home-cooked food."

"The food here is fantastic and delicious."

"The paneer grilled sandwich is delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers unique kathi rolls and wraps, perfect for a quick snack.

2

Expect smaller portion sizes, providing about 75% filling in wraps and rolls.

3

No napkins or spoons are provided, so plan accordingly.

05
Mama saaj and gyro image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Restaurant inside an international grocery store offers freshly made Middle Eastern dishes with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Food court setting includes diverse ethnic options and generous portions at reasonable prices. Energy is casual, with a single employee often managing service.

Food features authentic Middle Eastern flavors with dishes like gyro that are flavorful and tender. Preparation takes longer than fast food but results in delicious, satisfying meals.

Chicken shawarma sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and a well-balanced mix of ingredients, including tomatoes that complement the taste even for those who usually avoid them.

People are saying

"The chicken shawarma here is juicy, flavorful, and perfectly grilled."

"I found the food here to be amazing and incredibly satisfying."

"This gyro sandwich had the best seasoned meat I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is located inside an international grocery store, functioning like a food court.

2

Expect generous portion sizes that can easily feed multiple people.

3

Prices are very reasonable compared to the portion sizes.

06
Bearded Bagel image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop offers fresh bagels with generous portions and cream cheese alongside espresso coffee. Atmosphere feels quiet and chill with a hole-in-the-wall vibe and spartan seating suited for quick meals. Customers enjoy friendly staff and a warm, familiar environment despite modest decor.

Food stands out for its excellent quality and delicious flavors. Service remains great even during busy times.

Breakfast and lunch sandwiches come all day with a fantastic selection. The bagel sandwiches feature pepper jelly and chipotle cream cheese that stand out for their flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I've ever eaten."

"The food here is super good and tasty."

"I thought the bagel sandwiches were the best I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Expect a 25-minute wait for sandwiches around 11:30 AM on Saturdays.

2

Online orders may not process correctly, so check your card charges.

3

The food truck is popular at local events and offers a great selection.

07
Hanna’s Banh Mi bakery and Cafe image 1

Modern Vietnamese cafe with clean, beautiful decor and a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Music plays softly while people relax on comfy benches or gather in lounge areas. The vibe feels authentic and peaceful, making it suitable for casual dining or quiet moments.

Offers a spread of banh mi sandwiches, mochi donuts, and traditional Vietnamese Chè for dessert. Food reflects authentic Vietnamese street foods and homemade meals.

Crispy pork stands out with fresh baked bread and fillings packed with meat and vegetables. Both banh mi and BLT sandwiches taste fresh and come loaded with crispy textures and delicious fillings.

People are saying

"I thought the grilled pork banh mi was out of this world."

"The banh mi sandwiches here are some of the best I've ever had."

"The banh mi here is one of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of Banh Mi options, including unique dishes.

2

Prices for food items are on the higher side compared to other Vietnamese spots.

3

Pho is not served during the week, only on weekends.

08
Honest Indianapolis Restaurant image 1

Bright, clean space offers a cozy, authentic vibe with a welcoming atmosphere. The energy ranges from relaxed to lively when crowded. Families find it accommodating with thoughtful touches like a top-screen TV for children.

Authentic vegetarian Indian food shines here with dishes that improve in taste with each visit. The menu features Indian street food and Marathi specialties that deliver great flavor consistently.

Bold, loaded Bahubali/Kattapa sandwiches stand out with authentic flavors like the Kattappa sandwich tasting just like in Ahmedabad. Other options include Punjabi shaak sandwiches and the popular Vada Pav.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic, flavorful, and delicious vegetarian Indian street food."

"The dinner spots here are so delicious and tasty."

"The Katappa sandwich tasted just like Ahmedabad."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dosa night events to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers customizable dishes for dietary restrictions.

3

Takeout is preferred for a better food experience than dining in.

09
Twin Peaks image 1
Sports bar

Woodland-style dining with scenic views creates a mountain ski lodge vibe. Multiple TVs show various sports, complemented by a lively DJ and an outdoor area. The atmosphere is energetic and often loud, attracting a crowd interested in drinks, food, and sports.

Food offers consistently great taste and excellent quality. Meals pair well with drinks and create a lively atmosphere.

Nashville hot chicken sandwich stands out with a spicy kick and flavorful sauce. Fries dipped in the sandwich sauce add an addictive touch to the meal.

