Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Kentucky's best

Pie spots

Made for those who measure the quality of a bakery by the integrity of its crust and the consistency of its filling.

Based on 456 Opinions
+453
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
McCollum's On York image 1
McCollum's On York image 2
McCollum's On York image 3
View all

Dining space blends historical flair with calm, inviting atmosphere and soft music. Peanut butter pie offers rich, creamy texture, while Key Lime Pie balances tart and sweet flavors. Patio provides a comfortable, shaded setting for relaxed meals.

Peanut butter pie stands out with a rich, creamy texture. The Key Lime Pie offers a good balance of tart and sweet flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is unique and absolutely delicious."

"You'll find unique and enjoyable cocktails here."

"The atmosphere and service here are amazing."

Good to know

1

Street parking is available just one block away from the restaurant.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy hours.

3

Lunch prices start at $12 for a sandwich and chips.

02
Tokyo Pie image 1
Cocktail bar

Small space bursts with super-colorful urban Tokyo decor and giant screens showing sports and anime. Hand pies shine with generous dipping sauce and unique flavors like the Kinoko Pie with chewy Japanese mushrooms. Energy feels like Tokyo streets, perfect for late-night drinks with a laid-back vibe.

Hand pies come with a generous amount of tasty dipping sauce and include options like the Grilled Cheese and Kinoko Pie. The Kinoko Pie features Japanese mushrooms similar to Enoki and has a good chew, though the hand pies do not have a cheese pull.

People are saying

"I was blown away by the pizza's perfect crust and toppings."

"The atmosphere here is so cool and laid-back."

"The Kinoko Pie tasted pretty good with a nice chew."

Good to know

1

You order through a QR code and pick up your pizza at the bar.

2

Happy hour deals are available, making it a great time to visit.

3

Food and drink prices are fair for the quality offered.

03
Publix Super Market at Triple Crown Shopping Center image 1

Supermarket offers extensive food stations and a lively upstairs dining area with children's race car carts. Bakery shines with key lime pie and other pre-orderable pies. Beverage choices include a café serving smoothies and craft sodas.

Key lime pie stands out with a strong reputation for flavor. Multiple pies can be pre-ordered, and the bakery section draws attention for its cakes and pies.

People are saying

"The bakery here makes gorgeous petit fours and cupcakes."

"The grocery store's deli and bakery selections are awesome and fresh."

"I considered the Key Lime pie to be the best I have ever eaten."

Good to know

1

The store is known for its cleanliness and organization.

2

Expect a variety of buy one get one free offers during sales.

3

Prices are generally higher than competitors like Kroger.

04
Spear Ridge Café image 1

Barn-inspired design meets modern style with an open kitchen and lively buzz. Outdoor seating and a self-serve drink station create a relaxed vibe. Pies shine with grandma's pecan recipe and rich peanut butter cream.

Pecan pie uses a grandma's recipe and has a classic taste. Peanut butter pie offers premium quality and a rich, creamy texture.

People are saying

"I had a really solid, delicious burger here."

"I thought the chicken salad sandwich was the best."

"I liked the peanut butter pie; it was exceptional."

Good to know

1

The total cost for a family of four is around $58.

2

You can add protein to salads for an extra $4.00.

3

The café offers good portion sizes for the price.

05
Servatii Crestview Hills image 1

Pastry shop shines with pecan pie known for perfect quality and a wide pie selection. Cozy, adorable setup fills the air with fresh bakery aroma. Prices are high, especially for overpriced cookies, but giant pretzels offer a unique treat.

Pecan pie stands out for its consistent quality, often perfect and highly regarded. Other pies include Boston Cream Pie and Lemon Meringue Pie, alongside desserts like cheesecake, tiramisu, cannoli, and key lime pie.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were fresh and tasty."

"The German Chocolate cake was a light beige, not chocolate."

"Their pecan pie is perfect every time."

Good to know

1

The cookies cost $40 for a dozen.

2

Expect a 30-minute wait during busy hours.

3

The facility is peanut free for allergy safety.

06
Libby’s Southern Comfort image 1

Crowded space glows with cozy lighting and Southern décor, making it warm and inviting. Outdoor dining shines with a heated patio and blankets for comfort. Pies like honey pie offer a scrumptious dessert that stands out.

Honey pie and oatmeal cream pie stand out with their amazing flavors. These pies offer a scrumptious dessert option.

People are saying

"The fried chicken and hush puppies here are amazing."

"I found the Shrimp and Grits really good and flavorful."

"It took an hour after the entree to get a slice of pie."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited to pay lots and a few meters nearby.

2

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

3

The restaurant has a kids menu available.

07
Frisch's Big Boy image 1

Diner offers a family atmosphere with a warm, cozy vibe and friendly staff. Pumpkin pie features whipped cream topping but portions can be small, while pecan pie tastes good though packing takes time. Space feels peaceful and inviting for a relaxed meal.

The pumpkin pie comes with whipped cream covering a missing chunk, and the portion size can be smaller than expected. Pecan pie tastes good, but pie orders can take a long time to be packed.

People are saying

"I found the food to be amazing and delicious."

"The drive-thru team is so kind and accommodating."

"I had the best pumpkin pie I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The restaurant will be closing on December 23rd.

2

Expect higher prices compared to other diners in the area.

3

The bathrooms were not clean and could use attention.

08
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Open bakery offers weekly cookie flavors and a sweet aroma that fills the clean, fast-paced space. Lemon Pie delivers a strong flavor, while Biscoff pies are a solid choice. High demand often leads to sellouts.

Lemon Pie stands out with a strong flavor. Biscoff pies offer a solid choice. The pecan pie is very thin and lacks substance.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"The Dubai brownie was very rich and indulgent."

"This week's Lemon Pie was to die for."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers a variety of cookies that change every week.

2

Expect high traffic, especially during weekends.

3

Prices are fair considering the size and quality of cookies.

Discover more

Kentucky

Area guide
Loading Map...