Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Mile Square

Sandwich spots

Made for those who appreciate the precision of a well-constructed sandwich and make it their go-to choice for a reliable meal.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop image 1
Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop image 2
Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop image 3
View all

Sandwich shop inside a commercial food area offers awesome views and a relaxing vibe. The space feels clean and cute, attracting a lunchtime crowd from nearby offices. Sandwiches feature high-quality meats and ciabatta bread, toasted and assembled with care.

Food comes out fresh and delicious with huge portions served quickly. The family-owned spot offers consistently amazing quality for a quick lunch or grab-and-go meal.

Fresh, toasted ciabatta bread forms the base for sandwiches like prosciutto and mozzarella and Cajun Turkey and Roast Pork. Friendly staff serve tasty, warm sandwiches quickly at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best downtown."

"I thought the food was really fresh and delicious."

"The staff here are the sweetest people during breakfast."

Good to know

1

The cafe is located inside the Regions Bank lobby.

2

The prices for breakfast sandwiches are reasonable.

3

They use high-quality Boar's Head meats for their sandwiches.

02
Harrison’s image 1
Restaurant

Renovated bank building with a preserved vault room creates a unique dining setting. Atmosphere stays relaxed and sophisticated with low noise and friendly energy. Spacious outdoor patio offers a quiet spot for food and drinks, featuring water served in upcycled liquor bottles.

Food features amazing flavors and delicious dishes paired with superb drinks. Service complements the meal with excellent attention, creating an upscale dining experience.

Chicken parm sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Italian panini comes with crispy fries on the side. Sandwiches pair well with soup for a simple meal.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is terrific, especially the chicken dishes."

"The food here was amazing and delicious."

"I found the Italian panini sandwich delicious and very good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially for larger groups.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Tuesday is steak night with special pricing on steak dishes.

03
Lincoln Square Pancake House image 1

Pancake restaurant offers a gorgeous view of the Capitol building and features Indiana-themed decor with local sports memorabilia. Atmosphere shifts from peaceful and cozy to bustling and lively depending on the crowd, with an open service area that can amplify noise. The space feels somewhat cramped but maintains a friendly, upbeat energy from the staff.

Food here is fantastic with generous portions and a great selection of choices. Service matches the food quality, making meals satisfying and filling.

Chicken Salad sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Croissant sandwiches come warm, flaky, and flavorful, often filled with egg, cheese, bacon, or turkey sausage and pepper jack cheese.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be great and wonderful."

"The breakfast here is hearty and perfectly cooked."

"The croissant sandwich was warm, flaky, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Expect a manageable wait despite busy events in town.

2

The restaurant is often crowded during conventions or events.

3

Breakfast portions are larger than average and well-priced.

04
Tsaocaa Indianapolis image 1
Bubble tea store

Spiral staircase and loft seating create a cozy, unique layout with a family room feel. Fast wifi and varied seating options support studying or relaxing without loud music. A cotton candy machine and games add playful touches to the comfortable atmosphere.

Food features cocoa egg waffle and coconut milk bubble tea with fantastic taste. Drinks and overall ambience complement the rapturous flavors.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with fried chicken that tastes amazing and costs about $6.50. Large sizes are available, making them easy to share.

People are saying

"I thought the bubble tea here was the best I ever had."

"I thought the bubble tea here was phenomenal and refreshing."

"Their chicken sandwich is so crunchy and delicious."

Good to know

1

On weekends, they have mochi doughnuts.

2

The fried chicken sandwich costs $6.50, which is a great deal.

3

You can order online using the posbank machine.

05
Café 251 image 1

Bright, clean space attached to a corporate building draws downtown workers for quick lunch with healthy options. Busy during lunch hours, the line moves quickly and the atmosphere supports people watching. Menu offers a large variety with well-made sandwiches and salads.

Food comes out fresh and homemade style with a focus on quick, tasty meals. Prices stay affordable while delivering consistently delicious flavors for lunch.

Hearty and well-made, the Club sandwich offers a filling meal with good quality ingredients. Breakfast sandwiches feature bread that balances well without overpowering, though some find them a bit dry and bland.