People are saying

"The bartenders here are awesome and make great food suggestions."

"The bartenders here make watching live sports a personal and enjoyable experience."

"I found the Nashville hot chicken sandwich to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect a $5 cash cover charge on UFC nights.

2

The restaurant has themed days, making the atmosphere more lively.

3

Wednesdays feature special events that attract larger crowds.

10
Pho Tasty image 1
Vietnamese restaurant

Small, cozy Vietnamese restaurant with a calm and relaxed atmosphere. Affordable prices and authentic pho stand out, along with phenomenal banh mi featuring soft, flaky buns and fresh garnishes. The vibe is homey and unpretentious, making it a solid spot for casual dining.

Food stays fresh and hot with every order. Pho and other dishes come out consistently great and delicious.

BBQ pork banh mi sandwiches feature a sweet sauce with bright pickled carrots and jalapeños. These sandwiches stand out for their authentic Vietnamese flavors and delicious pickled vegetables.

People are saying

"The pho here is amazing, flavorful, and the best tasting in the area."

"The food here is delicious and always great."

"This sandwich is the best banh mi I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant adds an 18% gratuity for parties of four or more.

2

Boba tea costs $5, with an extra $1 for boba pearls.

3

Expect reasonable prices for generous portions of pho and other dishes.

11
Capriotti's Sandwich Shop image 1

Sandwich shop with a classic Italian vibe and energetic funk music creates a lively atmosphere. Customers find sandwiches fresh and flavorful, especially the Philly cheesesteak loaded with meat and mushrooms. The space stays clean and comfortable, though the back area is noticeably darker.

Food comes out fresh and hot, made to order with quick service even when busy. The BBQ sandwich stands out as especially delicious and the overall menu stays consistently tasty.

Sandwiches are fresh and flavorful with large serving sizes and many choices. Signature options like the cheesesteak, pastrami slaw, and Thanksgiving sandwich stand out for their quality and taste.

People are saying

"I found the food to be completely amazing."

"This Philly Cheesesteak tastes just like back home."

"This cheesesteak sandwich is overflowing with meat and flavor."

Good to know

1

Capriotti's uses roasted turkey made fresh daily instead of deli turkey.

2

The restaurant is a counter order and pickup place.

3

Expect a total price around $45 for a meal for two.

12
Drake’s Keystone image 1
American restaurant

Spacious American restaurant with two separate bar and dining areas and an open bar to the outside that adapts to weather. Atmosphere is pleasant and lively, featuring live music and game nights that draw a varied crowd. Multiple TVs and a fireplace add to the relaxed, social vibe.

Food features beautiful presentation and great quality, especially the sushi and grilled shrimp cheese sandwich. Dishes like tomato bisque complement the menu well.

Chicken sandwiches come breaded crunchy but not greasy and juicy. Club sandwiches are large and gourmet, often served with sides like sweet potato fries.

People are saying

"The service here is so attentive, they always refill your drinks."

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"This chicken sandwich is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great drink specials and sushi starters.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Parking can be challenging; arrive early to find a spot.

13
Books & Brews image 1

Combination of bar, bookstore, and game store creates a relaxing, fun vibe with a family-friendly atmosphere. Space includes a stage for live performances and areas for board games, trading cards, and reading. Crowd enjoys games and hanging out without typical bar noise distractions.

Food comes with good quality and pairs well with great beer. The menu supports a friendly atmosphere that complements the dining experience.

Buffalo chicken and regular chicken sandwiches stand out with solid flavor. One order arrived incomplete, with only half a sandwich sent.

People are saying

"It's a great place for a game and a beer."

"The food menu was simple but delicious."

"The chicken sandwich was on point."

Good to know

1

The tap room is 21+; the entrance and side room are open to everyone.

2

Karaoke night happens every Thursday at 8pm with a two-drink minimum.

3

Trivia night occurs every Monday at 7pm with a $5 entry fee.

14
Joe's Grille image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill with laid-back atmosphere and friendly, diverse crowd. Features pool tables and an outdoor fire pit for a relaxed social vibe. Offers great food and drink specials with a focus on tasty wings and burgers.

Food stands out for its consistently good wings that are juicy and delicious. Great deals like 75 cent wings on Wednesdays complement the laid-back atmosphere and reasonable prices.

