Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Castleton

Jewelry stores

You are looking for jewelry that reflects your personal taste rather than mass-market trends.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Barrington Jewels image 1
Barrington Jewels image 2
Barrington Jewels image 3
View all

Showroom shines with exquisite jewelry and a warm atmosphere that feels personal and family-owned. Repairs are quick and high-quality, handling complex fixes like a 33-year-old tricolor gold bracelet. Pricing stays reasonable, making it a trusted spot for custom and routine needs.

Jewelry repair happens quickly and effectively, including complex fixes like a 33-year-old tricolor gold bracelet. The store offers ring resizing, replating, cleaning, and reappraisal services with timely completion and strong customer support.

People are saying

"The salespeople at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

"The Ring Store staff are so helpful and knowledgeable."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so nice and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The repair process takes less than 30 minutes for most items.

2

Pricing for repairs is very fair, with some services starting at $8.50.

3

Barrington Jewels warranties their work, ensuring customer satisfaction.

02
Sam's Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Showroom features natural diamonds and real gold in a calm, clean space. Custom pendants and diamond rings show detailed craftsmanship. Jewelry cleaning services keep pieces looking like new.

Great quality diamonds and fine jewelry stand out here. Custom pendants and natural diamond rings show detailed craftsmanship. Jewelry cleaning restores pieces to look like new.

People are saying

"The service at this jewelry store is so patient and knowledgeable."

"I found the Ring Store nice and friendly."

Good to know

1

Sam's Jewelers offers custom jewelry options for personalized gifts.

2

They provide free cleaning service for all jewelry purchases.

3

Expect a wide selection of natural diamonds and fine jewelry.

03
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 1

Offers first-class jewelry with hand-crafted designs and a great watch selection. Staff provides knowledgeable service and personalized care. Enjoy ring cleaning and exchanges with a welcoming atmosphere for thoughtful purchases.

Jewelry features first class quality and knowledgeable associates who take time to assemble and help with selections. Services include ring cleaning and exchanges, with staff going beyond to meet jewelry needs.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are patient, kind, and incredibly knowledgeable."

"Heather at this Jewelry Store was so helpful and kind."

"Heather at the Watch Store was amazing and so helpful."

Good to know

1

The store offers a healthcare responder discount for eligible customers.

2

Shipping is available for non-local customers, ensuring timely delivery.

3

Appointments are recommended for custom design consultations.

04
D & L Jewelry & Repair image 1

Bright, clean space offers high-quality jewelry with gold and VVS diamonds. Staff provide personalized attention and advice, making visits comfortable with refreshments. Efficient repair and resizing services ensure trust and satisfaction.

Offers high quality jewelry including gold and VVS diamonds with a great price. Provides excellent repair and resizing services with trustworthy and attentive staff.

People are saying

"They fixed my ring and it looks great after the repair."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store is so friendly and helpful."

"The Watch Store staff were so nice and professional."

Good to know

1

They completed the resizing one hour after I left the ring with them.

2

The owner completed the ring resizing within 20 minutes.

3

The repair was fairly priced.

05
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Bright, clean space offers personalized service with staff like Mya and Brenda guiding you patiently. Jewelry cleaning restores pieces to better than new condition, while inspections let you see diamonds under a microscope. Calm atmosphere ensures a relaxed visit.

Staff like Mya and Brenda provide patient guidance and explain jewelry care clearly. Jewelry cleaning restores pieces to better than new condition, and inspections include viewing diamonds under a microscope to check the cut.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so friendly and helpful."

"I felt so informed about rings after my visit to the Mall."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Expect a 5-8 week wait time for ring repairs, but some can be done in 4 days.

2

Addison is a highly recommended employee for jewelry needs.

3

Communication about order status can be inconsistent; follow up regularly.

06
The Gold Cobbler image 1

Shop offers quick resizing and custom jewelry with immaculate craftsmanship. Friendly service ensures fair prices and honest advice. Efficient repairs meet urgent needs with skilled goldsmith expertise.

A skilled goldsmith handles ring resizing, chain repairs, and stone replacements with quick turnaround. Honest advice and immaculate craftsmanship make it a trusted spot for jewelry repairs and custom pieces.

People are saying

"I got my engagement ring resized and it looks even better now."

"I'm so pleased with the ring repair work done at this Ring Store."

"They did a great job fixing my necklace clasp for a fair price."

Good to know

1

The resizing is completed within 4-5 hours.

2

Prices for services are reasonable compared to other places.

3

Matt provides high-quality repairs and custom jewelry design.

07
Banter by Piercing Pagoda image 1

Affordable pricing and smooth ear piercing make visits easy. Staff like Melonise and Izzy provide helpful guidance on a wide range of quality jewelry, including belly rings. Exchanges require in-person visits, ensuring personal service.

Great quality jewelry stands out here with a variety of pieces including belly rings. Staff like Melonise and Izzy offer helpful guidance on jewelry differences and selections.

People are saying

"The jewelry store staff are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

They will not exchange the item via mail or in the store.

2

The company did not honor their 90-day exchange policy.

3

The ear piercing process was smooth.

08
Zales image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers knowledgeable staff like Sunita and Joel who help with rings and necklaces. Quiet atmosphere suits low-key shopping. Repairs covered by warranty through Kay Jewelers ensure peace of mind.

Staff like Sunita and Joel provide patient, knowledgeable help with selecting rings, earrings, and necklaces. Repairs go through Kay Jewelers with warranty coverage and free service.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and patient."

"Andrea at the Ring Store found my ring paperwork quickly."

"I got amazing customer service at the Watch Store today."

Good to know

1

Warranties may not cover all repairs; check terms before purchase.

2

Expect high prices; some items may be marked up significantly.

3

Customer service has received numerous complaints about dishonesty.

09
Macy's image 1
Department store

Large department store has a bright layout with organized sections and a pop-up Toys R Us. Jewelry area offers personalized service and quality pieces including kids' earrings. Spacious eating area adds comfort after busy holidays.

Jewelry selections include a variety of pieces like earrings for children. Staff assist one person at a time, offering personalized attention. The overall collection features nice quality jewelry.

People are saying

"I found a great selection of casual clothing and shoes here."

"I found a large selection of furniture at this store."

"The staff at the Jewelry Store were so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Macy's hosts seasonal events like the Thanksgiving Day Parade and holiday window displays.

2

In-store events and fashion shows are regularly held at Macy's.

3

Parking can be extremely difficult during Black Friday at Macy's.

Discover more

Castleton, Indianapolis

Area guide
Loading Map...