People are saying

"I found the salads and produce to be really fresh."

"The staff really understood my breakfast sandwich order perfectly."

"The food here is really good and delicious."

Good to know

1

Café 251 is located in the Capitol Center building on the first floor facing New York Street.

2

The breakfast burrito costs only $5 for a reasonable size.

3

The place can be busy during lunch hours, but the line moves quickly.

06
Tavern at the Point image 1

Cozy bar space with about 14 seats and an amazing patio offers both indoor and outdoor seating for various evenings. Atmosphere balances between intimate and lively, though harsh lighting and echoing noise from metal ceilings affect the vibe. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs with water bowls, making it a spot for people-watching and casual hangouts.

Brisket taco stands out as a culinary masterpiece with phenomenal flavors. Food service stays engaged and attentive, ensuring needs for food and drinks are met promptly.

Chicken sandwiches feature crispy outside and tender, juicy inside with well-seasoned batter. Club sandwiches stand out for their quality and flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The American food, especially the brisket, is amazing."

"The chicken sandwich was so crispy, juicy, and tender."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the small dining room size.

2

Street meter parking is available, but can be tricky at times.

3

Nightly alcohol deals are offered, including Titos Tuesday.

07
Good Vibes Cafe Bar image 1

Spacious coffee shop with comfortable seating and an open, sunny layout invites relaxation and work. Board games and free wifi create a casual, friendly atmosphere where people gather to read, study, or hang out. The vibe stays bright and welcoming, making it easy to spend hours inside.

Flavors stay balanced across food and drinks, showing clear care in preparation. Fresh croissants and well-presented dishes pair with great coffee and tea for a solid food experience.

Sandwiches come out fast and taste great. The turkey sandwich looks amazing and pairs well with the coffee.

People are saying

"I loved their unique signature lattes, especially the cookie butter."

"The food, especially the croffles, is outstanding and perfectly balanced."

"I will definitely return to this place for their sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The cafe stays open late, making it a great spot for evening coffee.

2

Access to the cafe is only via stairs, located on the second floor.

3

They offer several non-dairy milk options for lattes and drinks.

08
Sun & Moon Cafe (Indianapolis) image 1

Interior decoration features dope design with a relaxed, friendly atmosphere that feels inviting and chill. The cafe stays nice and quiet, making it suitable for quick coffee or lunch in a clean setting. The vibe is casual and welcoming, with a focus on comfort rather than coziness.

Food comes out quickly and tastes amazing. The hibachi stands out with flavors better than typical mall Chinese food. A variety of options pairs well with quick coffee in a clean, bright setting.

Breakfast sandwiches come in a custom option and are available for lunch. Some sandwiches can be unevenly cold, with the left side cooler than the rest.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing and delicious."

"I thought the coffee here was really so good."

"I found the custom breakfast sandwiches delicious."

Good to know

1

The cafe just opened a couple of weeks ago.

2

They are still adding items to the menu.

3

The prices at the cafe are very reasonable.

09
Tinker Coffee on Market image 1

Modern space offers comfortable seating and a warm atmosphere with friendly faces and carefully curated music. Busy yet welcoming, it attracts those looking for inventive coffee flavors and a good spot to work or meet friends.

Food options include matcha oatmeal and various interesting dishes. Coffee and food consistently taste good and delicious.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with herb mayo and fresh ingredients. The Cheapside sandwich offers a flavorful, satisfying start to the day.

People are saying

"The coffee here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

"The food and coffee here are amazing."

"I had the best breakfast sandwich I ever had."

Good to know

1

Tinker Coffee opens at 6 a.m., perfect for early workers.

2

The coffee shop offers free Wi-Fi, making it a good spot for working.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

10
The Rathskeller image 1
German restaurant

Basement German restaurant offers an authentic atmosphere with super tall ceilings and a historic building. Outdoor Biergarten features live music and plenty of seating, creating a lively vibe. The crowd enjoys excellent German beer and traditional dishes in a fun environment.