Dagwood sandwich stands out with its impressive size and layers. Both the burger and chicken sandwich offer solid, satisfying flavors.

People are saying

"You can grab a great sandwich while watching live sports here."

"I found the food here to be really great."

"I thought the chicken sandwich I ordered was very good."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 8pm with a competitive atmosphere.

2

Monday is free pool night, making it a great time to visit.

3

Karaoke takes place on Saturdays, adding to the weekend fun.

15
Gaucho’s Fire at 82nd image 1
Brazilian restaurant

Small, cozy Brazilian restaurant with authentic food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Brazilian music and TV screens showing soccer add to the relaxed, family-friendly vibe. Seating includes metal stools and wood booths, reflecting a casual, unpretentious setup.

Food here is consistently delicious and amazing with generous portions like the meat lovers fries. Quality and flavors stand out as exceptional and satisfying.

The sandwich features perfectly seasoned meat and gooey warm cheese on good bread. It is large, full of grilled perfection, and easy to eat quickly.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and plentiful."

"I found the authentic Brazilian food here to be tasty and rich."

"I loved the Brazilian steak sandwich and fries."

Good to know

1

Prices are in the $10-20 range per person, which is reasonable.

2

The restaurant offers big portions at fair prices.

3

They charge $2 for extra sauce and Yuca dust.

16
City Barbeque image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue restaurant offers indoor booths and outdoor sidewalk seating with blues and juke joint music playing softly. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with a laid-back vibe suitable for casual dining. Drive-thru service adds convenience alongside comfortable, friendly surroundings.

Food stays fresh and hot, which keeps flavors strong and healthy. Meat dishes come out consistently excellent and well-prepared, making the overall food quality amazing.

Pulled pork and brisket sandwiches come generously stacked with smokey flavor and packed high. Sandwich options include the More Cowbell and turkey, which reheats well without losing taste.

People are saying

"The brisket and pulled pork here are tender and delicious American Food."

"The food here is tender and delicious."

"I thought their pulled pork sandwich was very good."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru option provides fast service for those on the go.

2

Expect to pay around $30 for a rib order, which may not be enough for larger groups.

3

They often run out of one or two menu items during busy hours.

17
Desi Chowrastha - Indian Eatery image 1

Spacious Indian restaurant with beautiful decorations and a live pani puri counter creates a vibrant atmosphere. Well-lit interior feels like a traditional home, blending authentic South Indian vibes with modern comfort. Large TVs show cricket and music videos, adding to the lively energy.

Offers flavorful South Indian cuisine served hot and fresh in a laid-back setting. Food comes fast and tastes consistently authentic and mouthwatering.

Grilled vegetable sandwich has a crisp exterior and a warm, fresh filling. Bombay grill sandwich and paneer sandwich offer Indian-inspired flavors, though the Bombay grill differs from the original version.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and definitely worth the price."

"The North Indian food here is authentic and bursting with rich flavor."

"I loved the grilled vegetable sandwich; it tasted fresh and comforting."

Good to know

1

Brunch buffet is available on Saturdays and Sundays from 8 am to 11 am.

2

Lunch buffet runs Monday through Friday until 2:30 PM; arrive by 1:30 PM for best selection.

3

Every Monday, unlimited Panipuri is offered.

18
Hari Foods image 1
Indian restaurant

Small space with limited seating creates a cozy, authentic street food vibe. Atmosphere feels relaxed but lively, often busy and packed. Vegetarian Indian snacks and sweets offer flavorful, quick bites at reasonable prices.

Offers authentic Indian street food with a strong focus on vegetarian dishes like aloo tikki chat and chole bhature. Food stays fresh and hot, maintaining quality with friendly and helpful service.

Large Bombay sandwich stands out with green chutney and Indian ketchup. Vegetable sandwich and cheese sandwich also offer solid options among typical Indian snack sandwiches.

People are saying

"The vegetarian Indian street food here is incredibly flavorful."

"The Indian street food here is so flavorful and authentic."

"The Bombay sandwich is large and delicious."

Good to know

1

Seating can be limited during busy times, especially at lunch.

2

Arrive early on weekends to avoid long wait times.

3

Prices are excellent for the quality of food offered.

Discover more

Castleton, Indianapolis

Area guide
Loading Map...