Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwich spots with American food in Downtown

A sandwich shop that takes the craft seriously enough to be a destination, not just a quick convenience.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Almost Famous image 1
Almost Famous image 2
Almost Famous image 3
View all
Cocktail bar

Swanky cocktail bar with eccentric decor and lively music sets a comfortable, classy vibe. Frequented for drag shows and tapas, it offers unique drinks like Martinez and exceptional espresso martinis. Seating includes outdoor options and unobstructed views for performances.

Impossible biscuits and gravy stand out as a unique offering. The steak and eggs dish looks small but is actually filling. The grilled cheese and queso asado sandwich add variety to the American menu.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with killer flavor and creative twists like the queso asado option. Biscuits and gravy also appear alongside sandwiches, showing a varied menu.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee; the pistachio latte was perfect."

"The American food, like the steak and eggs, was fabulous."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was the best in the city."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

The drag show happens every Saturday night at 9pm.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends due to high demand.

02
Chilly Water Brewing Company image 1

Brewery with an outdoor patio and live music creates a laid back atmosphere where locals gather. Walls feature music-themed murals and records, adding character without overwhelming decor. The vibe stays chill and welcoming, blending good beer with a casual neighborhood feel.

Spicy chicken nachos stand out with a bold kick. Loaded fries serve as a popular, flavorful appetizer. Burgers and nachos round out the classic American menu.

The Ring of Fire sandwich features salami, ham, capicola, chipotle aioli, provolone cheese, and banana peppers. The pressed sandwich offers a spicy, savory flavor that pairs well with a cup of chili.

People are saying

"The beer selection here is amazing, with brews made in-house."

"The American food, especially the loaded fries and nachos, is super tasty."

"The Ring of Fire sandwich was so good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but it's best to arrive early during peak hours.

2

The kitchen closes shortly after the bar opens, so plan your food order accordingly.

3

The brewery offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan menu options.

03
St. Joseph Brewery image 1

Brewpub inside a converted Catholic church features high ceilings and beautiful architecture that create a unique atmosphere. The space feels open and lively, with music mixing decades of hip-hop and R&B. Outdoor seating includes a pet-friendly patio with games like cornhole.

Bison meatloaf stands out as the star dish, served open face and highly praised. Other notable items include sirloin steak, poutine, and jambalaya, with fries recommended over mac and cheese as a side.

Pork katsu and pulled pork stand out as bold sandwich choices here. Chicken sandwiches and burgers also deliver solid flavors with sides like fries and beer cheese mac and cheese.

People are saying

"The food here is 10/10, cooked to perfection."

"The bison meatloaf here is excellent, just like I remember."

"I had the pork katsu sandwich, it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Sunday brunch is a popular time to visit, so expect larger crowds.

3

Parking can be challenging, so arrive early or consider alternative transport.

04
Brew Link Brewing Downtown image 1

Large brewpub with indoor and outdoor seating offers a family-friendly atmosphere that balances lively energy with a zen feel. Spacious layout includes a fireplace and a projector screen, creating a relaxed and welcoming vibe. Music and good conversation fill the space, making it suitable for groups and casual meetups.

Brisket comes juicy with flavorful sauces. Dry rub chicken wings stand out alongside hot, fresh loaded fries and Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac N Cheese.

Cuban sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. The pork tenderloin sandwich offers a local Indian twist and tastes delicious.

People are saying

"I loved their house-made beers and the great variety."

"The American food here, especially the brisket and chili, is fantastic."

"They changed the Buffalo chicken sandwich recipe, now it has tenders."

Good to know

1

There is free parking available, but it fills up quickly.

2

The food and drinks are priced affordably for downtown.

3

Brunch is served all day on Sundays.

05
The Garage Food Hall image 1

Old warehouse space transformed into a historic food hall with a museum feel and revitalized industrial design. Atmosphere is lively and chaotic, filled with live music, pinball machines, and multiple bars offering tastings and mixed drinks. Crowds gather for a family-friendly vibe and diverse activities like sim racing, creating a bustling social hub.