German food stands out with authentic flavors that recall time spent in Bamberg and Mannheim. The dishes are consistently delicious and paired with fantastic service, even for large groups.

Classic German dishes and sandwiches come out perfectly cooked. The Reuben sandwich stands out, alongside roast beef, bratwurst, chicken, and grouper sandwiches.

People are saying

"The German food here is authentic and outstanding."

"The outdoor seating here is perfect for enjoying live music under the stars."

"I loved their Reuben sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is often busy.

2

Expect a cover charge for live music events.

3

The venue has stairs leading down to the restaurant; elevator access is unclear.

11
Dave's Hot Chicken image 1
Chicken restaurant

Chicken restaurant offers a trendy tree house theme with cool wall art and a neat, clean interior. Loud music creates a lively atmosphere suited for a quick, spicy meal. The vibe feels friendly and welcoming, making it a popular spot for families and casual diners.

Food comes out fresh and delicious every time with great service to match.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with a mild yet flavorful taste. The cauliflower sandwich offers a solid alternative, and the combo with cheesy fries rounds out the meal well.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and outstanding."

"The staff here is so friendly and kind, they even gave our toddler a sticker!"

"I thought the chicken sandwich was really good and crispy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open late, allowing for late-night visits.

2

Expect no wait times during off-peak hours.

3

Parking can be a problem on weekdays.

12
The Social View image 1

Bar occupies an upstairs space with a wrap-around patio offering a rooftop view of downtown. Atmosphere balances chill vibe with live music and tabletop games, creating a relaxed yet engaging environment. Outdoor seating draws those seeking a quiet spot or a fun night out with friends.

Food arrives quickly and tastes fantastic with quality that rivals five-star restaurants. Staff, including owners and cooks, check in to ensure satisfaction.

The sandwiches feature a signature grilled chicken with a bacon jam that adds a sweet touch. Options include a fried version and a fried fish sandwich, all served hot and paired well with fries.

People are saying

"You have to try their chicken wings; they're crispy and juicy."

"The food here is amazing and top-notch."

"The Social Signature Sandwich with bacon jam is amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday with great deals.

2

Karaoke takes place on Wednesday nights starting at 8 PM.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 7 PM with a $5 entry fee.

13
Loughmiller's Pub & Eatery image 1

Scottish/Irish style corner bar with old school tavern feel and firefighter decor creates a crowded, loud atmosphere filled with laughter and good vibes. Tables sit close together, fostering a friendly, comfortable environment popular with office workers and locals. Outdoor patio seating adds a relaxed option away from downtown bustle.

Food comes out quickly and looks great. The menu includes themed options with amazing taste at reasonable prices.

Hearty sandwiches deliver a symphony of flavors with options like the pork tenderloin sandwich standing out. Burgers and salads also complement the solid sandwich lineup.

People are saying

"The food here, especially the burgers and sandwiches, was amazingly good."

"The bar staff here is fantastic and incredibly friendly."

"The pork loin sandwich here is huge, about three times the size of the bread."

Good to know

1

Dogs are not allowed anywhere in the bar.

2

Only individuals aged 21 and above are allowed inside the pub.

3

The kitchen closes 90 minutes before the bar closes.

14
Jimmy John's image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop features a busy atmosphere with a simple interior. Energy rises as it gets extremely crowded, especially during peak times. Food service is steady but not notably fast, with pesto pasta salad available behind the counter.

Food arrives quickly and is made correctly. The quality ranges from mediocre to satisfying, with consistent preparation.

The Pepe sandwich comes out quickly, even before reaching the soda fountain. The sandwich tastes pretty good, but the sandwich maker can be incredibly rude.

People are saying

"I got my delivery super fast and it was perfect."

"The people at this lunch spot are awesome and super friendly."

"I always got great food made correctly."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during peak lunch hours.

2

This location is known for quick service, especially during off-peak times.

3

Parking is limited; consider arriving early or using public transport.

Discover more

Mile Square, Indianapolis

Area guide
Loading Map...