Lobster roll stands out with rich flavor and appears in several variations like grilled cheese. The BBQ brisket offers a solid option alongside diverse choices like hamburgers, pizza, and sushi.

Cuban and Brazilian steak sandwiches stand out with rich, bold flavors. Other options include a Honey Spice Chicken sandwich, a BLT lobster sandwich, and a flavorful chicken salad sandwich.

People are saying

"It's a cool spot with great vibes."

"The American Food, especially the lobster roll, was so satisfying and delicious."

"I loved the variety of international sandwich options here."

Good to know

1

Parking at The Garage Food Hall is difficult, especially on weekends.

2

The Garage Food Hall closes at 10 pm.

3

It is best to grab a table first before ordering food.

06
Pig Pen BBQ image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Smoky aroma from a woodfire smoker fills a lively garage-style food hall. The vibe is casual with generous portions and affordable prices attracting meat lovers. Signature dishes include pulled pork and mac and cheese, noted for their standout flavors.

Pulled pork stands out with unbelievable flavor and tenderness. Brisket offers great flavor and is tender, while ribs come with a tasty Cajun sauce that balances medium spice and sweetness. Mac and cheese and hand-cut potato wedges complement the meats well.

Pulled pork sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and often come with hand-cut potato wedges. Some find the pulled pork a bit dry, but many praise it as a go-to order.

People are saying

"The pulled pork sandwich is some of the best American food I've ever had."

"The brisket here is so tender and flavorful."

"I had one of the better pulled pork sandwiches Iโ€™ve ever had."

Good to know

1

The $10 lunch special includes a generous portion of food with one meat, one side, sauce, coleslaw, and pickles.

2

Prices are affordable, averaging about $20 per person.

3

The portions are large and filling.

07
City Barbeque image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue restaurant offers a casual, comfortable atmosphere with blues music and local sports memorabilia decorating the spacious dining area. Seating includes patio options and various table styles, creating a welcoming environment. The vibe is calm and cool inside, contrasting with a lively outdoor setting.

Brisket and pulled pork come out moist and tender, often not needing sauce. Hush puppies are crispy and flavorful, standing out among classic sides like coleslaw, baked beans, and macaroni and cheese.

Pulled pork sandwiches come with tender meat and generous portions, often paired with City sweet sauce. Brisket sandwiches stand out as very tasty, and seasonal options like the Carolina Goldmine sandwich add variety.

People are saying

"I thought the BBQ here was the best I ever had."

"The brisket here is the best I've had in a while."

"The pastrami sandwich here is a solid 9, really good."

Good to know

1

Parking can be chaotic, so arrive early to find a spot.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is recommended for some vendors.

3

The cornbread portion is smaller than what online pictures suggest.

08
Milktooth image 1
Restaurant

Open-air seating with close tables creates a lively, very loud atmosphere often compared to a nightclub. Decor blends funky, eclectic styles with a Dutch influence, attracting a cheerful crowd. Outdoor patio welcomes dogs, adding to the casual, energetic vibe.

Grilled cheese stands out with versions that impress and satisfy. Dutch babies offer both sweet and savory options, while dishes like bacon meatloaf and loaded grits deliver rich, hearty flavors.

Huge sandwiches stand out, especially the grilled-cheese breakfast and smoked turkey options. The egg tastes sweet from the sauce, and quick takeout for breakfast sandwiches and coffee comes at a good price.

People are saying

"You have to try their Dutch baby pancakes for brunch; they're amazing."

"The American Food here, especially the biscuits and gravy, was delicious."

"The grilled-cheese sandwich is huge, rich, and decadent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, so arrive early to secure a table.

2

Expect a standard wait time of at least 30 minutes during peak hours.

3

The menu changes every two weeks, offering seasonal dishes.

Discover more

Downtown, Indianapolis

Area guide
Loading Map...